link
Our next petition is PE2233, lodged on 21 July by Katherine Jones on behalf of Action to Protect Rural Scotland, which calls for the introduction of a moratorium to prohibit planning permission from being granted for any hyperscale data centres until the Scottish Government has carried out a thorough assessment of their impacts on Scotland’s communities, greenhouse gas emissions, land and water resources and electricity grid; regulations are modified to require all hyperscale artificial intelligence data centres to carry out an environmental impact assessment; and the Scottish Government puts in place guidance on hyperscale AI data centres and green data centres.There has been a significant amount of public and parliamentary interest in this issue in the early months of this parliamentary session, with a number of questions and motions having been lodged on the subject and a debate having been held in Opposition time. The Scottish Parliament information centre briefing highlights the recent direction that was issued by the Scottish Government, which requires any planning application for a data centre with a power capacity in excess of 50MW to be accompanied by an environmental impact assessment. The briefing is also clear that the Scottish Government could introduce what is effectively a moratorium by adopting a “no support” policy, as it has done for new coal mines and oil and gas developments that employ fracking. The briefing goes on to explain how that principle works in practice.In its submission, which was provided before the direction that was issued on 16 September, the Scottish Government suggests that it is not clear whether a moratorium would be lawful, noting that the Government cannot prevent applications from being submitted and that each application is considered on its merits. It further notes that planning authorities already have a responsibility to consider environmental impacts. The Government argues that there is a large opportunity to be had with attracting large-scale investment into Scotland through data centres and that“there is a unique opportunity to design a system with controls and guidance that gets it ‘right’ from the start.”In their submission, the petitioners indicate that they are content that points 3 and 4 of the petition have been addressed. They consider that point 3 was addressed by the Government’s direction issued on 16 September, while point 4 was addressed through the motion that was lodged by Patrick Harvie and agreed to, as amended, by the Parliament on the same date.However, the petitioners feel that the ask for a moratorium, as set out in point 1 of the petition, and the ask for that moratorium to remain in place until a thorough assessment of the impact of data centres has been carried out, as set out in point 2, have only been partially addressed. The petitioners point to the SPICe briefing and advice that they have received from Environmental Rights Centre for Scotland that is clear that the Scottish Government could lawfully introduce a moratorium, which would address point 1 of the petition.They also explain that they have not yet had clarity from the Scottish Government on how it will deliver part 2 of the petition, which is the call for a thorough assessment of the impact of data centres on Scotland’s communities, greenhouse gas emissions, land and water resources and electricity grid. The petitioners point to work that is being progressed by the Climate Action Committee and by the Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee. They consider, though, that“at its heart this is a planning question”and ask us to consider referring the petition to our colleagues on the Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee.Do members have a view on where we should go next?


