Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Roads, Pavements and Footpaths (Maintenance) (PE855)

Tuesday 27 March 2007 Local Government and Transport Committee Petitions 10 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

Petition PE855, which is on the maintenance of local authority roads, pavements and footpaths, was submitted by Leslie Morrison on behalf of Kirkside area residents. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to review the performance of local authorities in Scotland in maintaining and repairing roads, pavements and footpaths.As members know, we have had a long-running interest in the maintenance of non-trunk roads and we took evidence on the petition from the Society of Chief Officers of Transportation in Scotland on 6 March 2007.How would members like us to respond to the petition? Again, as we are almost at the end of the parliamentary session, I hope that we can conclude our consideration of the petition today. However, given that the maintenance of roads and of other local government assets, including paths and pavements, is undoubtedly a continuing issue, the report of our conclusion could be made available to our successor committee, so that it is aware of this committee's work. I would expect any such paper to draw attention to the witness sessions that we have held and the evidence that we have taken on the maintenance of local authority non-trunk roads. I invite comments from members.

Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab Stirling
link

As you know, convener, I am particularly interested in the subject. We have held several evidence sessions and we have started to move the agenda on, but much monitoring and discussion has still to take place. I endorse your suggestion that the issue is significant and that it should be passed on to the committee that takes over responsibility for local government concerns. As you say, we should highlight what has been done and the ways forward.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Leslie Morrison is to be congratulated on raising this bread-and-butter issue that all of us who are regularly contacted by constituents about the state of our pavements, roads and streets know is a cause of concern and, in some cases, anger. It is also a safety matter. Not maintaining pavements leads to people tripping, falling and suffering serious damage. Many people make fun of pothole politics as if it is somehow of a lower order than high-level policy making, but my impression is that for the people whom we represent, the issue is extremely important.The evidence that we received from Bill Barker and Graham Mackay of the Society of Chief Officers of Transportation in Scotland was particularly useful—as SCOTS has been throughout my period on the committee—in its factual specificity and helpful detail about how to address the problem. I was struck that Mr Mackay said that although expenditure on trunk roads has risen, local authorities' budget has substantially fallen. Money has been made available to tackle some of the problems on trunk roads, but local authorities cannot meet their obligations in the way that they would like to.I was struck in particular by Mr Mackay's evidence to me. When I asked him what the total cost would be of bringing Scotland's roads, footpaths and lighting up to standard, he said that it would be £2,000 million. He also agreed that a programme to tackle that over 10 years would cost £4,000 million. That is the scale of the problem that we face. All Governments—whether the current Executive or another Executive in a month's time—will have to grapple with the problem, which is extremely serious. I therefore concur with the recommendation that we should draw the matter to the incoming Administration's attention. As committee members who represent different parts of Scotland, I hope that we can all convey that more urgently needs to be done to tackle the problems, prevent avoidable injuries and provide safe transportation for people on their local streets, roads and pavements.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

I am broadly satisfied that monitoring of the condition of roads and pavements is adequate. The reports that we have received from Audit Scotland and the local surveys that councils undertake show that the scale of the problem is understood and has been evaluated.Councils have been ranked relative to their performance. Not long ago, an Audit Scotland report ranked my local authority—the City of Edinburgh Council—28th out of 32 for the standard of roads. We hope to correct that situation in a month or so's time. A council survey ranked 37 per cent of roads in my constituency of Edinburgh Pentlands as poor or very poor.In the last analysis, the condition of roads and pavements has been well documented, audited and monitored. We are left with an issue of political priorities that concerns how local authorities apply their budgets and how much weight they give to road and pavement maintenance.The fact is that the scale of the problem throughout Scotland, which was highlighted in the evidence that we took from SCOTS and other bodies, suggests that road and pavement maintenance has been a very low priority for local authorities in comparison with the other demands on their budgets. My view is that the situation must change because we cannot simply allow the local road network to deteriorate. Sooner or later, councils—regardless of their political complexion after May—will have to attach greater priority to that responsibility, if the situation is not to deteriorate further.I am afraid that we are talking about a situation in which it is easy for councils, because of competing demands and pressures on their budgets, to postpone the repair of a road for another year or two. When our councils are under such pressures, by and large capital maintenance programmes tend to be deferred, but there is invariably a day of reckoning and that day is arriving. Fergus Ewing is quite right—as I am sure that the rest of us are aware from our postbags, the poor state of our roads and pavements is one of the most common subjects of complaints from constituents. People are demanding action and our councils will have to respond through their budget setting.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

Although I do not necessarily agree with David McLetchie's political attack on his local authority, I agree with what he said about local authorities having to decide on their priorities. From our examination of the issue, it has been clear that some local authorities have spent their full grant-aided expenditure allocations on roads and pavements; in fact, in some cases, spending has been well above that level. Some councils have a good record on maintaining their roads—West Lothian Council, for example, has been one of the better councils in that regard in recent years, partly because of its decision to invest more than its GAE allocation to tackle the issue.I agree with David McLetchie that it is for each local authority to decide what priority to attach to road maintenance. Given that, in general, local authorities have received above-inflation increases in their total resources over recent years, a significant amount of the responsibility must lie with them and the decisions that they have taken. I am sure that Audit Scotland will continue to keep the situation under review.Road maintenance is an important issue Scotland-wide, in that it has implications both for public safety and for the economy. If the economy is to continue to function well, we must ensure that our entire road network, not just our trunk road network, is well maintained. I expect our successor committee to continue to take interest in the subject and, to help it to make progress, we should draw its attention to the evidence that we have received from SCOTS and the work that Audit Scotland has done.David McLetchie mentioned local authorities deciding to postpone investment when their budgets are under stress, but I remind him that one such occasion was when the Conservatives were in power—that is when much of the backlog built up. Equally, I remind my colleague Fergus Ewing that the Scottish National Party's proposal to withdraw £1 billion from local authority funding would put council budgets under stress, with the result that, if Fergus Ewing got his way, they would find it all the more difficult to invest in roads in the years ahead. Thankfully, I am sure that the electorate will come to a different decision.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Let us stick to the petition. The election campaign is coming up in the next five weeks, so we do not need to hold such debates now.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

You want to take the politics out of politics.

Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab Stirling
link

I agree with the convener that the backlog has not built up overnight.With regard to David McLetchie's comment about the additional money that councils have or have not made available, the fact is that it has not dealt with the huge backlog that Fergus Ewing highlighted and which will cost hundreds of thousands of pounds to clear. That is the problem that our successor committee will have to address.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I omitted to say earlier that, as politicians, we tend to focus on cost rather than on people's capacity or ability to carry out additional work if they are entrusted with more resources. If this budget were to be increased from about £250 million to £500 million, it would mean that twice as much work would have to be done. Can the industry deliver that? The fact is that, instead of having to deal with peaks and troughs, it wants a long-term, secure, continuous flow of work. Indeed, according to, among others, Alan Watt from the Chartered Engineering Contractors Association, that is one of the industry's key demands.As far as the legacy paper is concerned, it might be relevant to point out to those who succeed us that when money is allocated they need to examine not only the figures but the capacity of the industry and local councils to deliver the greater volume of road and street improvements and pavement repairs that we require. Moreover, no matter who is in charge, the next Executive, perhaps very early in the next session, will have to come up with a long-term plan to ensure that those who engage local authority roads engineers and workers, and people who carry out work on trunk roads—very often both have contractual relationships and co-operate to solve the problem of local authority responsibility—know that there will be a secure and guaranteed increase in funding. In fact, they should know that as soon as possible in the next four years.I do not want to go on all afternoon—after all, I have a lot to say a bit later on—but I should point out that Dr Malcolm Reed, the head of Transport Scotland, told me not so long ago that there is no preparation pool in Scotland for trunk road projects. If, like the A74 project, the proposals for the Aberdeen peripheral route are taken to the Court of Session by fanatics and if the project has to fall as a result, the real victims will be the thousands of people throughout Scotland who rely on getting work from such projects, because there is nothing to fill their place. Continuity of work and the industry's capacity are as important—if not more so—than the headline allocation. It would be easy to say to local authorities, "Do 50 per cent more," but local authorities could just as easily say to us, "How? Where are the people to do all this work? Haven't you thought this through?" As the industry and local authorities have made clear, this is a real problem, and I hope that it can be included in our legacy paper.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

I suggest that we conclude our consideration of this petition by writing to the petitioner, drawing attention to the work that we have already done with SCOTS and to the Audit Scotland report. We should also highlight the points made by Fergus Ewing, with which I agree, on the requirement to take account of the capacity to deliver this work and the need for forward planning over a period of years.We will also draw the matter to the attention of the successor committee with responsibility for transport issues. I suppose that it could also fall within the local government remit; it all depends on whether our successor committee has the same combined role. In any case, we will recommend that the matter be examined by the committee or committees with responsibility for transport and local government issues. Are members agreed?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Local Government and Transport Committee Tuesday 27 March 2007 Committee business · 2
  2. Petitions Petitions · 12
  3. Petitions Petitions · 10
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 158

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.