Welcome to the fourth meeting of the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee. I am in the chair today because our convener has a significant constituency interest in animal welfare and has therefore gone to hear the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment talk about foot-and-mouth disease at the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee. He will join us later, at which point I will vacate the chair.Today for the second time we will hold round-table discussions as we try to work out our work programme for the coming year. We have already held a round-table discussion on tourism, and the format of that meeting was quite successful. It was relatively informal, so rather than have any desperate formality today, I invite participants simply to catch my eye if they wish to contribute.Today's meeting will be in two parts, with a short break between them. I welcome all our visitors, including Lewis Macdonald MSP, who joins us today. I remind everyone to turn off their mobile phones.We recently held an interesting away day at which we thrashed a number of issues around. Would any of our guests like to offer their views on how we might make best use of our time, on behalf of the Parliament and the country, on issues affecting energy? Your views will help to inform committee members on how to devote their time over the next few months.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Brian Adam only · show everyone- Brian Adam SNP 27
- Adam Scorer Energywatch 6
- Duncan McLaren Friends of the Earth Scotland 6
- Professor Miller 5
- Dr Barlow 2
- John Stocks Carbon Trust 2
- Elaine Morrison Solar Cities Scotland 2
- Dr Anable 2
- Dr Dan Barlow WWF Scotland 1
- Professor Andrew Miller Royal Society of Edinburgh 1
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 1
- Mike Thornton Energy Saving Trust Scotland 1
- Gavin Brown Con 1
- Lewis Macdonald Lab 1
- Christopher Harvie SNP 1
- Dr Jillian Anable UK Energy Research Centre 1
- David Whitton Lab 1
- Dave Thompson SNP 1
Brian Adam’s contributions
27 contributionsIf we wanted to be a bit luddite about this, would it be fair to say that the environmental aspects would not necessarily be the first issue in which the committee might want to interest itself? Would they not be more for another committee to examine?
That could involve either importing the technology or developing our own technology as part of a renewables economy.
I call Professor Miller—although I remind committee members that they should feel free to participate, too.
How would that square with the Government's policy of decluttering the landscape—perhaps not quite a bonfire of the quangos, but something similar? If your solution is to have an overarching body—a non-departmental public body, for example—to co-ordinate action, how would you square the circle? Do you suggest that if we had such a body, we should get rid of all the other bodies because they already do different aspects of the work?
Whatever it is called, it would be an at-arm's-length arrangement. The view expressed by the responsible minister is that he wishes to declutter the landscape. If you were to suggest an overarching energy body, and we were to go along with the idea, we would have to declutter in other areas before going ahead.
I will let Professor Miller respond to that question, although others may respond too.
Is that the kind of response that Duncan McLaren and Adam Scorer would make, or would they respond differently?
A member's bill on that is on the way, and the Government might even be willing to pick up on the issue.
I will let Elaine Morrison in, and then the MSPs can make their points.
We can return to that. Some members of the committee want to ask questions: first Gavin Brown, then Lewis Macdonald and Christopher Harvie. We will then give some of our guests the opportunity to respond.
Should we also be taking the gas and electric meters out of their boxes and placing them somewhere prominent? I refer to the smart meters that Adam Scorer mentioned.Lewis Macdonald will put the next question.
I invite Christopher Harvie to pose his question.
I realise that Dr Anable has not yet had an opportunity to respond.
I will get round to some of the people who have indicated that they want to speak, but I invite some of our guests to address Lewis Macdonald's questions, because he has to go. In the question that particularly caught my attention, he suggested that perhaps we should not just confine ourselves to Scotland when addressing these issues; we should be co-operating with our compatriots in these islands, particularly when talking about a body such as the Food Standards Agency. Do any of our guests want to comment on that?
Where does that stop? If something is affecting the environment, its effect does not stop within these islands, let alone at the border between Scotland and England.
There is no doubt that some of Ofgem's decisions have been particularly controversial and have worked against environmental improvements.
The supergrid is attractive, but what do you say to those who say that the greater the supergrid the greater the transmission losses?
The words having been taken out of my mouth, I will give Elaine Morrison the opportunity to contribute.
You are certainly issuing us with lots of challenges, but we are more than happy to accept them.
If we install smart meters that are prominently placed so that people know the implications of their behaviour on their personal finances as well as on carbon emissions, will we not create an industry that only measures the problem, rather than change behaviour?
What is the payback time for the capital investment?
You have made a number of suggestions that should probably more appropriately be directed at the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee. It might not be the best use of our time for us to duplicate the work that the Government is doing on its proposed bill. I do not deny the importance of what you say, but our role is to inform future policy requirements. We must be careful not to duplicate work that someone else has done.I will let Dave Thompson ask his question, as he has not yet had a chance to speak and his voice is probably in as bad a state as mine.
Thank you for dropping us into the incineration difficulty—that is just a throwaway line.
Is in-car feedback work done to highlight, for example, the difference between a car's published miles per gallon and the miles per gallon that are actually achieved, which reflects how people really drive?
I understand that Duncan McLaren can answer Mr Thompson's question. We will end this session after that.
On that note, I thank our witnesses for their contributions to the discussion. Perhaps you would consider dropping us a note about the key issues that you want us to consider in any inquiry that we might hold in the coming year. You have issued a range of challenges to us. We will have to consider how well we can address them, or whether it is appropriate for us to address them. If there is anything that you wanted to say but did not get the opportunity to say today, you may put it in writing and we will consider it. Thank you very much.
In this meeting
Everything on 19 Sep 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 19 September 2007 Committee business · 1
- Work Programme Procedure · 64
- Item in Private Procedure · 1
- Work Programme Procedure · 63
- Skills Strategy Committee business · 17
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.