Can I have a copy of the work programme that has the second page? I must have lost the other page; I have so many papers.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Margaret Smith only · show everyone- Pauline McNeill Lab 15
- Margaret Smith LD 11
- Stewart Maxwell SNP 5
- Michael Matheson SNP 3
- Bill Butler Lab 1
Margaret Smith’s contributions
11 contributionsGiven my constituency interest, I am a bit concerned by the suggestion of taking north Edinburgh drug advice centre out of the list of individuals and organisations that will give oral evidence. Last week, I was in Saughton prison in Edinburgh—as you can see, they let me back out again—to see its Fairbridge project. However, when I spoke to the prisoners, the issue of the effect of drugs on their lives and their offending came up time and time again. I appreciate that time is limited, but that aspect is obviously central to the issues that we have to consider. The staff to whom I spoke said that one of the key reasons why people reoffend quite quickly after release is that drug services are not set up to deal with them speedily. They might have to wait a month before someone is available to discuss their problems, drug rehabilitation and so on. However, without a job or any means of support, people reoffend within that time to get money for drugs. As I have said, I think that the issue is absolutely central to our inquiry.
I still suggest that it is important to take oral evidence on the effect of drugs. I do not have a problem with the fact that some of us might want to visit the north Edinburgh drug advice centre outwith a committee meeting, and I think that such informal meetings are quite useful, but the issue of drugs is central to what is happening in a lot of people's lives and to why they cannot get out of the cycle of reoffending. It is important to be able to question people on the record about that. Other witnesses may touch on that when they give evidence, but it is a central issue and I feel that we would benefit from hearing from people who deal with drugs issues all the time.
You ask a reasonable question, but I do not have a breakdown of how members envisage dealing with the witnesses or of which witnesses would come to which session, so it is quite difficult for me to answer. I just feel that the issue of drugs is absolutely central to our inquiry. I am not wedded to the idea that we have to hear evidence from the north Edinburgh drug advice centre, but I think that we have to take oral evidence from somebody who is able to answer our questions about the importance of drugs and of proper drug rehabilitation services in tackling reoffending behaviour. As I said, I am not wedded to the idea that that oral evidence must come from the north Edinburgh drug advice centre, although it would be useful to visit that centre.
I am quite happy with Michael Matheson's point that there could be a second phase that would take us into more informal meetings. I just want to ensure that on what I consider to be a central point—the importance of the drugs issue—we are able to question somebody who is among the first set of witnesses for oral evidence. That would allow us to get to the bottom of the matter and find out what services are being made available to people and whether that is one of the reasons why there is a revolving-door issue for a number of people with such problems.
For clarification, would the meeting in Glasgow be one of the four evidence sessions, or would it be additional to those meetings?
From the breakdown, it appears that the most obvious meeting at which to slot someone else into a panel is that on Wednesday 29 September. I hope that any organisation worth its salt would be happy to take on the challenge at a couple of weeks' notice. I want to ensure that we cover the issue of drug rehabilitation for prisoners on release. From talking to prisoners, prison officers, Fairbridge staff and people from Edinburgh prison throughcare centre and other organisations, I have a sense that that is a big contributory factor in reoffending. Much good work is being done in prison to get people ready for release and to get them to think about what they will do when they are released. However, when they are released, one of the first issues with which they have to deal is the fact that they have a drug habit.The important point is that we should hear from people who can tell us what is being done to tackle the problem. I am relaxed at the prospect of leaving things as they are for the moment and re-evaluating them after 15 September, with a view to slotting in a representative of Fairbridge or another organisation on 29 September. We will take advice on which organisation would be the best for us to hear from. The issue is not geography, but who is providing the service and has the information that we need to access.
The issue that we are considering is the effectiveness of rehabilitation programmes in prisons and the work that is being done in prisons with people who have a drug problem. One difficulty seems to arise at the point of release—what kind of throughcare is put in place for people in relation to their drug habit? I understand that there is a gap. It may be a gap of only a week, but we have been told that it is extraordinary for it to be that short and that there is more likely to be a gap of something like a month between people receiving rehabilitation in prison and their getting it in the community. There does not seem to be a smooth transition from what is being done to tackle drug misuse in the prison context to what is being done in the community. We probably want to hear from organisations that work both in prisons and in the community.
I am talking about situations in which work is being done with someone in prison, but there is absolutely nothing there for them when they walk out the door. One of the first things that seems to happen is that such people offend to feed their habit and end up back in prison straight away. The people who have worked with them in prison are left feeling frustrated. The issue is immediate throughcare, rather than how people are dealt with three or six months down the line.
Yes.
I am happy with that approach, as long as the issue is dealt with.
In this meeting
Everything on 30 Jun 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Justice 1 Committee Wednesday 30 June 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 92
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Alternatives to Custody Committee business · 50
- Work Programme Procedure · 35
- Civil Partnership Bill Bill debate · 18
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.