link
We will deal first with closed petition PE14, on security of tenure and rights of access.
Official Report · Committee
Carbeth Hutters (PE14)
link
We will deal first with closed petition PE14, on security of tenure and rights of access.
I agree with the recommendation in the clerk's note. We went as far as we could go in our consideration of PE14. Our additional consideration of the matter led to a possible course of action being suggested and it is for the Carbeth hutters to decide whether to pursue that course of action through the courts.
I will make a general point, which I think was made when we considered the petition previously. We must be wary of putting ourselves in a position in which we become a source of legal advice—we are not equipped to be such a source. The committee does not have the resources to commission legal opinion except in exceptional circumstances that relate to our work. I cannot identify any action that we could usefully take on the matter. If something is brought to our attention in the future, I am sure that we will find time to discuss the matter further, notwithstanding the closure of PE14. However, I do not anticipate that that will happen soon.
link
I remember dealing with the petition, which was lodged in 1999. The Carbeth hutters have received genuine sympathy and support, as have other people who subsequently supported the principles of the petition and its call for protection for hutters. Members have seen the correspondence that we received from hutters, who express dissatisfaction and concern because their situation has not moved forward since 1999. It is worth saying on the record that the failure to make progress is the result not of a lack of support or action on the part of the committee—or the Justice and Home Affairs Committee in the previous session of Parliament—but of the lack of a solution that can be tried and tested.Members know that we appointed an adviser on the matter, who identified all the potential legal solutions with us in a private meeting. After considering different aspects of the law, we took the view that it would be impossible to secure legal protection for the hutters without upsetting the balance in relation to other aspects of the law. I think that we settled on an approach that would consider the application of what I read as a type of right-to-buy provision in the Land Registration (Scotland) Act 1979. The Executive responded that it could not comment on the application of the 1979 act, which took us no further forward. As the clerk's note says, Alasdair Morgan intimated to the committee that the Rascarrel bay hutters were aware of a case in which the 1979 act was being used, but we do not know the outcome of that case.I am reluctant to leave the matter in the air and I do not think that the committee should make the decision that nothing can be done; I am not convinced that we have exhausted the potential for revision of the 1979 act. Do members think that we should ask the Executive to reach a conclusion on the matter? I accept that the Executive cannot comment on the application of the 1979 act, which is a matter for the courts. However, is there scope for amending the 1979 act to strengthen the right-to-buy provisions that appear to apply to people who already have a lease?If the Executive were to say, "We have looked at amending the act and there is no way of doing so that would give comfort to hutters", I would accept that that is the case. However, so far the Executive has said only that it will not comment on application of the act.
I tend to agree with the convener's last comments. Notwithstanding the action that is still under way, it is starting to appear as if the only solution to the problem is a political solution; one that would involve changes to legislation. If that is the case, clearly the best place for that to be examined and, potentially, determined is the Executive itself. I would be sympathetic to a recommendation that asked the Executive to comment specifically on that. I do not propose to ask the Executive to comment on how it thinks the law should be applied, but on whether there is scope to change the legislation.
link
That is the only unanswered question. Hugh Henry said:"As neither Ministers nor officials can provide legal advice, I am unable to comment on Professor Rennie's view that the hutters could claim to be tenants-at-will. This is a matter for the courts to determine. Section 21(1) of the Land Registration (Scotland) Act 1979 provides that the hutters can ask the Lands Tribunal for such a determination if they wish to test the matter in court."Although I accept the answer, the only unanswered question is whether the act could be strengthened in some way that would give hutters and other similar leaseholders some protection under the law.The clerk has reminded me of our previous correspondence with the Executive, in which the Executive said that there was no prospect of a legislative solution. The clerk will advise whether we received that letter before Professor Rennie's report was published. Even if that was the case, I would still wish to write to the Executive on the basis of that report.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.