link
I refer members to the clerk's note on SSI 2005/150, which is also subject to the
negative procedure.
Official Report · Committee
Act of Sederunt (Fees of Shorthand Writers in the Sheriff Court) (Amendment) 2005 (SSI 2005/150)
link
I refer members to the clerk's note on SSI 2005/150, which is also subject to the
negative procedure.
I make the same point again, although with less force because the increase is only 3.7 per cent in this case. Although an explanation is provided—the increase is the mid-point between inflation and average earnings over a 12-month period—I ask simply whether the spending of public money in this way is justified, given that we have not had it demonstrated to us that attempts are being made to make savings and to increase the efficiency of the operation. I should add that I am not entirely convinced that 3.7 per cent is the mid-point between 3 per cent and 4 per cent, but I will leave that arithmetic niggle to one side.I am more cautious about going in hard in this case because, in many respects, the processes that are undertaken might be determined by legislation, which would mean that, without changing the relevant law, they are not susceptible to efficiencies that might be introduced. I would nonetheless like to ask what attempts are being made to introduce efficiencies in this area of public expenditure.
link
I have absolutely no knowledge of the salary of a shorthand writer. If I knew that the background to the instrument was that the pay of shorthand writers had dragged behind that of others, I would be happier.
You make the point well, convener. We simply do not know the background, so it is reasonable to ask for further information. That would be consistent with our approach to the previous instrument.
There is a chance that you might know about the matter somewhere in your subconscious. I hope that the matter was previously considered when I was not a member of the committee, so that I cannot be accused of forgetting about it. The second paragraph of the letter from the Lord President's private office states:"The method used to calculate this percentage increase was explained to the committee at the time the Acts of Sederunt increasing the fees of sheriff officers and messengers-at-arms were considered by your committee."Does anybody recall that and do they recall whether I was here? I am sure that the clerks have the information at their fingertips.
link
I certainly recall the correspondence; it is likely that you were here because you joined the committee at the same time as Stewart Stevenson, who proposed that we write to seek more information on the matter.My only reservation is that I do not want the committee to write to the Lord President with another question every time we consider an instrument of this kind. At some point, somebody will say to us, "Why don't you just do the work on it?"
Bruce McFee pointed out the method that is used to calculate the percentage increase, which is different from the reasons for imposing the increase; we are seeking more information about the latter point.
I accept that distinction.
I would prefer not to be asking questions on each such instrument that comes before us. I will cease to ask such questions if, in the first instance, information is provided that enables me to understand that there is justification for the increase and that efforts are being made in this area where public money is spent, as in others.I have examined the issue considerably and am sure that if the Minister for Finance and Public Service Reform has not yet turned his mind to achieving efficiencies in this area, he is likely to do so—the matter is part of an overall picture. If we were provided with the information in the first place, extra work would not be generated. It is part of our duty to justify such increases, which are relatively—although not excessively—substantial.
link
I take it that the committee is minded to seek further information from the Lord President about the fees of shorthand writers.
On the general point that Stewart Stevenson just made, is it possible to mention to the Lord President that it would be helpful if we had that information in the first instance so that we do not have to keep going back to his office to ask about each case that comes before us? That would preclude this happening each time we consider such increases in fees.
Following on from that, we assume that the Lord President asked for such information in the first case in order to reach his decision. Perhaps more explanatory information than we currently receive would be useful and would not cause too much extra work.
link
I apologise, Bruce—I did not hear the last part of what you said.
Okay, I will let you read it in the Official Report.
link
I am sure that it was dead important. The clerks were pointing out to me that correspondence from the Lord President would not normally be attached to our papers. However, because we have been asking questions, the correspondence is his office's pre-emptive attempt to give us the information that we seek. Is the committee saying that it is not satisfied, but wants more information?
I think that we should give the Lord President's office a "could do better" on its report card. Let us hope that we never appear before him.
link
You accept that his office has given us the method that was used to calculate the percentage increase, but do you want the office to justify the increase being slightly higher than inflation?
We accept the method that the Lord President has used to calculate the increase, but we do not know the rationale for the level of the increase.
The bottom line is that there is now a focus on improving efficiency in public services—it is one of the Executive policies that I support in broad terms and which has broad support throughout Parliament. It is part of our duty to ensure that when such instruments come before us, that policy is addressed. I do not accept that that is the case in respect of the two instruments that we have considered today. It might be that that policy is being addressed, but the evidence does not show us that.
link
So—you just want to check that the Lord President's method of calculation is not wildly out of step with the approach to public sector pay in general.
The important point is that the sheriff courts, like everyone else, should seek to make their operation more efficient and to show us that they are doing that. If, in doing that, they then say that they need to increase fees, that is fair enough.
link
Okay.Members have agreed to discuss agenda item 5 in private.
Meeting continued in private until 13:12.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.