Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Scots

Tuesday 29 February 2000 Procedures Committee Committee business 28 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

28 contributions
Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I welcome Irene McGugan, who has come here this morning to speak on the first item on the agenda—the use of the Scots language.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

I thank the committee for addressing the issue and for taking the trouble to produce a helpful paper. It seems anomalous that members are able, with the permission of the Presiding Officer, to speak in the chamber in Scots—and are reported in Scots in the Official Report—yet are not able to lodge a motion in Scots or Gaelic. If oral Scots is acceptable, perhaps written Scots should be considered to be eligible for use in motions.The ambiguity of the status of Scots as a language has been mentioned. I contend that it is a language. It is recognised by the European Bureau of Lesser Used Languages as one of the lesser-known minority languages of Europe. That definition is good enough for me.The consultative steering group report had several interesting things to say on the use of Scots and Gaelic. It concluded that the normal working language of the Parliament should be English, but that that did not prohibit the use of Scots or Gaelic. It took the view that most members would be expected to understand both spoken and written Scots, and that there would be no need to provide interpretation facilities for any MSPs who wanted to use Scots.The Welsh Assembly model, as outlined in the paper, seems to have a great deal to commend it. Any difficulties of interpretation between Scots and English could easily be addressed by any number of academic experts and Scots language organisations who could advise Parliament.The paper suggests that if Scots and Gaelic were considered acceptable languages in which to lodge motions, motions in any non-English language would have to be allowed. However, that logic is flawed, as has been highlighted by other decisions that have been made by Parliament. We have signage in English and Gaelic only and there is no suggestion that we should have signs in every language. The Parliament is about to appoint a Gaelic officer, but will appoint no officer for any other language. The Welsh have not adopted that principle; they use English and Welsh and have not sought to use other languages.As a member of the Equal Opportunities Committee, I shall support any and every move towards an inclusive Scotland. However, there is a case for acknowledging the status of Scotland's indigenous languages—Scots and Gaelic—and a strong historical and cultural argument can be made for that.Finally—before members ask me all sorts of questions—I suggest that the option of being able to lodge motions in Scots or Gaelic with an English translation would be acceptable. That would not require an amendment to standing orders—which would make the change easier—although when I tried to submit a motion in both Scots and English it was rejected on the basis that standing orders prescribe that a motion should be lodged in English only. Allowing motions in Scots to be lodged would be a significant step forward.

Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I ask John Patterson to comment, for the committee's benefit, on the interpretation of standing orders in relation to the lodging of a motion in English and Scots.

John Patterson Clerk Team Leader
link

That is set out on page 7 of the paper on Scots. Motions are to be lodged in English, but the advice that the paper sets out is that they can also be lodged in any other language.

Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Would the business bulletin print both versions if motions were lodged in English and another language?

John Patterson Clerk Team Leader
link

That would be possible.

Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

What is current practice?

John Patterson Clerk Team Leader
link

It would print both versions.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

That was not my experience—my motion was rejected.

Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

As we understand standing orders, the chamber desk ought to have accepted your motion in both versions, and printed it in both versions. I do not see any logical reason not to accept that.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

Irene is right to draw this matter to our attention, particularly the refusal to accept a motion that was lodged in Scots. That was erroneous and should not be repeated. A member should have the right to lodge a motion in any language they choose, as long as they provide an English translation. The burden on providing the translation should be on the member, although the clerks would want to check it. Given that one is required to give notice before speaking in another language, as we know from the Gaelic debate on Thursday, the clerks might ask for the translation to be checked before the motion is published in the bulletin. That would be reasonable if the clerks felt that the translation might be inaccurate.There would be no question but that, for legal reasons, the English motion would take precedence. That is the nature of the legislation. Nothing can be done about that, except to change it by primary legislation. We are not proposing that. However, we are being unduly restrictive. Irene is opening up an area that we should be relaxed about.

Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

All of Mike's points are perfectly valid. Do members see any difficulties with them?

Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Should we advise the chamber desk of our decision, or will the chamber desk pick it up from the clerks' internal briefings?

John Patterson Clerk Team Leader
link

You should write a letter.

Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We will write a letter incorporating Mike's points of clarification.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

Could we copy the letter to the Presiding Officer and ask for a brief notice in the business bulletin so that the matter is clarified? A precedent has been set and we want to overturn it as quickly as possible.

Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

That is fair. Are you happy with that, Irene?

Iain Smith LD The Deputy Minister for Parliament · North East Fife
link

I am not against the pragmatic way in which this is being suggested, but we ought to be clear about procedures in terms of the precedence of the English version, which Mike referred to, and the lodging of amendments. If a member wishes to lodge an amendment to a motion that has been lodged in English and in another language, who will the onus be on to provide the translation of the amendment into the other language?

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

It should be on the member who lodges the amendment.

Iain Smith LD North East Fife
link

With the deepest respect, that is not necessarily the case. If English has precedence and the person who is lodging the amendment is not a speaker of the other language—whether it is Gaelic, Scots or some other language—I am not sure that the onus should be on them to provide the translation of the amendment. We need to be clear about that.

Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I am improvising here, but I would have thought that if a member wished to amend a motion lodged in English and Scots, it would be competent to lodge the amendment in English only.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

The English version would be formally moved, so the other version would have no legal standing.

Iain Smith LD North East Fife
link

We must be clear about that, because members might have their rights to lodge amendments restricted.

Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We should point out in the notice in the bulletin that if members wish to amend a motion in Scots or in any other language, they need amend only the English version.

Donald Gorrie LD Central Scotland
link

Sometimes, the number of questions or motions a member lodges becomes a political virility symbol. I hope that people would not feel obliged to show their 100 per cent Scottishness by using Scots incessantly. It is useful to have talked about this, and it is relevant to certain motions, but I hope that some common sense will be applied.

Murray Tosh Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

It will probably not be, now that you have drawn attention to it, Donald. I appreciate your point, and it is up to each of us to interpret as we see fit the various ways in which parliamentary questions are recorded and presented.Irene McGugan does not need to stay for the rest of the meeting if she has better things to do, although she is welcome to stay.

  1. Scottish Parliament Procedures Committee Tuesday 29 February 2000 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Scots Committee business · 28
  3. Correspondence (Committee Amendments to Bills) Committee business · 19
  4. Voting Arrangements Evidence session · 2
  5. Correspondence (Notice of Lodging Amendments) Committee business · 5
  6. Committee Videoconferencing Facilities Committee business · 9
  7. Access to Committee Papers Committee business · 1
  8. Work Update Committee business · 3
  9. Standing Orders Committee business · 29

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.