I welcome Jim Wallace, the Deputy First Minister and Minister for Justice, and his officials. Members have a background note on the affirmative instrument that is next on the agenda. I invite the minister to speak to motion S1M-3930.
Jim WallaceLDThe Deputy First Minister and Minister for Justice · Orkney
I will explain the background before I go into the detail of the regulations.The general commissioners of income tax—who are unpaid lay volunteers—expressed concerns about their potential liability for costs and expenses in relation to legal proceedings that might arise from the execution of their duties. In response, the United Kingdom Government agreed to insert immunity and indemnity provisions into the Taxes Management Act 1970 and provisions were made for that in the Access to Justice Act 1999. Those provisions have now been commenced and cross-regulations made in respect of England, Wales and Northern Ireland.However, before similar arrangements could be made in Scotland, it was necessary to seek executive devolution of the power to commence the provisions and to make associated regulations. The Scotland Act 1998 (Transfer of Functions to the Scottish Ministers etc) Order 2003 has been considered by the Scottish Parliament and by Westminster. It was approved by the Privy Council on 27 February and came into force on 28 February. The way is therefore clear for the Scottish ministers to commence the immunity and indemnity provisions in Scotland and, subject to commencement, to make the regulations that are before the committee today.A commencement order that is not subject to parliamentary procedure has now been made, and will come into force on 31 March. However, the associated regulations that are before the committee today are subject to affirmative resolution and had to be laid in draft last month in order to ensure that they will come into force before Parliament is dissolved. It is desirable to have the regulations made soon after the new provisions are in place, not least because similar regulations have been in place for some time in the rest of the UK.Once the immunity and indemnity provisions have commenced, the Taxes Management Act 1970 will provide a general rule that an order to pay expenses cannot be made against a general commissioner in any proceedings in respect of an act, or omission in execution or purported execution, of his or her duty. Exceptions to that general rule are made for proceedings in which a general commissioner is being tried for an offence, or appealing against a conviction, or where it is proven that he or she has acted in bad faith. The act will also permit a court, in proceedings in which an order to pay expenses cannot be made against a general commissioner, instead to make an order against the Scottish ministers.The regulations set out how the amount of any payment by the Scottish ministers is determined and the circumstances in which an order for payment can be made. Regulation 4 provides that if an order is made, it shall provide compensation for expenses that are reasonably incurred by the person concerned. Regulation 5 precludes the making of an order against a public authority. To put the matter in context, I must say that I am not aware of an order for expenses ever having been made against a general commissioner. Nevertheless, the new provisions will contribute to removing the risk, however remote, of any such liability. I therefore invite the committee to approve the regulations.
I get the firm impression that this is a bit of tidying-up that relates to history. Since the regulations derive from the 1970 act, they clearly precede the resumption of the Scottish Parliament by many years. Does the instrument relate to all the commissioners' work? In other words, does it concern the income tax system in general, rather than being restricted to that part of it which falls within the purview of the Scottish Parliament?
Mr Stevenson is correct. Although the instrument relates to the 1970 legislation, an amendment was made to the 1970 legislation by the Access to Justice Act 1999. The power to commence the provisions in the 1999 act lies primarily with the Lord Chancellor. However, given that the Scottish ministers appoint the general commissioners in Scotland, it was decided to seek executive devolution of the commencement function. The role of the commissioners is as a tribunal that hears appeals against decisions that are made by the Inland Revenue on a variety of tax-related matters. Therefore, their role goes well beyond decisions that relate purely to the tax-varying powers of the Scottish Parliament.
The minister will know that I have no objection at all to ministers in this Parliament taking on additional powers. However, in this case, it appears that the powers that we are taking on are in relation to the misuse of a responsibility that lies not with us but with others. The Scottish ministers' responsibilities related purely to the appointment of the individuals, but the exercise of those individuals' functions is over an area that is absolutely nothing to do with the Scottish Parliament. It is curious that we should pick up the tab for matters that are related to income tax, but which are not the responsibility of the Scottish Parliament.
Indeed, the Scottish Parliament does not have powers relating to taxation other than the powers of variation. However, the matter is not strictly to do with income tax; rather, it is to do with the manner in which the commissioners who are appointed by the Scottish ministers perform their duties as a tribunal. In that respect, therefore, there is a difference. On that basis, we seek to commence the provisions to bring us into line with other parts of the UK.
In other words, you hold that the matter relates to what is very broadly a part of our justice system, and to a court that is interpreting and administering law in general—as indeed the civil and criminal courts more usually do.
I use the word "tribunal" rather than "court". You used the phrase "pick up the tab". No tab has ever been picked up, as far as we are aware, but there might always be a first time.
I hope that the regulations will never be put to the test. However, the request came from the general commissioners themselves, who felt that they needed the additional protection.
That the Justice 2 Committee, in consideration of the draft General Commissioners of Income Tax (Expenses) (Scotland) Regulations 2003, recommends that the Regulations be approved.—Mr Jim Wallace.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.