I note that Mike Pringle, who is a member of the Subordinate Legislation Committee, is also here. He, too, has expertise in the area.I hope that the committee will bear with me, because there is a substantive problem with the regulations, but there is also an issue to do with the Scotland Act 1998. I will work my way through the issues, if the committee is okay with that.The Subordinate Legislation Committee feels that there is a strong case that the regulations that purport to authorise the Scottish ministers to appoint the Lord Advocate as the person to enforce orders of the International Criminal Court are ultra vires. The purpose of regulation 3, which is the one in question, is to authorise the Scottish ministers to appoint the Lord Advocate as that person, and regulations 4 and 5 impose duties directly on the Lord Advocate rather than on the Scottish ministers collectively—I will return to that issue later.The Subordinate Legislation Committee doubted that the enabling power allowed that authorisation, so it asked the Executive for further justification and questioned the constitutional propriety of conferring statutory functions on the Lord Advocate as an individual Scottish minister that do not relate to his position as head of the systems of criminal prosecution and of the investigation of deaths in Scotland. The Executive replied that it considers that regulation 3 is within the vires of the enabling power, which confers a power on the Scottish ministers to appoint a person to act on behalf of the ICC. In the Executive's view, section 26 of the International Criminal Court (Scotland) Act 2001 provides no reason why the Lord Advocate should not be that person.The Subordinate Legislation Committee was not persuaded, because section 26(2) of the 2001 act provides:"The regulations may authorise the Scottish Ministers-(a) to appoint a person to act on behalf of the ICC for the purposes of enforcing the order; and (b) to give such directions to the appointed person as appear to them necessary."We think that that indicates that the person is a third party. We see no indication that the section intended that the Scottish ministers should appoint one of their own number. On the contrary, because it also enables Scottish ministers to give directions to the person appointed, the appointment of a Scottish minister appears clearly to be ruled out; it cannot have been intended that the Scottish ministers should give the Lord Advocate or any other minister directions as to how they were to carry out their functions.Simply to specify by regulations the person to be appointed also appears to be of doubtful vires, as it can be argued that the power is intended simply to authorise to ministers the subdelegation of the power to chose the person appointed, so it is not for the regulations to specify that person. The Subordinate Legislation Committee noted that, in that regard, the equivalent English regulations, which are made under identical powers, confer powers to appoint a person rather than a named individual.In the Subordinate Legislation Committee's view, if there is any doubt about the intention behind the section 26 powers, the situation is clarified beyond all reasonable doubt by statements that were made by the ministers in charge of the International Criminal Court (Scotland) Act 2001 on two occasions during its passage through the Parliament. I think that the committee has before it the information on what Iain Gray and Jim Wallace said.