Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Budget Process 2006-07

Wednesday 26 October 2005 Justice 1 Committee Committee business 328 contributions · 15 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

328 contributions · showing 1–200
Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I welcome our panel of witnesses: Doug Cross, who is the secretary to the finance standing committee at the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland; Tom Buchan, who is the president of the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents; and Joe Grant, who has recently been appointed as the general secretary of the Scottish Police Federation—I congratulate him on his appointment. We will go straight to questions.

Mary Mulligan Lab Linlithgow
link

I start the questioning by considering the number of police available within the service at the moment. The witnesses will be aware that expenditure had been made available in recognition of the number of police who are likely to reach retirement age over the next few years, up to 2009-10. Has the recruitment exercise begun to address that issue? Is it on schedule? Will it deliver the number of police required to continue to address the present and future workload?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

The first peak in the number of retirals was in 2005-06, and there is sufficient funding to cover those who retire in this financial year. The next two years will be easier on the service. The next peak comes in 2009-10, as a result of a significant increase in the number of officers that took place 30 years ago. The purpose behind the bid that was put in last year, which was partly met by the Executive in the budget, was to allow us to accelerate the recruitment of officers before 2009-10. The settlement that we received will allow us to recruit 60 additional officers in 2006-07 and a further 60 in 2007-08, giving us 120 additional officers with some form of training before those retirals take place in 2009-10. That will partly address the issue of recruitment—it will be a significant help. Not all the police officers who are eligible to retire will do so, so the combination of those who choose to stay on and the additional police officers will assist. However, it should be noted that there will be a significant difference between the experience of those whom we manage to recruit over the next couple of years and those who leave the service with 30-plus years' experience.

Mary Mulligan Lab Linlithgow
link

I will come back to the issue of experience with regard to training. Are the two lots of 60 officers in addition to the number that you would normally recruit? Will that address some of the needs that are created when officers leave at the other end?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Yes, they are in addition to the number that we would normally recruit. As I said, that will partly assist.

Mary Mulligan Lab Linlithgow
link

How successful have you been in recruiting such numbers? We are aware that—fortunately—employment is at a good level at the moment, so you are in competition with many other industries. Have you had any problems with recruitment? Is the training of the new recruits sufficiently well funded to enable officers to come into the service offering a good contribution? I recognise that, as you say, many of those who will be leaving have a great deal of experience that it will be difficult to fill in for.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

We have not started the process with regard to the additional officers yet; that will start next year. We are not experiencing any difficulty in attracting recruits but, as you can imagine, ensuring that we get the right people into the job is a long process. We have had some experience of that process during the past year, when we had the first of the retirement peaks. We do not anticipate that attracting an additional 60 recruits in each of the next two years will be problematic. However, as you suggest, training will be a challenge for the Scottish Police College at Tulliallan. My understanding is that it has put in a bid for additional resources to allow it to meet that challenge. There is quite considerable throughput at the college; it is a busy place at the best of times. I am sure that it will cope with the additional officers, but doing so will be a challenge.

Mary Mulligan Lab Linlithgow
link

You say that a bid has been made for additional resources, part of which will be for trainers. Will there be sufficient people available to fulfil that role?

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

There will be sufficient people at the college. The difficulty will come when we try to let the trainees accrue operational experience during their probationary period. Understandably, given the numbers that we expect in 2009-10, the service will have difficulty enabling officers to accrue in the best possible way that supervised experience under the tutelage of experienced officers.

Mary Mulligan Lab Linlithgow
link

You said that you do not expect to experience any difficulties with recruitment. Is that the case across Scotland?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

No areas have been experiencing any particular difficulties. The situation seems to be good across Scotland. The police service is still a sought-after profession, although it is a difficult one.

Stewart Maxwell SNP West of Scotland
link

You know the number of people who will be eligible to retire over the period and I assume that you can estimate fairly accurately how many will actually retire. Can you confirm whether the 120 additional officers who will be recruited in the next two years will match that figure?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

The number who will be eligible to retire will be significantly in excess of 120. However, as you suggest, experience tells us that not all of those who are eligible to retire will do so. A number of factors come into play, such as individuals' circumstances and the economic climate. It is difficult to predict the numbers with any degree of certainty but we know that a significant number of officers will choose to stay on. That will certainly help to plug the experience gap that will arise when the retiring officers finally go.

Stewart Maxwell SNP West of Scotland
link

To be absolutely clear, is it your expectation that you will have roughly 120 additional vacancies?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

No, from the additional resources, we will have an additional 120 officers who will plug the vacancies as they arise. Around 300 officers will be eligible to retire in 2009-10.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Obviously, you will be aware that target 1 for the Justice Department in the draft budget document for 2006-07 is"To continue to increase the police clear-up rate for serious violent crime."

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

The document goes on to say: "Desired level of improvement to be discussed with police forces."What discussions have taken place between the Executive and police forces since the target was first published in last year's draft budget? What level of improvement has been agreed, and does that level of improvement vary among police forces?

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

I take it that you are talking about target 1, which is to seek an increase in the clear-up rate. I am not aware of any consultation that has taken place with our association on that. We are somewhat disappointed that that target has been chosen. We know for certain that much of the work that we have done and the measures that will be put in place over the coming period will lead to an increase in the number of known reports of violent crime. A significant percentage of that increase will be people who, by the very nature of how we learn that they were victims, are unco-operative. By that, I mean that we are looking to put in place a protocol with the health service whereby it would notify us about incidents in a way that it was unable to do before and which would give the victim a degree of anonymity. For example, the health service could indicate the postcode at which a male was found and what sort of condition he was in.We know from experience and from consultation with accident and emergency departments in various hospitals that a significant number of people attend those departments with injuries sustained in such incidents. We will be informed about them, although by their very nature those are cases in which the person does not wish to co-operate. De facto, that will lead to an increase in the number of indirectly reported serious violent crimes, but the victims will not want to help us in any way.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

That is helpful. Are you saying that no discussion took place between the Executive and police forces about the target?

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

Other than our response to the committees, the answer to that question is yes, as far as our association is concerned.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Does Joe Grant have anything to add?

Joe Grant Scottish Police Federation
link

Likewise, we have had no such discussion with the Executive. You refer to discussion with forces—such discussion is most likely to take place with ACPOS. However, I have a view on the matter, which is that we are looking at the process from the wrong perspective. Our objective should be to harness resources for crime reduction rather than crime clear-up. Far greater benefits can be achieved for our communities and other stakeholders through crime reduction. The stakeholders that would benefit include the national health service, which provides treatment; the police service, which conducts investigations; the Procurator Fiscal Service, which carries out prosecutions; the courts administration—a reduction in crime would affect trials, sheriff courts and lawyers; the Scottish Prison Service; and social work departments. They all have an interest in ensuring not only that we clear up crimes but that we reduce crime in the first place so that we do not have to go through the process.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

We all agree that a reduction in crime is vital, but the Executive's published target was on the clear-up rate for serious violent crime. Are the witnesses telling the committees that no discussions have taken place between the Executive and their organisations on increasing the clear-up rate for serious violent crime?

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

The first notification that we had that we would be invited to comment on the issue was when we got the letter inviting us to come to the committees. From my perspective, it is highly likely that we might see a decrease in what Joe Grant referred to as the clear-up, or detection, rate because we fully expect that there will be an increase, not only in the area that was mentioned but in other areas involving known crimes of a seriously violent nature. It would be foolish of us to come to the committees with a guesstimate, simply to give you a target that we think can be achieved. I am not convinced that we can say to the committees that there is likely to be an increase in the clear-up rate. Indeed, there may well be a decrease; that much we may expect.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I hear that loud and clear, but what surprises me—I suppose that it also surprises other members—is that the Executive has not initiated a discussion with your organisations to consider a target that it has set. We should perhaps take up that matter in writing with the Executive. There are follow-up questions that I could have asked you, but that would be inappropriate when those discussions have not taken place.

Margo MacDonald Ind Lothians
link

If chief constables or senior officers have had discussions with the Executive, would not it be logical that the witnesses would have discussions with them before having discussions with the Executive?

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

All that I can say is that we had no notification of, or consultation on, the target until we received the letter—dated 3 October, I think—that asked us to prepare for the Parliament's justice committees an estimate of what we might be able to achieve. That was the first time that our association was notified of the target. We were not consulted on the selection of the target, but we honestly believe that we could have been helpful in the process. As Joe Grant said, we would much rather focus on crime reduction than on increasing crime clear-up rates, as that would bring benefits. Indeed, that is what we are working on with our violence reduction units. I have probably said enough on that.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

It strikes me that I should seek clarification both for the record and so that I am clear in my own mind. You said that there was no formal contact whatever between ACPOS and the Executive on the target—we heard that loud and clear—but was there any informal contact at any level between ACPOS and the Executive?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Yes, the target has been discussed at ACPOS level. The drive towards reducing serious violent crime features in the ACPOS document "Policing Priorities for Scotland 2003-2006", so there will have been discussion between ACPOS and the Executive on reducing serious violent crime.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

At what level did that discussion take place? If I may say so, your answers seem slightly contradictory.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

I think that Tom Buchan was referring to consultation between the Executive and his association.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Can you perhaps help the committees by outlining for us what discussions have taken place, at what level those discussions took place, what level of improvement was agreed at the level that the discussions took place and what progress has been made in achieving the agreed level of improvement? Perhaps the point at which progress might be made has not yet been reached, but will you respond to the first three parts of my question?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

I cannot give you all that information because it does not sit within the ACPOS finance business area, for which I am secretary.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Can you help the committees by explaining who could give us that information?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

The ACPOS secretariat office should be able to provide information about what discussions took place.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I am grateful for that answer. Convener, it might be helpful if the committees could get that information—it is unfortunate that we cannot get it today—in written form at least, in time for our discussion of our comments on the various issues, including that target.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

We can provide that information in writing.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

That will be helpful.As we have no further questions on that topic, Marlyn Glen will ask about another issue.

Marlyn Glen Lab North East Scotland
link

My questions are on the proposed efficiency savings. In September 2004, the Minister for Justice announced the creation of a police business benefits unit, which was intended to"seek out savings in back-office functions such as IT and payroll, and advise forces on how best to cut red-tape and squeeze best value out of their procedures."What savings has the BBU identified so far?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

The business benefits unit has been working closely not only with the ACPOS finance standing committee but with force staff who are involved with best value. In the past year or so, the BBU has assisted the finance standing committee to undertake a number of studies on how the eight forces can introduce better collaboration on fleet management. That work has moved on apace, as we are now starting to consider opportunities for collaboration with other partners in the emergency services on fleet management.We have also looked at payroll management and procurement. On payroll, we have determined that there will be opportunities for at least a couple of large forces—not all eight forces at this stage—to work together on a common payroll service as and when their current payroll systems require replacement. That work will be taken forward.With regard to procurement, some significant work has been done in relation to the purchase of terminals for the new Airwave system. That has produced significant savings of about £6 million. We are also currently in discussions regarding a framework agreement for the purchase of uniforms across Scotland.Another area that we are looking at, or will be looking at in the near future, is the area of information technology, which you mentioned. We are looking at ways in which we can collaborate to get better prices for the IT equipment and associated software that we purchase. We are looking to see what scope there is for a common desktop, so that we can produce some efficiency savings in that area.The business benefits unit has been heavily involved in those areas of work, and it ties in with the work of the finance standing committee.

Marlyn Glen Lab North East Scotland
link

You seem to be concentrating on cash savings, rather than on time-releasing savings.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

The savings in those particular areas of work have been cash savings. On efficiency savings, the recently published targets for cash efficiency savings start in this financial year and go over the next two financial years. That is a new concept for us. Although we have been able to demonstrate and evidence cash-flow savings in the past couple of years through the production of our best-value annual report, the targets and the protocols behind them are new territory for us.We have been working closely with our colleagues south of the border who have had such targets in place for a bit longer than us, to try to develop some good practice in relation to efficiency targets and savings. There is not a whole lot of information out there in terms of guidance as to how the process will work. By tying in with the practice of our colleagues in England and Wales and our local authority colleagues, we are starting to develop ways of monitoring efficiency savings in the eight forces in Scotland that will enable us to present that information to the Executive. Preparatory work has taken place over the past few months, since the targets were announced.

Marlyn Glen Lab North East Scotland
link

So that is very much on-going work.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Yes. The best-value annual report that we have produced for the past couple of years highlights both cash and non-cash savings. The report for 2004-05 is due to be published in the next few weeks. It is going to the finance standing committee tomorrow for sign-off and will be sent out to the Executive's police division to demonstrate what we have been doing in the past financial year. We will base the efficiency savings targets that we need to meet of £10 million in 2005-06 on that report.

Joe Grant Scottish Police Federation
link

As Mr Cross says, the targets have just been announced, which is an issue of contention between us and the Executive. Once again, there was no consultation or involvement of the police service in those targets being arrived at. That is a fundamental flaw in the process. It is also an anomaly that no guidance was issued at the same time on how police forces and services throughout Scotland are to report on the efficiency savings. Both those areas give me and our members concerns that the focus is away from the constables, the sergeants, the inspectors and the chief inspectors who are at the coalface of service delivery, and that the emphasis is on the cost of providing the services rather than on the basic element of providing policing services locally for our communities.

Marlyn Glen Lab North East Scotland
link

To help us to consider the budget with some clarity, I ask the witnesses to guide me through the issue. Do the savings that we are talking about form part of the police efficiency savings that are set out in the technical notes for the Scottish Executive's efficient government plan?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

We have a target of £4 million in cash savings for the three-year period. The recently announced target for efficiency savings is for £10 million in 2005-06, rising to £35 million in 2006-07 and £50 million in 2007-08. That is the work that we are preparing for.

Marlyn Glen Lab North East Scotland
link

So the savings that you talked about are part of that process, not over and above it.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

They form part of it. Before being asked to make savings, ACPOS pulled together the work that goes on in each of the forces on best value and continuous improvement. The report that we will produce in the next couple of weeks will identify that we have a combination of cash and non-cash savings in the region of about £15 million, although the figure is augmented by the fact that we have about £4 million of savings as a result of Airwave handset procurement, which is a one-off saving. The underlying savings are about £11 million, which is a combination of cash and non-cash savings.Now that we have the targets, we are trying to formalise the process to ensure that we have effective monitoring procedures in place that will allow us to report how we are faring against them.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Could I just clarify who is talking to whom, which is a recurring theme? I assume that, irrespective of whether we are talking about efficiency targets, cash-releasing savings, time-releasing savings or targets that set the service's objectives, the Executive has spoken to ACPOS on the matter.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Do you mean on the efficiency targets?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

We are aware of the cash-flow savings targets, which have been published for some time, but we are not aware of the basis of the targets for the efficiency savings, which were published just a couple of months ago.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Not in relation to those savings.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Are you saying that there was no discussion about the overall envelope of the savings as well as no discussion about where the savings would come from, which are two slightly different matters?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

There was discussion about the fact that the Executive would seek efficiency savings from all its services, including the police. We knew that there would be a requirement for savings that could be significant, but there was no discussion about the details and where the savings would come from.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Would it be fair to say that the detail of where the savings come from is more properly a matter for the police than for the Executive? I assume that you want a degree of control over where you make the efficiency savings.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Now that we have received the target, we are turning our attention to how we will achieve it and demonstrate that we have done so. However, in developing a strategy for delivering the savings, it would be useful to know where the targets of £10 million, £35 million and £50 million come from and what their basis is. Another aspect on which we are still uncertain is that, in addition to the cash and non-cash savings, it has been declared that a saving is to be made in relation to procurement throughout local authorities. We are not sure whether we have to contribute to that, too. We have asked for clarification on that, but we have not yet received it.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I will take a belt-and-braces approach on the issue and follow on from Jackie Baillie's question. You say that when the technical efficiency notes for the efficient government programme were published, you had no knowledge of what would be in them.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

We picked up the information about the savings from the website.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

That is clear. Bill Butler has suggested that we clarify the matter. According to the technical notes, the accountable officer is the chief of the Justice Department.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

The committees are aware of the fairly widespread publicity this morning that ACPOS is looking for more money, principally to cover the consequences of dealing with anti-terrorist measures and antisocial behaviour orders. To clarify where all that comes from, I ask Mr Cross whether that desire has been intimated to the Justice 1 Committee or the Justice 2 Committee.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

No. We discussed with the Executive's police division counter-terrorism measures, which are a fairly significant issue given recent events. The ACPOS portfolio holder who has responsibility for counter-terrorism measures has discussed with the police division and his colleagues down south the counter-terrorism strategy. It is clear from those discussions that, if we are to have a co-ordinated counter-terrorism strategy throughout the United Kingdom, additional funding will be required.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

I want to be absolutely clear about the matter. I accept that unless discussions take place with your counterparts down south, it is difficult to know what is required or what may lie ahead and therefore to quantify the money that is required. Has ACPOS discussed with the Scottish Executive a projected additional resource requirement?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

ACPOS has been in discussion with the police division to identify the requirement. Work continues to determine that amount.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

That relates to the anti-terrorism obligations.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Yes.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

What about ASBOs? I understand that the request for more money embraces the additional workload for ASBOs. Have your organisations formally intimated the requirement to the justice committees or the Scottish Executive?

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

The Association of Scottish Police Superintendents has frequently called on and made a plea to the Executive to recognise that introducing new legislation has an impact on resources. That was done at our conference and in our recent call for a review of policing, which resulted from our feeling that the Executive affords scant regard to the fact that when new legislation is put on the statute book, some impact on resources is inevitable.Our association welcomed the antisocial behaviour legislation, but we recognised that it would have an impact on resources. In the area of my force—Strathclyde police—in excess of 50 full-time equivalent officers work on nothing other than ASBO-related matters. That is a significant number of officers and the figure does not take full account of the number of police support staff who are engaged, through disclosure and such matters, in working with ASBO units. The committees will appreciate that that relates to just one force area.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

I thank the chief superintendent for that helpful answer.We are all a bit in the dark, because the first that we knew of the request was the publicity this morning. For the benefit of the committees, which are undertaking the budget process, do you have figures? Does Mr Cross have a projection of the financial imposition on police forces to deal with anti-terrorist measures?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

No. ACPOS is developing that.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Discussions have taken place with the police division about the requirement down south, but that does not mean that that will be mirrored in Scotland, because a significant part of the requirement there centres on the city of London. We know that the figure down south runs to a few hundred million. If we are to provide a counter-terrorism strategy at our ports and so on that is consistent with that of England and Wales, resource will be required. The figures are being worked up as the threat levels are being assessed.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

At the moment, you cannot quantify any projected estimate.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

I cannot quantify the requirement today.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

Is this the issue that you wanted to ask about, Margo?

Margo MacDonald Ind Lothians
link

Yes. I am interested in the whole subject. I was going to say at the start that I have written to the minister.

Margo MacDonald Ind Lothians
link

Thank you. I wrote to the minister before recess and I await a reply. One of my reasons for writing was my concern that the new Terrorism Bill will have a direct operational effect on the prioritising of resources in Scotland. We have heard this morning that figures have been set for recruitment to fill the posts of people who will retire. We have also heard about financial and time savings. Were those figures arrived at before or after you were aware of the requirements that the Terrorism Bill would place on you?

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

That is a good question and I am not sure of the answer. We always have to have our finger on the pulse over significant changes that might come our way because of new legislation. As you rightly point out, legislative changes might well impact on the service and its resources, but that is difficult to predict. Although we know that there will be changes almost immediately, we will have to wait and see.

Margo MacDonald Ind Lothians
link

When the Prime Minister told the House of Commons that he was determined that the new bill would go through, he said that the police had asked for it. Does that include the police in Scotland? As you have said, the impact on operational requirements will be different here. Did you ask for the bill?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

I think that the Prime Minister's reference to the police would more likely be to the discussions that he would have had with the Association of Chief Police Officers in England and Wales. He would not have had any direct discussions in Scotland.

Margo MacDonald Ind Lothians
link

No, but I would have assumed that you would ask the Minister for Justice here. Is nobody bothering?

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

We mention in our paper that an enhanced demand for resources will be generated by recent changes in terrorism measures. However, that has not been quantified because it is difficult to do so at this stage. As you rightly say, there might be a change in the legislation. It would be foolish to think that we are not engaged and that there has not been an increased deployment in resources for terrorism measures since the London incidents.

Margo MacDonald Ind Lothians
link

Because of devolved competencies, the police here are answerable through various routes to the Scottish Parliament. Is there any conflict of interests because of the requirements that are being placed on the police for training? I know that additional training will be required because of the new anti-terrorism measures, even before the Terrorism Bill is enacted. There are also training and implementation requirements as a result of the Scottish Government's measures against vandalism and general lawlessness at community level.

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

You rightly raise the question of priorities. As you would expect, when there is a risk at national level, resources have to be found to address that risk; meanwhile, at the local end, the most important piece of the legislation that the Executive has passed was that on ASBOs. There is a tension over the deployment of resources, an issue that has been the subject of some research down south. We have to deploy our resources in line with the priorities determined by the chiefs of police. Obviously, terrorism measures are pretty high up on the agenda, which will clearly have an impact on other resources.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

The answer to the question that Annabel Goldie posed would be that you have not yet quantified the resources required. I presume that, at some point—once you have had a chance to see the impact of the new terrorism legislation—you would enter into discussions with the Executive if you thought that additional resources were required.

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

All it takes is a change in threat level. That will impact on the deployment of resources, as would a change in the legislation. To a certain extent—

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I am just trying to clarify that when it becomes clearer what the implications on Scottish police forces could be—

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

The situation could change dramatically.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

At that point, you would begin to formulate a view as to whether you required additional resources.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Yes. That would be addressed at that time.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

I return to the question of where more money is required, particularly in relation to ASBOs. You have indicated, Chief Superintendent Buchan, that your association has frequently made known to the Executive the anticipated need for more money to fund, resource and deal with the practical consequences of ASBOs. Do we have a figure for that? Has anyone managed to quantify the requirement? You said that, in your area, 50 officers are currently deployed on ASBOs. That sounds to me like a significant allocation of personnel. Does ACPOS or the ASPS have any round figure for what you think will be required?

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

It is not so much what will be required as what is being spent. It would be helpful, when legislation is enacted, for consideration to such financial requirements to be given. We seldom see that, if ever—I think that the Police, Public Order and Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill may be the first time that I have seen it happen. Every piece of legislation that is enacted will have an impact on resources to some extent, but we are never engaged in consultation or asked what we think the impact will be. We can take a retrospective approach and say what we estimate ASBO enforcement is costing the service in terms of cash for resources deployed.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

Is that a quantifiable figure? Could it be made available to the committees?

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

Yes, if there was a request for such information. We would have to determine the number of officers involved. You will appreciate that the number would be expressed as full-time equivalent, because only part of the work of some people will relate to ASBOs. There are also dedicated officers who work in liaison with local authorities; the costs of their deployment can be costed.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

That would be helpful. The committees are trying to consider the current implications of the budget for your organisations and for police officers. In a moment, I will come to the subject of savings. It is difficult to get a handle on where savings will come from if you are already struggling to cope with the demands of funding new obligations. Could we ask for information on that, convener?

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

That would only be fair. You went public on the subject this morning before coming to the meeting.

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

It was not me.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

Somebody did, anyway. You need to be clear with the committees on your views about what additional resources might be needed. I presume that you cannot know what the implications of the Antisocial Behaviour etc (Scotland) Act 2004 will be until the act has been in operation for a certain period. Would it be fair to say that?

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

Could we hear a reply to that question first, please?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

That is correct. Currently, the impact of ASBOs is being absorbed within police budgets. The work on that is continuing. As Chief Superintendent Buchan says, significant resources are being deployed on ASBOs in his area. As he has also pointed out, all the significant new legislation that comes through will have an impact. As far as priorities are concerned, requirements can be absorbed, but they will have an impact on the rest of service delivery. Your point is correct. We would need to have sufficient time to be able to put a cost on such activities. The information is not always available, particularly in relation to new legislation—we do not always know what the costs are until the new measures are up and running. We would need the opportunity to come back and state what the costs in question have turned out to be. The point is well made.

Margo MacDonald Ind Lothians
link

Chief Superintendent Buchan said that, if the level of threat from terrorism was raised, that would have a dramatic impact on budgeting, presumably at a local, operational level. I do not imagine that the same level of information will exist for the increased use of resources with regard to new operational requirements under the Terrorism Bill as might be the case for antisocial behaviour deployment. I mention that in passing because, presumably, the committees will need to have some way of evaluating that expenditure. I suspect that, for security reasons, the same level of information will not be readily available, although I may be completely wrong about that.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I think that, in relation to that question and Annabel Goldie's questions, our witnesses have said—they may correct me if I am wrong—that they cannot quantify yet what additional resources are required for anti-terrorism measures but that, when the information is available, they will indicate their views to the Executive. They are saying that they are short of resources. We have asked for more information on the additional resources that are required so that we can comment, as we are scrutinising the budget process. Is that a fair summary?

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

That is a fair summary. We have to go with what we know at the time. The point that Ms MacDonald referred to was that things could change dramatically tomorrow if there were one or more terrorist incidents in Scotland. We need only look at what happened to the Metropolitan police. We have to consider the current threat level and take cognisance of any new legislation that impacts on Scotland, but it is less easy to make any safe predictions, because things could change dramatically. When you compare that with the impact of antisocial behaviour legislation, which is reflective—looking back at what we have done—you will appreciate that one is significantly more difficult than t'other.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

Your additional point, that threat levels can increase regardless of whether there is additional legislation, is noted. Increased threat levels have increased resource implications—the committees will take that into consideration when they produce their report.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

Reference has been made to the Scottish Executive's efficient government technical efficiency notes, which identified two areas for efficiency savings in relation to the police: cash savings and time-releasing savings. Mr Cross, I was struck by your saying that you were not aware of how those efficiencies were computed; you simply picked them up from the web. I am slightly startled to hear that. I do not understand how potential areas for efficiencies can be meaningfully identified without a full discussion with our police forces. Are you saying that, other than the cash-flow element, which was discussed, the rest was really just handed to you as targets that our police forces were to meet?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

There was some discussion about a requirement for efficiency savings to be made and about the fact that the figure might be significant, although not in relation to the targets of £10 million, £35 million and £50 million.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

Where do those figures come from? Could I have produced figures just as good by pulling them out of the air?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

I do not know where those targets come from. It may well be that those figures have been considered in conjunction with the best-value annual reports that we have published and shared with the Executive. The figures may be a view on what might be achievable on the basis of those reports.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

You do not know—they might have been a restatement of those reports. Projected cash savings are £4 million for this year and £6 million and £8 million for the ensuing years. We have heard your assurance, in response to Mary Mulligan, that the police business benefits unit will contribute to that by making back-office function more efficient, but what other specific efficiencies will produce those figures?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

By way of an example, the work that we undertook in 2004-05, which will be contained in the best-value annual report, identifies both cash and non-cash savings through all the categories under the efficient government banner. Of the £15 million savings that we identified last year, £6.5 million came from better procurement. As I explained earlier, a big chunk of that is wholly related to Airwave, which will not be repeated. However, a further £2 million of procurement savings have been generated by forces through better purchasing. If that continues, it can be realised into cash-flow savings. We have made improvements in internal organisation and management, we have found better ways of doing things and we have reduced bureaucracy. Last year, that generated savings of about £3 million over the eight forces. Investment in the workforce has improved through a consideration of better, more efficient ways of working throughout the force.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

I know that colleagues want to question you specifically on time-releasing efficiency gains.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Right. Procurement is one aspect of cash flow, but there has also been a lot of work on managing and trying to reduce absence levels in the forces. Significant improvements have been made in some forces. Of course, such improvements mean that there will be cashable savings because they reduce the need for overtime.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

I have a brief final question. Will the efficiency savings have an impact on front-line services? What is the priority in the reallocation of cash savings? Members of the panel might have different views on that matter, but perhaps Chief Superintendent Buchan will want to say something first.

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

I would have preferred you to have started with Mr Cross.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

I thought that you would have preferred that, but I am asking you.

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

The bottom line is that we need every penny that accrues from savings. There is a recognition that things can be done better, and the service has demonstrated that. There is still much to be done to make things better and to be smarter. There is much to be done on single-point-of-entry data recording and mobile data, for example—indeed, there is a raft of things that we must do to improve the processes in which we engage, some of which can be lengthy.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

Will those have an impact on front-line services?

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

There could be savings and improvements. Some of our processes require a significant amount of time—Mr Grant is perhaps better able to speak about that. It can take six to eight hours to deal with a domestic violence incident, much of which will be taken up with paperwork. We recognise that if processes are reduced and the time that it takes to deal with such incidents is cut down to three hours, not only will there be cash savings as a result of officers spending only half of their time dealing with such incidents, but the process will be much smarter and more efficient. We are working hard on such things. Savings can be accrued and we can make processes smarter and better.

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

Speaking as an operational commander, I would say that the public like to see police officers. Therefore, money that is saved should go towards augmenting what is at the front and towards the police's interface with the public. I have not yet been to a meeting at which I have been told that the trouble is that there are too many police officers on the streets. We know that the public want more police officers.

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

We should augment the number of police officers.

Joe Grant Scottish Police Federation
link

Our concern is that, like work pressures, financial pressures are heavier than air and will float down to the street. We are concerned that such pressures will affect service delivery. We have a concern—which is not baseless, as we have seen it in other services—that the delivery of the service is costed on an officer turning up at someone's door within a reasonable time of 15 or 20 minutes and then doing what needs to be done. There could be a hand on somebody's shoulder or a report of a crime could be made and there could be subsequent investigation and reporting on the individual in question. We are concerned that such services may be reduced if financial pressures are further increased. As we have stated, it is clear that we are already under quite a bit of pressure from additional elements that were not previously costed. That concern is not baseless, but I do not know whether it has been fully realised.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

There may be different priorities, but we all want to see improvement in the service and a better focus on front-line policing. That might mean increased police resources or making more police officer time available for front-line duties and freeing up other work that they do, but I think that all three associations want to improve the front-line visibility and efficiency of the service.

Stewart Maxwell SNP West of Scotland
link

We have covered the targets for time-releasing efficiencies of £10 million, £35 million and £50 million over the next three years. It was said that £3 million was saved last year as a result of management efficiencies and so on. You clearly said that you were not involved in negotiations on those figures, but have you thought about them in depth now that they have been issued? Are there specific time efficiencies that will contribute towards the savings?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Yes. Our finance committee has begun to turn its thoughts to how we might achieve such efficiencies; after all, we are in the first year of this three-year period of efficiency savings. If we continue some of our previous work, we might be able to achieve the first target, which is not far from the level of efficiency savings that we have already achieved.If we are to achieve the more significant savings that are required next year and the year after, we will have to improve the technology and systems and reduce the amount of bureaucracy. We are considering a combination of elements. We must improve occupational health provision as best we can to reduce the number of lost officer days. Investing in technology and IT to reduce bureaucracy and to make things more efficient for officers will also play a part. Moreover, we have to think about whether we can generate substantial efficiency savings by building on the business benefits of the Airwave system, which some forces are delivering this financial year, and by considering the opportunities that are afforded by the use of mobile data. We are also trying to improve joint working arrangements with our local authority partners and other emergency services and have already started discussions with the Crown Office and the courts on various practices. After all, reducing the amount of time that officers spend in court will certainly make a difference to Mr Grant and his members and go a long way towards achieving some efficiency savings.Some elements such as IT might require upfront investment but, in response to your question, I point out that we have started to think about how to achieve these efficiencies. However, some of that work is at a pretty early stage.

Stewart Maxwell SNP West of Scotland
link

You said that, although you are in the first year of this period of efficiency savings, you have only just turned your thoughts to these matters. However, the lead-in time for technology can be fairly long. How will investment in technology over the next two to three years allow you to achieve the time-releasing efficiency savings to meet targets of the magnitude of £35 million and £50 million?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Technology on its own will not allow us to meet those targets; it is only one element of a package of measures that we are taking to achieve the savings. I expect that the 2006-07 target of £35 million and the 2007-08 target of £50 million will be achieved from the existing areas that I have mentioned and from new elements such as the use of mobile data.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Are you considering making time-releasing efficiency savings through the civilianisation of certain posts that are currently filled by police officers?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Each force is carrying out an on-going review of the police officer posts that could be civilianised and the posts that require specific police duties. Indeed, all forces have done a significant amount of work on the matter. However, we could consider not only civilianising some posts but outsourcing custody work. That would release significant efficiency savings into the police service and allow us to put the officers in those posts on operational duties. Investment might be required, but civilianisation will form part of the overall strategy of securing time-releasing savings.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

With regard to IT, would it be possible to employ civilians instead of police officers to input data?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Some forces have carried out a considerable amount of work on what we call data input bureaux. Instead of police officers having to come back to the station to input all the information on a crime into the crime system, they telephone it to data input bureau staff, who input it into the system instead. That takes place in a number of forces already, but there is probably scope for further work on that. In general, we could examine the areas in which support staff could be deployed to undertake some of the admin tasks at less cost.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Given what you have said, if any police officers are freed up as a result of the time-releasing initiatives, will you be able to pick priorities or will you merely have to provide extra manpower to meet the need that has been generated by new legislation? You have already mentioned the fact that the implementation of ASBOs has required one police force alone to deploy 50 extra police officers. If you generate extra police manpower, will you be able to set priorities or will it be a case of firefighting?

Joe Grant Scottish Police Federation
link

It is the view of the federation that releasing officers in that way will leave us at a standstill, because there has been no real growth in police budgets for quite a number of years. Part of the Executive's brief was that we would be able to use the efficiency savings, but we will not be able to use them to achieve growth; they will simply enable us to continue to do what we are doing at the moment. I do not think that that is good enough for the public and it certainly does not feel right to those officers who are carrying out the work.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

It seems that you are saying that the time-releasing initiatives will not allow you to prioritise. Is that correct?

Joe Grant Scottish Police Federation
link

Yes.

Tom Buchan Association of Scottish Police Superintendents
link

I think that Mr Cross mentioned Airwave. I am sure that members will be aware that we have modernised our area control rooms and telephony systems. In some territorial divisions in Strathclyde, that has resulted in a 30 per cent increase in the number of calls received. Regrettably, that tells us that, historically, 30 per cent of people were not getting through at peak times. If a 99 per cent success rate is achieved for people being answered the first time that they call in, that will produce a consequential increase in workload, even though some of the calls may be duplications. It is estimated that in some divisions in Strathclyde the number of calls taken has gone up by 25 per cent to 30 per cent. That is significant.The reason why I mention that is that it reinforces the point that Mr Grant made. That increase in business is not a consequence of new legislation; it is just a result of our doing better something that we did not do terribly well before. There is a price to be paid for such improvements. We must best manage our resources to meet the extra demand that is generated. To minimise the number of people contacting us who require an officer to go out to them immediately, we need to have a professional call-handling unit. Inevitably, that will be resourced by taking officers off the street, so there is a double whammy. It is a question of achieving balance and fighting hard to stand still.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

How do you envisage that the Executive and the Parliament will be notified of any savings that are achieved? I am aware that we have mentioned that in the context of the business benefits unit and the backroom services, and you referred to the best-value review. How do you propose that the monitoring and measurement will be reported back?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

As I have said, there is not a great deal of guidance on what will be required of us. We have started discussions with our colleagues down south, who have been doing such work for a bit longer than we have. ACPOS has decided that its finance committee should play the lead role in monitoring the savings. We have started by considering how we will allocate the savings across the forces and what targets each force should have. Progress on that will be monitored quarterly by the finance committee and the information will be fed up to ACPOS. The business benefits unit will be involved, too. Each quarter, we will be in a position to give some information on our progress on achieving those targets.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

We are in the process of doing that. The figures—which are relatively new to us—are efficiency savings only for the service as a whole. It is clear that the only way to achieve those savings is to break them down into targets for individual forces. Having said that, we are conscious that although there will be a target for forces, national initiatives will generate savings that will help to reduce the amount that each force has to contribute, which will make things easier for forces and should not impact on their service-delivery targets.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Do you envisage that the finance committee will have dialogue with the Executive or will most of the information be in the best-value annual report—or will both happen?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

A report will be produced at the end of the year, but we will have dialogue with the Executive throughout the year and we will be able to provide information. We do not know what we will be asked to do and we are not entirely sure what audit or inspection regime will be put in place. We are still to receive that information. We anticipate that the monitoring will take place internally in ACPOS and that we will report to the Executive as and when required.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

It seems that you are prepared to engage meaningfully with the Executive, but you did not have the courtesy of engagement from the Executive at the beginning of the process, which we have noted.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

We agreed earlier that we will pursue elements of what the witnesses said. I will take brief, final questions, the first of which is from Jackie Baillie.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Forgive me for asking this, but I want to get absolute clarity. We could debate whether there has been a percentage increase in police budgets; I do not have the figures with me to contest what you are saying. On the basis of what you have said, is it fair to say that you address efficiency anyway as part of your best-value audits?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Yes.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Secondly, if you released internally the £10 million, £35 million and £50 million savings, would you spend them on front-line policing?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Yes. We have to address

efficiency, because we do not always get the total amount that we think we require to police, so we need to put in place efficiencies to bridge the gap. In considering the debate about cashable or non-cashable efficiency targets, it is important to recognise that there is a shortfall and there are pressures from new legislation. It is imperative that savings that are generated are kept for the benefit of the police service rather than going elsewhere.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Sure. My understanding of time-releasing savings is that you keep them and control how they are allocated, so that is not in question. It is not as if the police are losing money; it is a question of how you reallocate it. You achieved £15 million efficiency savings in 2004-05, which I consider a big deal, from backroom functions. Were those savings reallocated in their entirety to front-line policing?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Well, £4 million of the saving was from Airwave. That one-off procurement saving assisted the forces' capital programmes. The saving was a combination of cash and time-releasing savings. The time-releasing savings were generated by forces and will have been used to meet the pressures in each force.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

There is no way of tracking that. We have not had to monitor the savings in the way that we might have to monitor savings against the new efficiency targets that have been put in place.

Margo MacDonald Ind Lothians
link

Are the cash-releasing efficiency savings reallocated in the entire police service in Scotland? If so, who decides the priority of allocation to forces? I ask that, because when Professor Arbuthnott decided how to divide up the cash for the health service—a similar thing—it was determined that more cash would go to where people were sicker. Will more cash come to Lothian and Borders police because more work is undertaken here that the other forces do not have to bother about?

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I should really rule that question out of order.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

The time-releasing savings to which we refer have been gained from individual forces' achievement of efficiency savings and best-value continuous improvement. The savings are made in the individual forces; there is no overview in the reallocation of the savings. Savings that are identified in a force will be used for the benefit of that force.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Likewise, no cash savings target was in place for 2004-05.

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Not in the figures to which we refer, which are for 2004-05—before the targets were put in place.

Margo MacDonald Ind Lothians
link

I have a wee doubt about that, but I will leave it to the committees to clear up.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

It occurs to me that one of the areas of savings was the Reliance contract, whereby police officers were meant to be freed up. Can you identify what savings have been made in that regard? If you cannot do so today, can we get that information?

Doug Cross Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland
link

Yes. I would not like to give a figure today. I have a rough idea, but I could provide you with a figure from each force, which would be more accurate.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

That would be helpful. There are no further questions. I thank all three witnesses for their evidence, which I am sure we will put to good use.I have had a request for a brief comfort break. We will reconvene at 12 o'clock.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

Our final witnesses this morning are from the Scottish Prison Service. Members will know Tony Cameron, the chief executive, as he has been before us many times before. Willie Pretswell is the director of finance and business services. We have approximately one hour for questions.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

In the draft budget 2006-07, under the justice portfolio's second objective of "Reducing re-offending", target 5 is "a 2% reduction in reconviction rates in all types of sentence by March 2008". What contribution is the Scottish Prison Service expected to make to achieving that target?

Tony Cameron Scottish Prison Service
link

There is no direct read-across from that Executive target to the key performance indicators that the Parliament has approved for the SPS. However, over the past few years, we have concentrated on our key mission as part of the criminal justice system, which is to keep in secure custody those committed by the courts. That is what we will continue to do. Obviously, people are unlikely to reoffend during the period in which they are committed, although if someone creates a lack of order in a prison, that would be a criminal offence. We aim to keep people in conditions that are safe and secure for other prisoners and our staff. We have a role in two aspects of care. One bit of evidence from a number of countries is that prisoners, as a class, do not do well. They tend to suffer multiple deprivation, not least in relation to health care—the drug abuse problems are well known. Therefore, one of our main aims is to increase the health care that we give to prisoners. Secondly, we have the opportunity to try to ensure that people leave prison slightly less likely to reoffend and, if possible, slightly more employable than they were when they went in.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

That is rehabilitation, in other words. How do specific rehabilitation programmes in prisons seek to address offending behaviour and reduce or minimise the potential for reoffending?

Tony Cameron Scottish Prison Service
link

I will deal with your question in terms of the most potent influences on offending, the first of which is age. As people get older, they tend to reoffend less, although there is not much that anyone can do about the progress of time. Another factor is having a home. When someone is in prison, they have a home but, when they leave, they might not. If they do not have a home, they are more likely to reoffend. We seek to do a lot to join up seamlessly with partners in the community to ensure that people do not fall down a hole in the grid. Another factor is employability, or at least the ability to do something useful that gets you up in the morning. Education is probably the most important thing in that regard, rather than specific programmes. In recent years, we have increased our education hours by about 50 per cent because the reading ages of many of the prisoners are not high and the three Rs are not well embedded. You cannot be trained to do a job if you cannot read and write. Many of the people who are in prison did not go to school often and so have a huge learning deficit.Although one should not stress too much the extent to which these can make a difference, there are what we might call psychology-based programmes that seek to alter behaviour in various ways. Some help people to cope with things and others change the way in which they think about crime. We have increased the amount of both of those types of programmes. We have accredited programmes, which are ones that experts from a number of countries regard as being quite useful. However, if you give the wrong sort of programme to the wrong person, you can make them worse rather than better. The other programmes are what we call approved activities. For example, they can be on drug awareness or coping skills to try to enable people to live a more independent life. We have increased both types of programme massively. We delivered about 871 approved activities in 2001-02; in 2004-05, we delivered 2,304, which is a huge step change in what we are putting in.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

The committees would acknowledge and welcome that step change in the number of programmes and in the number of learning hours, which have increased by 50 per cent. Do you or Mr Pretswell believe that sufficient resources are devoted to such programmes to allow the progress that you have outlined to continue and perhaps grow, and thus, one hopes, to reduce reconviction rates by reducing reoffending?

Tony Cameron Scottish Prison Service
link

A balance must always be struck in running a complex organisation, particularly one that runs a set of societies that are separated from general society. We have found from our long experience that overadherence to one measure tends to result in neglect of others. Everybody would like more of everything, but the important point in any rigorous budget process is to prioritise and ensure that the taxpayer gets the best aggregate deal for the total amount of money. I can say that the budget for the SPS for 2006-07, which is what we are commenting on, is satisfactory to allow for the potential prisoner population in that year and to achieve our key performance indicator targets, which include, among others, the ones that we have been speaking about, which I would loosely call those on opportunities and care.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

So, while achieving a correct balance between the multiplicity of priorities with which you must deal, there are sufficient resources to allow for real consolidation and progress in the elements that we have been talking about.

Tony Cameron Scottish Prison Service
link

Not just consolidation, but progress.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

By consolidation, I did not mean just standing still, but a situation in which you can grow and progress from the point that you are at.

Tony Cameron Scottish Prison Service
link

Yes. For example, in the financial year that we are halfway through, our aim is to deliver, under the opportunity agenda for prisoners, 1.3 million hours of offender development. We have started counting the number of hours because some programmes last weeks and hours and others last only a few days. Previously, we counted each programme as one, which did not seem sensible.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

How much of an increase will that constitute?

Tony Cameron Scottish Prison Service
link

I cannot tell you what the number of hours was in the past, but our target is a significant increase in activity this year compared with activity last year.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Is it possible to give the committees that information—

Tony Cameron Scottish Prison Service
link

I cannot do that sum off the top of my head.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Not off the top of your head, but if you could give that information in writing, that would be helpful.

Tony Cameron Scottish Prison Service
link

Yes. There is no difficulty with that.With the care element of the agenda, we hope to mirror the sort of care that a prisoner could get in the community if he were not a prisoner. That is difficult to do in a secure prison setting, but we do not believe that a prisoner, just because he is a prisoner, should be denied the sort of health care and other care to which he would be entitled otherwise. The fact is that the people with whom we deal do not often avail themselves of such care when they are in the community, but in prison it is brought to them and they avail themselves of it.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Are you satisfied that you are moving towards that aim?

Tony Cameron Scottish Prison Service
link

The health service rightly has a lot more money than we have, but we try to maintain and, if possible, improve the relative standard of our care. In so far as one can judge, at present the degree of general health care that we give is equivalent to the care that people receive in the community. However, we should bear in mind the fact that we do not have a cross-section of the community: 95 per cent of our prisoners are male; they tend to be young men; and two thirds of prisoners who come into prison test positive for illegal drugs. Those are not the average figures in the community. There are special challenges in health and general care. We hope also to address a number of special issues to do with women prisoners in Cornton Vale.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banff and Buchan
link

I raise a technical point with Mr Cameron. I understand that the 2 per cent reduction in reconviction rates that you mentioned relates to individuals being reconvicted. Do you have a sense—I suspect that it cannot be much more than that—of the contribution that you make to the reduction in the number of crimes as distinct from the number of people who reoffend? Both aspects make a clear contribution. Some people will never offend again because of the success of your programmes and other interventions, and others will reduce their offending. Will you give us a sense of that balance?

Tony Cameron Scottish Prison Service
link

You are quite right on the last point: serious sex offenders rarely offend again; they have one of the lowest reoffending rates. One would not think that to listen to the media, but that is the case.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banff and Buchan
link

I think that you are talking about reconviction rates. Is that a fair comment?

Tony Cameron Scottish Prison Service
link

Absolutely, although the same would apply to charges. We provided a seven-page submission to assist the committees. We are aware that there is not much time before the conclusion of the budgetary process, but we were invited on 24 October to make any key points on the budget and the efficient government initiative, so we have set down the points that we feel will help the committees to respond in a useful way to the Finance Committee. I draw the committees' attention to the graph in annex C to our submission, which is relevant to Stewart Stevenson's question. The information in the graph is based on published sources. It tracks over the past 50 years the progress of crime as reported to the police per 1,000 of population and the progress of the prison population per 100,000 of population. The reason for the difference is to get it all on the same page—one could not do so otherwise. The interpretation of the graph is difficult. It is not easy to say that more imprisonment reduces crime. If that were the case, the system did not work for 40 years. Over the past 20-odd years, we have seen a significant reduction in crime from its peak in 1990, but the increase in the prison population has continued. The number of people who are brought to justice in the courts has not increased, but sentence length for a given set of crimes has increased. We are not sure what that is doing to the reduction of reoffending. If one postulates that more imprisonment has helped, it is difficult to see why it did not help in the previous 40 years. If one does not think that it helps, we have not got much better at doing things all of a sudden. Admittedly, we have done a great deal more in the past 10 years on the opportunity agenda, about which I spoke to Bill Butler, but I would be a brave man if I were to claim that the reduction in crime is as a result of that—as practitioners, we simply do not believe that to be the case. Something else is happening in the community to help to reduce crime, and reducing it certainly is.I am sorry that I do not have an easy answer to that interesting question.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

I want to probe more into the employability, education and three Rs programmes. Whom are such programmes directed at? The Justice 1 Committee is particularly interested in knowing whether such programmes are directed at short-term prisoners. Is there a possibility of having mandatory testing to identify literacy and numeracy problems early on and of directing people with such problems, even those serving short-term sentences, into the education programmes that you highlighted as receiving more money and attention?

Tony Cameron Scottish Prison Service
link

The answer depends on whether you are talking about what we call education or what I am now taught to call skills acquisition—my colleagues tell me that I must use that phrase now. We tend to provide that for everyone, whether they are in for life or for a short term, although that does not include those who are in overnight.A large number of people come to prison for very short terms and there is not much that we can do with them at all, apart from to patch them up medically, as they may be with us for only a few days—and many of them are not with us, quite, because they are still suffering withdrawal symptoms. Taking the definition of a short term as being under four years—four years is the legal breakpoint—we try to make education available to everyone.When it comes to programmes to address offending behaviour, especially the expensive programmes, we have tended to concentrate on long-term, serious offenders. We have to concentrate our resources somewhere and our judgment has been that addressing our best efforts to the long-term population is likely to give the best pay-off. That is partly because we can be pretty sure that they will complete the programme—if they want to—and will not be released before the end of it. Nevertheless, we are now trying to get arrangements whereby someone can continue a programme in the community or start a programme in the community and continue it in prison.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

That is helpful, but it goes quite against the Justice 1 Committee's finding that, even for prisoners who serve a short term of six weeks or less, identifying problems and providing help and support may well improve their employability prospects and, hence, the prospect of their not being reconvicted and not reoffending.

Tony Cameron Scottish Prison Service
link

The figures are not robust, but international evidence shows that, for short-term prisoners, incarceration increases the likelihood of reoffending. If someone is likely to reoffend, that tendency is increased by the mere fact of their incarceration. All the problems that they had before are still there, but some of them have been multiplied by their incarceration because the dislocations that I talked about earlier are all accentuated by that. I am not arguing that sentencers should not have that option but, as a society, we should not kid ourselves that short-term incarceration is likely, of itself, to reduce reoffending rates. All things being equal, it will have a tendency to increase reoffending rates.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

That is certainly not what I was saying. I was saying that, when someone is incarcerated, you should use the opportunity to identify the problems and to try to work towards—

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice 1 Committee and Justice 2 Committee (Joint Meeting) Wednesday 26 October 2005 Committee business · 1
  2. Items in Private Procedure · 1
  3. Budget Process 2006-07 Committee business · 328

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.