Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 27 June 2007 Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Procedure 85 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Showing Tavish Scott only · show everyone

Tavish Scott’s contributions

15 contributions
Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

Item 2 is our approach to the committee's work programme. I welcome Jim Mather, the Minister for Enterprise, Energy and Tourism, and Graeme Dickson, whom I knew previously—it is nice to see you again, Graeme.I propose to invite members to ask the minister questions on the three areas of his portfolio after he has made a few opening remarks. We are pleased that you have come to the committee, minister. We know that you have a busy diary and we appreciate your giving up time to appear before us with less than a week's notice.

Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

Thank you. We will start by considering the economy. Before inviting questions from around the table, I will kick off by drawing your attention to a quote from the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth. During the debate entitled "Wealthier and Fairer", he said:"I confirm that our target for this session of Parliament is to raise Scotland's growth rate to the UK level by 2011."—Official Report, 30 May 2007; c 194.You have just made that point. Would you expand on it, to give the committee a feel for what you hope to achieve in your portfolio over the next four years?

Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

You have been fair and have expanded on what the cabinet secretary said, but how did the Government conclude that that target was the right one to aim at? How, specifically, will you hit that target?

Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

It might be an unfair question, given that you have been a minister for only five weeks, but I am interested in the specific measures that you plan to take to increase the growth rate. As you have said, the target is ambitious.

Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

Marilyn Livingstone has raised an important point to which we will return, both with the appropriate committee and with your ministerial colleagues.

Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

That was an interesting comment on bottles of whisky, but we will leave it for the health ministers to sort out.

Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

Indeed, and rather successfully too.

Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

Chris, we are pressed for time. Could you focus in on a couple of questions?

Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

Your answer does not have to be as long as the question. We have only 20 minutes left.

Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

I call David Whitton and thank him for his patience.

Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

I will finish the questions on the economy, after which we will go quickly on to energy and tourism. I understand that you probably do not have the authority to tell us when a legislative programme will be put before Parliament, and cannot do so. I appreciate that you are constrained in relation to the date, but I would like to know whether the committee can expect any proposed legislation. If I understood your answers to David Whitton, Iain Gray and Gavin Brown, you will not reform Scottish Enterprise through legislation. Is the committee to expect any proposed legislation in the economy portfolio area in the next year?

Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

That is very helpful. I think that I can read the code in all that—it is clear to me what you are saying. Shall we go in reverse order for questions on energy and tourism, starting with David Whitton? And can we keep it snappy as we have only 10 minutes left? Questions to the minister should be short.

Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

Given the current weather, I agree that we should deny the seasons.

Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

I am pleased to hear that last answer. That is very helpful.I have a final question on renewables, which my colleagues have asked about this morning. My understanding is that there is to be a moratorium on onshore wind farms for the next year. Am I right in thinking that, or has the position changed? It would be helpful to know what the Government's policy is on onshore wind farms.

Tavish Scott LD The Convener · Shetland
link

Thank you for your time this morning. We will review the evidence that you have given us and will write to you with any questions that we have. We are grateful for your attendance this morning. Thank you for taking time out so soon in your new ministerial position.We will take a five-minute comfort break. I suspend the meeting until 12 minutes past 10.

  1. Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 27 June 2007 Committee business · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 3
  3. Work Programme Procedure · 85
  4. Proposed Energy Efficiency and Microgeneration Bill Bill debate · 8
  5. Business in the Parliament Committee business · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.