With your permission, deputy convener, I would like to explain that I have lodged motions to annul both of the statutory instruments because of serious concerns about their fairness and independence and the consequences of creating a two-tier disciplinary system. I want colleagues in the committee to consider the evidence that we have now received and further evidence that we should seek—in particular, I draw the committee’s attention to the letter that we have received from Calum Steele—and we should do that before deciding whether the regulations should be allowed to pass without a challenge.For me, the central issue is fairness, which must apply irrespective of rank. Dame Elish Angiolini’s 2020 review was clear. Her recommendation 27 called for gross misconduct hearings across all ranks—not simply for chief constables but for every rank—to have an independent legally qualified chair, an independent lay member and a policing member. At paragraph 12.61, she considered the additional costs of that and concluded that the benefits of“independence, transparency and public confidence”outweigh them.However, the regulations depart from that recommendation. Senior officers receive independent panels with legally qualified chairs, but other officers continue to have their cases determined within the police disciplinary structure. Why should a constable facing dismissal have less independent adjudication than a chief constable facing precisely the same consequence? What evidence justifies rejecting Dame Elish Angiolini’s recommendation?There is a striking inconsistency even within the Cabinet Secretary for Justice’s own words on the matter. Speaking to the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents in June, Neil Gray warned that perceptions of preferential treatment for senior officers and inconsistent standards went to the“heart of confidence, fairness and legitimacy”.He said that such perceptions “undermine trust in leadership”. How can ministers acknowledge that danger and then introduce regulations that establish different standards of independence according to rank? That is precisely the perception that we should eliminate.The Association of Scottish Police Superintendents understands the responsibilities that are placed on misconduct hearing chairs and the pressures that are inherent in the disciplinary decision-making process. We should hear directly from the association about whether the arrangements provide sufficient independence, competence and protection from improper influence.On that point, Calum Steele’s letter is troubling. He served 15 years as the general secretary of the Scottish Police Federation and has extensive experience of disciplinary proceedings. He reports accounts of hearing chairs being pressured to deliver particular sanctions before evidence has even been heard, including alleged references to their career progression. He also describes investigations concentrating on evidence that supported allegations while failing to pursue evidence that might exonerate the officer. Those are serious allegations that require examination.How can officers have confidence in a process in which investigation, presentation and initial adjudication remain substantially within the same organisation? External appeal safeguards exist but might come only after careers have been damaged, expense has been incurred and proceedings have been prolonged. Is it surprising that some officers perceive a two-tier system or describe the existing arrangements as a kangaroo court? Perception matters—the cabinet secretary himself said so.There is also the issue of the threshold for gross misconduct. Calum Steele argues that“allegations are too readily classified as gross misconduct”,only to be resolved at a lower level. He questions whether performance issues are being pursued through disciplinary procedures with dismissal becoming the starting assumption. Who determines the threshold for gross misconduct? How often is the original classification reduced? What independent scrutiny exists? A gross misconduct allegation can cause immense damage before wrongdoing has even been established.We should consider the effect that delays have on those involved, because reporting of Police Scotland’s professional standards departments has been cited as showing an average of 389 days to conclude investigations and hearings. I want clarification of precisely what that figure measures. It is reported that some officers have remained suspended or on restricted duties for years, with careers in limbo, families living with uncertainty, officers facing financial and emotional strain, and complainants and victims denied timely answers. The process itself must never become the punishment, which I fear is what is happening.When proceedings are mishandled or dismissals are overturned, who is accountable? Who pays for the errors? What effective recourse exists, without costly appeals and litigation?09:15Calum Steele has identified troubling provisions in SSI 2026/276. Regulation 15, which would introduce regulation 16A, would permit someone without legal qualifications to determine complex legal arguments at pre-hearings. Regulation 16A(8) would permit earlier procedural decisions to be reconsidered in specific circumstances. What safeguards would ensure that such discretion would be exercised fairly, with proper reasons given and effective recourse? Regulation 17, which would amend regulation 18, raises questions about presenting officers’ submissions and the admission of written evidence instead of oral testimony. How might contested evidence be effectively challenged? What would ensure that the provisions operate fairly? Those questions concern the integrity of decisions, including those that involve dismissals being overturned because procedures were defective.What about openness and accountability? There is greater provision for public scrutiny of senior officer proceedings, with other officers facing different arrangements. Publishing an outcome is not equivalent to allowing for public scrutiny of how it was reached.His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary in Scotland has identified serious weaknesses relating to conduct and discipline. We need to establish what has been done to address them. That is why I want the committee to take evidence from Calum Steele, the Scottish Police Federation, the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents, HMICS and, of course, ministers. We need answers on the questions about independence, gross misconduct thresholds, overturned decisions, delays and representation costs, and we need to know the Government’s justification for departing from the Angiolini review’s recommendation.We cannot amend the instruments. The procedure that is being used means that we cannot retain the provisions that we approve of and remove those that we find objectionable. We must judge each instrument as a whole. That is why I have lodged motions to annul the instruments.In my view, ministers have departed from the clear recommendation of the Angiolini review without providing convincing evidence that their alternative approach is fairer, more independent or more effective. The allegations that Calum Steele has raised, the weaknesses that HMICS has identified and the contradictions in the Government’s position deserve proper parliamentary examination. The burden on ministers is to justify the regulations. In my view, they have not yet discharged that responsibility, so the committee should not endorse the regulations until they do.I thank the committee for its indulgence.