link
On the second item of subordinate legislation, I refer members to a note that has been prepared by the clerk. This is a negative instrument, and I invite comments from members.
Official Report · Committee
Act of Sederunt (Fees of Sheriff Officers) 2004 (SSI 2004/513)
link
On the second item of subordinate legislation, I refer members to a note that has been prepared by the clerk. This is a negative instrument, and I invite comments from members.
I have given the clerk a note of the issues that I have with the instrument. I do not propose to move that nothing further be done on the instrument at this stage, and I suspect that I am unlikely to do so within the prescribed period. Nevertheless, there are several questions that the clerk's paper simply does not answer. First, does the 3.7 per cent increase in fees include the change that allows sheriff officers to be paid for postage in addition to the prescribed fees? If it does not, the increase will be greater than 3.7 per cent.Secondly, how has the figure of 3.7 per cent been arrived at? The previous instrument, which was dealt with 12 months ago in December 2003, raised the level by 3.2 per cent. I do not know where the new figure has come from. Is it the same as the figure for average wage inflation over the same period? If so, why has the increase not been based on the average inflation in the cost of living? After all, those figures are different. No justification has been given for that.Thirdly, I simply do not understand how the various figures relate to the costs of the provision of services by sheriff officers. Indeed, I cannot see any relationship between the actual fees and the different headings setting out the work that is involved.My final point is relatively minor. Some recent legislation—for example, with regard to planning—has provided for the sending of legal notices by e-mail. However, I am not sure whether any notices can legally be provided by sheriff officers by e-mail. If they can, there does not appear to be any provision for fees in that respect. As a result, I propose that it is reasonable for the committee to write to the Minister for Justice and seek answers to those questions before allowing a committee member to decide whether to move that nothing further be done under the instrument.
link
Thank you for giving us notice of the issues that you wished to raise.At this stage, all the committee can do is to write and ask for clarification on the points that Stewart Stevenson has raised. I believe that we would write to the minister on the subject of sheriff officers' fees.
So we would write to the minister rather than to the Lord President.
link
Yes.
Okay.
Given that the changes are to be enacted on 1 January, what would be the effect of this delay?
It would have no effect.
link
As this is a negative instrument, it has already been laid and simply lies there for a number of days. There is still time for someone to lodge a motion to annul, but Stewart Stevenson has said that he wants to wait for answers to his questions before he makes any such decision. The provisions will come into force on the date of enactment, unless Parliament annuls them. All we would do is to recommend that Parliament should annul the instrument, but that can happen only if a member moves a motion to do so. No member is moving such a motion this morning, but it would not be out of order for the committee to consider any such motion within the timeframe.We have until 20 January. I have to say that I would not be minded to support a motion to annul the instrument unless we received something earth shattering from the minister. That said, I have no problem with asking the Executive why it has arrived at a figure of 3.7 per cent—in any case, fees should be updated to reflect any changes in technology—but I do not know whether there is a legal answer to the question whether such an increase is allowed in the first place.
It is unlikely that I will lodge a motion to annul. However, I want to ensure that ministers argue the case for introducing provisions that will require the public to bear additional costs. I do not believe that the clerk's paper presents that argued case. That is the real issue for me. I am not trying to deny sheriff officers, who in effect work as private companies, the proper reward for their work.
link
In the spirit of what Stewart Stevenson said, I see no problem in writing for more information, unless anyone dissents. When we receive a reply from the minister we can decide which aspects should be included in a report. The reply will not constitute the whole report, but there may be elements within it that Parliament should be aware of when it agrees the instrument. Is that agreed?
Members indicated agreement.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.