Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Draft Arbitration Bill

Tuesday 20 April 2004 Justice 2 Committee Bill scrutiny 28 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

28 contributions
Annabel Goldie Con The Convener · West of Scotland
link

Item 3 on the agenda is the draft arbitration bill. The committee will remember that I undertook to meet Lord Dervaird and Lord Coulsfield. I duly did that, with Nicola Sturgeon—

Annabel Goldie Con The Convener · West of Scotland
link

I beg you pardon—with Karen Whitefield, not Nicola Sturgeon. Pauline McNeill was also there, along with Margaret Mitchell from the Justice 1 Committee. Lord Dervaird and Lord Coulsfield simply explained to us what lay behind the bill. Also present at the meeting was a solicitor—a Mr Arnott—who has extensive experience in arbitration, and we were able to ask questions.We gave no commitment whatever; we simply undertook to report back to the committee that the meeting had taken place. It occurs to me that the Executive should be informed of what has been happening. It may be that the Executive has an interest in the matter, although I have no idea. If the committee agrees, I think that we should write to the Executive to confirm that we held the meeting, and to ask the minister whether she has views or opinions on the current state of arbitration in Scotland and whether the Executive has any legislative intentions. If that is acceptable, we will have a letter drafted to that effect.Members indicated agreement.

Annabel Goldie Con The Convener · West of Scotland
link

I remind members that tomorrow we have a joint meeting with the Justice 1 Committee to discuss the budget process. That meeting is at a quarter past 10 in committee room 1.

Mike Pringle LD Edinburgh South
link

Oh, good. I am glad that the meeting is not in the Hub.

Annabel Goldie Con The Convener · West of Scotland
link

The next meeting of the Justice 2 Committee will be on 27 April. At that meeting, we will take evidence from the minister. We also propose to consider a report on our youth justice inquiry and to consider our response to the Procedures Committee's legislation inquiry.

Mike Pringle LD Edinburgh South
link

We did not decide to try to ask the insurance industry for its views. There seem to be many differing views on how insurance will work in the Tenements (Scotland) Bill.

Annabel Goldie Con The Convener · West of Scotland
link

I am sorry—what are we talking about?

Mike Pringle LD Edinburgh South
link

I am going back to the Tenements (Scotland) Bill—

Mike Pringle LD Edinburgh South
link

Yes—you were saying that the minister is coming to give us evidence. Was any thought given to trying to get some opinions from insurance organisations about how the Tenements (Scotland) Bill will work?

Annabel Goldie Con The Convener · West of Scotland
link

You mean the insurance companies or the insurance industry.

Mike Pringle LD Edinburgh South
link

Yes. Does not it seem to be a contentious area?

Annabel Goldie Con The Convener · West of Scotland
link

Have there been any submissions from any parts of the insurance industry?

Anne Peat Clerk
link

I cannot remember. Some of those whom we approached to give evidence said that they were not in a position to add anything, but I cannot remember whether that included anyone from the insurance industry. I will need to check that and get back to you.

Annabel Goldie Con The Convener · West of Scotland
link

I believe that mortgage lenders were invited to submit evidence, but they said that they had nothing to add. In terms of taking oral evidence, members will see that our timetable is squashed to the point of impossibility. I can certainly offer to write a letter to the appropriate body in the time that is available, if that would assist the committee. There is a body called the Association of British Insurers.

Mike Pringle LD Edinburgh South
link

I wonder whether other members believe that it would be helpful to do that.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

It would be helpful. A number of points have been raised not only in this meeting, but at our previous meeting, some of which were contradictory. We need to get to the bottom of those.

Annabel Goldie Con The Convener · West of Scotland
link

I suggest that we leave it to the clerks to determine—Interruption. It has been pointed out to me that we received a written submission from the Association of British Insurers.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Can we check whether that submission addresses the specific points that have come up in evidence?

Annabel Goldie Con The Convener · West of Scotland
link

If it does not and any points need clarification, you can let the clerks know and we will draft a letter. We can undertake to do that.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

On owners associations or management schemes being partly reserved matters, that issue came up during the passage of the Title Conditions (Scotland) Bill and there was much discussion about it in committee. I wonder whether the clerks could look back at those debates to see what was said in the end.

Annabel Goldie Con The Convener · West of Scotland
link

I understand the technicalities that are involved, in that the bodies to which you referred are constituted or defined as business enterprises. That is what it makes it incompetent for us to legislate on them.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

A formula was used during consideration of the Title Conditions (Scotland) Bill that enabled us to address the issue. However, I cannot remember exactly what that formula was. Could we have a wee look for that?

Annabel Goldie Con The Convener · West of Scotland
link

We can arrange for the clerks to do so. If there are no other matters arising, I bring the meeting to a close.

Meeting closed at 16:47.

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice 2 Committee Tuesday 20 April 2004 (Afternoon) Committee business · 5
  2. Tenements (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 258
  3. Annual Report Committee business · 3
  4. Draft Arbitration Bill Bill debate · 28

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.