The committee is not finished. We are just one hour late in reaching agenda item 4. Petition PE124, which is from Grandparents Apart Self Help, is on grandparents' right to contact with their grandchildren. I refer members to paper J1/02/43/2, which is the clerk's note on the petition. We have received several responses to the petition, from the Minister for Justice, the Sheriffs Association, Children 1st and NCH Scotland, which are attached to the note. All the correspondence has been intimated to the petitioners and the Public Petitions Committee.In summary, all the respondents are content with the current legislation. They do not believe that the petitioners' request, which is to name grandparents in the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 as having an important role to play in the lives of their grandchildren, is the way forward. That is not to say that the respondents think that grandparents do not have an important role to play. I ask the committee to consider the wider issues that have been raised and to consider the points that NCH Scotland made in its letter to the committee, which reads:"we would not favour extending to grandparents the same rights and responsibilities that are accorded to parents under the Children Act. Grandparents and other family members can currently apply for contact orders and for parental responsibility and residence orders. We do appreciate the difficulties and expense that this can involve and believe that instead of a change in the law, the interests of grandparents should be more explicitly acknowledged and promoted in guidance to both Sheriffs and to social workers.Firstly, grandparents should be notified of any applications in relation to a child/children, so that they can be represented. Secondly, guidance to social workers and others advising the courts should explicitly require that grandparents and other first degree members of the extended family should be notified of applications and their views and wishes sought and formally recorded."
Official Report · Committee
Petitions
Children (Scotland) Act 1995 (PE124)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Christine Grahame SNP 4
- Maureen Macmillan Lab 1
- Paul Martin Lab 1
- Donald Gorrie LD 1
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 1
The record
9 contributionsI agree with the points that NCH Scotland has made. I am a grandmother and I am sure that others at the committee today are also grandparents. We appreciate the pain and anxiety that grandparents and other members of the extended family go through if they are deprived of the company of their grandchildren or do not hear about them, because they have been kept out of their grandchildren's lives. The way forward is not to change the law, but to consider the extended family when relationships break down and the arrangements that are made for children. The concerns of the extended family should be brought to the attention of the sheriff. If recognition is given to the role that grandparents, aunts, uncles and so on play in children's lives, the means exist for that role to be recognised. What is paramount at all times is what is best for the children.
Guidelines could ensure that grandparents are considered throughout the process. If we were to consider the legislative route, I would be concerned about the confusion and emotional difficulty that could be caused to children in cases of parental separation. Legislation that ensures the rights of grandparents could make the situation even more difficult. Petition PE124 is well meant; it was lodged as a result of genuine concern. I would like social services and other services that support children and young people during the separation process to give serious consideration to their guidelines on supporting children during what is a difficult and emotional time. I repeat that it would cause even more difficulties to add to the legislation that is already in place in relation to the direct parents.
I suggest that we should consider a change to the sheriff court rules about the requirement to intimate actions. That would not mean that someone could be part of the proceedings, but I understand that there is no requirement at present for grandparents or first-degree relatives to receive formal intimation of a case, which means that a court case can proceed without grandparents or other first-degree relatives knowing about it until well into its run.I suggest that we write to the Sheriff Court Rules Council and the British Association of Social Workers Scotland to suggest that a procedural rather than a substantive change to the rules be made.
I agree with that suggestion and with the suggestion that we should write to the minister, who has promised that a family law bill will be introduced. The role of grandparents should be considered in that bill. We should pursue the Sheriff Court Rules Council, BASW Scotland and the Minister for Justice so that they are able to pursue the matter in their different ways.
I support that approach. Mediation is extremely important and is of growing importance in some exceedingly complex cases—it can play an invaluable role. It would be a service to consider mediation in the context of the family law bill.
Quite. Perhaps I should have declared an interest, as I was once a family law practitioner. It is better if cases are resolved by mediation that embraces as many people as possible who are involved in and who have a genuine commitment to the welfare of the child.My experience is that things have changed. In my early years in practice, grandparents were not often involved, but that has changed over the years. I am pleased that the matter is being pursued further.I do not think that the minister is considering changing the family law bill. The mediation process and more intervention rather than confrontation in the court process are far better ways forward.Are members content that we write to the Sheriff Court Rules Council, BASW Scotland and the minister specifically about the mediation process?
Members indicated agreement.
It is also incumbent on the committee to write to the petitioners. We will write to Grandparents Apart Self Help and the Public Petitions Committee's clerk to advise them of our progress. We have no intention of letting the matter go.
In this meeting
Everything on 17 Dec 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Justice 1 Committee Tuesday 17 December 2002 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
- Item in Private Procedure · 2
- Convener's Report Procedure · 8
- Title Conditions (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 180
- Petitions Petitions · 9
- Petitions Petitions · 19
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.