Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Housing Support Grant (Scotland) Order 2009 (Draft)

Wednesday 18 March 2009 Local Government and Communities Committee Subordinate legislation 33 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

33 contributions
Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

Agenda item 4 is on an affirmative Scottish statutory instrument. I welcome back the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing, Nicola Sturgeon, from whom we are taking oral evidence on the draft Housing Support Grant (Scotland) Order 2009. The cabinet secretary is accompanied by Jamie Hamilton, a policy analyst with the Scottish Government. I invite the cabinet secretary to make any brief introductory remarks.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow Govan
link

The draft Housing Support Grant (Scotland) Order 2009 sets out the amount of grant that is payable in the financial year 2009-10. The purpose of the order is to provide grant to any local authority that could not otherwise balance its housing revenue account without raising rents to unaffordable levels. Only Shetland Islands Council, because of its high housing debt, continues to qualify for grant, and in 2009-10 it will receive around £1.4 million, payable in 12 equal monthly instalments. Shetland is an exceptional case given that its debt per unit of housing stock is more than four times the Scottish average level. Without the grant subsidy, its rent levels would have to increase from the current average of about £56 to around £72 a week. Currently, all other councils can balance their housing revenue accounts from rental income.

Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

Do members have any questions?

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

How did Shetland get into this state of affairs? When 31 other councils in Scotland can balance the books, why does Shetland Islands Council, which has benefited substantially from its oil fund for many years, need the Scottish Government to give it a housing support grant of £1.4 million?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow Govan
link

Obviously, I am not responsible for the period over which the council incurred its debt, but I will make a couple of points. First, Shetland's reliance on the grant is decreasing—this year's grant is around £200,000 lower than last year's. Secondly, although Shetland is now the only council that gets a housing support grant, that has not always been the case. Other councils have received support previously but do not require it now.On the reasons why Shetland is in this situation, the council has indicated that the expansion of the oil industry in the 1970s meant that council houses were required quickly to house the incoming workforce, and it had to incur high levels of debt to pay for the construction. There is a difference between Shetland and other councils in that other councils tend to borrow principally from the UK Government, whereas Shetland's debt is internal, as the money was borrowed from the council's reserves. Nevertheless, the debt charges still fall on the housing revenue account, which is why the account cannot balance without this grant.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

So Shetland is lending money to itself, and the Scottish Government is subsidising that, using the general body of taxpayers' money. Is that right?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow Govan
link

You would have to ask Shetland about the arrangements. It is a historical position, not something that is current, but I do not think that that changes the situation materially. Other councils have borrowed from the UK Government. The fact is that, without the grant, rents in Shetland would rise to unaffordable levels. That justifies the action that the order is taking.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

I can understand why someone might get financial support for borrowing from a third party such as the UK Government—that is what I would call a real debt—but someone borrowing from themselves as part of a book-keeping exercise and then getting financial support to pay their own interest sounds like the sort of financial jiggery-pokery that you might expect from some of the organisations that have come to prominence in the past few months.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow Govan
link

I do not think that that is a fair comment. Whatever the reasons for the debt—they predate this Government and they probably predate the establishment of the Scottish Parliament—we have a situation in which, without the grant, tenants in Shetland would bear the burden of unaffordable rents. That is not acceptable.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

I have a question on one of my favourite subjects, and it would be remiss of me not to ask it. If Shetland Islands Council were to transfer its stock, would the UK Treasury not write off that debt, thereby sparing us the need to pay a subsidy of £1.4 million a year?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow Govan
link

As I am sure you agree, the future of the stock is entirely a matter for the people of Shetland.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

Yes, but could you confirm, for the record, that the current deal on the table is that, if the council transferred the stock, the Treasury would write off the debt, which would mean that that money would come from Her Majesty's Government and the Scottish Government would not have to pay for the grant?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow Govan
link

I am not sure that that is the case in Shetland because of the different nature of the debt that I explained earlier. The UK write-off applies only to debt from the UK Government.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

In other words, real debts, not money you notionally owe yourself. Is that right?

Jamie Hamilton Scottish Government Housing and Regeneration Directorate
link

I am not speaking for the council, but Shetland could equally borrow that money from the UK Treasury. The option would be open to the council to do that if it wanted to.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

Then it could transfer its stock and get it all written off.

Jamie Hamilton Scottish Government Housing and Regeneration Directorate
link

That would be for the council to decide.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow Govan
link

Neither of us speaks for Shetland Islands Council, but we have a situation in which, without the order, tenants in Shetland would face rent hikes.

Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

This is an entirely innocent question—

Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

I assure you that it is. How do you set a fair rent? It occurs to me that people in my constituency are not paying a fair rent because they are already paying more than people pay in the Shetlands. We are working pretty hard to keep it down. I would not want to see a disproportionate hike in Shetland's rents, but how do we set a fair rent?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow Govan
link

I will reserve judgment on whether that is an innocent question but it is a fair question. There is no set level of rent that a council must hit before housing support grant can be paid and, as members will no doubt be aware, there is no precise definition in Scotland of what is an affordable rent. The figures that I used in my opening remarks are based on the average rent throughout Scotland, which is £56 a week. Without the support grant, Shetland would be looking at rents around £72. That is judged to be considerably above the average.

Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

I accept that, but in areas such as mine, people are paying £60-odd.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

How long are we likely to provide housing support grant to Shetland Islands Council? What period of borrowing did the council establish under the internal borrowing mechanism to build those houses? Was it a 30-year or 50-year period? Does the Scottish Government expect to be picking up the housing support grant for years to come?

Jamie Hamilton Scottish Government Housing and Regeneration Directorate
link

On current trends, the grant would dwindle away to zero in about seven years, but it depends on Shetland's finances over the next seven years: if they prove to be better, it will be less than seven years.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Is the figure that the cabinet secretary gave for the average rent—£56—the average weekly council house rent in Scotland?

Jamie Hamilton Scottish Government Housing and Regeneration Directorate
link

Shetland's rent is £56; the average council house rent is about £51.

Mary Mulligan Lab Linlithgow
link

If we did not provide the grant, would the necessary increase cause Shetland Islands Council to have the highest rents in Scotland?

Jamie Hamilton Scottish Government Housing and Regeneration Directorate
link

Absolutely. If you did a comparison today, that would be the case.

Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

That concludes our questions, so we move to agenda item 5. I ask the cabinet secretary to move motion S3M-3508.

Motion moved,

That the Local Government and Communities Committee recommends that the draft Housing Support Grant (Scotland) Order 2009 be approved.—Nicola Sturgeon.

Motion agreed to.

  1. Scottish Parliament Local Government and Communities Committee Wednesday 18 March 2009 Committee business · 1
  2. Equal Pay Evidence session · 104
  3. Child Poverty Evidence session · 80
  4. Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 4
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 33
  6. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6
  7. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  8. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 26

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.