Agenda item 3 is consideration of petitions, some of which have been in the system since before the election. We have three papers before us, the first of which considers four petitions: PE420, which was submitted by Councillor Sam Campbell; PE567, from Mr Rab Amos on behalf of the Roslin bus action group; PE569, from William Cox; and PE642, from Christine Grahame MSP. The four petitions overlap in that they relate to bus services; in particular, they raise the question whether the legislative framework for bus services is sufficient to enable local authorities and communities properly to influence the bus industry. The Public Petitions Committee has asked this committee to consider the petitions and to decide whether to take further action on them, to refer them back to the Public Petitions Committee or to agree that they do not merit further consideration.When we considered our work programme, we decided to undertake an inquiry into the impact of the Transport (Scotland) Act 2001 and, in particular, the implementation of the aspects of the 2001 act that relate to quality partnerships and quality contract schemes. That post-legislative review will give us an opportunity to examine in close detail the operation of the bus industry in relation to the 2001 act and the opportunities for local government to influence that. Therefore, we could cover the issues that are raised by the four petitions as part of the inquiry. The paper from the clerks suggests—and I certainly recommend to members—that we respond to the petitioners, indicating that we intend to hold an inquiry, during which we will cover the issues that the petitions raise and examine their merit. I open up the meeting to members who would like to comment on the course of action that we should take.
Official Report · Committee
Petitions
Bus Services (PE420, PE567, PE569 and PE642)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Bristow Muldoon Lab 13
- Bruce McFee SNP 6
- Paul Martin Lab 4
- Iain Smith LD 2
- Andrew Welsh SNP 2
- Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab 1
The record
30 contributionsI agree largely with what you said, convener. It strikes me that the petitions are not really about whether bus services should be deregulated, but about the budget decisions and priorities of individual local authorities and the subsidies that they give to bus services. It is for the local authorities to address the specific issues that are raised in the petitions. The wider issue of whether the revised legislative framework is working is something for our later inquiry to consider.
First, I record apologies from Christine Grahame, who submitted petition PE642. She had hoped to be here, but she is convening the Health Committee this afternoon.Iain Smith said that the petitions are about particular issues with local authorities. There has been a temporary reprieve for the Meigle Street service, which is the case mentioned in PE642; the service has been taken over by another operator and runs with a different schedule. Scottish Borders Council will report on a review of bus services at the end of September. However, petition PE642 involves more than just the straightforward question of the reregulation of one specific service. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to"take the necessary steps to ensure that local authorities, when developing policies of social inclusion of the elderly, ensure provision of an adequate bus service for essential lifeline services in the areas for which they are responsible."If we want to promote social inclusion, it would seem strange not to look at the basic problem that people face, not only in rural areas but in other areas of the country, in accessing bus services either at any time of day or outwith peak periods. Petition PE642 raises an issue that should be considered by the committee and we should take it on board for further action.The Scottish Executive talks about joined-up thinking, but it is pointless for it to say that it promotes healthy lifestyles, community integration and the use of services while people—many of whom are at the bottom of the pile and rely on buses because they do not have the income to buy a car to get around—are denied access to those services simply because no bus service runs through or near the area where they live.I do not know the time scale for your proposal, convener, but I would say that the issue merits further action by the committee and that we should intimate our intention to accept the petition and to carry out further investigation. It may be that the results dovetail neatly with the question of quality bus partnerships and quality bus contracts, but I suggest that there is another aspect to the petition that the committee should consider.
Do you propose that we conduct a specific investigation into petition PE642, separate from the proposed inquiry?
Yes. I recognise that petition PE642 has a link with the other petitions, but it raises other issues that merit proper investigation.
I have some sympathy with Bruce McFee's comments. There is a distinction between the other petitions, which call for an adequate bus service, and petition PE642, which mentions "essential lifeline services". That gives petition PE642 a much greater degree of urgency. I notice that we will consider the more general issues, but the paper by the clerk simply says that we will do so later in the session. I seek assurances that we will do so sooner rather than later and that that work will not end up being an afterthought at the very end of the session. The convener proposes to include the matter in the consideration of quality partnerships and quality contract schemes, but that inquiry will come later in the session. Essential lifeline services are matters of considerable urgency.
I am persuaded more by Iain Smith's line. I understand what Andrew Welsh says, but the petitions fit neatly together and they fit into the item in our work plan on quality contracts and so on.
I will try to draw the discussion together. I realise that an alternative suggestion has been made by Bruce McFee, but my view is that the four petitions are all about the same issue. They might use different language and have a different emphasis, but they all raise the same issues—issues on which every MSP could draw examples from their own area, where communities have inadequate bus services. My view is that the issue is not sufficiently distinctive to petition PE642 for us to single out that petition. It would be better to consider the issue in the round.It would also be problematic for the committee to set a precedent by investigating in detail a petition that draws attention to the withdrawal of one specific bus service. We would soon be deluged with similar petitions from throughout Scotland and, having set the precedent, we would find it difficult to decline to examine other such petitions in the same detail. I do not deny that the issues are important. However, we should treat the four petitions with the same degree of importance, because they deal with overlapping issues.Andrew Welsh referred to time scales. We expect to commence an inquiry by early summer 2004, once we have got through the major pieces of legislation that we must consider, including members' bills, but particularly the local governance bill. That is the time scale that I envisage. I hope that that is helpful for members to know.
I listened to what you said, convener, but I think that it would be unfair to represent petition PE642 as a request to investigate the withdrawal of a particular bus service. As I said, a temporary solution, although not a full one, has at least come into play in relation to that withdrawal. That is something that we could replicate all over the country, which is why I suggest that we consider the whole issue of how local authorities incorporate transport provision into their social inclusion policies. It seems strange for transport provision to be omitted from those policies, because it is such a vital element.Frankly, the way in which to avoid being inundated from every part of the country with petitions such as petition PE642 is to investigate the issue to which it refers rather than say that if we investigate one such case we will open up the floodgates. I suggest that the reverse would be the case. If the committee considered the issue in detail—including taking elements from the other petitions, because there are similarities—perhaps we would not get the deluge of petitions on the withdrawal of bus services that I suspect we might otherwise get.
For clarification, I am not suggesting that we do not examine the issues or that they are not important. I am suggesting that we examine the issues as part of our inquiry.
I agree with the convener. If we go down the road of considering a petition because it uses buzz words such as "social inclusion" or "essential lifeline", there is a danger that we will not accept petitions that do not use such words. We must consider the merits of the case for each petition. Petition PE642 is clearly about the removal of a particular bus service. The conclusions that it draws about that removal may or may not be valid. Clearly, all local authorities should take into account social inclusion as part of their community planning and transport strategies. If they do not, they are probably failing to meet the guidance under the legislation. However, we can consider that as part of our examination of the effectiveness of the Transport (Scotland) Act 2001 and the quality partnerships.
For once in my life, I agree with Iain Smith. I will leave it at that.
Okay.
Although buzz words do not bother me, I am bothered about essential lifelines. I think that that aspect hauls petition PE642 out from the others. I also note that the convener said that that aspect would be covered by the inquiry, which should be in early summer 2004.
We seem to have two proposals. One is that we consider the issues raised by all the petitions as part of our inquiry. The other is Bruce McFee's proposal that we carry out specific work on petition PE642. Are you pressing that proposal, Bruce?
Yes.
In that case, the best way of resolving the issue is to vote on how we should deal with the petitions. The first proposal—outlined in the briefing paper—is that we indicate to the petitioners that we intend to consider the issues raised by the petitions as part of our inquiry. The second proposal, suggested by Bruce McFee, is that we consider evidence on petition PE642 at this stage.
Can Bruce McFee confirm exactly what his proposal is, because both proposals are pretty similar? Bruce McFee is asking for Christine Grahame's petition PE642 to be considered, but I understand that we are proposing that it will be considered with the others anyway.
Yes.
I wonder what the difference is. Can Bruce McFee clarify that?
My understanding—and Bruce McFee can correct me if I am wrong—is that he is indicating that we should carry out work on petition PE642 and take evidence on it now.
So he wants an inquiry into that petition.
I can help Paul Martin with this. I want an inquiry into petition PE642. I recognise that some issues are common to the four petitions, but any work that is done now would easily dovetail at a later stage with any further examination of quality bus partnerships and contracts. There is merit in that particular—
I do not want to reopen the argument.
I just feel that the committee should consider petition PE642 now.
If everyone is clear about the two options, I will put the question. The question is, that we accept my recommendation that we consider the issues raised by petition PE642 as part of the inquiry. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForJackson, Dr Sylvia (Stirling) (Lab)McMahon, Michael (Hamilton North and Bellshill) (Lab)Martin, Paul (Glasgow Springburn) (Lab)Muldoon, Bristow (Livingston) (Lab)Smith, Iain (North East Fife) (LD)AgainstMcFee, Mr Bruce (West of Scotland) (SNP)Welsh, Mr Andrew (Angus) (SNP)
The result of the division is: For 5, Against 2, Abstentions 0.It is agreed that we will consider the issues raised by all four petitions as part of the inquiry that we agreed to undertake into bus services, quality partnerships and quality contracts.
In this meeting
Everything on 30 Sep 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Local Government and Transport Committee Tuesday 30 September 2003 (Afternoon) Committee business · 1
- Items in Private Procedure · 5
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Petitions Petitions · 30
- Petitions Petitions · 8
- Petitions Petitions · 4
- Budget Process 2004-05 Committee business · 99
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.