Good morning. I welcome everyone to the joint meeting of the Justice 1 Committee and the Justice 2 Committee to scrutinise the budget process. I have received apologies from Colin Fox, Maureen Macmillan, Nicola Sturgeon and Jackie Baillie. I formally welcome Ken McKay, the adviser to the committee, who will assist us in our scrutiny of the budget process from here on in.The only item on the agenda is our consideration of the budget process 2005-06. I welcome the team from the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service. Stephen Woodhouse is the director of finance; Shona Barrie is the team leader of the policy group; and John Dunn is head of the High Court unit. I thank you for coming along this morning. There are a number of questions that we would like to put to you.
We are making very good progress. You will know from our previous appearances before the committee that we have carried out a major restructuring of the way in which the Crown Office works, to improve relations with the police. That seems to be working well.In the High Court unit, there has been a major restructuring of the way in which advocate deputes operate. We are introducing new information technology systems, which will improve the flow and management of casework through the system. We are now looking at the electronic transfer of cases to the Scottish Court Service. In general we feel that we are making very good progress—as evidenced by our improved performance against our targets.
I will pick up on the point about the electronic transfer of cases to the courts. Can you give us more information about that? What stage is that work at?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
The sheriff court material has been going to the Scottish Court Service for some time now. We are now piloting the transfer of High Court cases to the Scottish Court Service. John Dunn will perhaps say more about that.
John DunnCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
We started the transfer of data in February as a pilot. That was successful and we have been continuing with it since 5 April. We have a little bit to do at our end in getting our data as up to date as we would like them to be—and as they need to be—but benefits are arising from the process. Those include the fact that the data files will be sent to the Scottish Court Service a fortnight in anticipation of the sitting. Prior to that—I hope two weeks prior to that date—the Scottish Court Service will have an electronic version of the indictment, which will generate savings in the quantity of paper that is used. In addition, a benefit will arise from the fact that once the Scottish Court Service has in its possession electronic data files, it can update, in real time, the court disposals. That information will then inhabit our standard office system—SOS VI. Therefore, as a result of the electronic exchange of data and indictments, the disposals will be available to the staff in the COPFS much more quickly than has been possible hitherto.
The Lord Advocate told the committees on 7 October last year that the budget beyond 2002-03 was not a flat-line budget as additional money would be released by removing inefficiencies and by investment in IT, which you touched on in your response to Margaret Smith. Can you tell the committee a little more about the progress that has been made on those two fronts? You say that IT has generated and will generate savings. Can you quantify the savings in monetary terms? What savings have been, and are being, generated in removing inefficiencies?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
On the IT front, the systems that we are putting in automate the bulk of the processing; a lot of the paperwork is done electronically, so we do not need people to push paper about. We estimate that the saving produced by that amounts to, approximately, the costs of 80 staff.
That is the most direct saving. There will generally be more efficient handling of cases and better planning of cases and of the work load. That will generate savings in due course, but we have not attempted to evaluate the next stage of that work.
We can do that once we have got the new office system fully in place—installation started late last year and will not be completed until we put the system into Glasgow in June. Until then we will not be in a position to assess the implications fully.
Yes.You mentioned other changes. On the solemn side of the business, we had a project called project solemn renewal, which relates to the serious cases. We have simplified much of the process for taking precognitions. Again, we are piloting that project.
John DunnCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
I can pick up on that as I am one of the co-chairs of that project. What it means is that we can target our resources more effectively. It is not a theory, because it arose from experience in one of the fiscals' areas. I have some figures that show that a significant increase in the work load was capable of being dealt with within existing resources.The particular area concerned had a net increase in petitions from 456 to 567. That meant that there was an increase in precognitions reported to the Crown Office from 326 to 416. That might not sound like much, but that is just for one area. We simplified the precognition process in relation to sheriff and jury work, not so that it is done carelessly but so that it is done in a manner that is fit for its purpose in the sheriff court. The efficiencies gained from that could be used to pick up the increase in work that arose and, in addition, to focus on High Court work to generate as good a product as possible for the end user: the advocate depute who is prosecuting the case in the High Court.
That is good to hear, but are you looking to make other efficiencies that would have the same beneficial effects as the one that you have just illustrated?
John DunnCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
Things are starting to feed through. The quality of our preparation is improving. We are better prepared because we have more advocate deputes, and we now have much greater opportunities for preparation and engagement with our counterparts in the defence, which means we are beginning to see a fairly dramatic improvement in the rate of disposal of our High Court business.
I have the figures for this year and last year. This time last year, it was an unfortunate fact of life that we were adjourning a high percentage—on occasion, as much as 60 per cent—of our cases in the High Court in Glasgow. Most of those adjournments were on defence motions—I do not doubt that this will take us back to the Bonomy proposals in due course. However, more recent figures show that far fewer cases are being adjourned, to the extent that in the last sitting for which we have records, we adjourned 25 per cent of cases. Clearly, the figure of one in four is not ideal, but it is a big improvement, and there is scope for more improvement. All those things are building up a critical mass to improve our throughput and our efficiency.
I want to try to get a picture of all this. If we go back to 2001-02 and 2002-03, my understanding is that there was an aggregate increase in your budget of about £24 million. Have those moneys been fully deployed with the various changes that you have talked about, or does any surplus remain?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
The moneys have been fully deployed. We have had quite large increases in legal staff since that time, as the committees probably know, and as 60 per cent of our budget goes on pay, a lot of the moneys have gone on that. The investment in IT has absorbed £3 million or £4 million each year. Just keeping the system going absorbs quite a lot. For example, we spend £10 million a year on our buildings.
It will be a continuing charge, because we have to maintain a network in 50 sites. Developments are required for the Bonomy measures and might be required for the McInnes review, but we think that the bulk of the IT spend either has happened or will happen this year, and it should scale down from 2005-06 onwards. We expect the spend to be much less, because the main change—which is the future office system—is happening now.
In large measure, it is attributable to the ability to focus resources on the preparation of our more serious cases—namely the High Court cases—and the fact that we now have a complement of advocate deputes that is greater than we had in the past, which means they now have available to them a week of preparation time prior to the sitting. In a sense, the way in which that time is being used anticipates the Bonomy proposals, because the advocate deputes have their papers and engage with their counterparts in the defence to see what the position is, so that we know which cases are going to trial, on which cases pleas are likely to be made and which cases may have to be adjourned. We can discuss the reasons for adjournment and see if we can identify a means of not adjourning a case. For example, if the reason is something as simple as an expert witness not being available in week 1, we can try to schedule our case in such a way that it runs in week 2 of the sitting. Those are the primary reasons for the upturn in the disposal rate of our High Court business.
That also prevents witnesses from needing to come along and victims from being distressed as a result of thinking that their case will be heard in the first week when it might not be.
We could give a rough estimate. We can probably quantify how much time is saved by conducting the precognitions more effectively, because they now take less time. I am not sure that we could put a figure on the effect on the High Court, but we could take that away and have a think.
It is important to bear it in mind that although witnesses might not have attended court, thereby incurring costs for the Crown Office, they might have been told that the trial was the next day so they would in effect be on standby and would be inconvenienced. We are trying to eliminate that element so that when witnesses are told that a trial is going ahead on such and such a date, that will be so.
I want to spend a bit of time on this, because it is the focus of our job to ascertain whether the Crown Office has an adequate budget to fulfil its commitments. At some stage, you are going to have to be a bit more forthcoming about your estimates and about where you think the savings will be made. I would find it difficult to sign up to a flat-line budget if you cannot tell me where and how the savings will be made. I cannot see from where you are going to get the resources to meet the extra commitments and the targets that we all admire. I have to say early on that any information that you can give us either at this stage or later is crucial to our doing our job. Are you able now to give the committee your estimates of the savings from the introduction of the future office system?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
The savings will be about £1 million a year from the first stage, as I told Mr Butler. We think that there is scope for approximately another 30 posts to go in the second stage of FOS. I cannot recall immediately what that stage will cover—I think that it is summary processing—but it will automate another swathe of work and will save approximately £400,000 to £500,000 from 2005-06.On savings generally, we are considering ways of conducting witness citation to try to reduce the inconvenience to witnesses and the cost to us. We are also considering our estates. For example, in Edinburgh we hope to move from five sites to three by the end of 2006—provided that we can get out of the leases on some of our buildings—which should save approximately £250,000 in rent. We are considering our procurement strategies to see whether we can make more use of central contracts, such as Scottish Executive and perhaps Scottish Court Service contracts, given that we use many Scottish Court Service buildings, to try to reduce the operating cost of the service. We think that there is scope to make 25 per cent savings in the course of 2005-06 just in keeping the service going. We are considering a range of efficiencies.
That is what I am trying to draw you on. We have heard before about the plans that you have for making savings, some of which make perfect sense to me. At some point, would you be able to give the committee even an estimate of the figures and say where the efficiency savings will be made? I realise that it might be difficult to do that today, but when would you be able to do it?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
In your view, from what you have been able to scrutinise so far, will the savings that you estimate will be made by the efficiency reforms be sufficient to accommodate the commitments that you have signed up to in the Crown Office budget?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
I believe that they will be sufficient for 2005-06. Members will know that we received additional funding for the introduction of the High Court reforms on the IT side and for the introduction of preliminary diets. In my view, we will have enough to operate the system properly and to deliver the service that people expect.
I seek clarification on the same point. You spoke about £1 million per annum in savings on staff costs because of the cuts that have been made so far. Is that a net saving from staff costs or have you offset the figure against the costs of introducing the IT equipment?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
Right. So the total saving is not £1 million. You said that an investment of £4 million will be made in IT, which means that there will be an on-going IT cost that you have not quantified. Perhaps you might quantify it for us now. What are the annual on-going IT costs for maintenance and so on?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
You said that your investment in IT had allowed you to remove staff. You also said that the removal of staff will save you £1 million a year. What are the additional costs of the IT equipment? In other words, if you save £1 million and yet the IT costs are X, what is the actual saving?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
I am not sure that I understand the question. The actual saving is the fact that there will be 80 fewer support staff next year—2005-06—than there are at the moment.
Maybe I am not explaining the question properly. I understand that there are 80 fewer staff, but you said that you had invested in additional IT equipment. What is the cost of the additional IT equipment every year?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
It is not additional IT equipment. The cost is that of enhancing the system. In 2005-06, we expect to spend £3.6 million on IT, which includes works for Bonomy, developing further stages of the future office system and the partial replacement of terminals that need to be upgraded because they need more memory. It also includes other projects such as the development of work for victim information and advice and the enhancement of our management information system so that we can get to information more quickly. All of those are things that will enable us to manage the business better. Although some of that work will not produce direct savings, the best way of putting it is that, if we did not do the work, we would have to employ more staff. If we did not invest in an automated system for disclosing witness statements to the defence, the operation would be extremely time and people intensive.An evaluation has been undertaken, but I do not have the figures to hand. A lot of what we are talking about is routine stuff that is needed just to keep the IT going. We have a big, complex system that does not, in itself, generate savings.
I am a bit confused. I thought that you said earlier that you were investing an extra £4 million in IT and that, because of the extra investments and the change from paper to electronic data—which means that you will save on paper work and so forth—you will save £1 million. I am trying to get at the cost of the extra investment that is being made in the transfer to electronic data. Can you quantify the additional costs? I am talking not about upgrading personal computers, which is a normal, on-going procedure that you would undertake every so often, but about the extra investment that you are making in IT. I thought that you mentioned earlier that, given that you need 80 fewer staff, the result is a saving of £1 million. Can you quantify that particular part of the IT budget?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
It is the cost of the full system over a number of years. I think that the figure is about £6 million; most will have been spent in 2003-04 and 2004-05, with some being spent in 2005-06. The £4 million that we are spending on IT in 2005-06 is not all going on FOS.
It is not all going on the future office system. I think that you are comparing two different numbers. Not all of the £4 million that we are talking about, which is to be spent in 2005-06, is being spent on the future office system.
As I said earlier, it would help the committee to prepare its report if you could give us estimates. We are trying to establish straightforwardly where money is being invested and where savings are expected, so that we can judge what we think is a flat-line budget.
Shona BarrieCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
Yes, and the costs of any of the other efficiencies that you talked about. We would like those costs to be provided in straightforward terms, if you get my drift.
We still have some vacancies—offhand, I think that there are about 10 vacancies—and we are currently running a recruitment campaign. We hope to recruit some deputes on temporary contracts. Quite a lot of what we call temporary fiscals work ad hoc, to cover maternity leave for example, so we hope to recruit some people on such contracts.
I meant to ask earlier about the savings in relation to the 80 staff, because a quick calculation indicates that their average annual salary must be £12,500, which seems extremely low.
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
Not as such. Area fiscals can move staff between offices. For example, the office in Airdrie was under particular pressure after the fire, so other offices in the Lanarkshire area and Glasgow moved staff in to help.We now have the capability to move work to different offices, so for example if an office was acquiring a backlog in marking cases for prosecution, cases could be moved electronically to another office to help to release the pressure. A combination of such operations can help to deal with particular problems.
I understand that you tackle problems on an area basis and that you move work around. Would there be advantages to the establishment of a flying squad?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
I am not sure how advantageous that would be. What would such a squad do if no one needed help? That would be the basic problem. I think that we considered the possibility a couple of years ago and concluded that it would be better to use the area structure flexibly to move work or people.
John DunnCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
I cannot prejudge what the Lord Advocate might do in the spending review. We are considering our requirements, but we have come to no final decision about what we might do.
Yes, absolutely. We are forecasting the work load and taking account of the changes that we know about, to ascertain whether we will have enough resources. If we conclude that we will not have enough resources, we will put in a bid.
You mentioned that you were not sure what the Lord Advocate's attitude would be. Is there not an obligation on you, with your working knowledge of what actually happens in the sector, to determine whether representation should be made to the Lord Advocate?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
Various things may well happen over the next few years that would impact on the provision of the service. I wonder how far down the road you are in estimating what the implications might be for the budget.
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
We are some way down the line. It is difficult to know quite what the effects of the Bonomy measures will be. Equally, the McInnes review has some potentially wide implications for summary business. Its proposals could produce savings in some areas, but it will also have some cost implications. We have not yet come to a final view about that.
Shona BarrieCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
No policy has yet been developed on McInnes—it is difficult to predict what the Executive's policy might be in the vacuum in which we find ourselves. It would be premature of us to try to attach figures to the results of the McInnes review if we do not know what the result of the open consultation will be.
Yes. As you imply, we will have to. There will have to be a number of caveats, because of the uncertainty over the practical effects of the forthcoming changes, and the Lord Advocate will then have to take a view on the matter.
We must compile our final report by 18 May. You said that you will be in a better position to give us your view in May. Might you be able to give us an indication of that before we draw up our report?
Shona BarrieCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
Yes. You said that you could not tell us about those, because they are not clear—they are not clear to us either at the moment, and I do not see how we can compile a report on that basis. It will be just our opinion, but we have to present a report to Parliament on whether we think that your budget is adequate, based on what you tell us. To be blunt, it would be useless for you to come to us at the end of May, when we are presenting our report. I do not see how we can make a judgment, unless you can tell us that you might be able to give us at least a preliminary indication of your views before then. Might that be possible?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
If the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service were to be awarded an injection of additional cash today, where would you choose to spend that cash so as to improve the efficiency of the service?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
It would depend on how much it was, but I would probably choose to invest it in some of our buildings. Some of them are laid out in a way that is not ideally suited for the team working that we do now. That is particularly true for our Glasgow building, which probably needs the most work on it.
More staff are always welcome, although whether they are necessary is another matter. We hope that the Bonomy measures will serve to identify the cases that have to go to trial. It is anticipated that the churning of cases will thereby be eliminated. We hope to generate savings in due course as a result. It is a very attractive offer—thank you very much.
You have already touched on some of the issues around the implementation of the Bonomy and Normand recommendations with respect to information technology. However, it is clear from the annual evaluation report that the Crown Office is already implementing those recommendations. Will the recommendations generate additional costs for the COPFS, apart from those that might be incurred by implementing the IT proposals? Will they lead to savings in the longer term and, if so, how will you be able to evaluate them?
John DunnCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
As far as the High Court is concerned, members will no doubt know that we are in consultation with the Law Society of Scotland and the Faculty of Advocates on a practice note to achieve early disclosure of the basis of our case. Such disclosure will include the provision of witness lists, productions and statements and we expect that that will allow the defence to be in a better position to be ready for the case when it is indicted to a preliminary hearing. We hope that, as a result, we will be able to identify at the hearing before the judge the cases with a guilty plea and those that will involve trials. The fact that we will have trial diets instead of adjourned trial diets will mean savings. Obviously, early disclosure will incur costs, but those costs will be covered by the provision for the IT that will be required to support that.We want to make the system as user-friendly as possible. For example, I do not think that the police would disagree if we said that the quality of their statements can sometimes be patchy. We are working alongside them to improve the quality of those statements to ensure that they are fit for purpose for us and the defence. In that way, we will be able both to prosecute and to brief the defence so that it understands the case against its client. Although costs will be incurred, they have been budgeted for and indeed will be offset by the savings that we hope to make by eliminating the churn of cases. After all, that was at the core of Lord Bonomy's recommendations.
How will you track those costs and savings to find out whether they balance out or whether the costs are greater than the savings? Will you make that information available so that we can judge whether additional money is required to fund the changes?
John DunnCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
The savings that arise from implementing Lord Bonomy's recommendations will not be apparent until implementation takes place. I trust that we will be able to evaluate how High Court business is dealt with prior to the enactment of the Criminal Procedure (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill and how it is dealt with after its enactment to discover what efficiencies have been gained and what savings have been made. It is hard to attach any figures to that just now.
We are hoping to compare data from the year immediately prior to the implementation of the Bonomy recommendations with data from the matching period immediately after implementation to find out what it has meant. For example, we could examine the throughput of our High Court casework to find out the number of trials and pleas. Because we have unit figures for the cost of a plea or a trial, we can then work out the savings that have arisen.
As the implementation of the Bonomy recommendations is partly motivated by a wish to improve the service, you must believe that the changes will deliver savings. Have you any impression at all of the overall effects of implementation with regard to improving the service's efficiency and to costs?
John DunnCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
We could try to extrapolate from the figures that I gave earlier by comparing last year's adjournment rate with this year's. However, one would need to examine the costs of the cases to see whether they involved the attendance of witnesses and whether the witnesses were paid for their attendance or were simply inconvenienced. It is hard to quantify the savings without doing quite a bit of backtracking to calculate the costs involved.
The Crown Agent has advised us that, as a result of the Bonomy reforms, all police witness statements will routinely be given to the defence. That does not happen at the moment. Can the committee be provided with estimates for the cost of copying those statements?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
Our budget includes costs for amending the IT system to allow the disclosure of all material to the defence. That includes police witness statements, but we have not costed those separately. We need a system to keep track of what has been sent and to whom, both so that we do not miss things out and so that, if the defence claims that it did not receive something, we can defend ourselves by saying that we sent it to such and such a person on such and such a date. The cost of that system is about £800,000 over two years, but we have not costed police witness statements specifically.
The change is more radical than might be thought, because the defence must be given not just the statements of police witnesses but the police statements taken from witnesses, which could be statements taken from civilians. The requirement is across the board. We have worked with the police to improve the quality and format of their statements.
I want to pin you down on the cost. Is that £800,000 over two years the total cost to the Crown Office of the additional commitment to provide all police witness statements to the defence routinely?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
Have the budgetary implications of shifting business from the High Court to the sheriff court been estimated? What is the additional estimated cost to the Crown Office?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
There will not be additional costs. Sheriff court cases generally cost us less because they do not involve advocate deputes and are generally shorter trials. In general, sheriff and jury cases conclude earlier than High Court cases. If that pattern continues in the cases that transfer, we expect that at worst the change will be cost neutral and at best it will produce some savings.
Yes. It should be borne in mind that an expedited precognition format will be adopted for the sheriff and jury cases. That does not mean that the precognitions will be of a lower quality. They will be fit for purpose, although they will not be full High Court precognitions. In a sense, High Court cases involve the ownership of the case being transferred from the office to an advocate depute, so the precognition must contain every piece of information that requires to be known. In sheriff and jury cases, there is locally based knowledge, especially if people are working in teams and are aware of the case load. Therefore, savings will be made as a result of cases that might previously have been tried in the High Court being tried by a sheriff and jury.
Will procurators fiscal require additional training, given that they will be required to work on more sheriff and jury cases? Is there anything in the budget for that?
Shona BarrieCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
We already provide a wholesale programme of advocacy training that is fit for purpose so that deputes are trained for sheriff and jury cases and have the requisite advocacy skills. I do not think that we expect additional training to be required.
John DunnCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
It should be borne in mind that the types of case that we anticipate being transferred are ones with which deputes and principal deputes are already very familiar. I know from experience that the cases that will in future be dealt with by a sheriff and jury are of a type that is regularly dealt with by the sheriff court, although they will be a little bit more serious.
Across the board, it represents a 7 per cent increase in sheriff and jury business. That increase has been examined by the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service and we are confident that it can be absorbed. As I understand it, the Scottish Court Service has also examined the increase, because that obviously has an impact on its sheriff court business. I do not wish to speak out of turn by speaking for the Scottish Court Service, but I understand that it does not have any anxiety about that business being absorbed into the court service in the sheriff court.
Shona BarrieCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
Could I stop you there? We are familiar with the idea that, under the proposals, a 20 per cent reduction in High Court business will result in a 7 per cent increase in the sheriff court work load, although I am not saying that we accept that that is the case. We are trying to draw out any additional burdens or responsibilities that will result from the shift. You suggest that there are no additional training requirements and that, if anything, there might be a saving as a result of that transfer of business.
Shona BarrieCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
With team working, the people who prepare and investigate cases are likely to take them to court and prosecute them, so they will be familiar with them.
We have all read in the press recently about the recovery of money. Will you update us on how much the criminal confiscation unit and civil recovery unit have recovered? Do you have figures on that?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
No problem. The units that I mentioned are quite new, and it is a new process. Do you expect that the amounts that are recovered will increase and that you might therefore recover more money in 2004-05 and 2005-06?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
I think so. The units have a fair number of cases on the stocks, and they are processing them. You will appreciate that the cases are complex; it takes a long time to get anything out, so we will probably not see the benefit until 2005-06. Of course, the money goes not to us but to the Scottish consolidated fund. I certainly expect an increase by 2005-06.
It goes initially to the Scottish consolidated fund. I know that it is not distributed by the Lord Advocate; I think that 50 per cent of it is distributed by either the health or the justice ministers as grants to help communities that are affected by drugs and such like.
I can speak from personal experience as I worked in the fraud unit from 1997, when the legislation was put in place for criminal confiscation in drugs cases. There has been an increase in the figures year on year. It is difficult to predict exactly where we will be, because that depends on what the criminals do.
Stephen Woodhouse said that the money goes back to the Treasury. Does that mean that it goes back to London and that money that has been recovered in Scotland will not come to Scotland?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
Am I not right to say that 50 per cent of the money goes to the Treasury and 50 per cent is returned to the Scottish Executive to use on projects in communities that have been affected by crime? We have to remember that most of the money has been gained from illegal activities through which the Treasury has been done out of money. That arrangement is an attempt to ensure that the Treasury gets back money that it has been denied. Do you not agree that it is more important that the money should go back to the communities that are affected by crime than that it should go to the Procurator Fiscal Service, which will have been helpful in prosecuting the activities of the criminals, but will not necessarily have been directly affected by them?
Stephen WoodhouseCrown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
We reported on that specific point last time.If nobody wishes to clarify anything before we conclude our questions, I offer a point of information. Our adviser points out that the spending review process does not match our budget process exactly, which is perhaps why your mechanisms for decision making seem to be slightly out of synch with our need to report. That is something for us to bear in mind. What you have said has been helpful and we would appreciate any more detailed information that you can give us. I think that you know what we are driving at—we want to see where the efficiency savings are so that we can look at the overall budget. I thank you all for attending this morning and we are grateful for your information.I welcome the Scottish Court Service team. We shall hear from Cliff Binning, who is the director of operational policy and planning, Nicola Bennett, who is the director of finance, and John Anderson, who is the principal clerk of session and justiciary.
Thank you for your written submission, which was helpful. I want to ask you about your spending priorities for 2005-06. What improvements in spending need to be made to improve the Scottish Court Service?
You have spoken about the spending review as being slightly out of synch. For 2005-06, we do not anticipate any additional funding, but we anticipate that we will be able to fund fully all our current commitments with the exception of some of the specialist courts where there have been pilot schemes. We will not be able to extend the specialist courts to any more of the courts in our estate, but we can fund everything that we are doing at the moment.
If you believe that you have sufficient money in your budget, are you confident that you will be able to continue improving the courts' fabric? Many of the courts need refurbished. Further, will you be able to ensure that all courts in Scotland comply with the obligations of the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 and legislation that the Scottish Parliament has passed—for example, the Vulnerable Witnesses (Scotland) Act 2004? Some courts in Scotland have closed-circuit television and other facilities that allow vulnerable witnesses to be given the help that they need, but such facilities are not available in all Scotland's courts. Will you be able to meet all your obligations from existing resources?
We have made a significant investment in technology for the courts. We focus on different priorities each year. We have acquired new technology since the Vulnerable Witnesses (Scotland) Bill was introduced—for example, mobile units. We originally thought that we might need appropriate equipment in every court. However, our current assumption is that we will be able to move sufficient equipment around our courts to make them more flexible. The equipment is being procured this year. There will be running costs, but those will not be as significant as the initial investment in the equipment. Each year, we decide on priorities for modernising courtroom IT systems. I hope that that answers your question about court facilities for vulnerable witnesses. We are confident that we have a solution for that.On the fabric of court buildings, anyone who looks at our funding can see that, because of the amount of money that we have for our estate, we are struggling. We must constantly juggle priorities. Our key priority is the redevelopment of Parliament House and that is taking a lot of funding away from the rest of the estate. However, we must focus on what is important. We are looking at the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 to ensure that we comply with all the elements that we need to. We could do with more money in that area, but it is not a high priority for the spending review. A bid for that area would not be successful because it would not gain anything in the public's eye. We hope that that funding situation will improve in the long term, once Parliament House has been redeveloped.
Does that mean that, because you believe that those things are not particularly attractive or appealing, you do not ask for the money? I would be concerned if that were the case. There might not be obvious public benefits in complying with the requirements of the 1995 act, but people with disabilities must go to court on occasion and they should be able to get the same treatment there that an able-bodied person gets.
Absolutely. Perhaps I can clarify the position on the relative priorities across our programme. The test of priorities rests on a number of variables: the capacity to allow the courts to operate the throughput of business effectively; the capacity to secure maximum value for money from the estate; and—more important—the capacity to have an appropriate response for people with particular needs. It is correct to say that, in an ideal world, more expenditure would be available to target disability discrimination, but part of our strategic approach to disability discrimination is to fulfil the test of reasonableness under the statutory definition, which is to ensure that we are taking all reasonable steps to comply as far as possible with the position on disability discrimination. I hope that that helps to clarify matters.
Have the Normand and Bonomy reports had any budgetary implications for the service, either in additional costs or in savings? If so, what are they and has account been taken of them in the present expenditure plans for 2005-06?
I will deal first with Andrew Normand's report. A central thrust of that report was that criminal justice agencies had to generate the capacity to operate more effectively within the system and had to invest in the transaction costs and the information costs that were associated with that. Within current budgeted provision, we have invested and will continue to invest in two sources of capacity on that front. One source is improved personnel management capacity to engage and interact properly with the Crown and key justice players. An early response to the Normand report and the Pryce-Dyer report on the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service was to ensure that, from an organisational and management perspective, we had sufficient capacities in place for that engagement.Another element of Andrew Normand's report is the need for better sharing of information between agencies. On that front, and again within budgeted provision, we have invested in improved management information systems and continue to invest in improvements to our main computer system for criminal operations. That is the general position on Andrew Normand's report.As far as High Court reform is concerned, it might be helpful to deal with specific legislative areas that were covered in the financial memorandum to the Criminal Procedure (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill and to deal with wider service areas. On the specific legislative provisions, we have secured funding under the financial memorandum and in budgeted provision to provide for the staffing and comparatively minor input to technological resources that were required to respond to the bill.It might be helpful to place the wider High Court reform within the dynamic of continual Scottish Court Service strategic and business planning. Part of our planning process, as with every organisation, involves some analysis of environmental demands that are likely to arise in the future. Irrespective of High Court reform, our analysis for the 2002 spending review was that court users and partners would rightly call for improvements in technology, accommodation and facilities to address the needs of vulnerable witnesses and victims in general, particularly in view of technological improvements in relation to the giving of evidence.I hope that that covers the position on the Normand report and on High Court reform.
I want to double-check on some specific matters to do with High Court reform. I presume that we are talking about greater use of court facilities to take care of the extra work that preliminary hearings will involve, although perhaps you are content that the reduced number of adjournments will balance out the increased use of court facilities that will result from preliminary hearings. What is your thinking on the budget consequences of those two things?
In a sense, the relationship between preliminary hearings and what might be termed the general business of the court is such that, in key locations, there will be a need to provide the requisite accommodation for those people who are associated with the preliminary hearings. Again, that was taken account of in our analysis of what would be required for High Court reform.On the more general position, the proposition is not that it is calculated that there will be a reduction in the on-the-day business of the courts; the availability of more court time will not be associated with the reform. The proposition is that court time will be utilised effectively, which will have the dividend that cases will come to a conclusion more quickly and with more certainty than they do now. That is not the kind of impact that would generate recoverable or recyclable resource dividends for the Court Service.
You are saying that, although additional costs are associated with the preliminary hearings, those costs have been taken into account in your spending plans.
Is that covered in the financial memorandum to the Criminal Procedure (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill or is there any further information that we should have about the impact of the Bonomy reforms?
The financial memorandum to the bill reported on the position in so far as it covered the bill's precise and direct implications. The position on what I have called the wider element is such that the budgeted provision provides for a degree of flexibility to target capital investment on areas in which it is most needed. I do not know whether that helps.
The process involves two stages. The financial memorandum reflected an initial injection to get the change through—the £2 million to £2.5 million for the judicial resources and supporting staff that will be required, in effect, to run two more courts. That will create the capacity to get the change through in a year to 18 months. As Mr Binning was saying, we should then have a more efficient system, which will enable us to claw back resources from the High Court. That will be the result of the Bonomy package, which will involve the transfer of some business to the sheriff court and will improve the High Court's efficiency. As I said, the process has two stages. We are talking about a short-term investment of resources to get the change through. We anticipate that we will need fewer judicial and court resources to run the new, efficient Bonomy system. I do not know whether that is helpful.
It is difficult to isolate specific costs or savings that might arise from the Andrew Normand report, although there are indicators that we could prey in aid. The report suggests that better planning and interrelationships between SCS staff and Procurator Fiscal Service staff would lead to improvements in the throughput of cases. An example of an indicator is our target for disposing of 85 per cent of cases within 20 weeks of first calling in the sheriff court. That target might be used as an indicator of the extent to which the implementation of the Normand report recommendations is bringing a dividend. In the context of that target during the past year to 18 months, we have gone from disposing of an initial 76 per cent of cases within the 20 weeks to disposing of 83 per cent or 84 per cent of them. However, I do not attribute all that improvement to the Normand recommendations; part of it is due to the benefit that we are realising from more effective joint planning and exchange of information.
In our estimation, the Normand report would not have contributed to what might be called appreciable business or other environmental changes. It was not an activity-generating report but one that was calculated to improve efficiency and effectiveness. It is not the kind of report that would generate tangible business activity.
As we said in our opening statement, we are not equipped with enough information on what the outcomes will be and on the cost variables to draw any hard and fast conclusions about the impacts of the review of summary justice. The report was published and now there is an open consultation; in that context, it is difficult to determine the potential impacts.The other factor is that, inevitably, a range of configurations of the administration and geographical locations of bench and courts might accrue from consideration of the report and its recommendations. From all those perspectives, we are at an early stage in our considerations of the impact and budgetary implications of the report.
At the most extreme point of speculation, district courts could close completely and business could transfer to the sheriff courts, so becoming the responsibility of the Court Service budget. Would that be a cost?
That is a hypothesis and it could be argued that there would be a potential cost. However, one of the variables is that, in reaching a view on the potential cost, we would have to take account of the extent to which other elements of the McInnes report were implemented. Those elements include increased use of diversion from prosecution, for example. It might be possible to isolate certain hypotheses and proceed on that kind of analytical basis. Whether it would be helpful to do that is debatable.
I am thinking of the long-term projection over a three-year period. If the situation is as you describe it, where does that leave you in relation to the spending review?
I may be able to help on that. We have carried out an initial analysis of one option—based on a set of assumptions that are very broad at this stage. An estimate of cost has been put in, not through our proposals to the spending review, but through the justice area. They have put that bid through—
In the current spending review, a bid has been made to mark a certain amount of money for McInnes. We have worked out that figure based on a certain scenario, but we are very much at the early stages. As Cliff Binning said, we are still in the consultation period. We are trying to work out costs for a number of options. We have based our calculations on assumptions and things may change. Costs have been identified for the spending review—for the three years that you are talking about. However, although nobody knows what they will be exactly, there will obviously be costs elsewhere in the system.
It is difficult and not entirely productive to venture too far into considering what the implications of the review of summary justice might be. I listened to the earlier discussion on that exercise and the 2004 spending review. The dynamics of the two are different. In SR2004, the potential impact of the review of summary justice has been acknowledged and a preliminary assessment is on-going. As is appropriate, and using the best available estimates, the review will figure in SR2004. That is the current position.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.