Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Court of Session etc Fees Amendment Order 2002 (SSI 2002/270)

Wednesday 4 September 2002 Justice 2 Committee Subordinate legislation 7 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

7 contributions
Bill Aitken Con The Deputy Convener · Glasgow
link

The first motion to annul relates to the Court of Session etc Fees Amendment Order 2002. I invite Pauline McNeill to speak to and move the motion.

Pauline McNeill Lab Glasgow Kelvin
link

Thank you. I have lodged a motion to annul so that the committee may discuss the principles behind this negative instrument. Representations were made to me by a number of MSPs and by the Scottish Trades Union Congress. The minister will be aware that the STUC was concerned that it was not consulted on the instrument. I was satisfied with the Executive's response to that concern, in that it has made commitments for the future, but I feel that we have to discuss with the Executive the general policy on full cost recovery of fees in civil courts.In the main, the instrument would increase costs only in line with the rate of inflation, but it would increase the fees for proceedings before a judge by much more than that. The Executive may say that it has already made a compromise on those fees and that, after listening to what people had to say, the increase that was proposed has been reduced to an uplift of 25 per cent. However, the Parliament has never had the opportunity to discuss its attitude to the cost of civil justice, which is a live issue especially for the Justice 1 Committee, which has had an interest in the cost of civil justice as part of its inquiry into legal aid. Can the minister offer the committee a future discussion about the general policy on the cost of civil justice?I feel strongly that it is hard to justify increasing the fees for proceedings before a judge by 25 per cent. At least one petition that the Justice 2 Committee has dealt with—the petition from the victims of asbestos—will be directly affected by the increase in the cost of justice because the petitioners were not covered by legal aid. The costs for those who do not receive legal aid and must pay their own way to take ordinary actions such as divorce or personal injury will rise by more than the rate of inflation if the instrument is passed.I am concerned by the legislation. It is right that we should at least have a commitment to a discussion in future on the principle of full cost recovery of fees. Otherwise, the committee will be asked to agree to other negative instruments that will also implement increases that are higher than the rate of inflation.I move,That the Justice 2 Committee recommends that nothing further be done under the Court of Session etc Fees Amendment Order 2002 (SSI 2002/270).

Bill Aitken Con The Deputy Convener · Glasgow
link

Does the minister wish to respond?

Dr Richard Simpson Lab The Deputy Minister for Justice · Ochil
link

Let me give some of the background. The running of the sheriff courts and supreme courts—the Court of Session and the High Court—costs the Executive some £69 million a year. In addition, the annual salary bill for the permanent judges and sheriffs is £23 million. Under the current Administration, there are more judges and permanent sheriffs than at any time in our history.We are under constant pressure to improve the quality and user-friendliness of court buildings. The committee will be aware of the need to provide for disability, witness protection and the separation of witnesses, which are all issues for which our court buildings need to be improved. That is not an inexpensive operation. At the moment, we cannot meet all the demands, but we are working to do so, because we believe that coming to court for civil business should be as stress-free as possible.The question is whether the general taxpayer should foot the whole bill. There are those who subscribe to the view that the state should provide people with the means to settle their civil disputes when other means of settling them have not worked, but the Executive does not agree with that view. Why should the general taxpayer, most of whom will never see the inside of a court, subsidise those who use the courts to win a victory over another party or parties that often involves substantial sums of money for the winners?I make one important exception to that statement of my views. I believe that we should assist people who cannot afford to pay court fees. That is why, for the first time ever, the Court of Session etc Fees Amendment Order 2002—and the matching order, the Sheriff Court Fees Amendment Order 2002—introduces a policy of exemption from fees for those who receive legal aid and for those in receipt of earnings-related state benefits. That policy change has been widely welcomed by all those who use the courts. We are not financing the change by passing on the costs to other court users, because the vast majority of individual fees will increase only by the rate of inflation.I have received arguments that those whose income is only slightly above the benefits level may also struggle to afford fees. However, those who are prepared to pay for a solicitor will find that the court fees are on average only a fraction of the overall cost of going to court.Pauline McNeill asked why the fees for proceedings in front of a judge will increase by 25 per cent, when all the other fees will increase only by the rate of inflation. We believe that judges' time is a precious resource. There are substantial pressures of work on the Court of Session. Indeed, Lord Bonomy's committee is sitting partly in response to those pressures. It is essential that the courts function as efficiently as possible, so that as many people as possible can have their cases heard with the minimum of delay.I believe that part of the efficiency agenda means asking those who take up judges' time to meet a substantial share of the real cost of doing so. Of course, it will be the losers who pay for the costs. One judge sitting costs the taxpayer around £600 a day. The fees that we are asking for fall far short of that figure. Indeed, we are asking for payments in Scotland that are substantially less than those in English courts. The orders that we are debating today would put up the fee for appearing before one judge from £13 per half hour to £16 per half hour—an increase of £3. For appearing before the inner house, the fee goes up from £26 to £33 per half hour. If you feel that those figures are outrageous, you should compare them with plumbing fees. If you call out a plumber, you will pay a similar amount.The average length of a court day is five hours. If the two parties to an action engage a single judge in their case for a whole day, the fees for each party would be £160, or £320 for two parties. I told the committee that an individual judge's time costs the taxpayer £600 a day, so under our proposals the taxpayer will continue to fund about half the real cost of those proceedings. At inner house level, the subsidy would be even greater, as the real cost of salaries is £2,000 compared with total fees of £660 in a two-party action.Full cost recovery is a long way off. I have gone into the arithmetic to try to demonstrate that. Although the Executive is moving towards full cost recovery, we are a long way from that—at least in terms of charging at a realistic level for judges' time. That is deliberate. We consulted court users, although I take Pauline McNeill's point that we omitted to consult some other users, such as the STUC; that is an omission that we shall rectify in future consultations. Payments would have to rise to 100 per cent if we were to recover the real costs of the Court of Session. We were told that that was unacceptable and unaffordable, so we have listened and substantially moderated our proposal to a rise of 25 per cent at present, instead of 100 per cent.What will we do with the extra fee income? It will go straight back into reducing the running costs of the Scottish courts. It frees up some money in the court service budget to do other things and there are lots of useful things that we can do, as I mentioned.Why do I believe that the committee should reject the motion? I ask the committee to recognise that the order represents no more than a bit of good housekeeping and a reasonable approach to funding the real costs of the civil courts. It contains a number of good things, notably a provision to increase the exemption from fees for people on legal aid or state benefits. At the same time, however, I note that the motion reflects a real anxiety that court fees should not become a barrier to people seeking the help of courts to resolve disputes. I believe that increasing the costs of the courts to real time in the long term will mean that people are more likely to settle disputes. The asbestos dispute was mentioned, and almost all those cases have been settled. I do not know how many have gone to court, but I believe that the vast majority of those cases do not proceed to court. That is true of 95 per cent of all cases. Increasing the fees—although the increase is not substantial—puts one more bit of pressure on the defendant to say, "Is this actually worth tackling?" It pushes matters in that direction, and that is important. However, I accept that we must look closely at whether increasing fees creates a barrier to people in seeking help from the courts.If the motion is withdrawn, I will undertake to review the impact of the fee increases after a year, and we will reflect on whether a further move towards full cost recovery should be contemplated. If we feel that that is something that we wish to move for, we will consult fully before any move is made to introduce another fees order. In addition, I will be happy to appear before the committee again to discuss the Executive's plans before they are finalised and before another statutory instrument is submitted to the committee under the negative procedure. Before we move further along that line, we need to consult further and we need to allow the committee to have a debate with the Executive on the exact nature of the move and on the proposals that would accompany it.

Bill Aitken Con The Deputy Convener · Glasgow
link

I thank the minister for that, because there have been concerns about the consultation or lack of it.

Pauline McNeill Lab Glasgow Kelvin
link

Brian Fitzpatrick intended to come along to speak to the motion this morning, but because of a fire at Falkirk High, the trains have been delayed substantially.Many months ago I made the point to Jim Wallace that I have always been concerned that there is too stark a distinction between fairness in civil justice and fairness in criminal justice. I accept the minister's point about the taxpayer who might never see the inside of a civil court, but many taxpayers might never see the inside of a criminal court and they probably hope that they never will. I am keen that civil justice does not take such a backseat to criminal justice because, for many people, it is as important. Some people have no choice but to go to court and ask the judge to determine how their finances are separated in their divorce action, and there are people who have disputes with their employers who have no choice but to go to court.As long as there is at least acceptance of my point that civil justice should not be regarded as less important than criminal justice, I am happy to accept what the minister said. His response has been fair, but it is important that not only the committee but the Parliament has an opportunity to think about whether its approach to the policy of full cost recovery in civil justice is one that we want to pursue. We are talking about one fee only and I have noted the statistics that the minister provided—I did not know that the figure was as high as 95 per cent. However, we might be heading towards much greater increases in the future and that is my primary concern.

Motion, by agreement, withdrawn.

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice 2 Committee Wednesday 4 September 2002 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 7
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 13
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  6. Interests Procedure · 5
  7. Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 5
  8. Petition Petitions · 2
  9. Land Reform (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 135

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.