Agenda item 2 is petitions. The first is PE528, on airport parking, which was submitted by MacRoberts Solicitors on behalf of Glasgow Airport Parking Association Ltd. This is the first time that we have considered the petition. I draw to members' attention a matter that I am sure they will all have spotted, because they will have avidly read their papers. The last page of the paper prepared by the clerk was missing, but it is now on members' desks. I will give them a few seconds to peruse it before I ask them to express their views.We could decide that the matter is worthy of further investigation and carry the issue forward, or we could decide that it is not worthy of further investigation at this stage and decide to note the petition. The third option is that we could hold final consideration of the petition back until we have a discussion on our work programme for the forthcoming year. We will have such a discussion sometime after the summer recess. I am happy to listen to members' views.
Official Report · Committee
Petitions
Scottish Airports (Access to Public Roads) (PE528)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Bristow Muldoon Lab 4
- Paul Martin Lab 2
- Fergus Ewing SNP 1
- David Davidson Con 1
The record
8 contributionsI read the papers that were originally circulated. It seems to me that it would be useful to get some further information. The Enterprise and Culture Committee seems—certainly in the evidence session that I saw—to have considered the petition along with other matters; it does not seem to have focused exclusively on the petition.In particular, I would like to know the extent to which other car parks are competing with BAA's and how the £5,000 charge that BAA is said to have made as a condition for access is influencing competition. In his evidence, Michael Hirst indicated that it was not at all uncommon for business travellers to find that they missed their plane because they could not get a place in a car park. This committee does not exist just to look after business people, but, if that is a problem, it is one that we would all wish to tackle. The petitioners gave evidence quite a long time ago and I would like to hear an update from them. For all those reasons—and various others that I will not go into now, for the sake of time—I think that it might be best to hold the petition over. We may not necessarily select it in our work programme, but I would like the committee to seek some more information and to consider the matter again once we have that information—perhaps in September, when we consider our work programme.
I support Fergus Ewing's comments. A number of questions arise from the evidence given by the minister and by Caroline Lyon, as reported in the papers that we have. I think that other issues may emerge—Helen Eadie certainly broadened the issue to include a number of other areas, such as taxis and access. We have two pieces of evidence from Caroline Lyon. When she was asked to confirm that no charges can be imposed under the byelaws, she said, "That is correct." However, when Nicol Stephen asked her a question, she agreed that the result of a commercial negotiation was perfectly legitimate if there was an agreed charge. We need to clear that up, particularly in light of the fact that there are currently no real park-and-ride or rail connections to allow people to park and take a train into some of our major airports. It would also be helpful to ask for written evidence from BAA, which is involved in the matter.
I take it that there is consensus that we should carry the petition forward until we consider our work programme for the forthcoming year and that there are a number of questions that members would like to pursue further before reaching a conclusion.
All that we have said is that we want to carry the petition forward, but we have not been specific about how we should deal with it. It is not the case that there are exclusive contracts only with airport parking. New shopping centres that are set up—I do not want to mention them by name—will have their own exclusive parking facilities and access to taxi services. Although supermarkets do not charge for parking, they have exclusive taxi services, and a wide range of hospitals now have parking charges and exclusive contracts. The issue arises in a number of areas. If we are going to carry the petition forward, we need to be specific about how we will consider it and how that will link in with the previous evidence that was taken.
I do not think that, at this stage, we are giving a commitment to carry out a formal inquiry into the issue. What has been suggested is that we delay consideration of the petition until we consider our work programme for the forthcoming year. That would leave it open for you to propose a broader line of inquiry into other areas of car parking that encompassed the issue raised in the petition.
I am not saying that we should not do that.
What I am saying is that, if you wanted to, it would be open to you to suggest further work. We are not making a decision here and now as to whether we will take the petition forward as a major item on our work programme. We shall simply postpone consideration of that question until our work programme meeting in September. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 21 Jun 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Local Government and Transport Committee Tuesday 21 June 2005 Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Petitions Petitions · 8
- Petitions Petitions · 4
- Petitions Petitions · 1
- Ferry Services (Clyde and Hebrides) Committee business · 17
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.