Members will be aware that concern has been expressed about these regulations, on which representations have been received from the licensed trade. The committee has until 28 January to consider the regulations. Therefore, if members are so minded, we are in a position to take evidence on the regulations from the cabinet secretary at next week's meeting. However, I highlight the fact that any member who wishes to lodge a motion to annul the regulations will need to do so at the chamber desk before that meeting.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Licensing (Fees) (Scotland) Regulations 2007 (SSI 2007/553)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Bill Aitken Con 19
- Bill Butler Lab 9
- Margaret Smith LD 4
- Nigel Don SNP 4
- John Wilson SNP 4
- Paul Martin Lab 3
- Douglas Wands Clerk 2
- Cathie Craigie Lab 1
The record
48 contributionsWe all received representations from the trade, including from the Scottish Beer and Pub Association. For my part, putting those issues to one side, I am concerned about the way in which the matter has been handled. The regulations were laid at the 11th hour. In effect, the committee is in a fait-accompli situation where a delay would have an impact. We should ask the cabinet secretary next week—and we should ask our clerks—what the impact would be of our trying to delay the regulations while the key issues are considered. We want to consider a number of issues further, so I suggest that we take evidence from the cabinet secretary next week.The trade has clearly outlined its concerns, but there is also an issue about the handling of the matter. The regulations went out to consultation on the back of research that cost the public purse thousands of pounds. The consultation was undertaken on the basis that the fees would double, but by the time the regulations were laid the fees had doubled again. In effect, the fees quadrupled without the trade or anyone else who was party to the consultation being told that there had been a substantive change.There are also some omissions. For example, there do not appear to be fees for the transfer of licences. We are told in the paperwork from the Government that it is trying to take an equitable approach, yet the regulations deal with private clubs in a different way, which in effect requires the trade to cross-subsidise them.There are issues about both the fees and the policy, but there are also concerns about the way in which the regulations were consulted upon and, therefore, the position that the committee has been put in. Many questions exist, so it is regrettable that, if we annulled or knocked back the regulations, I understand that that would have an impact on the time that is specified for bringing the regulations into force.It could be argued that the fees for publicans and traders whose premises have lower rateable values are not large—none of us would argue that they are—but they are being introduced in the context of other issues for the trade and the fact that we still await further indications from the cabinet secretary of what will happen under the polluter-pays direction of travel that he has adopted. This is a period of flux and change for the trade and I share its concern about how it has been treated in relation to the regulations. I would like the cabinet secretary to appear before the committee to answer our questions.
My view has always been that the trade should meet the costs of regulation and that fees should reflect that. However, we should refer to the trade on such costs and ensure that whatever fees local authorities charge are intended only to regulate and not to profit from the market.We require further information on several aspects of the regulations. Consultation of various licensing stakeholders took place from June to September 2007 and I would welcome sight of the responses. If local authorities raised substantial concerns about the level of fees, the committee must reflect on that. If local authorities did not say that fees were required to be significantly increased, that would raise the question of why we have reached the present stage. We also need a more detailed paper on the research that has been undertaken on fees both previously and more recently and which resulted in the Government's proposal to double fees.I have always been firm on ensuring that the licensed trade meets its responsibilities, but the Government also has a responsibility to be fair to the trade, which it does not appear to have been in the regulations. The cabinet secretary will have his opportunity to respond to that.
I agree with Paul Martin. I think that we all agree that the trade should meet the cost of regulation—there is no argument about that. As Paul Martin and Margaret Smith said, a variety of questions needs to be put to the cabinet secretary. I would welcome the committee inviting him to come along to answer the concerns.I do not know whether it is possible, but could we ask the cabinet secretary or his officials to write to tell us why, when the regulations were laid on 10 December 2007, the fees were double those that had been consulted on? That would mean quadrupling fees, as Margaret Smith said. I would appreciate seeing the rationale for that, which we do not have. If we had that reasoning, we would be better able to interrogate the cabinet secretary with some specificity.
We will write to ask for that information.It would be useful for the paper that the clerk will produce to contain comparators—to show how much a public house at the lower end of the scale pays now and how much it would pay under the regulations and to extrapolate that to a three-year figure, bearing it in mind that renewals will not be the issue that they once were. That would give us a balanced comparison.
As we are asking for specific information, can we also ask for guidance on the new licensing standards officers that are introduced under the Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005? The regulatory impact assessment points out that there must not be a funding gap for those. This may show my own ignorance, but I would like some idea of how many such officers people think that there should be, what they will do and how much that will cost.
It is not a question of your ignorance but that you were not a member of the Parliament when the legislation was considered by the then Local Government and Transport Committee about three years ago. I am sure that the relevant papers would have been submitted at that time. We can probably rely on the good offices of the clerk to ensure that you are provided with copies of anything useful in that respect.
My point is that we perhaps need an update on how many licensing standards officers councils think that they might need. Councils might now have a better view of those costs, on which they could only speculate three years ago.
We should be able to compare the situation when the legislation was passed with the likely situation today, given that local authorities have now taken on staff to ensure that they have the appropriate number of licensing standards officers. That calculation should be fairly simple once we have the information. Are you satisfied that we ask for that?
Yes.
I agree with the concerns that colleagues have raised. I seek clarification on what the convener said in his opening comments about the requirement to lodge a motion to annul with the chamber desk prior to our next meeting. What status would such a motion have if our questions were answered when we hear from the minister and other interested parties? Could the motion then be withdrawn?
Once such a motion was lodged with the chamber desk, the motion would become the property of the committee. On the basis of the motion, we would then have to decide at the conclusion of next week's deliberations either to accept or to reject the regulations. However, if the member who lodged the motion was generally satisfied that the cabinet secretary's assurances were acceptable, the motion need not be moved. As such, the motion would automatically fall.
Nigel Don asked how many licensing standards officers will be required and what they will cost. I understand that, as part of the research that was undertaken, licensing authorities were asked what they thought their costs would be under the new regime. I think that I am right in saying that those costs would have included the cost of taking on licensing standards officers. Clearly, as Paul Martin pointed out, we need a better understanding of what the research actually covered. That would probably pick up that point.Another small matter is that somewhere in the paperwork that we received—I have been unable to find the reference again—the Government uses phraseology about the need for fees to have a relationship to the costs involved. Although I accept the point that local authorities need to cover their costs through the fees, the phraseology used is a little bit less clear. Rather than provide licensing authorities only with the ability to cover their costs, the regulations may give a degree of flexibility that allows them to raise funds that more than cover their costs. Perhaps the clerks could check that out for us.Further to Cathie Craigie's question, I suggest that it would be prudent for us to lodge a motion to annul, which I hope need not be moved once we have had the evidence session next week. Perhaps the convener could give some thought to lodging such a motion on behalf of the committee to ensure that we have that opportunity.
I will give that some thought but, of course, another option is open to the committee, which is that if we are not satisfied at the end of our deliberations, we can simply reject the regulations.
I am seeking a way forward that does not necessarily lead us to the nuclear option, because people often step back from that. If we take on board some of the issues, but we do not accept what the minister says to us next week, we want a range of options to be available to us. I hope that by the time we get to next week, we do not have to take any of those options and that we can simply step back and accept what the minister says.
I will reply to that in a second.
Just to help Margaret Smith out, I suspect that she was looking at regulation 13, which includes the phrase:"are likely to be broadly equivalent to the expenses".I am grateful to Margaret Smith for bringing that up because if we are going to pick over the regulations, it might be useful if someone told us what that phrase actually means in statute. I do not know whether it is a typical term.
Would it be appropriate for the committee to take evidence from the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities or some other representative body of the licensing authorities, so that we are aware of the strength of feeling about the case for capping the fees at a higher level? If the minister wants to make a case on behalf of the licensing authorities, that is up to him, but it would be helpful to hear from them either in writing or through taking oral evidence.
Having heard what Paul Martin said, I think that it would be sensible to ask COSLA for some written evidence, so that that is before members and therefore need not take up any time during our next meeting.I have a question for the clerks, convener. Margaret Smith talked about a range of options. I might be wrong—it would not be the first time—but there is not really a range of options. A motion to annul has the same effect as voting down an instrument. If we really feel that we are not persuaded by what the cabinet secretary has to say, we can take the nuclear option, although I hope that we will not have to. There is nothing additional to be gained by lodging a motion to annul. I ask the clerks to let me know whether I am correct.
For a negative instrument, either the committee can simply note the instrument as made, and it would pass through the Parliament, or a motion to annul can be lodged. If it is agreed to by the committee, that motion would then require the Parliamentary Bureau to schedule some time in the chamber for the full Parliament to consider the instrument. If a motion to annul is lodged by a committee member, the committee would require to consider it at its next meeting with the involvement of and a contribution from the relevant Scottish minister. The committee would then reach a decision on the motion at the end of the debate.
That would give the committee greater ability to interrogate the cabinet secretary and use parliamentary procedure rather than simply voting down the regulations.
Yes, indeed. In fact, the only way to vote down the regulations is to lodge a motion to annul.
I am grateful. That clears it up, convener.
That was a useful contribution, and it enables me to come back to Margaret Smith's point. A motion to annul would be the best way of proceeding because the matter is controversial and, at the end of the day, it might be one on which the full Parliament should make a determination.
On that point, are you saying that, as convener of the committee, you would be willing to lodge a motion to annul the regulations, which we could keep in our back pocket, but which we hope would not have to be moved?
The problem is that, if I were to do that, I would be committing myself in advance of hearing what the minister has to say.
With respect, convener—
I know what you are coming to. To some extent, I am thinking aloud, which I am entitled to do. As I see it, we can arrive at a determination in two ways. First, the committee can consider the representations that are made next week and then vote against the regulations, in which case there would be no further option. However, if a motion to annul were lodged, the matter would go back to the Parliament. That is obviously the preferred option and I will ensure that an appropriate motion is lodged.
Would it help if, rather than your lodging such a motion, the deputy convener was prepared to do so? That would free you up to convene the meeting.
Any member can lodge a motion to annul.
Any member can do so, but the deputy convener could take responsibility for lodging the motion on behalf of the committee.
Is Mr Butler prepared to take that responsibility?
I am prepared to discuss with you which of us would be the most appropriate member to lodge the motion. I do not have a problem with that. The main objective is to do what serves the committee and, ultimately, the Parliament best.
I am just proposing that you follow a guide that I use in public life for the chairmanship of meetings, convener. That would be fairer on you.
Your point is well made.
I follow that same guide. It is by Citrine and it is very good.
There is general agreement that there is concern about the regulations. Interruption. I am sorry, does someone else have a comment?
I want to address the point that was made about the fees that the regulations seek to set. I note the comment that the cabinet secretary made at the foot of his letter to the committee, where he talks about calling on the Accounts Commission to investigate the fees that boards set, so there is a back-up as regards the fees that will be applied. The Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005 said that boards should only set fees that allow them to recover their costs and should not profit from fees that are excessive.
That is perfectly correct, but it is perhaps more a matter for next week's meeting.
I am sorry to labour the point, but in relation to John Wilson's point about the independence of the convener, my understanding is that a committee convener can move any motion or amendment that they wish to. When the convener considers the matter offline, after the meeting, he should be clear that if he were to move a motion to annul the regulations next week, that would not present a difficulty as regards his convenership.
A problem would arise if, once I had listened to the arguments, I did not wish to move the motion. At that stage, it would be up to another member to move it. That would seem to resolve that difficulty.Do members have any other points, before I try to pull together the threads of our discussion?
You should pull together the threads of the discussion.
First, it is agreed that consideration of the regulations be continued next week, when we wish to take evidence from the Cabinet Secretary for Justice. We will also seek written evidence from COSLA. The decision on who should lodge a motion to annul is remitted to me and the deputy convener, with the agreement of the committee that such a motion will be lodged, for use in the event of the committee not being satisfied. Is that a reasonable summing up of the situation? Margaret Smith clearly thinks not.
There is just one omission, which relates to the technicalities. We have received substantial representations from the trade. If we are to ask for written evidence from COSLA, we could keep ourselves right by asking the trade whether it is content for the written submissions that it has made to us so far to stand or whether it would like to add to them. We should ensure that there is a balance. The trade might have some thoughts on what has transpired today, for example. I would much prefer us to go into next week's meeting in the knowledge that there was a proper balance in the evidence that we had taken from COSLA and the trade and what we were to hear from the minister. That is one small additional suggestion.
We will ask the trade whether it wishes to supplement the written evidence that we have already received. Is that agreed?
Members indicated agreement.
That concludes the public part of the meeting. I thank the members of the public for their attendance and ask them to withdraw.
Meeting continued in private until 12:38.
In this meeting
Everything on 15 Jan 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Justice Committee Tuesday 15 January 2008 Committee business · 1
- Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill Bill debate · 13
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 40
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 48
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.