link
Under item 2, the committee is invited to consider the Police (Injury Benefit) (Scotland) Regulations 2006. Members have a note from the Subordinate Legislation Committee keeping them up to date with its report on the regulations.
Official Report · Committee
Police (Injury Benefit) (Scotland) Regulations 2006 (SSI 2006/610)
link
Under item 2, the committee is invited to consider the Police (Injury Benefit) (Scotland) Regulations 2006. Members have a note from the Subordinate Legislation Committee keeping them up to date with its report on the regulations.
I hope that the Deputy Minister for Finance, Public Service Reform and Parliamentary Business will withdraw the regulations. He can re-lay them so that they will still come into force on the date on which they are currently due to come into force. I suggest that because the Subordinate Legislation Committee, as it always so comprehensively does, has identified a number of drafting defects. They are not simple, limited defects. In the Executive's response to that committee, it acknowledges six significant errors. For example, "the reference to ‘regulation 55(5)' in regulation 24(2) is incorrect in both its reference to ‘regulation' and the actual section stated."The Executive also says:"In regulation 25(2), we confirm that ‘under this paragraph' ought to have referred to paragraph (1) …We confirm that regulation 28(4)(i) ought to have referred to paragraph 6 … The references in Schedule 2 ought to have been made to paragraph 8(3). The response continues:"This reference ought to have been ‘for the purposes of paragraph 6'",when the reference in paragraph 7 of schedule 3 was"for the purposes of subparagraph (1)".The Executive also confirms that "the reference in Schedule 3 ought to have been to paragraph 8(4)"when the reference in the regulations is to paragraph 8(5).The regulations are atrociously drafted. If we allow them to pass, that will set a low water mark for the quality of secondary legislation that we deal with. I hope that the committee can agree that we should say to the minister that he should redraft the regulations and re-lay them. Otherwise, the only option with which we will be left—which I am prepared to pursue, if the minister does not respond positively to my suggestion—is to move that nothing further be done with regard to the regulations.
I agree whole-heartedly with what Stewart Stevenson has just said. The regulations have been sloppily drafted—the Subordinate Legislation Committee flagged up the matter at its meeting on 16 January. The Executive has acknowledged the mistakes and has said that it intends to rectify the mistakes in the regulations by attaching amendments to another SSI.
On another topic.
Yes, on a completely different subject. The other instrument also relates to the police—that is about the only thing that the two instruments have in common.For the committee or the Parliament to recommend the regulations would be, frankly, a dereliction of duty. Unintended and unforeseen mistakes are one thing—they happen in life. However, when six significant errors in a very small statutory instrument have been clearly pointed out, it would be ludicrous to continue with it, even if we accept that all those mistakes will be corrected sometime in the future. I hope that the minister will take the opportunity to have the regulations redrafted before they are presented again to the committee for a decision.
link
Is anyone otherwise minded?
I agree entirely.
link
It is pretty clear that the committee would prefer the regulations to be withdrawn and properly drafted before they come before us again. I ask the clerk to remind me how we can suggest that.
If the committee wishes to pursue that action, the best thing to do is for the convener to write to the relevant minister, stating the committee's views and inviting him to withdraw the instrument. If, for whatever reason, the minister is unwilling to do so, as Mr Stevenson points out, a member can lodge a motion to annul the instrument. That would mean that the committee would have to deal with the matter again, next week.
link
What is the deadline for lodging a motion to annul the regulations?
The regulations will come into force on 1 February.
The deadline for the committee to report to Parliament on the regulations is 5 February.
So the matter will have to be dealt with by then.
It will need to be resolved next week.
But we cannot meet in public next week.
We hope to be able to make that possible.
What is the deadline for members lodging a motion to annul the instrument?
I defer to members on that.
link
The matter will be discussed at next week's committee meeting. I guess that we could accept a motion before that deadline, but the minister may agree to withdraw the regulations before that is necessary.
Indeed.
I suspect that a motion would need to be lodged by 4.30 on the day before the meeting.
link
That ends our public meeting. We will continue the meeting in private to discuss item 3, which is our Scottish Criminal Record Office inquiry.
Meeting continued in private until 13:20.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.