I welcome everyone to the 20th meeting this year of the Justice 1 Committee. As always, I remind members to turn off mobile phones and pagers. I have received apologies from Wendy Alexander.I say hello again to Ian Gunn, who is the governor of HMP Peterhead. Some committee members have met him previously. I will kick off with the questions. In the report on Peterhead—"HMP Peterhead follow up inspection 25-26 March 2002"—the building inspector said:"the residential buildings at HMP Peterhead have been well maintained and are in good physical condition".The report continued:"It would be worth while to produce a detailed cost benefit analysis before writing Peterhead off".What do you think?
Official Report · Committee
Prison Estates Review
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Christine Grahame SNP 115
- Alec Spencer Scottish Prison Service 75
- Dr McManus 67
- Ian Gunn Scottish Prison Service 65
- Michael Matheson SNP 48
- Maureen Macmillan Lab 43
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 36
- Stuart Campbell STOP 2000 Programme Team, HMP Peterhead 29
- Stewart Stevenson SNP 27
- Donald Gorrie LD 24
- Councillor Pratt 23
- Paul Martin Lab 11
- Debbie Armstrong STOP 2000 Programme Team, HMP Peterhead 6
- Bill McGee HMP Peterhead Visiting Committee 6
- Councillor Stuart Pratt HMP Peterhead Visiting Committee 1
- Dr Jim McManus Parole Board for Scotland 1
The record
580 contributions · showing 1–200Members have seen the buildings and have commented on their cleanliness and so on. My view is that the buildings are not really fit for purpose for a prison in 2002. I do not know whether spending a lot of money on refurbishing the buildings would be worth while when what the prisoners in Peterhead—and in Scotland—need is decent facilities, including in-cell power and integral sanitation. I am by no means a buildings expert, so I do not know how much refurbishment would achieve, other than temporary achievements.
What do you mean by temporary?
I do not know whether spending a lot of money on refurbishing a building is worth while when it might be cheaper to build a brand new one.
The question was whether it would be worth while to produce a detailed cost-benefit analysis before proceeding.
I cannot answer that question. I see buildings that are not fit for purpose. I have worked in a refurbished prison—HMP Aberdeen—in which power and toilets had been installed in cells. Such changes make cells much smaller and I do not know whether they are worth while. As I say, I am not a buildings expert so I cannot comment further.
You used the word "temporary". Would it be worth while to carry out a cost-benefit analysis to discover whether the building could continue in use for five to 10 years until a new building is completed?
There is the separate issue of slopping out. Prisons that still operate slopping out have had to consider what contingency arrangements might be required should the practice fall foul of the European convention on human rights. That would mean that we would have to make temporary arrangements to do away with slopping out.
I will come back to that, but I want to pursue the issue of the building for a moment. In his evidence to the committee, Clive Fairweather said that he was not aware of a survey of the building at Peterhead since 1979 and he recommended that a more detailed survey should be done. The committee has written to Jim Wallace and sent a copy of the letter to Tony Cameron asking them to confirm the position with regard to a structural survey. We asked them whether they will instruct another survey to be done and whether the committee could have sight of the 1979 survey. Do you know what the position is with regard to surveys at Peterhead?
I have not been informed that a survey is to be carried out.
Do you know when the last survey was? Was it in 1979?
I am afraid that I do not know.
On night sanitation, the chief inspector said that although portapotties are not satisfactory, they might do if the current staffing were at proper levels. I understand that, at present, the prison is understaffed.
The prison is under complement at the moment.
By how many?
We are between 20 and 30 staff under complement.
With the proper staff levels—with the 20 or 30 more staff—might there be a way of operating a temporary system of allowing prisoners access to night sanitation?
The matter was discussed some time ago by the local branch of the Prison Officers Association Scotland and the previous governor, Bill Rattray. My information is that that was discussed in principle only and that no risk assessments were carried out. Clearly, it would be possible to have such a system, but it could only be a temporary system. To me, that is not a valid system for dealing with sanitation in the 21st century.
Could it be done if the staffing in the prison was at complement?
I would have to discuss that with my colleagues at Peterhead and do proper risk assessments. Night shift staffing levels are not as high as they are during the day. Clearly, we would need to be careful about letting prisoners out of their cells at night. We would have to do formal risk assessments.
Are you aware of the POAS's position on this? It says that a temporary system of access to night sanitation would be possible with the current staffing levels.
Yes. The POAS has said that that could be done in principle. However, as I have said, it has not discussed the issue in any great detail.
Is it possible?
Anything is possible if we can negotiate it with the local union representatives.
The Scottish Prison Service has quoted the Minister for Justice as saying that it would cost £500,000 to implement the changes. Can that figure be challenged?
I do not think that that figure related to Peterhead prison. I have never heard that figure quoted locally or been informed that that figure relates to Peterhead prison.
I also have a question about the possibility of cabling for television in the cells. The chief inspector's position is that that is possible. We appreciate the current situation, but is it impossible to put cables into the cells?
There is a problem with the overloading of the electrical system. That is less to do with the prison and more to do with the surrounding infrastructure. The inspector that was with Mr Fairweather's team commented on the heat that was coming from the electrical system early in the morning. Clearly, there is overloading of the system. However, I am not a buildings expert so I cannot comment on that.
Has any investigation of the possibility of cabling been done, that could be presented to the committee?
I have not been asked to do that. We have considered ways in which we can reduce the cost to prisoners of the power that they use. We are doing that at the moment. The only power that prisoners can have at the moment comes from batteries and therefore they are being disadvantaged. We are considering a scheme whereby we might be able to make power less expensive, but that is as far as we have gone.
When will that scheme come to fruition?
I have somebody working on the project now. Hopefully, there will be some results in the next month or so.
Are you saying that, although it might be possible to put cabling into the cells, it would overload the system if those cables were then used?
That is my concern. I am not an expert on buildings. My estates manager has said that he is concerned about the overloading of the system and that it is not a good idea to put more strain on it. The issue about power for prisoners is more about batteries than it is about cabling.
I know that you are not a buildings expert, but I am anxious to get some idea in my head about the lifespan that the prison might have if it were refurbished.
I am sorry but I missed your question.
If the prison was refurbished and power was supplied to the cells and there was some way of dealing with the lack of sanitation, how long a life would the prison have?
It is impossible to say. I suspect that, because those buildings are strong, they would have a long life. The problem would be the fabric of the inside of the buildings. However, I would not like to speculate.
Are there any other questions? The condition of the buildings is quite relevant.
Do you accept that all prisons have to be renewed all the time and that Peterhead is not much different from any other prison in Scotland, such as HMP Perth, HMP Inverness, HMP Barlinnie and HMP Edinburgh?
Yes. Prisoners are entitled to decent conditions and, in this day and age, that means access to sanitation, in-cell power, hot and cold water and so on. Many of those issues were not relevant at the time when many of our prisons were built.
Might it be possible to build a 500-place prison on the adjacent site, either on its own or in conjunction with renewing some parts of the existing prison?
The estates review itself contains that option, so it is clearly possible.
But for a 350-place prison, rather than a 500-place prison.
Yes, sorry—for a 350-place prison. I would not want to speculate, but members will be aware of the amount of land that is available at Peterhead. It would be quite possible, yes.
A lot of land is available.
If an efficient, safe and civilised method of allowing prisoners access to lavatories during the night could be organised, would not that be better than having a lavatory in each cell? We do not normally have lavatories in our bedrooms or in our hospital wards—we go out. Would it not be all right to have a good method of arranging for prisoners to go out to the lavatory?
I agree. If we were able to control the system, we would prefer that prisoners did not have a toilet in their cells. In a lot of prisons, including Peterhead, prisoners eat their food in their cells. Clearly, that is not particularly hygienic. In an ideal world, they would use a separate toilet area. Obviously, prisons are not an ideal world, and there is an issue of control. The number of prisoners let out of their cells at any one time has to be controlled, not only during the night shift, but during patrol periods when staff have breaks and so on.
I return to Lord James Douglas-Hamilton's point about the land available at Peterhead, on which it would appear to be feasible to build another prison, or at least another accommodation block. Would it present much of a problem to managing the prison and maintaining security if building work was taking place on that site?
Yes—any major disruption would cause problems. As you know, the work areas for prisoners at Peterhead are a big distance away from the residential areas. Any building work that was carried on at Peterhead at the same time as we had to run the prison would disrupt the road between the residential areas and the work sheds. That would disrupt what is currently happening.
Do you think that such a problem would be insurmountable?
It is something that we would have to consider. If the decision were made, we would have to consider it and ensure that any problems with prisoner movements were not allowed to interrupt any other work that was going on.
In your view, would the problems be surmountable?
If the decision was made to rebuild—
If there was such a decision.
I am sure that we could manage that situation. If it were a matter of movement, that would not be a problem.
Would you agree that the subject of night sanitation—which is, to an extent, crucial to the future of Peterhead prison—is not high up on the list of priorities of prisoners at Peterhead or among the things that they consider important to them?
I would not totally agree with that. The prisoners feel safe and secure at Peterhead. As they do not know any other options, they are compliant in so far as they do not complain about the conditions as much as they perhaps would if they knew that there was an alternative—be that a new prison 500yd away or 150 miles away. However, I do receive complaints about slopping out. Dozens of prisoners at Peterhead are taking legal action through their solicitors regarding their having to slop out, so it is an issue for them.
If I recall the responses to the Peterhead prisoners' survey correctly, slopping out did not come very high up on the list of priorities. The security of being in Peterhead prison and the culture there was much higher up on the list. Am I correct?
Yes. The prisoners indeed feel much safer where they are. Therefore, although a few dozen prisoners are seeking compensation for the conditions under which they are kept—
Is that a few dozen out of 260 prisoners? How many prisoners do you have?
We have roughly 290 prisoners.
My final question is about the risk assessment that you mentioned. Can I take it that, if you were to find a method of letting prisoners out of their cells to have access to facilities at night, you would carry out a risk assessment of each prisoner? Would there be a different risk assessment for each prisoner? Some prisoners will be very low risk. For example, it will not take many officers to let out frail or elderly prisoners, but other prisoners will be high risk and perhaps two or three officers might need to be involved in letting them out. Am I right?
Yes. Different prisoners have different levels of supervision. The previous security category system that was in place across the SPS has changed to a supervision system, which sets a level for each prisoner when they are in custody in the prison. Given the dynamic nature of that system, prisoners are likely to be kept under lower supervision levels as they move through their sentence. As you said, the age of the prisoner makes them appear to be less of a risk to staff, but a minimum number of staff must be available, even if only one prisoner is allowed out of their cell. However, this is not the right place to go into security issues.
I am not going into those issues. Did you say that you were carrying out such a risk assessment, or that a risk assessment would have to be carried out if you were to go down the alternative route of allowing prisoners out of their cells to have access to night sanitation facilities? Is that work being carried out?
No.
Should that work be carried out?
A risk assessment would be done if it were decided to go ahead with that system. Each area of the prison would be assessed. I believe that you visited a part of the prison that houses prisoners who are ready to move on to other prisons and to progress through the system. Different risks arise in that area from those that arise in the induction hall, which houses prisoners who have just come into the jail. An overriding feature of such risk assessments is that they would have to address the question of the minimum number of staff that we would need to have on the spot if any prisoner were to be allowed out of their cell. I do not think that I should go into those numbers, but that work would have to be done.
As Donald Gorrie said, having toilets in the cells is not the happiest thing. Do you agree that it would be useful, from the committee's point of view, for risk assessments to be conducted for letting people out to use toilet facilities at night and the staffing levels that that would require? If that work was done, we would know what the staffing levels would need to be and what the operation of that system would require. That would allow us to say, "This is an alternative".
Any risk assessment would be done jointly with the local branch of the POAS. We would have to sit down and agree a suitable complement of staff for a night shift at Peterhead. We would also have to consider how we could use the existing complement to take account of such arrangements. That is the process that we would have to go through, and sometimes it is not easy to do that. I would not wish to embark on a risk assessment until I got the POAS to agree to do that work. That is the way in which the process would work.
We might raise that issue with the POAS in order to see whether that work could be done and whether we could have that information.
How big an issue is the location of the prison, given that that makes it harder for people from central Scotland to visit?
That is a complex issue for Peterhead prisoners. As you know, some prisoners have offended against their own families and therefore the family ties that mainstream prisoners have may have been severed. However, the issue comes up quite often, either because people's families cannot travel or because prisoners do not like to meet their families on accumulated visits in other prisons that are not dedicated sex offender prisons. Prisoners feel safe and secure in Peterhead because it holds only sex offenders. Some families are prepared to take account of that and to make the journey to Peterhead, which also means that the families do not feel threatened before, during or after a visit. However, there will always be prisoners who have problems with visits, wherever a prison is sited. For example, the opposite problem arises if a prisoner from the north-east is in a prison in the central belt. Visits are an issue. However, as I said in my reply to the question about night sanitation, prisoners see some of the benefits of being in the Peterhead regime. They will put up with some of the difficulties that they would not face if they were elsewhere.
I want to ask about the security of the prisoners. Setting aside the question of the site for a moment, would you recommend that a jail should be set aside for sex offenders or would it be satisfactory—or perhaps better—to have a large unit in an ordinary prison to deal with sex offenders? In the second scenario, although sex offenders would be kept separate, they would be part of the jail community.
The important thing is that sex offenders must feel safe and secure when they are going through programmes. It is clear that they feel safe and secure in Peterhead. If Peterhead were to close, we would need to think carefully about how we could replicate some of its advantages. There is nothing to stop sex offender programmes being delivered in other types of prisons, as is happening in Polmont and Barlinnie. It is clear that the model that we have at Peterhead has been successful. The decision whether to keep the model where it is or to replicate it elsewhere would have to be taken carefully. I would not say that the other option is not possible.
Taking the size of Scotland and the potential client base, so to speak, into account, what is the ideal size of a prison for sex offenders?
That is an important question. Care would need to be taken to calculate the present and future numbers of sex offenders. At present, there are more sex offenders in the system than can be housed at Peterhead. That said, not all sex offenders are long-term offenders, which is the type of sex offender that Peterhead deals with. In future, we will need to consider working with all sex offenders, which would mean that the number would be closer to 600 prisoners—not the 300 prisoners that Peterhead can manage.If Peterhead is to close, it is likely that long-term sex offenders will remain in the public sector in another prison. We would have to decide whether to incorporate short-term offenders or to continue to work with them in other types of prison. I do not have a number, but projections show that there is a rise in prisoner numbers. The evidence of the past 10 to 20 years appears to indicate a greater likelihood of a rise in the reporting of serious sex offences. It is clear that that could lead to an increase in the number of people who will be committed to prison for sex offences. I would not like to guess whether that likelihood would lead to an increase, but those issues would need to be taken into account.
If it were up to you, would you build a new prison at Peterhead, add a new house block and other facilities to the existing buildings or introduce ways in which night sanitation could work—through human agency for example. In answering that question, I presume that you might be able to achieve the introduction of supervised night sanitation by building a new house block. Would that option be better or worse than building a whole new prison?
Am I correct in thinking that the question refers to options that would follow on from a decision for the prison to remain on the Peterhead site?
Yes.
That decision has not been taken and I cannot guess what the minister will decide. However, if the minister decided to keep the prison at Peterhead, two options would be available. Option 1 would be to improve the existing buildings and option 2 would be to rebuild. The estates review is clear that to refurbish the existing buildings at Peterhead would bring limited value for money to the taxpayer. I agree with that. I am not trying to guess what might happen to the estates review.
I will pick up on some of the things that Donald Gorrie mentioned. Alec Spencer, from whom we will be hearing later on, quotes with approval Professor Bill Marshall, who said that group work"is best conducted in an institution with sound peripheral security that exclusively houses sex offenders."He also stated:"if sex offenders are integrated with other offenders, treatment benefits are typically slow in coming."Do you agree?
What I have seen over the past seven months indicates that we would have to be extremely careful about how we disturbed the culture at Peterhead in relation to the prisoners feeling safe and secure. The STOP programme is delivered in other prisons that are not exclusively for sex offenders. I cannot comment on that, because I do not have experience of those prisons. In dealing with the situation at Peterhead, I would recommend being extremely careful to keep sex offenders separate from other types of offenders. The last time that I appeared before the committee, I think that I went on record as saying that Peterhead is the first example that I have seen of sex offenders being able to live a normal life within a prison setting.
You talked about numbers of sex offenders and how you thought that as the trend for reporting such crimes grew, the number of those who would be convicted would grow. We are perhaps approaching the magic number of 700, which according to the estates review is the optimum number for a new prison. Opting for a prison of such a size would mean having long-term prisoners and short-term prisoners together in the same prison. Would that be a good idea?
Mixing long-term and short-term prisoners always presents difficulties, because long-term prisoners need stability and they can sometimes be disturbed by people coming in to do short sentences. If one had a prison that housed sex offenders of all sentence lengths, one would be delivering different types of programmes to different types of prisoners. One would have a shorter programme for a short-term prisoner, whose sentence was up to a certain length. At Peterhead, we are already developing different sex offender programmes for long-term prisoners, because it is not a case of STOP 2000 fitting everyone. I am sure that the programmes team will tell members about that shortly.If one had a population that was entirely made up of sex offenders, I suppose that it would be possible to tailor the programmes according to the sentence length. That system would probably indicate how one would house the prisoners, because one would want the people on the programmes to relate to each other, not only within the group rooms, but in their normal lives within the jail. One would want the prisoners to be challenging each other and discussing issues.
It strikes me that it would be a solution to have a prison for sex offenders of all sentence ranges. However, if that were the case at Peterhead, I wonder what the implications of the fact that some of the prisoners were serving short sentences would be. Would that make a difference to throughcare for such prisoners?
Throughcare issues would certainly arise, as they do with all sex offenders. When they are released, most sex offenders are not released directly from Peterhead—we put them in a prison fairly near where they intend to live after release. Having short-term sex offending prisoners would obviously increase the volume of prisoners who were released, which would put pressures on throughcare.
You do not consider that there would be an intrinsic problem in having short-term offenders at Peterhead, if a new prison was built at Peterhead?
Most offenders come from the central belt, or from the centre of Scotland—that is an issue. The more that one moves people away from that area, the more one increases the pressure on visits for those people and on dealing with throughcare issues while they are away from places near their home.
Maureen Macmillan will pick up on staff issues.
So I will.
That is what I am here for—prompting.
Yes, you keep us all right, convener.The prison estates review states that 240 staff would be affected if Peterhead were to close. What effect has the publication of the estates review had on staff morale at Peterhead?
In some ways, it has been a relief that the document has been released and that staff have been able to find out what the options are. Most staff were not surprised by what they saw. Initially, perhaps, they felt angry and frustrated that they had had to wait for two years and, in the end, most of them did not like what they saw.Staff morale is affected almost daily by the huge media interest in the issue not so much here but in the Peterhead and Aberdeen area. Staff are in the newspapers and on the local TV and radio every day, and what they see and read can affect them both positively and negatively, if they see something that they do not like the look of. As I said when I gave evidence to the committee six months ago, the indications are that staff are still very dedicated and committed to the task. Our sickness levels remain very low, and staff are coming to work and are working as a team.I am trying to ensure that we focus on the work and do not allow the media circus to distract us too much. Although that is very difficult, the staff know that they are three quarters of the way through a consultation period and are perhaps waiting for the next big stage, which will be a decision. I repeat that, although morale has been affected, staff are still working very hard.
You said earlier that your complement is about 20 to 30 officers short. Is that because of the uncertainty about the prison's future?
There are a number of reasons for that shortfall. One factor is that it has been difficult to recruit at Peterhead for some time. Obviously people are leaving us, but that has been a common feature in SPS establishments. For example, the people that we recruit as operations officers become very attractive to the police, which means that there is always a fair turnover in that area. Unfortunately, although we conducted a recruitment campaign over the past few months and were successful in recruiting seven people at Peterhead, because of various processes we ended up with only two people, who started on Monday. However, we then trawled for volunteers from other prisons to come to Peterhead, and it looks as though another two people will start soon. As a result, we are dealing with the shortfall.Our new supervision system will also affect the numbers of staff whom we employ, as it will mean that we will not be taking into consideration categories of prisoners and the danger that they pose to the public when they are in the prison setting. As I mentioned earlier, it could be that, at certain times, we might need fewer staff to monitor the types of prisoners that we have. At the moment, our current staff complement is based upon the old system. As the new system has been in place for only a month, we have yet to find out its real impact. However, it seems that, while many of our prisoners are in the prison setting, they will be considered as less of a risk to staff than they would have been under the old system.
The Peterhead prison visiting committee has said that if the prison were closed, a significant number of prison officers would resign rather than move away. What information has been given to staff about their future options? Have you assessed how many members of staff would be willing to move to other prisons in the central belt?
First of all, when the prison estates review was published, two of the directors came to Peterhead and gave presentations to staff. I followed that up with discussion groups with staff to talk about the issues, advise them on how to present evidence and so on. We carried out a similar exercise with prisoners.I have not assessed how many staff would or would not transfer. I do not think that it would be appropriate to do so at this time as it might indicate that I know that a decision has been made—which is something that I do not know. Clearly, if it is decided that Peterhead should close, that will be done quickly. Although staff have approached me individually and have asked me in confidence whether they could get a transfer to the central belt, I have not yet carried out any assessment or survey.
I will ask a supplementary question. The submission by Peterhead prison visiting committee states:"Within the Peterhead community prison officers and their families are accepted. Officers can walk to work in uniform. This is not always the case in communities in the central belt."Is that right?
After being at Peterhead for seven months, it is clear to me that the staff have the support of the community. I do not know what the situation is in the central belt. I suspect that, as in any other place, some people want to be recognised in their uniform and others prefer not to be. Prison officers, like police officers in uniform, can attract problems.
Is the uniform respected in Peterhead? Is there a positive feeling in the community towards the prison and the officers who work there, rather than even simply a neutral feeling?
I would say so, but I would also say that there is no evidence to suggest that prison officers in other parts of Scotland are not respected. There are places in Peterhead that an officer would not walk into at 10 o'clock on a Saturday night, because they may not be met with the greeting, "Oh good, here is a prison officer. Would you like a drink?"
MSPs know that feeling too.Other evidence has indicated that there is a positive acceptance of Peterhead prison within the community and that that is demonstrated by the way that officers wear their uniforms outwith the prison, which apparently they do not do so much in other areas of Scotland.
I have no evidence of what happens elsewhere. When I started my career, I did six weeks in uniform to experience the job of a prison officer. I wore my uniform on my way to and from work without any problems.
Where was that?
I lived near Glasgow and worked in Edinburgh. I cannot say whether that is good or bad evidence, but I do not think that it is right to say that everywhere other than Peterhead prison officers cannot wear their uniforms when they are going to and from work.
When the possible closure of Peterhead first came up in January 2000, were there any staffing issues of moment at Peterhead?
Do you mean—
In relation to numbers.
Yes, there was a complement issue. There has been one for a number of years, although I am not sure of the time scale. Over the past six or seven years officers have been offered a bounty—a lump sum—to come to Peterhead, from the north-east of England and places like that, because we could not recruit locally or from the rest of Scotland. Special arrangements were made and during the last recruitment campaign a bounty was offered to some staff who wanted to join the SPS, but they still declined to come. I do not know the reasons behind that. We can surmise that it is because of the estates review. I believe that there was a complement shortfall at that time, albeit I was not then working at the prison.
Is it fair to say that the prison officers from the north of England largely came to Peterhead in the aftermath of some of the difficulties that there had been in the prison in the early-to-mid 1990s rather than more recently?
Some of them came after the change to the two bands of prison officers. Some recruitment took place after that change was introduced in 1995, but I do not know the details.
I am grateful for that information. When I was at Peterhead I wondered why there were so many Geordie accents. That is now clear.I will move on to the issue of the STOP 2000 programme. Peterhead is internationally recognised for the work that it undertakes with sex offenders, principally through the STOP 2000 programme and the culture that exists within the prison in allowing such sex offenders to address their offending behaviour. What are the implications for the STOP 2000 programme if a decision is taken to close Peterhead?
An immediate issue would be how we dealt with the announcement and how we were able to assure staff and prisoners about what would happen after that. The programme at Peterhead, quite rightly, is well renowned. A lot of good work is being done not only by the people who deliver the programme, but by the rest of the staff who support it. If the programme had to be moved elsewhere, the transfer would have to be managed very carefully. We must not lose what we have built up.
If the decision is made to close Peterhead, the proposed time scale to transfer prisoners and for the treatment programme to be established in another prison is three years. Is that adequate?
The estates review says that Peterhead could not close within three years—the buildings issue would indicate that three years is the minimum. Clearly, should there be a decision to close the prison, we would have to start planning. One of the things that we would need to know is where in the system the prisoners would go. We would do what we could to protect the integrity of the programme and ensure that we continue to get prisoners to address their offending behaviour and so reduce crime and the number of future victims. That is what we are all about.
What should the time scale be?
It is very difficult to say. Three years would give us a starting period. We would have to wait until other prisons were built before we could decide where the sex offenders would go. If the prison is to close, we would have to start planning that. However, I think it would take longer than three years. I do not find it easy to articulate that. If the decision is to put sex offenders in an existing public service prison, before we can move 300 sex offenders, we will have to decant at least 300 spaces from somewhere else. That cannot happen until the prisoners have a place to go to. If it is decided to build another prison for sex offenders, there will be delays. My guess is that we would be looking at a time span of three to five years.
Thank you. That is very helpful. If it is decided to close Peterhead and transfer prisoners elsewhere, what are the implications for maintaining the integrity of the programme?
We would need to consider the prison officers who are currently delivering the programme and manage any transfer of their skills to another location. Some of those people may decide not to move and some may decide that they do not want to deliver the programme any more. Some of the programme deliverers have been doing the job for some time. There is always a natural drop-out rate and we would need to consider the resources required—prison officers, psychologists and social workers—in the new location to ensure that we had enough people still delivering the programme. Clearly, work would still go on during the three-year minimum suggested in the estates review. We would have to keep what expertise we can and then build it up in the other establishment—wherever that may be—during the three years, so that we could start to move people. No plans have been drawn up because we do not know where the new location would be if Peterhead were to close.
Thank you.
I have two short questions. My first question is very obvious. Why do you think that the community supports Peterhead prison so strongly?
The community has supported the prison for some time. The publication of the estates review has reinforced that support because the community now sees the threat that the prison may close. The prison has been a good employer in the area. Peterhead might have been a problem prison in the 1980s, with riots and so on, but there have been no good order issues over the last 10 years or so. Apart from one well-documented escape, there have been virtually no escapes from the prison's perimeter. That is why the local public support the prison.
So the public have confidence in your excellent work and that of the officers who work under you.
Yes.
Do you agree that it would be grossly unfair to judge Peterhead prison by what it was 20 years ago?
That is correct. In our recruitment campaign, we did some research on why people appeared not to want to apply to work at the prison. We wondered whether the reason was the impending estates review, but one major reason was that people thought of Peterhead as a powder-keg prison, or whatever you might call it. Even now, when a high-profile prisoner is about to be transferred to Peterhead, some of the tabloids do us no favours by using jargon such as "Pervs' paradise" and "Powder-keg prison". That does not help. People pick up the wrong image of what goes on in Peterhead when they read those papers.
Are you saying that the prison should be judged on its present merits rather than on its past history and on the events of more than 20 years ago?
Yes. We should judge the prison on the work that it does. The estates review is principally concerned with buildings, but if we can set aside the buildings issues, we should judge the prison on its work. The Prison Service does a lot of work that goes unsung not only in Peterhead but elsewhere. In many ways, I suppose that we could just carry on with the work without having all this attention. However, as we are the focus of attention at the moment, it is right that we sing the praises of the staff at Peterhead who are delivering what they are delivering.
In answer to Michael Matheson's question, you said that it would take three to five years to transfer the inmates and the programme elsewhere. In that time, might good staff vote with their feet rather than wait while the transfer is happening? Might experienced staff move elsewhere or leave the Prison Service entirely?
I am not sure. From the people who have come to speak to me in confidence, I would say that there seems to be a mix: depending on their age, some will retire in three to five years; others, although they would prefer to stay, will move if the prison closes; others want to move anyway; and some would prefer to stay within Peterhead.We will need to consider what options would be attractive to the staff at Peterhead so that we can retain them even if the prison closes and we need to look at jobs elsewhere. There is a commitment that no member of staff will be made compulsorily redundant and that there will be no cash cuts in pay. As when we managed the closure of other prisons, we will try to give people the option of moving if that is what they want to do or we will try to give them three options and meet one of those three options.
Having visited Peterhead, I feel that it is not like other prisons. The evidence that the committee has heard is that the STOP programme works in Peterhead because of the culture that has evolved among the entire staff and not only those who present the programme. Even if we accept that there will be natural wastage and that people would leave for various reasons anyway, might not those five years lead to a fragmentation of Peterhead's staff unit, which is at the core of why you have an award-winning programme? Would that cause destabilisation?
In the days when Peterhead had problems with the prisoner population and with things such as rooftop protests and hostage takings, staff had to go to work in bad conditions. They had to work in riot gear all the time. Those were difficult times. To their credit, those staff have been able to switch from what was very much a control environment to working with and engaging with sex offenders throughout the prison.In my view, if I were transported to another prison tomorrow and told that I had to work at a new prison, I would like to think that what the Peterhead staff did could be replicated elsewhere. They were able to change their way of working dramatically. They changed from working in a control environment to working within one in which they address offending and support prisoners. We should try to replicate what happened at Peterhead elsewhere. We should not say that that can only happen in Peterhead.
Evidence to the committee suggests that it took seven years for the STOP programme to get to where it is now. The programme was not a dramatic change for the staff, because it grew over time. That is why it has worked. I am not saying that the same circumstances could not apply somewhere else. However, if the Peterhead programme is broken up and the personnel who have grown with it are lost, what makes the programme work will have been changed.
We would need to handle the transition carefully. A group has been set up under Mr Spencer to examine how the transition might happen, should the prison close. The committee will no doubt speak to him about that.
Peterhead is far and away the most successful prison in Scotland. However, if the SPS rewarded that success by closing the prison, would any other prison that was given the task have the incentive to build to the same achievement levels?
I think that some of my governor colleagues might argue with me if I agreed that Peterhead was the most successful prison in Scotland—they might look at success in slightly different ways. However, we are looking at Peterhead's success in reducing future crime and in having a range of challenging programmes for prisoners. I would like to think that, if I were asked to repeat that success elsewhere, I would take on that challenge and replicate some of Peterhead's culture.
Thank you. Unless there are other questions, I will conclude this part of the meeting. Our next witnesses are Stuart Campbell and Debbie Armstrong, who will make a PowerPoint presentation about the STOP 2000 programme. Technology comes to the committee. I understand that the presentation will take about 40 minutes, after which committee members will want to ask questions.
The presentation will take 40 to 45 minutes.
I am not Anne Robinson; I will not be nasty about it.
Good afternoon. On behalf of the staff at Peterhead, particularly the programmes unit, I thank the committee for inviting us to talk about the work that is going in programmes at Peterhead. I will set the context for the presentation, as I am aware that some committee members did not attend the presentation at Peterhead. The group work that Debbie Armstrong and I will talk about is a part of the work at Peterhead prison that is supported by all members of staff throughout the prison. The work that we do is an important part of addressing and changing offending behaviour, but we require the support of all staff within the prison. The programmes that are currently available to prisoners in Peterhead prison are made up of nationally accredited and locally developed components. Debbie Armstrong and I will go through each programme, highlighting its key components. We are also looking to develop new programmes as we go along. We have for several years considered running the domestic violence programme at Peterhead; we have now decided to do so, as we recognise the need to do some work in that area. The need for the programme is very much driven by the work that we have done with offenders in programmes such as the STOP programme and the relationships programme. The domestic violence programme is now developed and ready to run and will commence at Peterhead in June.The next programme that we will introduce is the extended sex offender programme. That will begin in September as part of the set of accredited programmes about which Mr Gunn talked. There are three such programmes in the sex offender programme, which specifically challenges offending behaviour. We are currently training three members of Peterhead staff in the extended sex offender programme. They will have to go to England, where the programme is provided, and then come back to deliver the programme. The programme focuses on prisoners who have gone through the core programme but still have areas of behaviour that need to be worked on. The core programme is the start of the process for some of those offenders, particularly long-sentence prisoners. If major areas still have to be addressed, we will address them through the extended sex offender programme.The first programme at Peterhead is the cognitive skills programme, which covers a number of major areas including problem solving, creative thinking, social skills, negotiation skills, critical reasoning, values enhancement and the management of emotions.
I will just stop you for a moment, Mr Campbell, to remind members that committee paper J1/02/25 contains parts of the presentation. It is not completely compatible with the slides, but it covers the same ground, so it might be useful. We are now on page 2 of the paper.
The cognitive skills programme is one of the accredited programmes that is run in every Scottish prison. It is one of the programmes that we use most frequently at Peterhead in working with offenders, because it does not focus specifically on offending behaviour. It is what I would describe as a gateway programme, as it allows offenders to start to look at some of the areas of their life that do not relate to their offending. It allows the process of distortions to be broken down before offenders reach the STOP programme. The programme is effective in working with offenders because it does not focus on the critical elements of their offending. The anger management programme is shorter than the cognitive skills programme, which takes 36 sessions. Anger management runs over 12 sessions and takes place once a week. The main aims are: to recognise the link between anger, aggression, lack of self-control and offending behaviour; to recognise the signs and causes of anger; to raise awareness of the consequences of violence; to learn practical ways of dealing with anger; and to develop assertiveness and communications skills. A lot of the sex offenders who come to the programme do not have major anger management problems; they tend to use instrumental anger. That is why we developed a domestic violence programme. However, some offenders require interventions in anger. All the programmes that we run are based on a need. Our approach is not about letting prisoners go on programmes because they think that going in front of the Parole Board with a list of programmes will be good for them. It is based on needs. If they need to go into the programmes, they will do so. The drug awareness programme is a 12-session programme, with sessions once a week. The whole point of the programme is to give information on drug use. It gives facts about illicit drugs and their effects and focuses on the influence of the law. One component of the programme concentrates on health issues surrounding drug use, management of change from drug use and drug-free lifestyles. We look at tolerance levels on release to see whether offenders will continue to use drugs.The programme on alcohol use is also useful in our work with sex offenders. When we work with offenders at Peterhead, we do not allow them to say that alcohol is the reason why they committed a sexual offence, as we see alcohol as a disinhibitor to the offence rather than as the cause of the offence. The person who takes the drink has a disinhibitor to doing something else, but we do not allow prisoners to say that their committing the offence was alcohol's fault.We look to develop an awareness of the nature and effects of alcohol. We examine the role that alcohol has had on offenders' lives. It is important to link the programme to times in offenders' lives when they have used alcohol and the reasons for that. We also look at the impact that alcohol has had on offenders' health, relationships, home life, work and behaviour. It is important that they start to realise that drinking has an effect on other people. We start to look at strategies around controlled use or abstinence, as appropriate to the individuals' needs when they go back into society.The sex offenders awareness programme was developed at Peterhead prison. It looks at deniers, who are either absolute or partial. It looks at reducing risk and changing attitudes.
This is on page 16 of the paper that members have been given.
The programme increases the likelihood of future self-control and it links with STOP 2000. The main reason why we decided that we needed a programme to work with prisoners in denial was that a percentage of the population do not wish to go into STOP 2000 to address their offending behaviour. We needed a programme to work in the area of denial. We linked up with colleagues in England to source material for the programme. We have run the programme three times and it appears to have been well received. It does not look at the offence per se, because we cannot work on the offence if the offender denies it. We work with hypothetical situations of sexual offences. We will run the programme once more and then submit it to the SPS for approval status so that it can be run not only in Peterhead, but in prisons such as Glenochil, which currently houses some of the sex offender population.
The staff in Peterhead's programme group developed the relationship skills programme and submitted it for approval last year, which it obtained. It focuses on maintaining and developing intimate adult relationships. We look at what an intimate relationship is; how we choose a partner; what is appropriate; what our attitudes, values and beliefs about relationships are; why we are attracted to certain people; why we think in a certain way; and what our expectations are. We consider issues around power and control, which could range from who does what in terms of housework to huge issues such as dominance and violence. With sex offenders, there are an awful lot of issues around power and control in relationships.We look at communication, which is an important issue. Offenders need to be able to identify and express their emotions within relationships in an appropriate manner. We look at coping strategies and stress management. We have put those together because sex offenders typically use a lot of emotional or avoidance coping strategies. We try to promote problem solving, as that can help with stress management—if offenders can identify problems and talk them through, that eases stress.We look at ending relationships assertively. Typically a lot of the men with whom we work either slam the door, walk away and have no further contact or have relationships that end in violence. We consider how to end relationships assertively when people know that it is time to go.The STOP 2000 programme at Peterhead is run by a multidisciplinary team. By that, we mean that prison officers, psychologists and social workers are involved in the delivery of the programme. Each group has a maximum of 10 prisoners and, on average, each programme lasts for about 105 sessions, which works out as two or three sessions a week. The programme is split into 20 blocks. Block 1 is about establishing the group. The offenders get to know one another, what their boundaries are and what they expect from one another and the programme.Block 2 is about distorted thinking. A lot of the terms that offenders use come from cognitive distortions and thinking errors. We introduce those terms to the offenders and highlight some of the distortions that they use in their offending.Block 3 talks about coping strategies. As I said in relation to the relationships programme, offenders tend to use emotional or avoidance strategies rather than tackling the problem head on. Block 4 is called "My History". It gives the offenders their first chance to say a little about their background, what was important to them and what the highs and lows of their lives have been. It is up to them what they want to tell us, but they have the opportunity to talk about things that were significant in their lives and can gain a better understanding of their offending behaviour.Block 5 is a huge block. It is to do with the active account, which deals with the lead-up to the offence. We use a decision-chain format to track offenders' thoughts and feelings, which we link with their behaviour. We look not only at the hands-on stuff that they did when they offended, but at the thoughts and feelings attached to that. The block removes the myth that offences just happen. Offenders begin to realise that a thought and feeling had to be attached to the behaviour for them to be able to commit the offence. In block 6, we examine the role that fantasy played in offending behaviour. Some offenders will tell us that fantasy was significant for them for many years prior to their beginning to offend and we will talk about the reasons why they moved from fantasy to offending. Other offenders might talk about their fantasies in terms of short sexual thoughts. We will discuss what fantasies are, what is appropriate and inappropriate and what offending fantasies are.Block 7 is called "Patterns in my Offending", which many of the offenders with whom I have worked have described as one of the most useful blocks. It examines five areas of their lives. It looks at their lifestyle: where they were living; how they were living; whether they were working; and what they did when they were not working. It examines their attitudes: what they thought of themselves, of others and of relationships. It looks at their emotions: how they typically felt; what emotions they could express; and what emotions they could identify. It looks at their relationships: whether they were in a relationship at the time of the offending; whether their relationship had broken up; whether the relationship was satisfactory; and who the significant people in their lives are. Lastly, it looks at their sexual interests: what they were; whether fantasy played a role; where they developed; and how far back they go. The block helps the offender to understand their life as a whole and not to think of the offence as one event that simply happened.Block 8 deals with peer feedback and goal setting. It gives offenders a chance to give one another a pat on the back. They are encouraged to say something good about one another in the group room, which, for many of them, is the first time that they have received positive feedback about themselves. The goal-setting element involves congratulating them on their progress in overcoming blocks, asking them how they see themselves progressing from this point and encouraging them to think about the future.Block 9 examines the costs and gains of offending. Many offenders find it difficult to think of the gains that they had from offending, because it is not easy for them to admit that they enjoyed it—that they received sexual gratification from offending. They are encouraged to do a costs and gains matrix, which looks at the long-term costs for themselves and for their victims. They come to realise quickly that the short-term gains of offending were for themselves, but the long-term costs were very much for the victim.Block 10 is an introduction to the victim empathy blocks, in which we use written and video accounts. We read statements that victims of offences have made about what they thought, how they felt and how their lives have changed. We show video accounts of victims of offences speaking about their experiences and how their lives have been affected. We ask the offenders to comment on what they take from watching and hearing those statements.Block 11 is "Victim Narratives". For the first time in the programme, we introduce role-play. We ask offenders to speak to their offences through their victim's eyes and to say what it was like for their victim. We ask them to try to imagine how the victim thought and felt at the time. That is the first time that many of the guys on the programme have thought about the offence from the victim's perspective.Block 12 is "Victim Perspective Role-Plays". We ask offenders to take on the role of their victims, but that could be at the time of the offence, a few months after the offence, a few years after the offence or up to 20 or 30 years after the offence. We ask them to consider the impact that the offence had on their victim over a period of time.Block 13 is "Victim Letters". We ask the offender to write a letter—it is never posted—to their victim. We ask them to say the things that they think their victim might want to hear.Block 14 looks at "Old Me", by which we mean the offender at the time they committed the offence. We examine their lifestyles, their relationships, their expectations, how they thought, how they felt and what was going on in their lives. We ask them to make a collage using words and pictures that represent "Old Me" at the time of the offence, to get a good idea of who that person was.Block 15 is called "Future Me". Offenders are asked to do another collage, but to think about the sort of person they want to be in future. We ask, for example, what has changed for them? How do they want to think? How do they want to feel? Where do they see their lives going? Where do they want to live? How do they want to work? Who will be important? Who will be part of their support network? Those are all things for them to consider in the future.Block 16 is called "Future Me Alternatives to Offending". By then, we have asked offenders to identify what the "Future Me" person will be like and we put some of that into practice in role-plays. We take them back to situations that they have identified in their active accounts—the account that led up to the offence—and we ask them to role-play as "Future Me". The new thinking and feeling person has to deal with all the situations from the past, but do so more appropriately.Block 17 is called "Getting to Future Me". Offenders have told us about the wonderful new person they want to be, but how will they become that person? Realistically, what has to happen for them to get there?That leads us to block 18, which considers setbacks. Offenders will encounter setbacks, because things will not always go their way. There will not always be support for them. They will not always get the job that they want first time. They will not always be reunited with their families. How do they deal with that?Block 19 looks at "Future Me" role-plays, which relate to situations that the offender might be concerned about coping with in the future. The block looks at new ways or behavioural strategies that the offender can implement to make a more positive life. To make the role-plays more difficult for the offenders, some of their "Old Me" thoughts are whispered to them. They must not only use behavioural strategies to deal with the situation, but use cognitive strategies to silence the "Old Me" thinking.Block 20 is the final block. It involves a discussion about what the offenders have taken from the programme, what worked for them, what still needs to happen and where they go from here. Those are the 20 blocks that make up the STOP 2000 programme.
I see that the computer system is not working. It would take 10 minutes to fix it, which is not worth while because members have photocopies of the slides. You should not concern yourself, Stuart—that sort of thing happens to everybody.
Before we came to the meeting, we wondered whether the technology would let us down, and it did.The next programme that I will talk about is the adapted STOP programme. I will give the background to why we had to introduce an adapted programme. When we brought the core STOP 2000 programme from England, we quickly realised that the requirement that prisoners should have an intelligence quotient of 80 to be admitted into the programme was not realistic because many of the prisoners did not have an IQ of 80. To offer a service to those prisoners, we had to bring in the adapted programme, which is the third of the set of offence-specific programmes that we offer.We introduced the adapted programme to Peterhead last year. I will outline the different way of working that it involves. The programme is intended to meet the needs of prisoners with learning difficulties, who cannot get on to the core programme because they have, for example, difficulties with reading and writing, poor intellectual and social functioning, or difficulty in obtaining information. It asks a lot of any offender to go through the 20 blocks of the core programme that Debbie Armstrong outlined; the offenders must give a lot and they must carry the work that is done in the programme back into the galleries. They must also do a lot of work on their own. Therefore, those with an IQ of less than 80 would struggle.The adapted programme is designed specifically for sex offenders with learning difficulties. It is cognitive-behavioural in its approach and utilises a range of multimodal teaching techniques to enhance learning. It is not just about writing; it involves drawing pictures and so on. I honestly believe that a picture sometimes paints more than a thousand words. That is true for the offenders who are on the programme.The adapted programme aims to increase sexual knowledge; to modify offence-justifying thinking and the cognitive distortions that Debbie Armstrong mentioned; and to develop the offenders' ability to recognise feelings in themselves and others. One main component that we work on with offenders is developing victim empathy and allowing offenders to examine their feelings. To empathise with someone else, they must understand their own feelings. The programme also aims to achieve an understanding of victim harm and to begin to teach relapse-prevention techniques to offenders.The next programme that I will mention is the pre-release programme. When offenders are taken into prison, time does not stand still and life goes on. One main part of our work is to prepare offenders for their return to the community. We take offenders into the pre-release programme for a 10-day period, during which we cover areas such as employment, which is done in conjunction with the Apex Trust Scotland. Offenders can gain a Scottish vocational qualification at level 1. Many offenders want to know what benefits they are entitled to when they move back into the community, so the local Benefits Agency office gives a talk about that. We also talk to sex offenders about drugs, HIV and safe sex before we allow them back to the community and some offenders have alcohol awareness training. We cannot force offenders to take the programmes, which are voluntary. Staff in Peterhead and other jails are not coercing prisoners into programmes. They are promoting the benefits of the programme in order to change behaviour. If they wanted to, prisoners could sit in prison and not work on their offending behaviour or any related issues, but if they go on an alcohol awareness programme, for example, they can find information about that.We also consider the issues that will face an offender when he returns to the community. Many sex offenders are concerned about such things as supervision on release, where they are going to live, and how safe they are going to be.We also talk through the basic components of relapse prevention so that offenders understand what will happen to them when they go outside and can recognise the danger signs that they might not have known about before. We concentrate on throughcare and supervision on release, which is provided by the social work department at Peterhead.That concludes the presentation on what is on offer at Peterhead. I realise that we are slightly ahead of ourselves.
No one will complain. We will move to questions from members.
Your last point was about involving the social workers in Peterhead in the throughcare and pre-release programme. We have heard evidence that many offenders come from the central belt rather than the north-east. How do you involve social workers from the central belt? How does the transfer work?
Over the years, we have developed a procedure whereby we hold a pre-release conference before offenders leave Peterhead. In his evidence, Mr Gunn indicated that we normally move prisoners back to their jail of allocation six weeks prior to liberation. Six weeks prior to that, we normally structure a case conference that involves social work departments local to the area to which the prisoner is returning, and any other organisation, such as the housing department or the police, that will pick up offenders when they go back into their community.The case conference is structured to allow the offender the first chance to meet the officer who will be supervising him on release and to maintain that link when the prisoner moves back to his jail of allocation.
Is the transfer fairly seamless?
We try to make the transfer seamless.
The STOP programme is also delivered at Barlinnie and Polmont. Perhaps it is not appropriate for you to comment, but do you have any views on the quality of delivery of the programmes in those prisons?
Any programme that is delivered by trained staff has as much credibility as the programme at Peterhead. A member of staff at a prison other than Peterhead who gets involved with this line of work, goes through the training and then delivers the programmes is as good as a member of staff who does that at Peterhead. However, obviously, Peterhead has a larger concentration of sex offenders than any other jail in the country. The core business of Peterhead is to work closely with sex offenders.
Did you have anything to do with the way in which the STOP programme evolved or was established in those other prisons?
Before 2000, when we brought the suite of core 2000 programmes from England, I began working in the programmes team in 1993. At that time, we were working on introducing the programmes. As we moved on to prisons such as Barlinnie and Edinburgh, we were involved, along with psychologists, with the development and delivery of the programmes. However, things changed in 2000 when we moved to bring in the new sex offender treatment programme—the STOP programme, as it is now known.
Did the programme not start quite recently in those other prisons?
I think that Peterhead was the preferred site to begin the programmes in 2000, but things have moved on since then.
What is the rate of reoffending? It might be too early to answer that. How do you gauge the success of the programme? You offer quite a detailed programme. What tracking is carried out to ensure that, when prisoners are released, the programme has been successful? How many prisoners complete the programme?
Before I talk about reoffending statistics, I should point out that our sample is a narrow one. It was put together by me and members of the programmes team and is really intended for evaluation purposes. If an offender whom we put through our programmes returns to prison, we want to know what went wrong out there, what difficulties they encountered and why they came back to prison. Since 1993, we have put about 286 offenders through the programme. Six of them have been reconvicted of a sexual offence and seven of them have returned because of a breach of licence. I can submit a copy of the document that I am referring to as evidence, if the committee so wishes.
Yes, please.
Is that a narrow sample of prisoners? In what way was the information collated?
That information covered offenders who have gone through the sex offenders programme at Peterhead only. We have been involved in this work since 1993. We wanted to ensure that we knew why offenders were going through the programme, returning to the community and coming back to jail. We wanted to discover what they encountered, why they found it difficult and why they fell back into offending behaviour habits.
Are you referring to prisoners going back to any jail, not just to Peterhead?
Of the 13 who came back, six were reconvicted of a sexual offence. Seven came back because of a breach of licence, not a sexual offence.
So the rehabilitation programme has been successful for around 270 prisoners. Have any independent evaluations been carried out?
It is difficult to make that statement. I should highlight the fact that sex offenders could be out in the community at this moment, committing sexual offences. They can be difficult to track and, as a lot of research suggests, they can be long-term planners and can offend for a number of years before they are caught. Very little research has so far been done on that in Scotland. The programme has been introduced only in the past two years—we are very much in our infancy. In fact, we have been running since 1993, but we are now on a different programme. A number of years would need to pass before we could give hard statistics on the effectiveness of the programme.
In a number of our prison visits we have come across some very good programmes run by highly dedicated people. In each case, there has been some doubt about how many prisoners have benefited. For various reasons, quite a lot of them never came into contact with the programmes. Do all the prisoners going through Peterhead benefit from the STOP 2000 and other programmes?
I would hope so; I think that that is the whole point. However, to return to what I said earlier, we cannot just tell prisoners that they will take part in programmes; we have to create an environment in which they feel that programmes are of benefit to them. Whether they take part in the STOP programme is a totally different story. Many prisoners, because they deny their offence or are appealing against their conviction, will not involve themselves. Only a very small percentage of the prisoner population at Peterhead is not involved in any programmes at all, be they cognate skills or alcohol programmes or the deniers' programmes.Part of our remit relates to a desire to change offenders' behaviour. The aim is to get them to take responsibility, and it is for them to conclude that they need to change their behaviour so that they do not reoffend in the community.
Is there any evidence as to whether you actually do any good in the way of stopping reoffending, or has the programme not been running long enough for you to be able to say?
The programme has not been running long enough for us to make that evaluation. I feel that we are doing good and that we see a change in offenders with whom we work in the programme. I am sure that Debbie Armstrong will back that up in the light of her experience. I hope that, after they get over the initial stigma of being in prison and become involved in a programme and go through the 20 blocks of the core programme, they will see themselves as better people and can go out into the community and live an offence-free lifestyle.
It is important that prisoners believe that there is a benefit for them. The programmes are entirely voluntary, and prisoners would not put themselves through a programme if they did not feel that they would benefit from it. They believe in the programmes, which is important.
I have a couple of small points to raise. In Dr Jim McManus's submission to the committee, he states:"Around 30 prisoners per year complete the programme—approximately 10% of the capacity of the prison."In other words, he suggests that that is not a huge number. On average, roughly how many prisoners are released from Peterhead once they have completed the programme or shortly thereafter?
I do not have that figure.
I think that it is about 50.
I am not sure.
Alec Spencer is to give evidence later today. I shall read a quotation on reoffending from his book, which dates back to 1999:"The rate of reoffence among sexual offenders is known to be very high."That is a general offering—he does not use any figures. The rate of six out of more than 200 is certainly not something that any member of this committee—or anyone else—could reasonably describe as "very high". Am I correct in saying that those figures cover people who have been released over a period of seven or eight years?
Yes.
My question is straightforward. Do you find that the receptiveness of the prisoners who go on the programme varies, or are all of them pretty receptive to it?
Each brings their own ideas about what they want to achieve while they are on the programme. I am sure that the staff from Peterhead would testify that working with that particular prisoner group can be difficult. Staff must be able to motivate them into joining the programmes.
Do prisoners go at their own pace or do they go at a pace that is driven by the course?
There are two programmes, one of which—the adapted programme—works at the individual's pace. As I said in our presentation, the core programme lasts for 85 sessions—it can run over—whereas the adapted programme tends to work with the individual at a much slower pace. The expectation of prisoners who are on the core programme is that they can work at that pace because their IQ level is slightly higher. At times, we offer offenders work or support outwith the programme, if they require it or if there are areas in which they feel they are not doing very well. Such work or support does not get the offender out of doing the programme, but there are areas on which offenders must work and we will help and support them in doing so.
Pace is important. At Peterhead, we run the programmes two or three times a week. That allows the offender to internalise the work that they have done—they can go away and think about it, digest the information and come back prepared for the session.
What is the average length of sentence for a prisoner in Peterhead?
We deal with long-term prisoners, who have sentences of four years and over—at the top end, a prisoner might have a life sentence plus.
The STOP programme takes several months. What happens after the STOP programme has finished but while a prisoner still has five or six years of his sentence left? Is the programme reinforced?
We try to break the sentence up into manageable chunks. The first is the induction phase of the sentence. We do not allow prisoners to move into offence-specific work for the very reason that Maureen Macmillan highlighted: the work could become forgotten. The structure of the sentence must move along at a pace. We look to engage prisoners into programmes during the middle phase of the sentence. That happens before the date on which the prisoner qualifies for a parole hearing, so that when a prisoner goes before the Parole Board for Scotland, his representations will stand a better chance, as he will have done the programme and other work. At the end of the sentence, there is scope to tackle other areas that need to be tidied up or worked on. I talked about three programmes in relation to offence-specific work: the adapted programme, the extended programme and the core programme. There are other programmes, such as the booster programme, which we hope to introduce in Scotland in the near future. That programme is needed to boost the work that is being done.
That is needed towards the end of the sentence.
Yes.
Stuart, you said that you had been involved in delivering sex offender programmes, in one form or another, since 1993. That is almost 10 years—I am not sure how long Debbie Armstrong has been doing that type of work. How long does it take for a member of staff to begin to work on those programmes? How long does it take for them to train and to build a level of competence and experience so that they can act as a group worker on the programmes?
I joined the SPS in 1996. I underwent a two-year probationary period, at the end of which I moved to the residential halls where the prisoners live. At that point, I had to apply to join group work. By then, I had had two and a half years' experience of working exclusively in a sex offender prison. During that time, I attended numerous staff training events that examined sex offender awareness training and collusion training. I had a heightened awareness of dealing with that type of prisoner population. Further training is required before prison staff can deliver the programmes. It took three years before I began to deliver offence-specific work to offenders.
When a new member of staff is moved into the programme, the emphasis is on supporting them. We try to match carefully the member of staff with an experienced facilitator who knows the programme and its components and who also knows the dynamics of how to work in groups with offenders. It is vital that we match staff and facilitators in that way. Staff need to be supported and have continuing training throughout the programme. Our work does not stand still; research is produced and people need continually to update their skill base.
Debbie, you mentioned that you spent two and a half years in the halls working with sex offenders before you moved into group work.
I spent two and a half years, part of which was during my probationary period. However, that time was not spent exclusively in the halls.
Before a member of staff progresses to deliver group work, is it important for them to spend time working with sex offenders in the residential halls?
As I gained a sound understanding of the prisoner group with whom we work, it was of benefit to me to have the help and support of the rest of my colleagues at Peterhead.
Blocks 10 to 13 of the STOP programme cover areas from victim empathy to victim letters. What contact do you have with victim organisations and support groups? Do those groups have input into the programme framework?
We do not include victim organisations in our line of work. We have taken advice from them.
That is what I meant. I did not mean that they would be proactive.
In this meeting
Everything on 21 May 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Justice 1 Committee Tuesday 21 May 2002 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
- Prison Estates Review Committee business · 580
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.