Item 5 is consideration of the draft Crime (International Co-operation) Act 2003 (Designation of Participating Countries) (Scotland) (No 3) Order 2009, which is subject to affirmative procedure. I draw members' attention to the cover note in paper J/S3/09/31/3. The Subordinate Legislation Committee had no points to make on the instrument. I welcome Gerry Bonnar, from the Scottish Government's criminal procedure division, and Anne-Louise House, from the Scottish Government legal directorate, who join the cabinet secretary, Kenny MacAskill, for this item. Cabinet secretary, do you have an opening statement?
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Crime (International Co-operation) Act 2003 (Designation of Participating Countries) (Scotland) (No 3) Order 2009 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Kenny MacAskill SNP 12
- Robert Brown LD 10
- Bill Aitken Con 8
- Anne-Louise House Scottish Government Legal Directorate 1
- Stewart Maxwell SNP 1
- Bill Butler Lab 1
- Gerry Bonnar 1
The record
34 contributionsI will make a brief statement. I welcome the opportunity to contribute to the committee's consideration of the draft order and I hope that my explanatory comments are of assistance. The designations that will be made under the order are required to implement the United Kingdom's international obligations under the second additional protocol to the 1959 European convention on mutual legal assistance on criminal matters. The Crime (International Co-operation) Act 2003 provides statutory powers under which the UK can both seek and provide various forms of mutual legal assistance concerning criminal matters. Some of the statutory powers can be exercised only where the state in question is a participating country as defined in section 51(2) of the 2003 act. The draft order designates Albania, Bosnia and Herzogovina, Croatia, Israel, Montenegro, Serbia, Switzerland and the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia as participating countries in relation to sections 31, 47 and 48, and to paragraph 15 of schedule 2 to the 2003 act. It also designates those countries, with the exception of Switzerland, as participating countries for the purpose of section 6 of the 2003 act. Switzerland has already been designated as a participating country for that section.The effect of the designations will be as follows. Designation for the purpose of section 31 of the 2003 act will allow for persons in the UK to give evidence via telephone to a court in the designated countries. Paragraph 15 of schedule 2 to the 2003 act will ensure that the court in the designated country supervises. In many cases, a witness may not wish to travel to the foreign country; providing evidence by telephone is a method of ensuring that the interests of justice are served, without causing distress or inconvenience to a witness. The designation of the countries as participating countries in relation to sections 47 and 48 will mean that Scottish ministers will be able to facilitate the transfer of prisoners to and from those countries for the purpose of assisting with the investigation of offences. Designation in relation to section 6 means that service of a citation or other document must be done in that country by post, unless one of the listed exceptions applies. The aim of this direct transmission is to ensure that the relevant documents are served as expeditiously as possible.The Home Office laid before the Westminster Parliament, on 4 November 2009, a draft order making similar designations in relation to the provisions that apply in England and Wales. That order and this order will help to ensure that the UK meets its international obligations. I therefore invite the committee to recommend that the draft order be approved by Parliament.
Thank you, Mr MacAskill.
The instrument obviously looks pretty sensible for the most part, but I am struck by the power that Scottish ministers will have to facilitate the transfer of UK prisoners to a participating country. I am also struck by the presence of Israel on the list. I am not sure whether there are background issues here, but there have been, of course, matters to do with blockade, the position of Palestine and the interrelation between Israel and Palestine. Without wanting to go into detail on that, does the Scottish Government have concerns about any issues there? In particular, will the Scottish ministers' power be entirely discretionary so that it will lie entirely in their hands to make those decisions?
Basically, the order designates those countries as participating countries. In the instrument's operation, ministers will quite correctly remain constrained by the European convention on human rights. Extradition, for example, is dealt with elsewhere: as Cabinet Secretary for Justice, I have no say in such matters except in cases that involve the death penalty.We are simply seeking to close gaps. The countries in the list have, for various historical reasons, not been covered before, so together with the other parts of the UK jurisdiction south of the border we are moving forward to meet our wider European obligations.
With great respect, I do not think that you answered my question. Is the power of Scottish ministers to facilitate the transfer of a UK prisoner—not for extradition but to assist an investigation under section 47 of the 2003 act—entirely discretionary? I am aware that in certain civil matters the jurisdiction of foreign courts is dominant and there is no option to comply. I assume that we are not talking about that kind of situation.
As I said, the order will simply bring in the countries in the list. The provisions are dealt with by the member states of the Council of Europe, which issues the protocols that we sign up to. Quite correctly, the rules and regulations and procedures that we have to follow are dealt with in the main not by ministers but by the court system. Usually, a request is submitted to the Crown Office for determination and an application is made to the court. It is a legal matter, not only because we not only want to ensure that we do not have to deal with such matters but because, as you might imagine, one might have more concern about how political matters are dealt with in certain jurisdictions. The legal protections that are afforded as a matter of course will be afforded here.
I am sorry to have a third go at this question, but I am not sure that what you have said is entirely right. The explanatory note mentions powers for the Lord Advocate to facilitate certain things and, separately, the power for Scottish ministers to facilitate others. That sounds more like a Scottish ministerial process over which Scottish ministers have discretion than a court process. Is that power entirely discretionary or must a transfer be made if the other country seeks it? I assume that the power is discretionary, but I am finding it difficult to get confirmation of that from the cabinet secretary.
We have to act in compliance with ECHR: if we fail to do so, we will be open to judicial review. The primary mover in most such matters is the Lord Advocate, and the power for Scottish ministers is, in many cases, simply about facilitating legislation that will allow others to deal with them. It is not the desire of the justice directorate to take such issues in-house; they are quite correctly dealt with under the separation of powers.The Scottish Government is constrained by the ECHR, which, after all, is part of the Scotland Act 1998, so any such powers that we have are challengeable. As I have said, the issues at hand—and indeed many more issues under the Judiciary and Courts (Scotland) Act 2008, which has just received royal assent—are dealt with not by the justice directorates but through the court system, which is accountable to the Lord President.
Yes, but are the powers in question discretionary? I think that that is what Mr Brown wants to know.
The powers are challengeable because we have to act in accordance with legislation and ECHR.
Perhaps, convener, I can put this—
I think that you will have to specify to which powers you are referring.
I thought that I had already made it clear that I am referring to the power for Scottish ministers to facilitate the transfer of a UK prisoner to a participating country to assist in an investigation under section 47 of the 2003 act.
The short answer is no: that power is not discretionary. I will be required to act in accordance with the existing legislation, any amendment to which will require Parliament's approval. If the power is felt to be oppressive, it can be challenged under ECHR but, as I said, the Crown will deal with the mechanisms and procedures—
I am sorry to interrupt, but you said earlier that this is a matter for the courts, not for you. However, you now seem to be implying that it is a matter for you. Obviously the circumstances will not be quite the same as those surrounding Mr Megrahi's case, but the essential question is whether you have the right to say yes or no to such applications. Do you have automatically to comply with a request from a participating country—end of story, no discretion, no nothing—or are you able to consider the circumstances and say, "Yes, we will comply" or "No, in this instance and for various reasons that we think are good, we won't comply"? Do you have any discretion?
No. We require to implement the legislation that exists in terms of the protocols and international obligations that we have signed up to. In the main, implementation of those is not discretionary because it involves going through protocol and procedure. Such matters have to be supervised in court.
Why is it a power rather than a duty? What you have said implies that there should be a duty on Scottish ministers, but we are talking about a power. One would imagine that there would be a choice about whether to exercise it.
Caveats might well apply, as is the case with extradition—for example, if the potential existed for the death penalty to be used—but, in the main, such matters are dealt with entirely through the court and do not come to the justice directorate.
I am sorry, convener, but I am left in the position in which what the cabinet secretary is telling us does not seem to match what the paperwork suggests is proposed.
I will ask Anne-Louise House to comment.
Perhaps she can shed some light on the matter.
I do not know whether it is helpful to clarify that the relevant sections of the Crime (International Co-operation) Act 2003 make it clear that in relation to, for example, the transfer of a UK prisoner to assist an investigation abroad, there are certain conditions that require to be met before the prisoner can be transferred. Section 47 makes it clear that a warrant may be issued only if the prisoner consents or, in circumstances in which it is not appropriate for the prisoner to consent, a relevant person does so on their behalf.Another point is that the powers in question relate only to temporary transfer—you may have realised that already. Sections 47 and 48 of the 2003 act make it quite clear that the authorisation of a warrant involves the transfer of the prisoner and their return, so it is a temporary transfer rather than anything more permanent.
Can you confirm whether the use of the word "may" and the conditions that you mentioned mean that Scottish ministers have the discretion to say yes or no to a transfer and that that would be a proper exercise of their ministerial powers?
A warrant may be issued in respect of a prisoner, but the minister does not issue the warrant. Warrants are issued elsewhere. As the convener will know, in Scotland warrants are not issued by the Government. An application is made to the court. The issuing of warrants is a judicial function. It is not the Government that applies to the court for a warrant; in the main, it is the Crown or, in some cases, the police or the Scottish Crime and Drug Enforcement Agency that does so. It is a matter on which the powers of the Government are clearly separated from what is a function of the independent judiciary.
Could we continue to pursue the matter in an effort to get some clear information? I am not satisfied with what I am being told and I do not understand the system or the procedure. We seem to be getting mixed up between ministerial powers, court powers, Lord Advocate powers and warrants, and I would like to have a clearer view of the process. Maybe we have little option other than to approve the order. I did not anticipate that there would be a major issue, but I am afraid that I do not feel that I am being provided with satisfactory answers by the officials.
We will pursue the matter for a little while longer. I will revert to the minister.
Anne-Louise House's comments have provided a little clarification, but I share many of the concerns that Robert Brown has expressed. I, too, am not clear about what the process is. It might well be unfair, but some of us have concerns about people being automatically sent to some of the countries that are listed, even if, on paper, the transfer is temporary.Paragraph 1 of our cover note says that we must report to the Parliament by 30 November, so it seems that we have time to return to the issue. I had not anticipated that it would be quite such a confusing picture, although I was and remain slightly concerned about the transfer of prisoners. Before we take our final decision, it would be helpful if a step-by-step process could be laid down that shows what happens, who does what and what options there are.
I agree. If we have the time, no harm will be done. I am a bit confused about whether what is proposed is a power or a duty. In the best interests of all, including Parliament, we should defer a decision and get some clarification.
Are there any further questions of fact that might be helpful?
I have something to add about context, convener. This is number 3 of a series of orders. How the orders proceed has not been an issue on previous occasions, but I am sure that we can set out in writing for the committee the processes that are involved. I am sorry that we are not in a position to set that out more clearly today.On one point of clarification, the Scottish ministers' role is in facilitating the transfer of prisoners, which is separate from the granting of warrants and the like. We can set that out for you in writing, which might make it clearer.
If I detect the committee's mood correctly, there is some unease, especially bearing in mind the sensitivity of potential transfers to some countries, which might put us in situation with which we are less than comfortable. The matter is not entirely clear so, as Robert Brown, Stewart Maxwell and Bill Butler have suggested, it would be appropriate to continue the matter. As such, the best procedure would be for the cabinet secretary to not move the motion today.
Certainly.
You can come back to the next meeting with more information.That being the case, I do not think that we require you any further, Mr MacAskill. I thank you for your attendance.
In this meeting
Everything on 17 Nov 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Justice Committee Tuesday 17 November 2009 Committee business · 1
- Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 4
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 126
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 34
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.