link
Agenda item 2 is consideration of petition PE336 by Frank Maguire, on behalf of Clydeside Action on Asbestos. I welcome Brian Fitzpatrick, Des McNulty and Duncan McNeil to the committee. I also welcome members of Clydeside Action on Asbestos and the Clydebank Asbestos Group, who are in the gallery.I remind members of where we are with the petition. This is the seventh time that we have had the opportunity to discuss it. Members will recall that, when we first received it in May 2001, we thought that it was of the highest importance. We have given the petition a high level of commitment since then. It has been on our committee agendas and we have worked on it in the background at various meetings.Members will recall that we lost our reporters—Mary Mulligan and Margaret Ewing—when they moved on. Since then, because of the petition's importance, Bill Aitken, who is the committee's deputy convener, and I, as convener, have worked on it.During the summer, Bill Aitken and I attended Lord Mackay's by-order roll court to observe what was happening. That procedure is a direct result of our correspondence with Lord Cullen on speeding up the process. Today, members will have the chance to discuss what work needs to be done. The issue is complex and members have many papers in front of them, which I hope they have had the opportunity to read.For the committee's benefit, I will crystallise the issues on which we need to make progress today. Members must consider whether they wish to take more evidence. If the committee wishes to do so, we should consider how evidence should be taken. If we want to ensure that our deliberations are completed in the shortest period—I think that we do—we may take the view that we have enough evidence and that we need to do something else to progress matters. Other options in paper J2/02/35/1 include setting up a sub-committee or incorporating evidence taking into the main committee's business.I have read all the submissions in detail. I do not believe that the conclusions in Lord Cullen's letter would lead to a fast enough process. The timetabling that we were offered as a result of Lord Coulsfield's report has already been delayed—implementation has been delayed from January until April, which is a cause for concern.Another concern is that, although the new timetabling may be faster—there is some dispute about that—even if it were accepted as it stands, Lord Mackay would no longer fulfil his role. The committee had wanted to pursue the principle of the involvement of the judiciary. We were convinced by Frank Maguire's argument that the intervention of a judge would be extremely helpful and we must also consider that matter.It would be helpful to consider the appointment of an adviser to pore through all the correspondence and written submissions that we have received rather than have a further evidence-taking session. The difficulty with appointing advisers is the length of time that that takes. However, appointing an adviser would certainly cut down the need to take more evidence.Having considered the issues and all the papers that are before us, members must come to a firm decision on the definitive point of our report. We have made progress, but should we go further? If so, what measures should we take? I suggest that we should aim to make suggestions to the Executive by December at the latest. We should consider Lord Cullen's point that a procedure that involves heavier judicial intervention—as in the commercial court—will require one more judge. We should consider making a case to the Executive for an additional judge, which would require a regulation to increase the number of judges from 32 to 33.I have given a brief summary of the work that we have done. I want members now to focus on the action that the committee should take. We must try to stick to a timetable and be firm about where we want to go.