We now move to the witnesses who are here for item 2 on the agenda, on the recent announcement of cuts in funding to the Scottish Prison Service.Although the order on the agenda indicates that we will hear the trade union side first, then the chief executive of the Scottish Prison Service, I think it might be more appropriate if we were to hear Tony Cameron first. I ask Tony Cameron to come forward. We will hear evidence from him and from the Scottish Prison Service first and then we will allow the trade union side to give evidence.I understand that Mr Cameron is accompanied today by Mike Duffy, board member and director of the south and west area of the Scottish Prison Service. Good morning, Mr Duffy. I know Mr Duffy from a different job. Mr Cameron is also accompanied by Peter Russell, director of human resources, and by Alastair MacIntyre, non-executive director.I understand, Mr Cameron, that you wish to make a short opening statement before we proceed to questions. Please begin that statement now, but keep it reasonably tight, as I am sure that members have a lot of questions to ask.
Official Report · Committee
Scottish Prisons
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Tony Cameron Scottish Prison Service 144
- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 43
- Christine Grahame SNP 42
- Phil Gallie Con 29
- Derek Turner Scottish Prison Officers Association 26
- Pauline McNeill Lab 24
- Tricia Marwick SNP 15
- Lyndsay McIntosh Con 14
- Scott Barrie Lab 11
- David Melrose Scottish Prison Service Trade Union Side 9
- Andrew Hogg Scottish Prison Service Trade Union Side 6
- Euan Robson LD 6
- Gordon Jackson Lab 4
- Alastair MacIntyre Scottish Prison Service 2
- Maureen Macmillan Lab 2
- Mike Duffy Scottish Prison Service 1
- Peter Russell Scottish Prison Service 1
The record
380 contributions · showing 1–200Convener, you wrote to me on 4 November and I replied on 11 November, explaining the financial background to this issue. I also enclosed my note of 21 October to all Scottish Prison Service staff and some question and answer material which we provided for them.On 15 November, I sent all members of this committee a news release from the SPS, with our announcement. I wrote to you, convener, on the same day and provided further Q and A material which we used with our staff. I assume that all members have seen the material.The news release contains the main decisions that the SPS board has taken but, on Monday, to assist the committee, I sent a copy of the paper which the board considered when meeting to discuss the issue. I would like to say a few words about that. It is not a formal report, but an internal management document which assisted our decision taking. It is not a record of the board's decisions, but the board accepted the paper's main conclusions.The board decided to place greater stress than the paper placed on one aspect which I want to mention: the capital programme and what we call our estate strategy. We asked ourselves if we agreed to re-evaluate our use of the Low Moss prison site. The board thought that a strategic examination of the capital programme as a whole was needed in relation to the reduced number of sites. The Scottish Prison Service will be working on that examination next year.We have planned our announced rationalisation programme to minimise the operational impact across the service. We have tried, where possible, to ensure that the valuable programmes that are under way throughout the service are continued. Our task now is to complete the rationalisation programme as soon as possible without disrupting that valuable work. My preferred approach is for the SPS management and the trade union side to work together.I want to finish by underlining one important point: apart from Alastair MacIntyre, we are all civil servants and public servants, as are prison officers and all SPS staff. Our salaries—and all the money we spend—are paid for by the taxpayer, who has a right to expect the very best value for money for every pound allocated to us. That is what we aim to achieve.
Thank you. I anticipate a fair number of questions.I would like to go through the letter that you sent on 11 November in response to my letter on behalf of the committee, dated 4 November. I would like to clarify some of the things in your letter, then we can move on to other questions. In my letter, I asked for an explanation of how the money, which is now being clawed back, had been saved over the years. Your response in your letter was:"The Scottish Prison Service generated savings in running costs budget heads of £13m".Your letter continued:"That was prudent financial management in accordance with the end-year flexibility (EYF) Rules applicable to SPS as an Agency of the then Scottish Office. . . . This funding was earmarked to support the restructuring of our resources".When you say that the SPS"generated savings in running costs budget heads",what budget heads were those savings generated from?
In all.
The committee has expressed a desire to know how the money was accrued in the first place: what savings were being made in what areas. It was money that was clearly not being spent in the Prison Service and which was being piled up. We are making no judgment about that, of course, because there may have been good reasons for it, but we are curious to know from which budget heads the savings were generated.
One answer to that is to regard the savings of £13 million like any other £13 million that the Scottish Prison Service would have had to spend. It is no different in pound notes from any other pound notes that the SPS would have spent. In that sense, the £13 million was due to be spent on everything that the Prison Service spends its money on. Over the two years, it is of the order of contributing 3p in every pound that the Scottish Prison Service will spend.It might be more helpful for the committee if I take a step back and sketch out how the finances of the Prison Service work.
It was a fairly simple question in fact, Mr Cameron. I am not making a value judgment. The committee simply wishes to know from which aspects of Prison Service spending the savings were made. We can then make a judgment on what money was not spent over the two years to accrue the £13 million, and on what was planned for the future.
The answer is all: that is the simple answer to the simple question.
Were the savings evenly spread from across all budget heads?
No. They were not evenly spread; they were from different years. A large number of years are involved, and it would be incredibly complex and expensive for the taxpayer for us to go back over all those years now and calculate all the differences over the many thousands of things on which the SPS spends money.
So, in your evidence, you cannot actually tell us how the savings were accrued?
I can tell you how they were accrued: they were accrued from the total budget. They were, if you like, in proportion to our expenditure.The SPS, as an agency, has two types of finances. The intention is that its financial affairs should be run more like those of a business than is the case for a normal Government department. We produce income and expenditure and a balance sheet, like a business. We operate on what is called accrual accounting, in which income and expenditure are scored when the decisions are taken, not when the cash is received or spent. Although we keep an eye on the cash flow, as businesses do, the main focus of our attention is on our accrual accounts.We also have to operate as a Government department. Until now, Government accounting has been purely in cash. Each year, cash is allocated by Parliament. It has long been recognised, however, that there are expenditures that need to straddle the ends of financial years. Such expenditures can be on anything: they require cash to be carried forward, which is what gives rise to end-year flexibility.The £13 million was spending power generated by internal savings across the board, which any business might prudently accumulate over the years from its operating profit.
So there is no particular pattern to the way that those savings are generated. It is like having a massive piggy-bank. Every time that a few pence were saved here or there, you put them in the piggy-bank rather than putting them back into spending under the budget head that they came from.
That is not the analogy that I would use, but it is in the right direction. We would have spent the money in a cost-effective manner at the appropriate time.
On what?
On everything that the SPS spends its money on.
With respect, I do not think that that is a reasonable answer. You were saving the money: it was obviously being saved for a purpose.
Yes.
The announcement that you were not going to be able to spend that saved money resulted in a great deal of speculation. What was the plan for that money?
In one sense, the money can be regarded as having contributed 3p in every pound spent by the SPS over the next two years.
Well, what does that mean, Mr Cameron?
It is salaries, current, capital—
But what does that mean in practice?
Salaries, buildings, heat, light, power: everything that a business spends money on.
Which, presumably, is already budgeted for?
Yes.
What was the extra £13 million going to be spent on?
It was not extra. It was part of the SPS's total spending power, and was shown in our accounts accordingly.
And then taken away?
Absolutely.Parliamentary authority is required to carry funds forward from one year to another. At that point, the £13 million has to be identified; it did not really exist in our accounts as a separate item. It was just part of our spending power.Let us look at it this way: if ministers had decided to reduce the Scottish Prison Service's baseline expenditure by the same amount, £13 million, the financial effect on the SPS would have been exactly the same over those two years. The fact that it was done using EYF does not alter the fact that the total spending power of the SPS was reduced by £13 million to deployment elsewhere in the justice programme.
But the £13 million happened to be accrued savings that you had made in the equivalent of a piggy-bank.
It was part of £24 million that we had accrued. We did not accrue £13 million; we accrued £24 million. We retained £11 million of it, and £13 million has been redeployed elsewhere.
As a direct result of the cuts in the budget, we now have the announcements of prison closures and job losses, of which we have all received details. Is that correct?
No.
Are you telling this committee that the announcements about job losses and prison quotas have absolutely nothing to do with the £13 million cut?
No.
What are you saying? What do you mean by no? Do the announcements have nothing to do with the cut, or do they have something to do with it?
They have something to do with it, but your first question was whether the announcements were a direct result of the cuts.Prior to the last expenditure statement by the Minister for Finance, it was evident that the Scottish Prison Service would need to reduce its staff. That was made plain to the trade union side at a meeting with them in the spring of this year, before the figure of £13 million was known about as a separate item. That was the position then.The relevance of the announcement that I made a few days ago is that it accelerated the process of downsizing the Scottish Prison Service. We would have had to reduce our estate and the number of staff in some way in any case. The difference is that we are having to do so more quickly than we had planned.
I have a copy of a minute from a meeting that took place in the spring earlier this year, when your predecessor, Mr Eddie Frizzell, was the chief executive. The minute, from April this year, states that:"The staffing complement had drifted up and currently stood at 5000, and would have to come down a little over 3 years. Natural wastage should allow that."
Yes.
Is that what you are referring to as advice that job losses would be of the order of 400?
I did not say 400. I said that we would have to reduce our estate; 400 is approximately the number of staff that the financial information suggested that we would need to lose.
The minute mentions staff numbers coming down a little over three years and says that:"Natural wastage should allow that."Do you consider that to be adequate notice of what was subsequently announced?
I cannot speak for my predecessor. We notified and quantified the amount of loss of posts because the number of prisoners was not rising as fast as has been previously estimated. Four hundred is the approximate number, and natural wastage would have enabled us to remove approximately that number of posts, as about 130 posts are lost by the Prison Service each year.
Do you accept, Mr Cameron, that the report of HM chief inspector of prisons for Scotland, published in August of this year, was a fairly accurate reflection of circumstances in the Prison Service?
Yes.
That being the case, you show figures today which project a rise in the number of prisoners over the next couple of years, but you suggest that the current number is around 6,000.
Yes.
Why, then, when compared with the chief inspector's report, does that represent about a 20 per cent drop in the number of prisoners since August this year?
In August, the statisticians produced revised estimates of the prison population.
I am not talking about estimates; I am talking about precise figures. Your figure for 1999-2000 is a precise one of 6,000. It should be 6,100 but is actually 6,000. The chief inspector's report suggests that in August 1999, there were 7,025 people in prison.
Really? I do not recognise that figure.
Can I refer you to annexe 4 of that report, which shows the average daily prison populations. The total of those figures is 7,025.
Without checking, I could not comment on that.
When you are making a major decision, as you have done, on prison numbers and the closure of prisons, surely you should be in the position to give a reasonable, off-the-cuff, answer about why that difference exists.
No, I do not agree. It is important for us to focus on the numbers that our statisticians produce. Those are—
Never mind the facts. If the statisticians have got it right, that is fine.
There are fewer than 6,000 prisoners in our prisons and just over four months of this financial year to go. Nobody can tell exactly what the average prison population for the year 1999-2000 will be, but we will be surprised if it is above 6,000, because we have been running at less than 6,000 for most of the year. Something pretty strange would have had to happen in the past four months to make the figure much more than 6,000. That is the basis for our saying that we expect the average number of prisoners in this financial year to be around 6,000. It had been estimated by the statisticians that the current figure would be 6,200. Their later estimate, produced in September, was 6,100. As you can imagine, it is a difficult thing to forecast. We do not regard differences of that sort, but to my knowledge—and I stand to be corrected—there have never been as many as 7,000 prisoners in Scottish prisons. I have heard mention of 6,300 or so, but the figure has never been much more than that.
That is fine, because you did accept the prison inspector's report.
I did, but that is not to say that I accept every figure and word of it.
Perhaps that has been overlooked. In that case, can we accept another aspect of the chief inspector's report, which shows the level of overcrowding in Scottish prisons, even on the base numbers that you suggested, as something like 8 per cent. I refer to Scottish Prison Service establishments and capacity, on page ix. Barlinnie is 32 per cent overcrowded, Greenock 14 per cent, Polmont 10 per cent, Inverness 15 per cent, Edinburgh 16 per cent—
Where do you get the 8 per cent?
That comes from the chief inspector's report.
Where?
Page ix.
Yes, I have got that. Where is the 8 per cent that you mentioned?
I did a rough calculation and took an average. I am quoting Barlinnie, for example, as being 32 per cent overcrowded and Edinburgh as being 16 per cent overcrowded.
At the moment, we are 8 per cent under capacity.
So there has been a major change there.
No, not at all. You have not included the prisons that are not full.
I did. I totalled up the number of places that are shown on that page and found that there were, I think, 571 places too few.
Totalling up those numbers is not the right way to go about it; totalling up all the prison numbers is.
Presumably the statisticians have got the forecasting right and know better than the facts presented in the chief inspector's report.
The chief inspector gets his numbers from the same statisticians as we do.
Mr Cameron, is your position at the moment that, as a result of the announcement that you have made, overcrowding will not be an issue?
What we have announced is unlikely to make overcrowding any different from what it would have been. Phil Gallie is correct in saying that we have overcrowding in some prisons, although not over the whole estate. In the recent past, even when we have had overcrowding in the high-security prisons—if one can put it like that—we have still had a considerable number of spare, unfilled places at the medium-security and open prisons such as Dungavel, Penninghame, Noranside and Castle Huntly. Reducing the capacity of the open estate and the medium to low-security estate is unlikely to affect overcrowding. That was an important point in our deliberations.
Included with the internal note that you put out to various staff on 21 October was a question and answer sheet. Curiously, it was omitted from the information that you sent to the committee. You kindly sent the subsequent question and answer sheet, but not the original one, which included the question:"Will the inevitable overcrowding cause unrest?"Judging by the initial advice that you were putting around internally, you have attempted to backtrack on the issue of overcrowding. Your initial response was that overcrowding would be the inevitable result of the announcement about the clawback of the £13 million.
I do not see the question to which you refer.
It was part of a four-page question and answer sheet, which looks different from the one that you subsequently gave to us. I refer to the second last question from the end. The question and answer sheet—along with a copy of your letter dated 21 October 1999—was provided to me by a prison officer on the Friday, the day after the announcement was made. I find it curious that the question and answer sheet that was helpfully given to the committee does not use the tone of the original one. I am sure it is an oversight that that was not sent to the rest of the committee, for us to see the shift in emphasis. Are you now saying, "Will the inevitable overcrowding cause unrest?" and that your initial response in the Scottish Prisons Service was wrong?
No, and nor do I agree that there was any inconsistency or that we have changed our view. The second last question read:"Does this mean we will face overcrowding in our prisons in a few years time?"
With respect, that is not the second last question on the sheet that I have, which was given to me by a prison officer on the Friday immediately after the cuts. That says:"Will the inevitable overcrowding cause unrest?"The answer to that was:"Supervision of prisoners is more difficult in overcrowded conditions but care will be taken to ensure that issues like prisoners visits and other regime opportunities are not affected. SPS has managed overcrowding in the past without major difficulties."The question and answer sheet was put out to prison officers on the Friday, the day after the original announcement of the £13 million cut. Do you agree that the tone of the question and answer I have mentioned is somewhat different to the indications that you are giving to the committee this morning?
No.
You do not agree that there is any difference?
No.
The committee members may make up their own minds.
Can you remind the committee, Mr Cameron, when you took over the role of chief executive?
I took over the role in September.
Can you also advise us when the review that is now being acted upon was initiated?
The review was initiated after 21 October.
When was the announcement of the £13.5 million reduction made?
The announcement was made on that date: 21 October.
Given the short time that you have been in your job, perhaps you should have had some time to settle in before you looked for major changes to the Prison Service. Is it fair to say that the real reason for this review is simply to find a quick means of cutting that £13.5 million out of the budget?
The final point is the key one. As I said in my answer to a question from the convener, we might well have taken a similar route anyway, but over a rather longer time scale. You are correct: speed is the reason why we set in hand an immediate review. The result is the internal document that I have made available to the committee.
Do you not think that the haste with which this has been undertaken could present dangers in future? On the other hand, looking at the situation at Kilmarnock, perhaps you have got something in your back pocket, which is that if this does not quite work out, you could always find another private prison option.
We have no plans at present for another new prison, private or otherwise. Circumstances may change, but that is the current position of the board. No options are without risk; the status quo is not without risk. What we did, as I think that the report I have made available to the committee demonstrates, was to take a careful look at the whole of our estate. We have reduced the capacity—
I question the word careful, given the time scale.
I am quite satisfied by that. We have reduced the capacity of the Scottish Prison Service by the fraction that we think is safest: the open prisons and the medium-security prisons, not the high-security prisons. The public would expect no less.
Is the previous undertaking to end slopping out by 2004-05 now achievable?
Probably not by the date at which people have generally understood that that will happen, which is about 2005. It would be technically possible, but difficult. In the letter I sent to the convener on Monday, I specifically drew attention to the board's decision that we need to decide what to do with the whole of our capital programme and our estates on the reduced number of sites. There are some spare spaces on the existing estate, in which we can invest.Our capital programme has not been cut. We have maintained it because it provides for improvements. However, you are right that there is a tension between ending slopping out by a particular date and providing places for more prisoners, if more come to us. That is something that we need to work through; there are no easy answers. Over the medium term, we need to look at where the priorities lie.
So the target to end slopping out by 2004-05 is directly affected by the clawing back of the £13 million? Is it no longer achievable because of the loss of that £13 million?
It may be possible, or providing more prisoner places may be possible. If you press on a balloon, it balloons out elsewhere. If it is not that, it will be something else; but that is a fair point. On our current resources, we cannot provide for increased prisoner numbers of, say, another 500—if, by 2004, we have 6,700 prisoners in our prisons—and end slopping out by 2005.
Is it a direct consequence of the £13 million cut that you cannot guarantee that the medieval practice of slopping out will be abolished from our prisons by 2004-05?
No.
At your meeting with us in September, which I appreciate was only about 14 days after you took up your post, you told us why work had not been carried out at Low Moss. One
reason why Low Moss was in such a dreadful state was that the priority for the Prison Service—and bear in mind that this was in September—had been to end slopping out by 2004-05. As a result of that cut, a priority for the Prison Service in September is no longer the priority.
No, it is not the priority. I recall that well. Low Moss is a site that we regard as unsatisfactory, but it does have night sanitation. The board would have liked to close Low Moss, but the site is very useful. Some of the buildings on it are not very good and we are making some improvements. We have a tension: we would like to do something at Low Moss and we would also like to end slopping out. However, we may have increased prisoner numbers, which would need to be faced. Any business needs to look at the options available to it.What I said to the committee in my letter is that we propose to have a fundamental look at our estate strategy, taking into account the pressures upon us and the resources that we have. We will do that and make some decisions some time next year, probably in the spring.
You told us in September that you agreed that Low Moss was in an appalling condition and was rightly condemned by HM chief inspector. You said that one of the reasons Low Moss was in such a poor condition, and that work had not been carried out there, was that the night sanitation programme had priority for the Prison Service. When we asked for improvements to Low Moss, you invited us to say where we would make the cuts.
Yes.
We now find that Low Moss has not been modernised—no work has been done—and that there is a £13 million cut. Could that money, which had been accrued in savings, not have gone a long way to modernising the likes of Low Moss?
It could, but if we had used £13 million for that, we could not have paid for the salaries over the next two years.
With respect, you do not have the money at all now.
No, the question was contingent.
I was quite clear on what I was leading to. You accrued £13 million. You suggested to us in September that no work was done at Low Moss because the night sanitation programme had priority. You were sitting with £13 million, which you had not spent on Low Moss. Completion of the night sanitation programme by 2004-05 is no longer a priority. Everything that you told this committee in September has been turned on its head. Do you accept that?
No, not at all.
So night sanitation is not happening, but that has not been turned on its head? Low Moss had never been improved because of the night sanitation programme. You have lost £13 million, which you were allegedly accruing for something. Low Moss is in a truly appalling condition and we have no night sanitation programme to be completed by 2004-05. Do you think that that is progress?
I do not agree that Low Moss is in a truly appalling condition, nor did I say to the committee in September that it was. I said that the programme of capital works was focused on ending slopping out.Low Moss is a valuable site. We are quite open about the fact that the buildings are less than satisfactory. It is untrue to say that no money has been spent on Low Moss; money has been, and will continue to be, spent on Low Moss.You are right that the comprehensive spending review undertaken by the Government before the Scottish Parliament elections made improvements in night sanitation the No 1 priority for the capital programme—in sites other than Low Moss, as it already has night sanitation. I told the committee that that was the policy. I am now telling you that it is unlikely that we will achieve the 2004-05 aspiration—I do not agree that it was a target—particularly if we have to find accommodation for increased numbers of prisoners.
I accept that you did not tell us that Low Moss was in an appalling condition in September. You had not visited Low Moss then. Have you done so since then?
Yes.
I refer you to the evidence that you gave to this committee in September. You said:"One of the reasons that less has been done there is that a ministerial decision was taken that the priority for the Prison Service was to end slopping out by 2004-05."When Christine Grahame asked you about the wooden huts and the disgraceful state of Low Moss, you posed a question to the committee. You said:"What would you like to cut in order to do the work at Low Moss? The night sanitation programme?"—Official Report, Justice and Home Affairs Committee,14 September 1999; c 151-52.The work at Low Moss was not done and the night sanitation programme has been cut, so do you no longer have the priorities that you had in September?
The capital programme has not been cut since I appeared before the committee in September. However, work to refurbish prisons where night sanitation has not yet been installed will be logistically more difficult if we have an increased number of prisoners, because one has to decant whole halls to carry out the work. That is the tension between providing spaces for more prisoners and running the estate at near its total capacity, and ending slopping out. We have the same capital programme and the same amount of money to spend on capital works as we had in September.
However, the £13 million that has been taken could have made a big difference to the prison estate.
If £13 million out of our total resources had been added to the capital programme, you are right. If you postulate that, instead of having a capital programme of almost £20 million, we had a capital programme of £25 million over two years, we could make a big difference. That would mean that that money was not available to spend on current expenditure, 80 per cent of which is on salaries. As I said, the £13 million is best regarded as a contribution to all the money that the SPS spends. For example, we could have refused our staff a pay increase this year, next year, or the year after, but that is not what we would wish to do. We could have cut the numbers of staff by more. You are right that all sorts of options would have been open to us, and are still open to us, to reduce the number of staff by a greater number than we think is sensible, to provide more capital expenditure. If you are suggesting that I should cut the salary budget to provide more capital, we will consider that, but we have not regarded it as a sensible option.
With respect, you have announced that you will cut the salaries budget over the next couple of years—you will reduce the total number of prison officers.
Indeed, but the suggestion that I am hearing is that we should cut the salaries budget further to provide capital.
I am not making any sort of suggestion.
I misunderstood.
When you were here in September, you said that Low Moss had not been improved because the priority was the night sanitation project. That project is no longer on target for 2004-05. Low Moss has not been improved. You have allowed £13 million that has been accrued over the years to go into the greater Scottish block.
On your last point, ministers decided to redeploy the money elsewhere in the justice programme, as it is their perfect right to do. You will agree that it is a matter not for me, but for the Executive Cabinet, which took the decision.
link
I want to return to the matter of efficiency savings. I appreciate that you have been in post for only a short time, but this committee requires some answers. I give you notice that if we do not get them today, we will have to have them. As I understand it, efficiency savings occur after all bills and salaries have been paid. Over how many years have efficiency savings been accrued?
Four, five, maybe more—I am guessing.
link
For more than five years, you have been making efficiency savings in the Prison Service over and above the payment of salaries, over and above the fact that you have said in your evidence that you have resolved the problem of overcrowding.
I do not agree that efficiency savings have been made over and above the payment of salaries.As I understand the position, the SPS has accrued efficiency savings in its operations pretty well since it was formed in the early '90s. It will continue to do that. Any business that does not seek continuous improvement and greater efficiency to pay its way will be in difficulty.
link
All parts of the public sector—remember that this is the public sector and not a business—make efficiency savings, as a matter of course, once they have paid for everything for which they are due to pay, including salaries. You are saying something quite different.
It is not once they have paid their salaries—
link
If you have not paid your salaries, how can there possibly be savings?
Every part of the public sector—and, indeed, the private sector—is required to conduct a rigorous continuous search for efficiency improvements. The budgets of departments are set on the assumption that such improvements can be gained. For example, no pay rises are allowed for in the budgeting process. Pay rises must be generated by efficiency savings by the Prison Service and other agencies. That creates a spur to achieve greater efficiency. We will continue to search for efficiency savings. We are, of course, in competition at the margin. The taxpayer has a perfect right to expect every pound of taxation to be stretched as far as they would stretch their own spending.
link
I realise that, obviously.
It is a very important point.
link
Usually, efficiency savings are made for a purpose. Did you have a purpose in mind as you accrued efficiency savings over the past five years or more?
The purpose was to contribute to the expenditure of the whole of the Prison Service. We did not have £13 million of accumulated savings; we had £24 million, of which £13 million has been redeployed, leaving us with £11 million. What you think that money would have been spent on is a matter of semantics. I repeat my view that it would have contributed to every pound of spending by the Prison Service over the next two or three years. It was part of our spending power. There would have been the same effect if ministers had decided to cut the baseline—forget EYF and accumulated savings—and redeploy £13 million elsewhere. Nobody would then have asked what we would have spent our baseline on, as it would have been obvious. The fact that the money is from end-year flexibility is just a piece of semantics.
link
I give notice that I am not happy with the answers that I have heard this morning. I ask the service to think about this and to give us a real understanding—not semantics—of where the efficiency savings came from, heading by heading, as the convener has already requested.Will the savings from the proposed closure of the two open prisons be in addition to what you have just said?
We are not closing two open prisons. We are closing one open prison.
link
Will the savings from the proposed closure of the two prisons be in addition to the efficiency savings?
We are closing three prisons, mothballing a unit, and amalgamating some prisons.
link
And that will result in further savings?
No, that is how we will make the savings—by closing prisons and reducing staffing.
link
Is that in addition to the £13 million/£11 million that you talked about earlier?
I do not understand the question.
link
If you close three prisons, you save on salaries; is that in addition to the savings that you have made over the past five years?
We have not made the savings over the past five years. We will make the savings over the next two years. What has been redeployed is £7 million this year, and £6 million the year after, which we would otherwise have spent. The closures and reduction in staff are to enable us to live within our baseline of more than £200 million. We make efficiency savings by closing prisons, reducing staff, switching off the heat and power, and so on, and distributing the assets of those prisons across the rest of the estate. By doing that, our running costs will be £10 million or £11 million less than they otherwise would have been, as the paper that you have before you says.
link
I would like to move on from that. Do you project a decline or an increase in the prison population?
I do not project prison populations, the statisticians do. The paper before members gives their forecast.
Mr Cameron, I do not think that that is an appropriate answer. You are the chief executive of the Scottish Prison Service and you have a duty to be clear to the committee about the Scottish Prison Service estimates of prison population.
We do not make those estimates.
Are you saying that the Scottish Prison Service makes no estimate of prison population?
We share a group of statisticians who work for the Scottish Executive. They provide the projections of prisoner population, based on the actions of the courts. We do not decide how many people we are going to receive. That is decided by those who pass the sentences.The latest estimate of projected prison population can be found on page five of our paper. We gave the first two figures on actual populations: 6,029 and 6,000. The other four figures on projected populations were provided by the statisticians, based on their models of sentencing behaviour.
What is the strategic steer for prison governors?
Sorry?
"September 1999, the strategic steer for governors in charge of establishments projected that the prisoner population would reach some 6,700 on average by the year 2003-2004." Is that correct?
Yes, based on the figures that have been given to us by the statisticians.
The internal estimates that were being used by the Scottish Prison Service in September 1999 were 6,700 prisoners by 2003-04. In November 1999, the figure had suddenly changed to 6,000.
No, the figure is still 6,700, as is shown on page five of the paper in front of you. We have not changed the numbers. We expect to have 6,000 prisoners in this financial year.
Do you expect the prison population to increase, rather than decrease?
Absolutely.
So you intend to close establishments in the face of an expected increase in the prison population?
Yes.
link
I have a few more questions. As the chief executive of the Scottish Prison Service, do you have concerns about future overcrowding?
Of course I would be concerned if overcrowding were to reach high levels. Very high prisoner numbers would inhibit prisoner programmes and the good work of my staff in preparing prisoners for release and in addressing their offending behaviour. That work would be jeopardised by very high prisoner numbers.
link
Will you make representations to the Scottish Executive about those concerns?
As members know, the relationship between ministers and their civil servants is a matter for them. I am not at liberty to divulge that information.
link
Will you make representations to anyone about your concerns about overcrowding? As Trish Marwick said, it seems unlikely that you will meet the aspirations for ending slopping out. Will you raise those concerns?
The position that I have outlined today is not secret. There are risks in the future, just as there are risks in the status quo.The fact is that the prison places that we have closed tended to be those that we found difficult to fill. The overcrowding that has existed in Scottish prisons for many years tends to occur in the high security prisons—Barlinnie, Edinburgh and so on. We have not done anything to that sector. We have gone to great pains not to make a salami slice of cuts across the service. We have concentrated the effects of the cuts. The board took the strategic view that we could either salami slice the entire service—everything would take a percentage cut, which would hit the good, the bad and the indifferent—or we could concentrate the effect by the difficult task of closing establishments, saving whole places, particularly in the open prison estate.
link
I hope you will take on board the committee's fears about the future of the Prison Service, particularly in relation to creating more civilised conditions in prisons and to rehabilitation programmes. I would like to hear today that you will take our concerns on board. While the redirection of the £13 million may be a good thing, I think it is part of your role to reassure us that the Prison Service as a whole will not suffer.
I am a businessman and a non-executive director of the Prison Service. I am struck by the tremendous commitment, hard work and quality of the staff at all levels in the Prison Service compared with my experience of the business world. In the rigorous process of deciding what our programme would be, consistent concerns have been expressed by the members of the board about the impact of the changes on staff, on training and development and on taking the service forward. Speaking personally, I came into the Prison Service because I believe in it and I want to make a contribution. As a Scotsman I am as concerned as you are as MSPs about slopping out and if there was anything I wanted to see achieved faster it was ending that medieval—
link
It was?
It worries me. As you can see from our corporate plan, we aspire to a 21st century prison service. We ought to be setting an example. It is nearly the new millennium and we have prisons built largely in the 19th century and we have slopping out. It is disappointing. We are trying to achieve an end to it within the stated time scale but we would not be honest if we did not say that it is likely to be into the second half of the first decade of the millennium before we get it sorted.
link
Thank you for your honesty. My final question is whether closing an open prison is likely to be a detriment to the service. I would have thought open prisons contribute to diversity.
There are three open prisons. Over the past few years, try as we might, we have had enough prisoners to fill only two of them, so if we have to make reductions that seems the best place to do it.
link
Why is it difficult to fill them? Who determines that? Do prisoners have a choice?
They do.
It is based on security category and perceived danger to the public. A risk assessment process is in place. All the time, prisons are identifying people who they see as suitable for open prison. As Mr Cameron said, in recent years there have been vacancies, to the equivalent of one open prison, even at times of gross overcrowding in the rest of the estate.
I think I understand the now you see it, now you don't £13 million. It would have been used to fund the prisons that are closing, to pay salaries and fund the end of slopping out.
You have almost understood it.
That is good. I am pleased about that, because I have listened very carefully.
The money would have been spent on all the things that you mentioned, as well as others.
But you have said why this is happening—plain connection has been made for me.I now refer you to your corporate plan, to the evidence that you and Mr Clive Fairweather gave at the Justice and Home Affairs Committee's meeting of Tuesday 14 September, to the report of the chief inspector of prisons and—if I get the chance before Roseanna cuts me off—the papers that we have received from Penninghame prison.On page 15 of your corporate plan, which is dated August 1999, you say:"The number of prisoners is projected to rise to an average of 6,200 in 1999-2000".That is not what you are saying now.
That is right.
On page 16, under goal 1, you mention"eliminating or at least minimising overcrowding".Does that remain an aim?
Yes.
Further down, under goal 3, you refer to "ending slopping out".
What page are you talking about now?
I am referring to the second line from the bottom on page 16. That objective is now being deferred because £13 million is going elsewhere.Chapter 5 on page 18 gives prison population projections for 1999-2000 through to 2001-02. Are those now wrong? Are they different?
They are different.
In two months, they have become different.
Not in two months.
This plan is dated August 1999.
That is when it was published. It is based on figures that were produced considerably earlier than that.
When?
In March.
When were the current figures produced?
In September—after the plan was published, in other words.
In this meeting
Everything on 23 Nov 1999 →- Scottish Parliament Justice and Home Affairs Committee Tuesday 23 November 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 3
- Petition Petitions · 65
- Scottish Prisons Committee business · 380
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.