Item 2 is also subordinate legislation. These rules are subject to the negative procedure. They make provision for the process that is to be followed in making an appeal to the Scottish charity appeals panel and for the operation of the panel. The rules relate to the procedures that the panel will follow in the processing and determination of an appeal, the publication of the appeal decision and the criteria for the award of expenses. The rules also set out more detailed provision on the appeals process and appeal hearings. They will allow for the award of expenses against either the appellant or the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator. No motions to annul the rules have been lodged. The Subordinate Legislation Committee raised a number of concerns; in particular, it had a serious concern about whether rule 10 is intra vires, as the parent act does not provide the necessary powers for what is proposed. Another concern was raised about the clarity of drafting. In its response to the Subordinate Legislation Committee, the Executive has stated that it does not share that committee's view on the matter. In reporting to the Parliament on the rules, do members have any comments, particularly in light of the Subordinate Legislation Committee's concerns?
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Scottish Charity Appeals Panel Rules 2006 (SSI 2006/571)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Karen Whitefield Lab 5
- Christine Grahame SNP 2
- John Home Robertson Lab 1
- Patrick Harvie Green 1
- Tricia Marwick SNP 1
The record
11 contributionsDo we need to endorse the Subordinate Legislation Committee's concerns? We want to pick up on the fact that, as that committee says in paragraph 4, in principle it is not possible—as far as I know—to have something in subordinate legislation that is not authorised in primary legislation. We are back to the nature and quality of the drafting of subordinate legislation. It is an issue that we have already raised and that keeps being repeated. It is more than just a problem of style.
That is the part that the Executive disputes. In its response to the Subordinate Legislation Committee, it said that Scottish ministers have powers and may make rules on the practice and procedures of the panel. The power allows the ministers to get round the difficulties that have been raised by the Subordinate Legislation Committee. It would be legitimate for us to raise those concerns in our report and to ask the Executive to comment further on the issue. We could ask for further explanation about why the Executive considers that the Subordinate Legislation Committee was not right in concluding that the instrument is ultra vires.
This is the sort of argument that puts a committee in some difficulties. There is a risk of getting into a sort of playground argument—"Oh yes it is," "Oh no it isn't." Frankly, we do not know. It is clear that someone has advised the Subordinate Legislation Committee that rule 10 is ultra vires, but the Executive says, "Oh no it isn't." Who are we to believe? It is an issue that matters. Somewhere down the line, someone may feel aggrieved by the way in which an appeal is being handled. The process could be open to challenge on that basis. It is important that we get this right. I presume that the Executive has had advice from the law officers. What advice is available to committees? At the end of the day, we may get the blame if we get it wrong.
Ultimately, it would be for the rules to be challenged in the courts. As I said earlier, there has been no motion to annul.
link
I am not a lawyer of any description, but the Subordinate Legislation Committee's report seems to be about the meaning of the word "constituted". I am not entirely convinced that that committee's concern makes sense. This committee is constituted of nine people, but if two of us are absent, the committee is still constituted of nine people and is still able to meet. It seems reasonable that that should be allowed. We should get some kind of answer from the Executive about how it intends to ensure that rule 10 is not going to be common or standard practice and will be used only in exceptional circumstances. It would be reasonable for both parties to an appeal to agree that the hearing can go ahead if one panel member is absent, but it should not be a regular practice.
In response to John Home Robertson's point, I would guess that the Subordinate Legislation Committee's advice is coming from parliamentary officials, in the same way that the Executive advice is coming from Executive officials. The Parliament is duty bound to follow the independent advice of parliamentary officials as opposed to the advice of the Executive. Having said that, I think that there is clearly a dispute between the Executive's advisers and the Parliament's advisers on the matter. Can we suggest that it would be a good idea if the two sets of advisers got together to consider the legal advice that has been given to the Parliament and to the Executive and to work out whether there is a way round this?
We get back to the issue that the parent act enables rules to be made as to the practice and procedures of the panels but omits the circumstances in which a panel is constituted and duly empowered and enforced. The instrument takes that on its shoulders. That is the conflict. It would be a belt-and-braces approach, perhaps, but that should have been included in the principal legislation.
The best way forward would be for us to write to the minister seeking further information and clarification, based on the representations the committee has received from the Subordinate Legislation Committee. That does not mean that we have reached any conclusion or that we agree with the Subordinate Legislation Committee. We may well do, but at this point we seek further clarification on the conflicting advice. That is really the only way forward for us, as no motion to annul has been lodged with the committee. Are members content with that course of action?Members indicated agreement.
In that case, I suggest that our comments are incorporated into the committee's report to the Parliament on the rules and that we write to the minister on the drafting of the rules. In so doing, we should express our concern about whether the instrument is, as the Subordinate Legislation Committee suggests, ultra vires. We will not, however, make any recommendation on the rules. Does the committee agree to take that approach?Members indicated agreement.
Meeting continued in private until 11:40.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Jan 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Communities Committee Wednesday 10 January 2007 Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 12
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.