Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 19 September 2007 Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Procedure 63 contributions · 13 speakers

Speakers

Showing Brian Adam only · show everyone

Brian Adam’s contributions

23 contributions
Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

Some of our witnesses attended the earlier discussion. This is a reasonably informal opportunity to engage with the committee on the subjects into which we will conduct inquiries over the next year. I am happy to hear from members or witnesses who catch my eye. If you want to engage with some of the issues that were brought to our attention by the people who were here earlier, by all means do so.

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

I will let an MSP have the first go this time. I will come to you after that.

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

I am sure that he will be happy to do that. We will give him a couple of moments to gather his thoughts.However, I notice that one of our guest witnesses is volunteering to contribute. Malcolm Webb is here on behalf of Oil and G—

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

Oil and Gas UK. I almost got there.

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

Is that because of increasing use of gas for electricity generation?

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

How could existing energy businesses successfully diversify into other areas? I am thinking in particular of the engineering side and of the use of facilities at which production might be finished.

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

I presume you are throwing that question out to all of our guests.

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

Do you want to pick up on that issue, Mr Armour?

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

In that case, perhaps Mr Thoms would like to pick up the challenge.

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

Dr Smith, are you ready to respond to David Whitton's challenge?

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

Could a generating company saying that we should not reduce demand be seen as speaking from self-interest?

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

If we go down the route of rationing by price and there are issues of affordability, will the regulator have a role in helping with that policy shift through price regulation and direction to generators? What influence does the regulator have in relation to a shift in the mix? Some recent decisions have been controversial because they appeared to be in consumers' interests but not in the interests of the environment and the long-term future. Am I being unfair, Mr Gray?

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

Although regulation of the transmission and distribution networks does not have a direct effect on prices, it certainly has an indirect effect. You do not tell British Energy what prices it can charge, but you regulate access to the networks, which has an effect on the price to consumers.

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

I suspect that some of the points that you have made might not find a lot of favour with members round the table or with some of our other colleagues. I ask Grant Thoms to give a view from the perspective of the renewables industry on what our colleague from Ofgem has said.

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

You are suggesting that we ought not to leave things to the market. Rather, we ought to direct matters centrally.

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

And we do not have any power to make you do that, unfortunately.Stuart Haszeldine raised CO2 storage issues and the potential for a major new market for Scotland. I invite Malcolm Webb to respond to what he said.

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

Given that Mr Gray has told us that transmission costs account for only 3 per cent of the total energy bill, is it worth Ofgem's while interfering in the market at the margins when it might not provide any consumer benefit, which I understand is the main reason for Ofgem's existence? Would it not be better to allow the producers to make their own decisions on how best to hook up to the grid?

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

As far as the Scottish Parliament is concerned, the committee has responsibilities for the economy, energy and tourism. Although not all those functions are devolved, that does not prevent the committee from making recommendations to the Scottish Government to engage with Westminster on those issues. We will need to balance out what we will do relative to our remit, but we will not be absolutely constrained by that. We will certainly need to consider issues such as Ofgem's role; we cannot discuss energy without discussing that issue.Are there any views on how we might address the balance that is needed in electricity generation? Should we leave that issue to the market or should we be more actively engaged through things such as renewables obligations? There is a debate on that, so our committee perhaps has an opportunity to consider the issue.

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

Correct me if I am wrong, but I rather think that Scottish and Southern Energy and Scottish Power still have an interest in transmission. From what I remember, they are still integrated companies. It would certainly be open to us to engage with National Grid plc, which also has a role. Am I correct in saying that both SSE and Scottish Power still deal with transmission?

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

I wanted to encourage folk to address Malcolm Webb's point that we have gone from 74 per cent dependency on hydrocarbons to 79 per cent dependency. Everybody is shouting about renewables, and there is a debate about nuclear power. We have an opportunity to make our pitch as we decide what to do over the coming year.

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

Is that one of the mechanisms that your industry would suggest the Government ought to adopt?

Brian Adam SNP The Deputy Convener · Aberdeen North
link

As nobody has anything further to contribute, I draw the discussion to a close. I invite you all to think about what has been said and to tell us the main thing that you would like us to consider and into which we should hold an inquiry in the time that we have available over the coming year. Some interesting and challenging ideas have been advanced. It is a moot point how realistic it is for us to cross the boundaries of our remit, and it would not be a good use of our time to duplicate what the Government will do, but I assure you that we will have uppermost in our minds what we will do about energy. We might couple that with what we do on the economy. If you care to write to us, it will help to inform our decision in the next few weeks and, if there is something that you wish you had said, by all means put it in writing and send it to the clerks. Thank you for attending; it is much appreciated.

  1. Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 19 September 2007 Committee business · 1
  2. Work Programme Procedure · 64
  3. Item in Private Procedure · 1
  4. Work Programme Procedure · 63
  5. Skills Strategy Committee business · 17

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.