Item 3 is discussion of our work programme. Committee members have a paper setting out a suggested short-term work programme—I emphasise that it is only for the period until we have some proposed legislation to consider. The paper is only an amalgam of members' suggestions; it is not yet a tablet of stone and members can change their minds today. The idea is that we give the clerks a head start in preparing for the subjects that the committee would like to consider after the recess and the types of visit that it would like to make. As members will see from the paper, European matters came out as a strong interest among members and prisons are also an interest. The Protection from Abuse (Scotland) Act 2001 is mentioned for post-legislative scrutiny—that is, for us to see whether there are any problems after enactment. There is a suggestion for a speaker to address us on sentencing policy. At the end of the paper, there are ideas for a couple of visits.I open the discussion to committee members.
We have a list of the organisations from which evidence was taken when the bill was considered. It includes Scottish Women's Aid, the Family Law Association, the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents, the Sheriffs Association, the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland, the Scottish Partnership on Domestic Violence and the Scottish Legal Aid Board, and we also took evidence from the Lord Advocate.
We would have to prioritise. I do not know whether we have any time to think about that. Should we start by asking the Executive whether it has had any feedback?
I accept Michael Matheson's point that only one of the committees should work on an issue, but members of both committees would benefit from hearing about the chief inspector's annual report, especially as there is a new appointee to the post. Members will have an opportunity to thrash out the issues if we manage to organise an away day. We might be able to persuade Andrew McLellan to give an introductory talk to both committees on his annual report.
If there are no other matters that members wish to raise, I will go through each of the points in the paper to ensure that we agree on them.On European matters, the suggestion is that, as a starting point, we have an oral briefing on the basics of European law and legislation. Notwithstanding Michael Matheson's point that we should not always meet with the Justice 2 Committee, if that committee expresses an interest in such a briefing, it would make sense for it to be a joint one.
"Induction" is a helpful word—the meeting on prisons and the briefing on European matters will fall under that heading and will kick-start members' knowledge of the systems. We will then adhere to the usual principle of meeting jointly only to discuss the budget.
Yes, but it should not miss out anything important. The point is a fair one. People who spend their lives negotiating in Europe on such matters sometimes forget that we do not consider such issues every day.How do members wish to deal with the issue of prisons? I accept the point that we must be more specific about issues that we want to consider, but do members want to hear from Andrew McLellan in a joint meeting with the Justice 2 Committee, or should we ask him to talk only to this committee?
On the Protection from Abuse (Scotland) Act 2001, we should start by asking the Executive whether it has had any feedback on the act. We could also send a letter to the organisations that are mentioned in the note—and, as Margaret Mitchell suggested, to Victim Support Scotland—to inform them that we intend to examine the operation of the act and to ask them to give feedback to the committee. Members could then decide which organisations should give oral evidence. Unless members know now or have strong views about which organisations they would like to take oral evidence from, we will communicate with members during the summer recess and provide them with any written responses. As the evidence will be taken in the first week or two after the recess, we will have to give notice to the people involved. It might become apparent which organisations we should call.A number of members are interested in sentencing policy. Dr Neil Hutton of the University of Strathclyde, who was the adviser to the previous Justice 1 Committee on alternatives to custody, might be able to brief the committee on sentencing. Again, I assume that the briefing would be simple and would cover general issues. If the matter interests members, we could then decide which issues to consider further.
The issue includes the sentencing commission, but there are other topical points. The briefing from Neil Hutton will allow members to assess which issues would be suitable to form the basis of a piece of work.Visits do not have to be done by all committee members—we can do our own thing—but I want to get an idea of the visits that members would like us to organise during the summer recess for after the recess. We will set up at least one or two prison visits—preferably to prisons that Stewart Maxwell has not been to. We will discuss the dates further.
I support that suggestion. As Glasgow sheriff court is Europe's busiest court, it is worth going to see, and we will be well looked after by the Glasgow Bar Association. We could also ask representatives of the Procurator Fiscal Service to give us a talk on the day, which would give us two opportunities.
I do not see why we cannot do that. The clerks could arrange visits for Marlyn Glen and for anyone else who wants to go.We can fit in only about two visits in the recess. We are talking about a visit to a prison and a visit to Glasgow sheriff court, which could incorporate a short briefing from the Procurator Fiscal Service. That would be a good induction. For the prison visit, we could organise a visit to Cornton Vale for those who are interested, a visit to a children's hearing and a visit to another prison. We can consult members on which prison would suit them geographically and cover their general interests.
That brings us to the end of our agenda. I remind members that our next meeting will be held on Wednesday 3 September in committee room 3. The clerks will keep in touch with members over the summer recess. There will be plenty of time to go on a lot of visits and to do a lot of reading, which I am sure that members will do.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.