link
We move to agenda item 3. Members have a note on the order. I welcome Hugh Henry to the committee. Minister, you may speak to motion S1M-3826.
Official Report · Committee
Child Support Appeals (Jurisdiction of Courts) (Scotland) Order 2003 (Draft)
link
We move to agenda item 3. Members have a note on the order. I welcome Hugh Henry to the committee. Minister, you may speak to motion S1M-3826.
Thank you, convener. The order concerns child support, which, as you know, is a reserved matter in terms of general policy. However, the order relates to the jurisdiction of the Scottish courts in dealing with child support appeals. As such, it relates to a matter that is devolved by virtue of section 45 of the Child Support Act 1991. That provision enabled the Lord Advocate and now enables the Scottish ministers to allocate certain child support appeals to the courts. The order is essentially a tidying-up exercise. It will not change existing child support policy. It merely re-enacts existing provision that allocates certain child support appeals to the courts.When the child support system was introduced 10 years ago, its purpose was to take decisions about child maintenance out of court in order to speed up the process. It was decided at the time that appeals should be made through an out-of-court process involving a non-adversarial tribunal hearing. There was one exception—it was decided that the courts should deal with appeals that were based on parentage issues. That decision was taken because of the importance of issues beyond child support, such as immigration and inheritance, and because the courts were accustomed to dealing with such matters in determining issues of parental rights and responsibilities in the wider context of family matters.The exception was originally given effect in a United Kingdom order made jointly in 1993 by the Lord Advocate and the Lord Chancellor. The present order will revoke and replace the 1993 order as it affects Scotland. The Scottish order will stand alone. Similar, separate orders have already been made for England and Wales and Northern Ireland. I stress that the policy on the courts' role will remain the same.The order is necessary because the references in the existing order will be out of step with, and too general in regard to, changes that have been made to primary legislation that deals with appeals against child support decisions.Convener, do you want me to go into any more detail?
link
There will certainly be some questions.
If it assists, convener, I have three questions that I suspect are relatively technical—the minister might find that he does not need to give me any further information.
Okay.
link
We will go straight to questions.
My questions are fairly straightforward. I am not seeking to oppose the order; I am seeking clarity.First, the draft order does not have a number. Is the order number 1 or should it not be numbered? That is a minor drafting issue.Secondly, article 4 refers to an appeal made to a court in Scotland and"the care of the child … domiciled in Scotland on the date when the appeal is made".How is it determined who has care of a child when we are talking about transnational issues? I expect that that is something that is well known, but it is not known to me.Thirdly, I have a little, quirky point. I understand that there is a special register of births, deaths and marriages that applies to such events as take place in aircraft and vessels. Will the minister confirm that there is a distinctly Scottish version of that? I have the feeling that, even if someone is born in an aircraft in Scotland, the birth is registered in England for legal purposes.
link
Minister, I should explain that aircraft are Stewart Stevenson's specialist subject.
To add to Stewart Stevenson's question, is there a distinction between aircraft and helicopters? I know that children have been born in coastguard helicopters.
The first issue is fairly straightforward: we cannot allocate a number to the order until it is approved.The determination of the care of a child who is domiciled in Scotland is a matter of fact. If there were a dispute about that, it would have to be determined through the court system on the basis of family law.On births in planes, helicopters, ships—
And submarines.
—and submarines, the issue could well be one of domicile. The issue would relate to the jurisdiction of Scotland and the jurisdiction within which the vehicle was at a particular time. I will seek further guidance on the issue and get back to Stewart Stevenson through the convener.
If it assists, I point out that, although aircraft do not have a port of registry, vessels do, which might distinguish Scots from English vessels. The minister might bear that in mind.With the convener's indulgence, I have a question that the minister might be able to answer on the negative instrument that we are to consider next. I do not know whether the minister is staying for the discussion of that instrument.
link
The minister is not here to answer such questions; it would be a matter of courtesy if he decided to stay. However, we should deal first with what we have in hand.
I have one point that might assist the minister. I think that it is established in law that, where births occur in sea-going vessels that are outwith the territorial limits of a nation, the country of domicile determines the nationality.
Motion moved,
That the Justice 2 Committee, in consideration of the draft Child Support Appeals (Jurisdiction of Courts) (Scotland) Order 2003, recommends that the Order be approved.—Hugh Henry.
Motion agreed to.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.