Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Scotland Act 1998 (Modification of Schedule 4) Order 2009 (Draft)

Tuesday 5 May 2009 Justice Committee Subordinate legislation 32 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

32 contributions
Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

Agenda item 3 is evidence on the Scotland Act 1998 (Modification of Schedule 4) Order 2009, which is an affirmative instrument. Prior to the debate on the motion at agenda item 4, members may ask questions of the cabinet secretary and his officials on a matter that has been the subject of some controversy in the past. I draw members' attention to the cover note on the instrument. The Subordinate Legislation Committee did not draw any matters to the attention of this committee. SPICe has prepared a short background briefing paper.I welcome Kenny MacAskill, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice; Brian Peddie, the head of the European Union and international law branch; and Fraser Gough, a solicitor in the Scottish Government legal directorate.

Kenny MacAskill SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Justice · Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

The draft order stems from the judgment by the House of Lords in the Somerville case in October 2007. That judgment identified a significant legal anomaly in relation to time bar for human rights claims, which has resulted in substantial cost to the taxpayer by way of compensation payments and legal costs. I was pleased that there was strong support across the Parliament for our efforts to remove that anomaly and for the solution that was eventually agreed with the United Kingdom Government, which was announced in Parliament by the First Minister on 19 March. The draft order is the first stage in delivering that solution.As the Somerville judgment related to the wording of the Scotland Act 1998, before the problem that is highlighted by the case can be addressed, an order under section 30 of the act is required. That would give the Scottish Parliament competence to legislate to establish a one-year time bar for bringing human rights claims under the Scotland Act 1998, similar to the time bar that exists for claims under the Human Rights Act 1998. The draft order would achieve that. It has also been laid before the Westminster Parliament for approval, as required by the Scotland Act 1998.Assuming that the order is approved by both Parliaments, it will then be made by the Privy Council. A bill to amend the Scotland Act 1998 in relation to time bar will then be introduced in the Scottish Parliament. Our aim is to secure the passing of that bill before the summer recess, to enable the time bar to come into effect as soon as possible thereafter—all as announced by the First Minister last month.I hope that that brief explanation was helpful. I am happy to answer any questions.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you, Mr MacAskill. I remind members that we have received a letter dated 4 May from the Law Society of Scotland, which is pertinent to our considerations.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Good morning, cabinet secretary. As the convener stated, we have received a letter from Mr Clancy of the Law Society of Scotland. He states:"It is unfortunate that the Scottish Government did not take the opportunity to consult widely on this proposal as it will have the effect of limiting the capacity of many people, who may have had their human rights infringed by Scottish Ministers from taking appropriate action to vindicate their human rights."Do you share the Law Society's concern?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

I understand why the Law Society would welcome consultation; however, we had to act expeditiously. We could not move until there was agreement with the UK Government, although the matter was of great concern both here and south of the border. Once we had agreement, rather than compound the agony that is caused in many communities by people receiving money while they are serving sentences, we chose to move urgently. That is not the norm for us and it was not the norm for previous Administrations, but we reserve the right to protect the broader public interest. That is why we acted as we did.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

The Law Society also states:"It is a point of debate as to whether one year is the correct period for the time bar."You obviously feel that a year is the correct period. Why?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

That is the period that applies in the Human Rights Act 1998 and that is viewed as the norm in such matters, not simply in UK jurisdictions but elsewhere. We are satisfied with that. If others have other suggestions to make, we would be happy to consider them. Nevertheless, one year seems to be the appropriate period. The matter has been considered, consulted on and discussed, and we are happy that we now have that protection.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

There is always the fail-safe position that, on application and cause shown, the one-year period can be extended—is that not the case?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

Absolutely, as it is with other aspects of claims in Scotland on cause shown. The time bar period was considered in great detail before the Human Rights Act 1998 was passed and was viewed as providing the appropriate balance.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I am sure that I join many in welcoming the instrument, which puts Scotland in the same position as England and Wales. It is a matter of huge regret that it has taken us so long to do that. We all recognise that we have much better things to do with £50 million or so. Can the cabinet secretary give an indication of how soon he thinks that the measure can be put into effect and the £50 million can be moved from a reserve into front-line funding? We recognise the importance of doing that in today's climate.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

The member asks his question without wishing to indicate what is likely to happen under the next agenda item, of course.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

I can indicate what the First Minister has already indicated clearly. There are procedures to be gone through, and we seek to do so as expeditiously as possible. Good will from elsewhere has allowed us to address issues at the appropriate juncture. We hope to have dealt with the matter by the summer recess, if all goes smoothly. What follows falls within the financial domain. We want to ensure that the money is used to protect and preserve public services for good citizens, instead of being paid out to prisoners.

Robert Brown LD Glasgow
link

I want to explore two issues relating to the effects of the committee agreeing to recommend that the Parliament approve the order. Proposed paragraph 4A(4) refers to"such longer period as the court or tribunal considers equitable having regard to all the circumstances."It strikes me that that is a lesser test than the phraseology of prescription limitation legislation more generally, which refers to exceptional circumstances. Has the Cabinet taken a view on the extent to which the provision will allow other sorts of cases to go through—which is relevant to the £50 million that has been mentioned—and on which cases may be affected by the change from the existing three-year provision to the one-year period for which the instrument provides?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

The wording is lifted directly from the Human Rights Act 1998. As you and I know, different terminology and nomenclature are used in legislation north and south of the border. When setting the one-year limit, we considered the need to strike a balance. The wording that we chose does not refer to the ability to pursue claims outwith the triennium—the convener referred to claims outwith the period—but it is used in the Human Rights Act 1998. It is meant to be a fail-safe, where there is a manifest injustice that could not otherwise be recognised. We are open to suggestions. However, given that the wording appears in the Human Rights Act 1998, we believe that it is perfectly reasonable for us to incorporate it into the Scotland Act 1998.

Robert Brown LD Glasgow
link

Has any assessment been made of the extent to which this secondary option will be pursued and of the effect that that will have on the number of cases that come before the courts, both with regard to slopping-out arrangements and more broadly?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

Not that we are aware of. The assumption is that those slopping-out cases that have sneaked under the wire will have to be dealt with. Thereafter it is a matter for the courts, to some extent. I cannot prejudge what they may decide on any argument that is made, but it is fair to say that, once the one-year time limit has been set, the circumstances in which a longer period is considered equitable will have to be exceptional.

Robert Brown LD Glasgow
link

Can you or your officials give an indication of the sort of cases that may be affected by the provision? The Law Society of Scotland refers to people losing their rights as a consequence of the instrument. A consultation might have given a flavour of which cases would be affected. However, you have explained the reasons for not conducting such an exercise in this instance.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

Some of the same exceptions that apply to human rights cases subject to the triennium will apply to cases subject to the one-year limit. I refer to cases in which, through fault on the part of their lawyers or because they have slipped and broken their leg, people bring proceedings one week after the end of the limitation. There is a balance that needs to be struck. It is difficult to set absolute parameters for the circumstances that would apply.It is about manifest injustice. It is about circumstances beyond someone's control, because of ill health, incapacity or whatever. It is about providing that justice can be served by allowing matters to happen outside the one-year time limit, which is the approach that applies in Scotland in relation to the triennium or quinquennium. It is about ensuring that when something has gone fundamentally agley, and people have not just sat on their hands and failed to take action, the scales of justice can come down in favour of allowing a late application.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

It is difficult to envisage circumstances in which the kind of individual that we are talking about would not be very much on the ball about their claim.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Under the heading, "Policy Objectives", the executive note on the order says:"Under section 7(5) of the Human Rights Act, proceedings brought under section 7(1)(a) must generally be brought within one year from the date of the alleged breach, unless a stricter time limit applies to the proceedings in question."What circumstances do you envisage in that regard? Could a stricter time limit apply in the cases that we are talking about?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

The wording is a straight lift from the Human Rights Act 1998. Off the top of my head, I am not aware of proceedings that involve a time limit of less than a year, but there might be such instances. For reasons partly of urgency and partly of consistency, we simply took the wording from the Human Rights Act 1998, even though the act is perhaps written in more English than Scottish terms. There is no hidden agenda to target certain cases; it was simply about getting Scotland back in kilter with the rest of the UK, because UK bodies are protected whereas bodies in Scotland are not. That is the situation that we seek to remedy.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Was it deemed to be easier and better to go for equity throughout the UK and a one-year limit than to go for a limit of six months or nine months in Scotland?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

It was not simply about equity throughout the UK. The UK Human Rights Act was discussed and debated and much discussion and debate about the issue had taken place at European level. The one-year period emerged from those discussions. The Human Rights Act was passed contemporaneously with the Scotland Act, and the reason why we got into difficulties is that it was assumed that matters had been incorporated; there was no problem until legal eagles discovered the lack of protection for Scottish bodies. We are not seeking to reinvent the wheel; we are seeking to get Scotland into the position that we thought it was in until the Somerville judgment. We have simply sought to build in the protection of the Human Rights Act, which was the intention way back in the previous millennium, at the end of the 1990s, when the act was passed.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

Agenda item 4 is formal consideration of the motion to approve the order. I invite Mr MacAskill to move motion S3M-3961.

Motion moved,

That the Justice Committee recommends that the draft Scotland Act 1998 (Modification of Schedule 4) Order 2009 be approved.—Kenny MacAskill.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

If there are no comments from members, I take it that our consideration has concluded. The matter has been of considerable public concern, and considerable animosity has been directed towards the recipients of damages over the years, so the issue is fairly straightforward.

Motion agreed to.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice Committee Tuesday 5 May 2009 Committee business · 1
  2. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
  3. Judicial Appointments Board for Scotland Evidence session · 87
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 32
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 78

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.