Thank you for inviting me to join you. I hope that everyone can see the screen. If not, I ask you to make the appropriate adjustment so that you can see it. I know that I have to talk through some of the slides for the Official Report.I begin with a short story, as my task is very much to set the scene about ADR and mediation. The story is about a lady who was an employee of a major public organisation and to whom, for two years, a whole chapter of unfortunate events occurred. It started off with a small incident at work, which led to claims by her that she had been sexually discriminated against, harassed and bullied. Ultimately, the situation led to her being medically unfit to work. Her employers would say that they were a caring organisation, but that things had simply gone wrong. The employee's claims were all set to go to the employment tribunal. There were all sorts of issues to be addressed as well as stress, anxiety, anger and passion.Someone suggested that the matter should be dealt with by mediation, and it came to mediation not that long ago in a small town in the west of Scotland. The mediation took many hours; a lot was said and heard during those hours. Towards the end there was a remarkable moment that captures the power of the mediation process. The parties had moved together gradually during the day but there was still a significant gap between them over money. The money was really symbolic of the issues between them. At the end of the day, after some hard work, that gap was bridged.As the mediator, I suggested that the employer's representative should go to the—now former—employee and tell her what he could do for her. He went into the room in which she had been sitting for many hours and said that he wanted to acknowledge all that she had been through. He expressed the company's regret for what had happened to her, reassured her that steps would be taken to try to make sure that it did not happen again, acknowledged all that she had done for the company and told her that he was able to give her the payment that she was seeking. She looked up and thanked him. She said that he had changed her view about the organisation, that he had made a difference to her life and that she could now get on and start a new chapter in her life. Thus, the mediation ended, or so it seemed.Last week, I happened to meet the solicitor who acted for that lady. He told me that she had telephoned him the week before and asked him to shred all the papers in the case. She had been able to move on, leave all that behind her and start a new chapter in her life. We also heard from the solicitor acting for the employer, who said that the mediation had saved the company £75,000 in legal expenses, management costs, travel time and accommodation. That all happened in one day, and it illustrates how much the mediation process can achieve.There are many similar examples but I will just leave you with that one. My role today is to set the scene about ADR and mediation, to talk through the context in which they arise, to tell you a little bit about the process and to talk about what is happening in Scotland and elsewhere. I will confine myself to non-family mediation; there are others who are better versed in family mediation than I. I will speak specifically about the civil and commercial areas.It is appropriate that I declare the interest that the convener mentioned. I am a director of Core Mediation and Core Consulting. My real interest is in seeing mediation work more effectively for as many people as possible in Scotland.I will start by talking about nomenclature. We hear about alternative dispute resolution, or ADR. Many of us think that that description is now a bit passé and that the appropriate term should be at least additional dispute resolution or appropriate dispute resolution. Just last night, I read that people in New Jersey call it complementary dispute resolution, and there is a notion in England that effective dispute resolution might be a better description of what we are talking about.However, in a world of WMDs, I have come up with a rather different acronym: EMD, or the effective management of differences. What this discussion should really be about is how we can help people to resolve their differences more effectively.When people have differences, what do most of them want? Research and our instincts tell us that they want to find solutions. "Paths to Justice", which was published by Professor Hazel Genn of University College London and Professor Alan Paterson, showed that the majority of people who have disputes want to resolve them by agreement. Indeed, even people who are successful in court are still unsatisfied and would rather have resolved the dispute by reaching agreement. The underlying principle for us to examine—and perhaps subscribe to—is that people would rather reach agreement than go into battle, although that is what often happens. Too often, we operate in a confrontational or adversarial mode. The resolution of differences involves a substantial passage of time. We incur delay and a lot of expense—legal expenses and experts' costs, among other things. There are direct and indirect costs. Recent research by the accountants BDO Stoy Hayward has shown the extent of the indirect costs that businesses incur as a result of disputes. Management time is lost, profitability and staff morale go down, and managers suffer from stress, anxiety and loss of sleep. Such indirect costs arise because, when things go wrong, we tend to focus on the past and seek to blame people. In an adversarial setting, possible solutions are limited to winning or losing. Procedural formalities tend to dominate and many people find it difficult to accept the sheer loss of control that they experience when their disputes are handed over to others.We know that many people would like to have access to some form of resolution, but do not have that opportunity because the system is too expensive or because the courts are so bogged down with other proceedings that cases cannot be heard quickly and efficiently. We also know that disputes often lead to stress and can cause irreparable damage to contractual, professional and personal relationships.I am sure that the committee is interested in the burden on the justice system in relation to the weight and cost of cases going through the courts. The evidence shows fairly squarely that around 95 per cent—and in some examples, 97 per cent—of the cases that enter the civil judicial system are settled; therefore, judges adjudicate on less than 5 per cent of those cases. Those statistics raise issues about resources, the cost-benefit analysis, the burden on the courts and the situation of people who cannot get access to the courts or to other solutions. Even in the 95 per cent of cases where a settlement is reached, the outcome is often unsatisfactory, because cases are settled at the last minute, sometimes in an unprincipled way.The solution that I offer the committee is that we change our orientation in relation to the resolution of difference and—in the narrow sense—the resolution of disputes in the legal system. We should focus first on helping people to reach agreement. That should be the first principle. The adversarial system—the court—should be regarded as a last resort. It can be a super and appropriate last resort in some cases, but perhaps in only 5 per cent of those that enter the system, as the statistics show.A significant lead has been taken down south. Recent statistics from the former Lord Chancellor's Department, which is now the Department for Constitutional Affairs, show that in the past year the use of ADR, and of mediation in particular, has saved Government departments about £6 million. Indeed, the figures showed a 1,200 per cent increase in the use of ADR in the past year. The NHS Litigation Authority's statistics show that the time taken for medical negligence cases to be resolved has been reduced from 5.5 years to 1.98 years and that there has apparently been a 74 per cent increase in the number of cases dealt with by mediation. The use of mediation is increasing because it has many tangible benefits. Mediation encourages people to resolve their differences by consensual means wherever possible; it produces results more quickly; and it is more cost-effective—I have given an example of that. It is much less stressful, as it eliminates, or at least diminishes, the prolonged agony of negotiation followed by litigation. The time of managers, witnesses, experts and others can be deployed more meaningfully. In the commercial setting, that means that the business can make more profit.People often comment about the better, more satisfying outcomes that are achieved through the consensual process. Of course, when people are involved in reaching agreement with others and do so by themselves—or, if necessary, with help from other people—they have a stake in the outcome and ownership of the result. Privacy, rather than publicity, is a benefit that people recognise. The flexibility of working together on different ways to design processes is a considerable benefit over the rather fixed rules that the litigation procedure might have.Access to justice is a theme to which we might return in our discussions, but access to solutions also interests me. Can we help people to find ways to resolve the unresolved problems that they often have, whether those problems are commercial, professional, public, private, personal or whatever? In doing that, can we reduce pressure on the courts? That is a possible benefit, if we can take many such cases out of the court system or resolve them earlier. If money is an issue—it is for the committee—reducing the cost of the justice system and perhaps the legal aid budget might be a principal attractive benefit. There is a bigger picture. I am anxious to encourage the committee to consider ADR as an approach that applies not only to legal situations or courtroom disputes, but possibly more widely to all fields and at all stages. In other parts of the world, equal opportunities and human rights issues are addressed using what is characterised as ADR—mediation or consensual approaches. ADR could also be used in planning and the environment. I was struck recently by the fact that even the inquiry into the Scottish Parliament building and its cost might have been conducted more collaboratively. I leave it to members to consider that further.We look to create approaches that build rather than knock down and which emphasise collaboration, co-operation and consensus. That framework allows everyone involved in the difference of opinion, conflict or dispute to have an opportunity to gain from it and to reach a solution that works for them. That takes me to mediation's place as the principal means of managing differences and resolving disputes by agreement. When we talk about ADR, we talk primarily about mediation. That comes through in all the paperwork that members will have seen and perhaps had the chance to read. Nobody suggests that conflicts should or can be removed; the focus of our attention is on how we help people to resolve conflict. I will summarise what mediation offers. It offers the opportunity to approach negotiation in a structured or assisted fashion and it extends or enhances the negotiation process by—crucially—using an independent third-party facilitator who is impartial, who has or builds the parties' trust and who needs to be highly skilled in sometimes unusual and often difficult situations. The interpersonal element is prominent, which is where training and standards come in for further discussion.The independent third-party facilitator's role is to help people to communicate when they otherwise cannot, to be a buffer for emotions such as anger and to bridge the gap that sometimes exists between parties, so that parties can reach consensus on a practical solution for them.One great attribute of the process is that, in general, it is confidential. Anything that is said or done with the mediator in private or by those involved together is confidential. Mediation usually takes the form of a series of meetings, some of which are joint and many of which are private. That gives parties the chance to speak openly and frankly with the mediator.As I said, mediation has the benefit of speed and cost efficiency, although it is a rigorous procedure—nobody should suggest otherwise. Mediation is hard work, but it is in many ways preferable to the alternative. Mediations are usually conducted in a day or two and have a recorded success rate of about 80 per cent—sometimes more. The benefits are that the right people—and the right information—are at the table and that people can air the issues, express their feelings and their anger, and, sometimes, hear what they have not heard and understand what they have not understood. If one compares a court setting with meditation, one can see that meditation provides the opportunity not only for a day in court and for non-legal solutions but for legal remedies, too.Sometimes, people cannot resolve a dispute by themselves. They need the help of a facilitator to break the logjam. It should be remembered that most people want to reach agreement. We try to find ways to enable that to happen. The bigger picture reminds us that there is nothing new about that. When Nelson Mandela left Robben island, he said:"To make peace with an enemy, one must work with that enemy and the enemy must become one's partner."Way back 150 years ago, Abraham Lincoln said:"The only safe way to destroy your enemy is to make him your friend." I make no comment on the fact that that was an American President's approach.Let us move on to think about mediation in a wider setting. It is having a huge impact in the United States—that most litigious of settings. A statistic from 1997 shows that 98 per cent of the 1,000 largest corporations in America had used mediation. Last year I attended a conference at which the guiding principle was:"Mediation is now part of the fabric of dispute resolution in the United States".Issues arising from the 9/11 tragedy, tobacco and Enron are all being dealt with by mediation processes. Our Government has pledged:"ADR will be considered and used in all suitable cases whenever the other party accepts it".A very good report produced by the Department for Constitutional Affairs in August gives a number of interesting examples of where Government departments have used mediation to great effect in the past year or so. Those include foot-and-mouth disease, Alder Hey and land mines in Kenya.Judges in England are coming forward with radical propositions. For example, they have indicated that failure to use ADR, particularly when public money is involved—think about the court system—is "indefensible" and that independent mediators should be used wherever possible if the parties cannot sort matters out for themselves.I will skip over slide 19, which shows other comments made by English judges; perhaps those comments can be put into the record later.The European dimension has been made fairly clear through the report that is in front of members, the response of the UK Parliament and, in particular, the response of the Committee on Legal Affairs and the Internal Market, which produced a resolution supporting the ADR initiative that has been adopted by the European Parliament.There has also been significant growth in mediation in the commercial and civil arena in Scotland. Statistics from our own little business, Core Mediation, show that although the numbers are relatively low there has been a significant increase in the past year or two. A scheme in Edinburgh sheriff court run by the citizens advice bureaux has also contributed to the growth of mediation in Scotland.Slide 23 breaks down mediations into the public sector—the categories shown are local authorities, public bodies and Government agencies—and the private sector. Sixty six per cent of mediations are in the private sector. Slide 24 shows the types of industries that are involved in mediations. They include the building and construction sector, the property and land sector, the health sector, the commercial sector and the education sector. As members will know, there is quite a lot of work in the special needs area of the education sector. Legislation is now before the Parliament on that matter. Slide 25 shows the kind of disputes that are being addressed by mediation: professional negligence; employment, which is a great area for work using these techniques; special needs; information technology; management; intellectual property; and partnership disputes.I mention that 44 per cent of the referrals come from the insurance industry. It has a real interest in the matter and deserves to be encouraged to promote mediation. A telling factor is that 45 per cent of referrals come before the disputes have reached litigation stage. The statistics show that 88 per cent of the cases that were at that stage were in the private sector.I will give some examples of the areas in which mediation is being used. One of those is the health sector, where there is tremendous potential for the use of mediation, not only in disputes between patients and doctors but in the management of the health sector. We can think of other public sector institutions where that would also be the case. There is so much potential in Scotland for taking this approach and helping people to manage differences appropriately.We will slide over the comments from parties, save for the last one on slide 29:"what mediation offers is the prospect of a much quicker and much less expensive resolution with … very little risk".Those are the words of a health trust chief executive from a couple of years ago.In summary, it seems to me that most disputes are suitable for consensual resolution, using the various processes that come under the heading of ADR, but principally mediation. It is not a universal panacea, as some cases are not appropriate for or resolved by mediation, but it is another option that is arguably grossly underused in Scotland. There are great opportunities for us in Scotland.Einstein said:"Imagination is more important than knowledge".I challenge us all to think about whether we can lead in this area. Can we build on what others have done in other countries and shape a new approach for Scotland? One of my colleagues asked me to say this to the committee about mediation—it is good for people, it is good for business and it is good for Scotland.The challenge is something along these lines. I quote a statement made by Derek Bok, the former dean at Harvard Law School, a few years ago. He stated:"Over the next generation … society's greatest opportunity will lie in tapping human inclinations toward collaboration and compromise rather than stirring our proclivities for competition and rivalry. These may be the most creative social experiments of our time." We have an opportunity to take part in a very creative social experiment that could bring great benefits to the people of Scotland. There is a great deal to be done to raise awareness about mediation in Scotland, to educate people and to ensure that the standards are appropriate. There is a lot that the courts could do to encourage mediation, there is a lot that the Executive could do to commit to it—in the way that the UK Parliament has done—and there is much that the Scottish Parliament can do to support it. Encouragement, commitment and support are the three words on which I will end. I am happy to answer questions.