Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths Inquiry (Scotland) Act 1976 (PE767)

Tuesday 11 December 2007 Justice Committee Petitions 7 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

7 contributions
Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. I remind everyone to switch off their mobile phones. I have received no apologies—we have once again a full turnout of members.The first item on the agenda is consideration of petitions. PE767 is by Norman Dunning, on behalf of Enable, and calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to review the operation and effectiveness of the Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths Inquiry (Scotland) Act 1976. As members will recall, we have considered this petition before. Since then, we have received correspondence from the Cabinet Secretary for Justice.I draw members' attention to the options listed in paragraph 9 of paper J/S3/07/13/1. Are there any comments?

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Like other members, I have looked carefully at the clerk's paper and the cabinet secretary's response. However, I feel that certain points still need to be developed and questions answered fully.First, as we all know, legal aid presents no problems for people who either have no means or are very rich. However, those of middling means will find that their costs, which might run to £20,000 or £30,000, are insupportable. There is no real support for those families and individuals; moreover, they do not receive any victim support money, which is another outstanding issue.Secondly, as far as delays are concerned, I believe that the cabinet secretary says that most FAIs are held quickly. That is true, but only when they are not contested. My information is that when a case is contested it might drag on and on with delays of up to three or four years because of adjournments.Another issue that needs to be addressed is the fact that, at a cost of perhaps more than £100,000, these inquiries are also hugely expensive to the taxpayer.I acknowledge the cabinet secretary's comment that FAI recommendations will be monitored through postings on a website. However, such a step is small and quite insignificant and is certainly not what the petitioners were looking for. Such recommendations need to be monitored in some proper way by the justice department.I am not content with the suggestion that we close the petition, as I think that there are more issues to be considered, some of which I have outlined. We might want to write to the cabinet secretary with those supplementary questions. If we agree to send that letter but receive a similar response from the cabinet secretary, would it be possible for us to refer the matter of the review of the operation of the 1976 act to the Scottish Law Commission? Perhaps the clerks could advise us whether it would be within our power to do so. We should consider doing that, given that the law has been on the statute books without a review.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

That point is well made. One difficulty that we would have is that it would not be possible for us to refer the matter directly to the Scottish Law Commission. However, we could recommend to the Cabinet Secretary for Justice that that be done. Bill Butler has made some sound points that are worth following up.

Margaret Smith LD Edinburgh West
link

I find myself largely in agreement with Bill Butler. Members might be aware that I have intimated a wish to introduce a member's bill that would touch on FAIs, in the sense that it would deal with the deaths of service personnel overseas. Currently, their families have to engage with the coroners court process in England. In some cases, there can be a delay of anything up to five years. I am investigating that situation at the moment and I thought that I had better preface my comments by saying that I have an on-going interest in the wider FAI issue. As a constituency member, I have had a couple of quite distressing cases involving families who have felt let down by the FAI process and the way in which they have been dealt with. I would like to clarify something on page 3 of the cabinet secretary's letter to us. He says:"Inquiries are mandatory in cases of death as a result of an accident in the course of employment or in legal custody."Of course, that is true only if there is no other legal case. If there is another legal case, fiscals will often decide not to hold an FAI—even if that is against the wishes of the family. It would be useful to clarify that point with the cabinet secretary, just so that we have the full picture. There is an issue about how relatives are dealt with. I note that the cabinet secretary says that that has been the subject of training, but I think that we could do with a bit more information about what that training has entailed. I share Bill Butler's concerns about the situation in relation to FAIs, legal aid and victim support. I think that the response on the monitoring of recommendations does not go far enough. Therefore, I am minded to suggest that we keep the petition open and ask the cabinet secretary about certain points. Next year, we will probably face a much tighter business programme than we have had to date—as I am sure you are well aware, convener—but I would prefer us to keep the petition open, pending consideration of the work programme and any further response from the cabinet secretary.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

Again, there is not much that I would disagree with in those words. I should underline the fact that the Crown would be inhibited in the event of a fatal accident inquiry and a prosecution coinciding. Clearly, the Crown could not hold an FAI if the evidence that would be heard during the FAI would be largely identical to that which would be heard in, for example, a murder trial, as that could be prejudicial. If I detect the mood of the committee correctly, I think that our view is that we should keep the petition open. Members will recollect that, before the meeting, we discussed informally whether the issue raised in the petition might be worthy of inquiry, in connection with a wider issue, when the time becomes available. I suggest that, in the meantime, we keep the petition open and write to the cabinet secretary in line with what Bill Butler said. Once we have received a reply, we can revisit the petition with a view to taking any further action that we consider necessary. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Margaret Smith LD Edinburgh West
link

Can we also ask for more information about the extra training that has been undertaken in relation to relatives?

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is fine. We will incorporate all those comments and questions into the letter that we send to the cabinet secretary.

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice Committee Tuesday 11 December 2007 Committee business · 1
  2. Petitions Petitions · 7
  3. Petitions Petitions · 6
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6
  5. Budget Process 2008-09 Committee business · 9

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.