Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Prisons and Young Offenders Institutions (Scotland) Amendment Rules 2008 (SSI 2008/377)

Tuesday 16 December 2008 Justice Committee Subordinate legislation 17 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

17 contributions
Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

The Subordinate Legislation Committee raised no points on the rules. Do members have any questions on them?

Robert Brown LD Glasgow
link

I have some concerns about the adequacy of the background information on these rules, the justification for which seems scanty. I am not against the proposal to make mobile phones prohibited articles—perhaps we should have considered doing so some time ago—but, at the same time as there was publicity about the matter, there was also publicity about violent PlayStation games, for example. One can envisage a number of other issues in the background.The use of mobile phones by prisoners is an important issue, and I would like to see a more substantial justification of how the problem has arisen at this stage and why it is necessary to introduce a separate statutory instrument now. I would also like to find out whether the Scottish Government plans a more comprehensive review of the rules—perhaps they will be dealt with in due course under the proposed criminal justice and licensing bill. It is unsatisfactory that the matter has been dealt with in this way. Are computers allowed in prison or not? Are there issues with e-mail access? A number of other issues arise, about which I would like to know more from the Government.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

To be honest, I am astounded that action on mobile phones was not taken years ago. It seems to me a given that those who are behind bars should not have access to them, for the simple reason that they would have the opportunity thereby to continue their criminal enterprises. For example, there was an episode in which a prisoner used a mobile phone to encourage violence against a third party outside the prison. The matter should have been dealt with some years ago—many years ago, in fact.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Robert Brown makes some telling points—as do you, convener. We should write to the cabinet secretary asking for clarification on the matters that have been raised. The criminal justice and licensing bill is on its way. Although we do not want to prevent the rules from coming into force, we need a response from Mr MacAskill on the matters that have been raised.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

I should mention to the committee that a paper dated 15 December, which answers some of our questions, has only just now been put before me. I propose to circulate it to the committee later. Nevertheless, having scanned the document in the time available to me, my initial reaction is that certain questions remain unanswered. Dependent on what Angela Constance has to say, we may inquire further.

Angela Constance SNP Livingston
link

My understanding is that, in practice, mobile phones are contraband. I have never known an establishment in which they were allowed. The point certainly requires clarification, but I wonder whether this is a case of the rules catching up with practice. Prisoners were certainly not allowed mobile phones when I was a prison social worker, although mobiles, among other things, were occasionally—or not so occasionally—smuggled into prisons.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Angela Constance is right, to my knowledge. If the rules come into force, it would become a criminal offence for a prisoner to have a mobile phone in their possession, whereas, at present, if a prisoner is found with a mobile phone, perhaps some perks that they have earned are taken away.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

Committee members are well aware of the difficulties that arise in prison discipline due to the operation of the European convention on human rights and the fact that prison governors are no longer considered independent tribunals. That is another issue.

Angela Constance SNP Livingston
link

Computers and, in particular, violent Xbox games such as Grand Theft Auto or whatever—members can see that I am really up to date with all that—raise interesting issues. I do not think that they are routinely considered contraband, but we are tapping into similar issues to do with pornography. I am not averse to all such issues being looked at. I think that members will find that pornography is not considered contraband in prisons—it can be accessed within Her Majesty's institutions. Xbox games contain some interesting scenes that can be revisited. In Grand Theft Auto, a player can beat up a prostitute, and that scene can be revisited. That is rather unhelpful for certain types of offenders, whose heads we are trying to get into and change. That was an issue in one of the institutions that I worked in latterly—I will not name it.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

It certainly seems highly unedifying.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

The rules close off what has been seen as a legal loophole, although, as Angela Constance and other committee members have said, other loopholes may still exist. I hope that the paper from the cabinet secretary gives members—including the convener—some comfort. However, if there are other areas that the convener or committee members think require investigation and clarification, we should pursue them.

Robert Brown LD Glasgow
link

I do not think that anyone round the table is against the proposal to extend the definition of "prohibited article" to mobile phone possession and usage and to add a criminal sanction. Unlike committee members who have some experience of these issues, I make no claim to be an expert on prison rules, but I wonder whether they ought to be reviewed in the light of developing technology and different practices and challenges in prisons. I can go only on newspaper reports on the issues that we have been discussing. There are specific issues to do with drugs, for example.I wonder whether the prison rules ought to be reviewed by the Scottish Government. Among other things, if the rules were in a code, if you like, that would get round any ECHR issues, which the convener rightly touched on—it would be a different sort of ball game. That should be the nub of what we say to the Government. Perhaps we can inquire whether there is to be a formal, comprehensive and considered review of the prison rules.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

The Government has to some extent anticipated us. In the paper before me it indicates that a full review of prison rules is being undertaken. The difficulty, however, is that the review is unlikely to be completed before 2010. I will arrange for the clerks to copy to committee members the Government's paper today and also to copy to them—probably tomorrow—a draft letter. Thereafter, if members wish to pursue issues, they can feed those back through the clerks and we will amend the letter accordingly. That would be the most sensible procedure.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

I understand that a review is taking place, but did you say that it will take a further 12 months? That is a considerable period, given that the review is focused on communication issues and technology, in which significant advances have been made. Twelve months is a particularly lengthy period. Perhaps the review could be brought forward so that we can consider the issues in more detail sooner.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

You are guilty of understatement, because the review is likely to take more than 12 months. While that strengthens your argument, I should say that the review will not be restricted to the aspects of technology that we are discussing today.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Following on from Paul Martin's comments, I propose that the committee consider conveying to the cabinet secretary our wish that, if possible, the period of time for the review should be telescoped and matters dealt with more expeditiously. Further, it might be worth while our asking the cabinet secretary—probably through the convener—whether legal loopholes that are similar to the one we are considering today could be dealt with by regulation in the meantime. That would be an efficacious approach. However, the review has to be quicker, if that is humanly possible.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is generally agreed. The Government's paper will be copied to committee members, along with the draft letter, once the clerks have had the opportunity to prepare it. Thereafter, committee members can submit any additional matters that they wish to raise, and the clerks will attempt to incorporate them into the letter. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice Committee Tuesday 16 December 2008 Committee business · 1
  2. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 5
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 17
  6. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6
  7. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  8. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.