Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Procurement

Wednesday 30 September 2026 Transport Committee About 08:15 Evidence session 385 contributions · 12 speakers

This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

385 contributions · showing 1–200
Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

The second agenda item is an evidence session on public procurement as it relates to transport policy. We are grateful to our witnesses. Our first panel is from Transport Scotland, and I am pleased to welcome Alison Irvine, who is the chief executive; John MacIntyre, who is the head of procurement and contracts; Lawrence Shackman, who is the director of infrastructure projects; and Chris Wilcock, who is the director of ferries. Welcome back, Chris, and thank you all for coming. We will try to keep the questions and answers as short as possible. We will start with questions from Lloyd Melville.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

I will start with Alison Irvine, if that is all right. Rail infrastructure projects take an awfully long time—too long—to come to fruition in Scotland. Do you agree with that assessment?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

From the perspective of how long infrastructure projects take to come into delivery, I have heard people say that transport infrastructure projects in general take too long, and rail is no different from that. In fact, rail is particularly complex because of the need to integrate decisions on train and track, which is not always as simple as people might expect.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

I ask because there are absolute no-brainer projects such as Winchburgh station, which was first mooted in a master plan in 2005, but, 21 years later, is no further forward. When the Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Tourism and Transport was before the committee recently, he said that advice to ministers on Winchburgh was due “imminently”. Advice is imminent 21 years after the project was first mooted, but that still does not mean that shovels are in the ground. What is your assessment of what needs to be done to pick up the pace on such projects?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

The example that you have given is one where there is a relationship between land use planning and the infrastructure needed to support the planning decisions.The Winchburgh station project started out essentially as a planning condition for the developer to bring forward. If you have been there, you will have seen that the houses around Winchburgh are now going up, and the Government has made a commitment to support establishment of the station. I think that it was Jenny Gilruth, when she was Minister for Transport, who made the commitment that, once the station was built, ScotRail would provide services to it. That comes at a cost and already represents an investment. We are now at the stage when the location of the station has to be looked at and decided on, because the position that the developers had initially envisaged turned out not to be feasible due to the importance of the track that it is on.Those might seem like, to use your word, “no-brainer” decisions, but there is complexity around where accountability sits, where the responsibility for it lies and how to ensure that track is integrated with train, all of which build into the mix.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

I am sorry to cut in, Alison, but my specific question was on what needs to be done to pick up the pace for future rail infrastructure projects.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

The advice that we have to get to ministers is on how best to satisfy the commitment that they have made in their manifesto and to support, in an appropriate way, the extensive development that is going on in that space. That does not just involve Transport Scotland, Network Rail and ScotRail; it involves the developer, the council—in the case of Winchburgh, it is West Lothian Council—and so on. Those conversations take place, and our job is to get the advice to ministers so that they can take a view on it.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

John MacIntyre, as head of procurement, do you feel that particular procurement policies need to be simplified to speed up the process of rail development in Scotland?

John MacIntyre Transport Scotland
link

Transport Scotland is a delivery arm, in essence, so we do not really have a say on updates or amendments to legislation; we simply use the procurement rules that are there. For rail development, a lot of the work is taken forward by Scottish Rail Holdings, which is bound by the utility regulations. The majority of Transport Scotland’s regulated procurement is done under the Public Contracts (Scotland) Regulations 2015. The utility regulations are slightly different, but they cover broadly the same areas.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

That is your bread and butter in terms of procurement. Have you a view on where the barriers are? Have you an appeal to make to ministers about how to simplify the process to make your job easier?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

Can I interject? The situation that you are describing is not a procurement issue. It is a decision about where accountability sits, who is responsible for a project, who is going to fund it and who is going to deliver it.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

The 2026 date was dropped from references to the Aberdeen to central belt improvements last year. When will those be completed?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

The Aberdeen to central belt improvements are partly tied up with the rail recharge policy that was published in the past 12 months, which links our planned fleet investment with the necessary infrastructure to support that fleet for intercity trips.We expect Network Rail and Scottish Rail Holdings to come to us in the coming months with a revised business case for what I will describe at this point in time as the next element of that work, and then we will provide advice to ministers.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

At this stage, you do not have an indicative timescale as to when the full suite of works will be completed.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

I do not have that information in front of me. We have not taken a decision on it. We are working with Network Rail, ScotRail and Scottish Rail Holdings on the business case that will support those decisions.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

It is quite a move from saying 2026 to now having no definite timescale. Do you accept that?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

I accept that it is a move from 2026 to where we are currently, but that typifies the statement that I made at the start about the complexity of integrating matters involving the rail network.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

That brings me neatly to my next point. As you will be aware, public service reform is under way across Scotland and, as part of that, Transport Scotland will formally be brought back within the Scottish Government. Considering all the issues that we have discussed, will there be opportunities to simplify the process and ensure that rail projects can be delivered faster for communities across Scotland?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

What you describe presents an opportunity to design a governance system for transport that works for the people of Scotland, and we are part of that mix. You will be aware of the rail reform legislation that is going through Westminster, which will also bring about huge changes and should drive benefits associated with improving the integration between track and train, simplifying decision making and so on.Our industry works with the pace and the resources that we have available to us. I think that I said this to you, Mr Rennie, when you came to meet us over summer. One of the joys of the transport system is that people really like it, and they really like it when it works, and they always want to have more of that. That is great as an ambition. Part of our role is to help ministers manage those levels of ambition and expectations and then align them with policy. That is often a difficult job. That is not to do with any process associated with Transport Scotland or one relating to Network Rail or ScotRail; it is just about getting the right balance.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

To follow up on what Lloyd Melville asked, I have a quick question about Winchburgh, if you do not mind. I accept that this is not a procurement issue for you, but it has been raised this morning. Ministers have committed to delivering on the project, but there does not seem to be a budget for it yet. Do you know whether any money has been identified?09:45

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

As I said, ministers, as part of their manifesto, have committed to support Winchburgh rail station. My job is to give them advice, which includes consideration of the necessary budget to support whatever role ministers choose to play in that particular project. As you know, it is early days in the budget process: it is back at the stage of looking at how much money is needed in the system. All those things are in the mix.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

We will wait to see how the budget process plays out, then.Next, I want to ask about ports and ferries, starting with Ardrossan. Where are we with Ardrossan? The Scottish Government has bought the port, has it not?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd purchased the port in March this year and has done some work to improve it. It is due to close imminently for a few weeks while more substantive work is under way. I will bring in Chris Wilcock to give an overview of where we are on the improvement programme and the task force, if that is okay.

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

The port is shut just now for those more substantive works. As Alison has outlined, CMAL has been doing a lot of initial upgrades, some of them cosmetic and others operational, to improve the port’s appearance and resilience while we continue to operate there.CMAL is also working on the future plans for the port. The task force will meet in the coming weeks—next month, I think—to outline those next steps. The aim is to go out to tender for the works next summer, with a view to being on site by the end of the year. Much of that will be determined by the scope of the works, and that is very much what CMAL is looking at just now.Clearly, we are committed to the original works, such as upgrading the Arran berth, terminals and other elements there, but the scope is also about looking at the wider work that needs to be done, given the condition of the port and how we might want to operate from there in the future. The final costs and the detail of that will be known only once we have been through that scoping exercise, but CMAL is very much working on that and engaging with communities along with Transport Scotland and CalMac.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

As a punter who occasionally gets on ferries—I was on the ferry earlier this year to go to Arran—I can see what a mess Ardrossan is and that quite extensive work needs to be done to it. Is there a ballpark figure yet?

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

We are certainly expecting it to cost more than £100 million. We are developing other ports just now, such as Port Ellen, and the price of such projects is substantial. I cannot give you an exact figure for where we will be until we get that scoping work done. As I have said, there are wider considerations around how fully we will bring the port into operation and what will be needed to deliver a resilient service to Arran.As a starting point, we are very much focused on the aspects that were part of the earlier plan, but we are also exploring what else needs to be done, the overall affordability and whether everything could be done in one project or some things would need to wait.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

The port will have to close for quite a period, will it not? It could be one and a half or two years.

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

The current proposal is to close the port for that period of time. That is absolutely the most efficient way for the companies to develop the port. We will be able to set out all that once we know the scope.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

You said that the work would potentially cost more than £100 million. Is that affordable?

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

I go back to Alison Irvine’s point about our having to fit that into the overall budget process. Costs are significantly higher in the marine world than we might have hoped for at earlier stages in the project—we have seen that with other projects as well. We will need to work through the budget process to decide how we can afford that process or that full project again, depending on the full scope of those works. The affordability might inform that scope as well.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Sticking with CMAL for the moment, I want to ask about the normal process by which it procures ferries and ports. Let us say that, for a ferry, it goes out to market, invites bids, accepts a bid and then agrees a price. Then what happens? How does CMAL pay for it?

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

For ferries, that is funded via a voted loan, which is a loan from the Scottish Government to CMAL that is repaid over a period—usually a 25-year period for vessels. The loan is made up of the capital cost of the vessel, which will include an allowance for bringing the vessel into service and the site supervision, and then a small annual allowance on top of that for CMAL’s running costs as the vessel owner, as well as an allowance for owners’ upgrades. As is normal, a vessel owner that is chartering has to provide that funding to the charterer. The vessels are then chartered to CalMac or NorthLink. The overall pot of funding, or the costs over 30 years, generate a charter rate that is paid for by the operator and that therefore forms part of the overall subsidy to run the services.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

So CMAL does not have a budget for buying ferries; it has to come to you to get a loan.

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

Yes. It is funded through loans from the Scottish Government, which leave our budget. That is budgeted for as capital from the Scottish Government. We discuss closely with CMAL the requirement for the next five years, and that feeds into the budget process.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Do you agree, five years in advance, how much CMAL is allowed to spend on ferries?

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

We have the islands connectivity plan, which sets out the ambition to replace vessels over the short, medium and longer terms. Given the budget planning process, we obviously focus on that earlier phase. As I said, we have conversations with CMAL not only about what is happening this year and next, but what we need to do over five years. As I am sure you know, a vessel project takes around five years from the initial thinking up to the point when the vessel is delivered. That is why we need to plan on that basis. That is a rolling piece, as we go through the year.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Do you charge interest on the loans?

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

Yes, interest is charged on the loans. I am sure that it is the Public Works Loan Board rate.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

What is the rate at the moment?

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

That, I could not tell you.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Right.I will now ask about the potential direct award. Actually, I think that that question is in two bits, because there is a potential direct award for a couple of vessels to replace the marine research vessel Scotia and the marine protection vessel Minna, and then there are the two ferries. I think that those are separate, and I will explain why.I will take the ferries first. Back in 2023-24, in the Auditor General’s report on the audit of Ferguson Marine, he wrote about the yard’s five-year business plan. As you will remember, the business plan was based on the yard getting a direct award of the small vessel replacement programme from the Scottish Government, but that actually went out to tender and the yard did not get the award. In his audit report, the Auditor General said that there was“legal advice that a direct award would be in breach of the conditions set out in the UK Subsidy Control Act”.CMAL has publicly stated that the direct award of any contract for shipbuilding is not lawful. After the delays in the small vessel replacement programme and the Lord of the Isles replacement because of the consideration of direct award, has anything actually changed to make it legal?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

For a direct award of a ferries contract to be lawful, two things need to happen. First, there needs to be consideration of the subsidy that would be associated with it and a referral to the Competition and Markets Authority. As you will have heard Mr Flynn say in the Parliament on several occasions, that involves complex technical work that brings into play legal, financial and commercial specialisms. A team in the Scottish Government is working on that aspect.The second thing that needs to happen is that what are known as Teckal rules must be complied with in relation to the relevant body, which, in this case, would be CMAL.We have a role in the whole process, in establishing the business case for the procurement of the ferries. We are working with CMAL on that, and we expect a decision on the overall construct of phase 2 of the small vessel replacement programme to be made in the coming months, if not weeks. We also need to consider the governance arrangements and do the necessary due diligence to establish Teckal compliance for CMAL, in a similar way as we did for CalMac when the direct award of the Clyde and Hebrides ferry service 3—or CHFS3—contract was made at this time last year. There are multiple parts to the picture.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

As things stand, would it be legal to make a direct award?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

As things stand, work is progressing on the subsidy assessment and on Teckal compliance.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

I understand that. I have heard what you have said—I know that the work is progressing—but could you make a direct award today?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

We would not be in a position to make a direct award for the vessels today.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

The governance arrangements need to be changed in order to make a direct award legal.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

That is part of the mix.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

You said that you are doing some work. Are you doing the work that is needed in order to make a direct award legal?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

Yes.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Today, a direct award would not be legal, but you want to get to a point at which it would be legal.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

That is the cabinet secretary’s stated ambition.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

How long do you think that will take?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

We are working with CMAL to change its status from a public corporation to a non-departmental public body, so governance changes are being made. The additional work relating to the intricacies of the way in which our ferries bodies exist and of their status is ongoing. For the Government, the key aspect is the principles assessment.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

That does not answer my question. How long do you think the work will take?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

In our world, we always have a plan for the work that needs to happen, but, in my experience, there can be what I will call showstoppers—things that you might not have expected that can have implications for how long a piece of work will take. I do not think that it would be wise or, indeed, appropriate for me to say how long the work will take or to give you a date. I recognise that you want one, but if I were to say to you that, at this point in time, I would be comfortable that we would be ready—

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

You do not have to give me a month, but you could say that it will take roughly six months or up to a year.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

I think that it will probably take a maximum of six months.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Is that a maximum of six months from now?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

For the Teckal compliance, which is our aspect of the work.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

I have another question, but do you want to come in, convener?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

It could be sooner. It depends on how complex the work is.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Does changing CMAL’s status from a public corporation to an NDPB require legislation?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

No.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Therefore, you can do that. Is that sufficiently close to the Government to comply with the Teckal arrangements?

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

That is part of the consideration process. The move to non-departmental public body status is part of the process of the Office for National Statistics reclassifying bodies—I am sure that you are well aware of that—and that is as a result of the direct award to CalMac.10:00CalMac has also been reclassified as an NDPB. That happened earlier this year, and we have a derogation to treat it as a public corporation until the end of this financial year. We are working through all those elements and absolutely looking to see whether, in parallel, they take us either some or all of the way there.On Mr Simpson’s point on timing, it is worth reflecting on the fact that a lot of this work can be done in parallel. When we were doing the direct award to CalMac of the CHFS3 contract, that work was being done and it was made Teckal compliant very close in the lead-up to that. We just need certainty that there is a clear path to all that. That is the work that we are doing just now.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Let us say that we arrive at the point where CMAL can legally make a direct award. What would you do if CMAL—it is the experts in this—say, “Actually, we don’t want to make a direct award to Ferguson’s. We think we’ll get better value and better delivery times by putting the contract out to the market”? It has done that in other circumstances. Would you have to order it to make a direct award?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

I hope that we would avoid that circumstance. CMAL’s concerns relate to the current position, and we need to provide it with an assurance that ministers, as the procuring authority, have a lawful basis to move forward with a direct award. It is a bit like the Teckal compliance work in that we are having those conversations with CMAL.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

It would not be unrealistic for CMAL to say, “Look, hang on a sec. We’ve been through this with Ferguson’s. It didn’t deliver the two large ferries on time, it was way over budget, and its recent track record is not good. We think it would be better to test the market and see what else is out there.” That would not be an unreasonable position for CMAL to take, would it? If it says that that is what it should do because it will get better value for money that way, would you stop it from doing that?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

Ultimately, CMAL is a body that is owned by the Scottish ministers, and, ultimately, it is for the Scottish ministers to consider the advice that they get from CMAL and the island communities—from the voices that we hear from up there—as well as Ferguson’s and the yard in order to reach a decision on the appropriate route. That is why they are ministers; they get to make these big decisions, based on the advice that we and CMAL give them and they get from others—thankfully.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Has CMAL expressed a view on whether there should be a direct award?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

From the way that you have been asking your questions, I understood that you had heard directly from CMAL on that.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

I have not said any such thing. I am asking whether it has expressed a view to the Government.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

CMAL has regular conversations with us and with Mr Flynn, as they had with Ms Hyslop before him. As you would expect, there is a free and frank exchange of views on all things.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

On all things, Mr Simpson.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

On all things.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Are you able to share what that view is?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

Again, that is all part of the mix of the advice to ministers, so I think that we are probably better to leave it in that space.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Okay. I think that we can read into that.Those questions were all about the ferries. Are the two marine vessels in a different category? Could you make a direct award for them now?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

They do not fall under our remit, so it would not be me or Chris Wilcock who would answer those questions. It is the marine directorate in the Government that is procuring them. The Teckal compliance issue is not the same.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

It is not the same, so, actually, you could.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

No—

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

It still comes under the Government, does it not?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

Yes. That is what I am saying. For the marine vessels, the Teckal compliance issue is not a thing, but the subsidy control and the principles assessment remain key.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

In the case of those two vessels, it sounds to me like you could actually proceed.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

I think that I have given you all that I know. I am really sorry, Mr Simpson.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Does anyone know the answer to that?

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

As Alison Irvine alluded to, and as you said earlier, there are two packages in terms of who would procure them and how they could be procured—

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

—but those vessels cannot be procured yet. The position on legality needs the principles assessment, which relates to the subsidy control. You described the two halves, the second part of which is the principles assessment, and they are all wrapped up in the same piece of advice.For completeness, I note that, as the cabinet secretary said, the upgrades at the yard are again all wrapped up in the process of the principles assessment and the CMA referral. My understanding is that those vessels need to wait until that process is complete.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Okay. It seems to me that that element could proceed more quickly than the ferries, but none of you is able to answer that question. That is not very good, but I will leave it there.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

I have a couple of follow-up questions given some of the evidence that we have heard. They pick up on the discussion about the ports and the comments that Chris Wilcock made, but I am happy for anybody to answer them.First, I am interested in the scale of the works that are required at Ardrossan and how that picture is changing. I appreciate that there is a moving picture on how much needs to happens there. As I understand it, the works to the Arran berth are a priority, but there are also options for the Irish berth and the wider port infrastructure. How will decisions on what works will be carried out at Ardrossan affect the wider programme of port improvements?I am particularly interested in the plans at Gasay and Lochboisdale, which are also linked to the procurement of the replacement Lord of the Isles. I am interested in the balance between the pipeline of vessel procurement and the associated port infrastructure that will need to be in place when the vessels come into service.Is there anything that you would like to add on that balance and the sequencing? What implications will investment in ports such as Ardrossan have on the pipeline and the plans for, for example, Gasay?

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

I reiterate that, as you say, the process in Ardrossan is still a moving picture. I alluded to some other ports where, in the past, the final costs have been significantly higher for a variety of reasons including market changes. If your question is about whether that has come at the expense of other port projects that have had to be delayed, the situation is a bit more nuanced than that. We would go back to ministers and look at the overall budget. Transport Scotland has a much larger budget than the ferries element alone, although that is substantial, and we would look at the matter in the round. There would not necessarily be a trade-offTo give a recent example, Port Ellen came in at £108 million, which was a higher figure than we anticipated. Does that mean that something else in the ferries programme has to stop or be slowed down? That is not something that we have had to do, and I would not envisage that necessarily being the case, particularly in relation to the two ports that you mentioned—Ardrossan and Gasay. Ministers are still very much committed to those projects, which are much needed given the age and life expectancy of Lochboisdale.I do not necessarily see there being a trade-off, but we will need to understand the costs of both projects. CMAL is still working through the final designs for Gasay, and the cost will be a factor.You mentioned LOTI. That procurement process is still ongoing. We still anticipate CMAL getting the tender returns in November, I think, and the contract being awarded by the end of the financial year. We are still on course with where we hope to be on that.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

I will pursue a point of clarity on the future status of CMAL. You touched on the move from it being a private company owned by the Scottish ministers to being an NDPB. I understand that that is still under review. Will that shift to an NDPB allow for the direct award? Is that the structure that would allow for that?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

As Chris Wilcock outlined, it will take us some of the way but we might need to make other changes to the governance to ensure that we have the required oversight of CMAL.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

So do you not know at the moment whether that is the structure?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

The answer is that we are working through it rather than that we do not know.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

Okay. What is your feeling at the moment? Do you think that further work will be required?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

Most likely.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

It is part of the way.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

Part of the way—so further work would be required.That links importantly to the timescale, which we heard would be six months maximum. That will be the crucial thing for what the yard and Ferguson’s anticipate and, importantly, for the island communities that are waiting for the vessels. The last time that you were at the committee, Chris Wilcock, we talked about the situation with the Sound of Harris ferry—the Loch Portain—and the urgency with which vessels are in need of replacement. We cannot lose sight of that in this process, too.Thank you for that clarity—I have no further questions.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

If you go beyond NDPB status, would that require legislation?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

No.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

You can still do it, so why do you not go the whole way?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

That is, in effect, what we plan on doing.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

Yes.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

What would that status be? What is the technical status?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

CMAL would still be an NDPB. I apologise if I have overly complicated the matter, but it has moved from being a public corporation to an NDPB because of the funding position and the requirement against the Office for National Statistics classification. The further adjustments to the governance that we would need to make CMAL Teckal compliant are part of that overall work stream.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

And that would not require legislation.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

No, it does not require legislation.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Thank you very much for answering those questions.I will move on to the Scottish zero emission bus challenge fund 3—ScotZEB3. I know that we cannot talk about the legal issues around the appeal to the Competition Appeal Tribunal from McGill’s Buses, but I want to talk about the consequences for the successful bidders. It has been indicated to them that they can carry on with their work. It will come to a point at which they will have to commit their own finance, and it is in the order of £118 million to match the £45 million from the ScotZEB3 funding. It will come to a point at which they have to press the button and they are nervous, so what confidence can you give them that the money will definitely be forthcoming no matter what happens?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

I am trying to walk a fine line here because it would be inappropriate for me to talk about live court proceedings, Mr Rennie. The issue that you have highlighted is real and we are in close discussion about it with the other parties to the legal action and those who were successful through the bid. We will have to work through that.The final thing that I would say on the matter is that the organisations that were successful through that bid are commercial entities in themselves and have to take their own decisions. It would not be appropriate for me to speak on their behalf.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

I do not think that that is enough.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

It is a difficult position for us all.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

I understand that, but that implies that there is a doubt over the £45 million.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

As I said, it is a difficult position for us all and I need to be really careful about commenting on live legal proceedings.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

But I am not asking you to comment on the live proceedings. I am asking you to comment on the confidence that you have that the £45 million will be committed, no matter what happens.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

As I said, it is a matter that affects us all. There are different decisions that different entities will take. We are in the middle of live court proceedings, and I do not think that it is appropriate—10:15

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

But that does not stop you from committing the £45 million no matter what happens. So, win or lose, is the £45 million on the table? Will it remain?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

The challenge that is currently in front of the Supreme Court is about the lawful basis on which that subsidy was pushed forward. Whichever side is successful in that, there are consequences for the other side. Again, I do not think it would be appropriate for me, or indeed ministers, to give the level of confidence that you are seeking, here and now, today.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

But it is not just that one side or the other loses; the Government can make a decision about that money being guaranteed no matter what happens.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

The Government has to act with a sound lawful basis.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Yes, of course—I am not suggesting otherwise. I am saying that, if I was a bus company—if I was Ember, Stagecoach, Rock Road, Lothian Buses or First—I would now be worried. I would think, “I’m going to wait and see,” and that would delay the whole project. If it delays the whole project, that slows down the decarbonisation of the bus network, so the consequences are significant.I think, therefore, that you need to provide the companies with more confidence. Whether it comes from you or from ministers, there needs to be more confidence that the £45 million is guaranteed no matter what happens, otherwise everything slows down.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

As I said, we are in the middle of live legal proceedings. Ministers have to act on a lawful basis. Ministers have been quite clear on their support for the bus sector in general, but I do not think that it is appropriate for me to go as far as you might want to go today.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Okay. I think that the bus companies need that confidence, and I would hope that you would reflect on that in your discussions with ministers.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

We engage with the bus companies on a fairly regular basis, so we are alive to that.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

I want to talk about the cost of infrastructure in the UK and, as part of that, in Scotland. On average, the UK pays 65 per cent more per unit of infrastructure than comparable countries. That translates to £8.3 billion a year being wasted due to spending failing to deliver equivalent infrastructure. We invest more and we get less back. Why do you think that is?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

Can you tell me where you are getting your statistics from?

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

That is from a report that was produced by the Centre for British Progress.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

It is not necessarily one that I am familiar with.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Do you recognise the point that it is more expensive to do business here?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

I recognise the general point, but I am not familiar with the figures that you have quoted.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Why do you think that it is the case?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

There are probably a number of broad reasons, which you will no doubt want to delve into.First, there is the size and scale of the construction market, in particular in Scotland, along with the lack of population density and the extent of remote and rural areas here. With regard to the scale of our transport budget, we are roughly 8 to 10 per cent of the English transport budget, so we are a smaller market. That is a factor.You will no doubt have read the same things that I have read about the amount of work involved on things like business cases and impact assessments and all the various necessary consents that we need to get in order to take forward an infrastructure project. You will no doubt have views on that, but I do not doubt that that plays into the general mix.There is also the overall general health and appetite of the economy, how good Scotland is as a place to do business and the general skills that are available. All those things play into it. Perhaps Lawrence Shackman has more to add.

Lawrence Shackman Transport Scotland
link

We have quite exacting health and safety standards in our construction industry, and, as a result, we have a very good record compared with countries that take a lesser stance on that sort of thing. We certainly care very much for our environment, so there are constraints to ensure that the disruption to the environment through our projects is minimised, and we use mitigations as much as possible, whether it is for animals, the landscape or the people who we are potentially affecting by our construction projects. We try to make sure that impacts are minimised.There are a lot of factors to consider, and, as Alison mentioned, we have quite an urban population compared with a lot of other countries across Europe, so there can be a lot of impacts on the environment and people. We have to ensure that we bring all those factors on board in our projects, which comes at a cost. We have more to pay for a good product, but, at the end of the day, we get a safer and higher standard of output.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

You have talked about the size and the scale of the construction market, and you will be aware of what the Civil Engineering Contractors Association Scotland has said. It was pretty scathing. I know that the contract has now changed, but CECA said:“The bespoke TS contract used to procure road projects is regarded as a dated, unattractive anomaly by the market. As a result, TS is regarded by CECA members across the UK as the worst client to work for in the UK.”I understand that you have changed the contract, but why did you ever allow it to get so outdated?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

Lawrence Shackman and I both gave evidence to the Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee on that matter.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Apologies, but I did not follow that. Laughter.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

Did you not? The committee produced a very good report that, I think, sets out the position fairly.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

I would point you to it as a good read.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

For the benefit of everybody else, give us a few sentences on it.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

Our contracts have always reflected the market as we have found it at the time. We had a particular issue around 2021 or 2022 with the Tomatin to Moy contract for the A9, when we were all just coming out of Covid and, speaking candidly, we were not in tune enough with the construction sector.I would prefer to talk about the position that we are currently in, as you would imagine.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

I know that you would, but I am quite keen to go back.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

Yes, I am sure that you are.I would point to the committee’s report as showing that, actually, we have done a lot of good work. David Macdonald from CECA is here to speak to you after we have gone, and we have done a lot of good work with CECA and the construction industry. We have completely and utterly transformed our contracts, and we have ensured that we have the right balance of risk between parties. We have done our utmost, and, so far, we have been successful in attracting good competition to the A9 contracts. All of that helps us.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

I appreciate that, and I appreciate your setting it out.My wider question is on your ability to detect changes in the market and the sector. It got to a crisis point at which you had no viable bidders for the Tomatin to Moy section of the A9 because you had loaded so much risk on to the contractor instead of the Government. You therefore had to go back, which set back the progress of the construction of the A9, which is already behind schedule. How confident are you that you have the antennae, assessment and expertise to be able to detect such changes in the future? These things are not easy, so how do you ensure that that never happens again?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

I am fairly optimistic and confident that we are in a very different position from the one that we were in.

Lawrence Shackman Transport Scotland
link

You are going to talk to David Macdonald later in the meeting. We regularly engage with CECA to talk about a host of issues, which are mainly to do with the road construction sector. In the past, we had a more adversarial—I should say risk-averse—style of contract in which the contractor took nearly all the risk of construction. At the same time, for many years, that gave the Scottish ministers more secure outturn costs. We kept outturn costs very much closer to tender costs—the outturn cost was typically within 3 per cent of the tender cost. That meant that, for many years, there was a lot of price surety for projects such as the Queensferry crossing and various other motorway improvement—

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

You are referring to the Aberdeen western peripheral route and the like.

Lawrence Shackman Transport Scotland
link

The market has changed, and contractors are not willing to accept that risk. That is largely to do with market conditions and the uncertainty that those bring. In around 2021-22, it took us a little bit by surprise that only one bidder put in a tender for the Tomatin to Moy section. That had happened in the distant past, when we had to do comparisons to make sure that the tender represented value for money, but, at that stage, it was very clear from discussions with the industry that companies were no longer prepared to tender for our contracts on that basis.As Alison Irvine mentioned, we had a huge market engagement exercise with CECA and many other contracting authorities, following which we moved to the new engineering contract, option A, which involves the payment of a lump sum. That places a lot more risk on Transport Scotland and the Scottish ministers but, in theory, it reduces the tender cost proportionately. We now have to manage a contract a lot more closely out on site. We work with the contractor to look at any events that occur, and we try to make sure that we agree on additional costs or time there and then as the contract continues.In recent times, we have been looking at the framework agreement for the five remaining sections of the A9, which is worth almost £2 billion. As you will have seen in the past few weeks, we put that out to market and we have announced that there are five bidding contractors for that framework. That gives us confidence not only that we have listened to contractors but that contractors are confident about bidding for our work. That framework will be finalised by the end of the year, and we will be ready to call off the first contract—the contract for Dalraddy to Slochd, which is probably the biggest section of the A9—from January onwards.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

My question is not about the specifics. My question is, if such a change happens again, how confident can you be that you will pick it up?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

It is a question of engagement.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Why did not you undertake such engagement before?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

In 2021, the world changed. That is genuinely what happened.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

But the signs were there in relation to the AWPR, were they not? The additional costs for that were hugely contentious. Surely that was a warning sign that you should have reacted and responded to by taking a different approach.

Lawrence Shackman Transport Scotland
link

That was more of a contractual issue.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Are you saying that that was completely different?

Lawrence Shackman Transport Scotland
link

Yes—

Lawrence Shackman Transport Scotland
link

That contract placed a lot more risk on the contractor. It was not, by any manner of means, one of the more modern contracts that we now put out to tender. It involved a different set of rules, if you like.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

And the contractors entered into that contract.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

In addition, the Carillion liquidation issues were associated with that.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

I get the sense that the way that you do things now means that you have a greater sense of what is happening and a better relationship with the sector, which should help to avoid similar events in the future. However, problems might not arise in the same way in the future. The issue is whether Transport Scotland has sufficient expertise to be able to detect such a change. However, we have probably covered that.10:30Let us move on to consultants. There is concern about the amount of money that we spend on consultants across the transport sector. That is not just about Transport Scotland; it is about local authorities as well. On the A9 dualling from Perth to Inverness, you have spent £261 million, with only 11 miles having been built so far. On the A96, you have spent £88 million, with nothing having been built. In total, that is £340 million spent on consultants. On buses, there was £500 million for the bus partnership fund, which ceased four years later. Of the £500 million, only just over £20 million was spent, but the vast bulk of that was spent on consultants. Why is it essential to spend so much money on consultants when we get very little in return?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

I would dispute that we get very little in return, but I would not dispute your overall point about how much money is spent on consultants. It would be helpful to give a couple of examples to explain the decision making on when to do that.In Transport Scotland, Lawrence Shackman leads our infrastructure projects team, which includes a significant number of qualified civil engineers, so we act as an intelligent client. However, when we are proceeding with the design and development of an infrastructure scheme such as the A9 or A96, we require a surge in the number of people who are employed to do the design, the stakeholder engagement—which helps us to minimise the likelihood of inquiries at a later date—and the environmental work et cetera. We use consultants to balance the resource allocation because it would not be appropriate for us to come into that.To get a project ready to build, which is the bit that really matters to people, we have to spend time going through all the design and development work, to come up with a robust cost estimate, understand the risks, support stakeholder engagement and do all those other things. It is our role, as the intelligent client, to make the best use of the resources that we have.Would I like to spend less money on consultants? Yes. Every time that we are looking at a contract or post, do we take the opportunity to take a view on whether it would be better done within the civil service? Yes, but that has to be done as part of the overall spectrum of managing resources across the piece. There is also the issue of specialist expertise, which we do not always have.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

This is not about Transport Scotland, but we have been told that ZetTrans, the Shetland Transport Partnership, commissioned a consultant to look into why people were not cycling in Shetland. The consultants came back and said, “It’s hilly, cold and wet,” which I think the partnership knew already. That is not your responsibility but, sometimes, across the transport world—that is just one example—it looks as if there is an addiction to employing consultants because of the fear of getting something wrong when, actually, decisions could easily be taken by the organisations.Across the transport world, not just within Transport Scotland—I am sure that you would not do a study into cycling in Shetland—could a significant change be made to eradicate those kinds of consultations and surveys and the use of consultants, to get better value for money?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

I will not comment on that example, but there is always a balance to be struck when giving people and communities that are impacted by something an opportunity to have their say. When we take any scheme through the design, development and construction process, people have views. Many MSPs write to me about the views of people in their constituencies. I think that it is right for people to get the opportunity to express their views. Whether that is proportionate and appropriate, though, is really a decision for the authority that is responsible for the individual thing that it has been tasked with delivering.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Right—I have concluded my questions. I call Collette Stevenson.

Collette Stevenson SNP East Kilbride
link

Thank you, convener, and a very warm welcome to our witnesses.I want to touch on workforce planning, apprenticeships and, alongside those issues, supply chain visibility. In your annual procurement report, you say that 832 new entrant positions, 63 apprenticeships and 172 graduate positions have been created. Do you track whether those positions lead to completed qualifications and sustained employment, including through subcontractors?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

That is a great question. I will turn to John MacIntyre to talk about our work in that respect and to draw out some of the measures and community benefits associated with our procurement.

John MacIntyre Transport Scotland
link

Our corporate procurement strategy has various different enablers and objectives, one of which is about sustainable procurement and community benefits. The figures that you have just read out are for the financial year 2024-25; we are just putting together our figures for the financial year just past, and we hope that they will, indeed, show an increase.To get the figures, we go around our different suppliers. Generally, at any one time, Transport Scotland will have about 250 contracts in place, some of which will include community benefits and some of which will not, simply because the type of work that we are procuring is not suitable for that. We track the figures year by year and report them annually as a combined figure.Some of our schemes have more longevity—I am thinking of the A9 design scheme, for example, which has been going on for a long time. It has resulted in a very good initiative called academy 9, on which our design consultants and other stakeholders have done a lot of work. They go into schools and basically enthuse children—we hope—and older people about science, technology, engineering and mathematics, or STEM, activities. We track the figures for academy 9. With other schemes—say, a piece of work that lasts for a shorter time—we might still get community benefits, perhaps in the form of school visits, but those benefits will last only for the course of the particular contract.

Collette Stevenson SNP East Kilbride
link

So, there is no actual register of the jobs that come through, particularly with regard to the 63 apprenticeship posts. Where do the posts stem from? Do you keep a register of tier 1 contractors that subcontract down?

John MacIntyre Transport Scotland
link

Indeed. Every year, we collect statistics for our annual procurement report, which reports on our progress against our annual corporate procurement strategy. At the same time, we get figures from our tier 1 suppliers, and we ask them for information about their subcontractors, too. We do collect that information.

Collette Stevenson SNP East Kilbride
link

Do you keep a register of that? I would suggest that, elsewhere in the UK, compared to your approach, there does not seem to be necessarily more transparency—I would not say that there is—but there is a requirement, under the Procurement Act 2023, to keep a lot of information. Do you just have such a register, too, or are you willing to produce one? Basically, it follows the public pound for every procurement contract, from tier 1 right down to the subcontractors.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

We publish an annual procurement report, as you have heard, but I think that you are asking whether we track those 63 apprenticeships and where those people go—is that right?

Collette Stevenson SNP East Kilbride
link

There are multiple aspects to that, from, as you mentioned, visibility to the community benefits arising from apprenticeships and employability. Do you keep such a record, or would you be willing to set up a register for the public to look at?

John MacIntyre Transport Scotland
link

At present, we do not have such a register. We publish our statistics annually in our annual procurement report. However, I am aware of the type of thing that you are talking about. In other parts of the UK, as well as in Scotland, some contracting authorities take the approach of monetising their community benefits. Scottish Government advice, which we follow, has always been not to monetise community benefits, because doing so can sometimes be a little misleading, so that is not a route that we have gone down.

Collette Stevenson SNP East Kilbride
link

Do you think that, from a transparency point of view, that is something that the public would like to see?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

Perhaps we can look into that. We will take that away and look at what is done in other parts of the country, to see whether there is a way in which we can increase transparency, as that would be a good thing to do.The other thing that I would flag is that the contracts that we issue every year—we are talking about significant sums of money—provide direct employment for a lot of people beyond the 63 apprentices, the 172 graduate positions and all the rest of it. There is a much wider piece about how the spend that we are responsible for supports people to live in great places, live good lives and have fulfilling careers across the country.It is a matter of getting the proportionality right in terms of gathering the information that people want in a way that makes sense, so that we can stand behind that information and identify where we can improve it. There are always ways in which we can improve.

Collette Stevenson SNP East Kilbride
link

From a constituency MSP’s perspective, it would be useful to be able to promote the fact that small and medium-sized enterprises are taking on apprenticeships. It would be useful for that to be transparent and to be able to see the trail that that creates.

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

That is something that we can take away.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

Following on from Collette’s line of questioning, the creation of new entrant positions and apprenticeships as a community benefit sounds good. I am interested in how you ensure additionality. How do you ensure that these are not positions that would already have been created through the project? How do you build that into your procurement?

Alison Irvine Transport Scotland
link

That is another good question. If the Government spends money on one transport project, it creates jobs. If the Government spends money on education, that also creates jobs. You start to get into really complex assessments, which is why we try to be confident about the figures that we publish, so that we can stand behind them, without worrying about the additionality piece. Maybe what I am saying means that we are talking at cross-purposes—sorry.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

You are saying that community benefits are an important part of your procurement approach and strategy. The procurement report highlights the creation of jobs and apprenticeships as a community benefit. If that is really a community benefit, it cannot simply be the same as employment that is generated through other forms of infrastructure development, such as renewable energy projects. I am not conflating the two; community benefit is different from simply delivering a project.What you are pointing to as a community benefit is the creation of those jobs and apprenticeships. To me, a community benefit must be additional to the delivery of a project that you would have undertaken anyway.10:45

Lawrence Shackman Transport Scotland
link

The community benefits element is a major part of the quality score when we look at tenders. It is an opportunity for a contractor or supplier to add, as part of the tender process, extra things that they intend to deliver during construction or during the service delivery. This is going back a few years, but on the Queensferry crossing, for example, a specific number of graduate places was asked for in the contract and contractors who offered further places gained bonus points in the scoring of that contract. It is about that additionality during the tender assessment phase of a project and then, obviously, about ensuring that that is tracked through the delivery of the contract.There is additionality there. Obviously, community benefits cover a whole raft of things, including contributions to local funds or community initiatives such as storage areas.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

I am interested in that point about the other stuff that communities might need from projects. I spend a bit of time going up and down the A9 and big projects are on the go there, with large amounts of kit and resources that are not always fully used. How they use their resources and deploy their equipment is obviously up to the contractors, but at the procurement stage in such a big project, what opportunities could there be? What engagement do you have with, for example, local community groups or even local authorities about projects that they might be looking to undertake in and around that area? When you have a massive project that is bringing in a lot of resources and equipment, what are the opportunities to do some other additional projects alongside it? Would you consider something like that or is that not possible?

Lawrence Shackman Transport Scotland
link

It is certainly considered as part of the project but it is really very much for the contractor to take that initiative. Obviously, it is in their interest to put in that additionality and ensure that they can deliver on what they put into their tender in order to be able to win it.You are right: it covers a spectrum of things, such as generating employment in the local area, talking to the local communities about potential supply chain opportunities, working with schools and colleges for educational purposes, and trying to minimise environmental impacts as much as possible. They might suggest that they will do supplementary planting outside the limits of the site, for example, which only the contractor can do—we could not, in a contract, plant outside the limits of a site that we had statutorily purchased. It is up to the contractor to go out to the communities, see what opportunities there are, reflect that in their contract and then ensure that that gets delivered through the construction or the supply.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

Do you have any good examples of where physical works have happened outside of a contract?

Lawrence Shackman Transport Scotland
link

I do not have it in front of me but there are numerous examples in the annual procurement report of what has happened on previous contracts and what is being delivered at the moment on the A9.

John MacIntyre Transport Scotland
link

I could maybe chip in on that. As Lawrence described, as part of the procurement process for the A9 schemes, when the procurement goes out, we flag to suppliers any community benefits that we have identified as being required in or helpful to the community. The bidders get a chance to supplement that as well, and that comes back as part of the bid when it is assessed.A practical example on the A9 was the Luncarty to Pass of Birnam project. The contractor proposed a men’s shed initiative, which folk from the local community would come along to; it then put in that facility, which was welcomed. There are fundraising initiatives as well on a lot of our construction projects. On the Luncarty to Pass of Birnam project, the contractor also employed veterans through project resettlement, education, community, construction, employment—RECCE. Those are all worthwhile initiatives that would perhaps not normally be recorded as part of our construction projects. Going through a more formal process to allow contractors to offer those things allows us to monitor the contracts and ensure that they are delivered.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

Chris Wilcock, do you have anything to add on that? When ports infrastructure is being put in place, there will always be opportunities for other users. A lot of community engagement is involved in the port projects, but does anything in particular jump out at you on this question?

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

You are right that there are a lot of opportunities for people to engage on the ports projects. That is usually on what would be helpful and sometimes on the detail of more localised matters such as lorry parking, particular drop-off points or how different elements interact.CMAL’s contractors have done certain things, including a mini version of the engagement with schools, so there have been opportunities in that regard. In relation to the Islay class vessel contracts, match funding came from the yard to CMAL’s corporate social responsibility fund in order to fund projects in communities where the vessels are going to serve. On the small vessel replacement programme phase 1 project, opportunities were given to graduates and apprentices. I am not sure what the take-up of that was, but those are the sorts of things that have been built into those projects.

  1. 08:15 Civil Aviation (Consumer Protection and Regulatory Reform) Bill Bill debate · 28
  2. 08:15 Procurement Evidence session · 385

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.