Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Programme for Government

Wednesday 9 September 2026 Transport Committee About 08:15 Evidence session 342 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

342 contributions · showing 1–200
Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Good morning, and welcome to the fourth meeting in 2026 of the Transport Committee. We have received no apologies. The first item on our agenda is an evidence session on the Scottish Government’s programme for government, which was published last week.I welcome the Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Tourism and Transport, Stephen Flynn, who is joined by officials from Transport Scotland: Fiona Brown, director of strategy, performance and analysis; Mary Docherty, director of bus, concessionary and active travel; and Chris Wilcock, director of ferries.The cabinet secretary will say a few words to open the evidence session.

Stephen Flynn SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Tourism and Transport · Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Good morning. I congratulate committee members on their appointments to such a prestigious committee, which I am sure will hold my feet to the fire during the coming months and, hopefully, years.The past few months have been an interesting period for me as an individual, because I have had to make a fairly significant transition between Parliaments and make time to try to scrutinise everything that has been going on under the bonnet in transport at the Scottish Government in order to deliver on the commitments that we made to the Scottish people at the election.Throughout that time, I have been very fortunate to be ably supported by wonderful colleagues and officials in Transport Scotland and across the various agencies that are associated with the transport sector. I have also had the opportunity to go out and speak to the public across Scotland and hear their concerns directly, which was incredibly important.The first place I went to was Uist, in the Western Isles, because I was very conscious of the obvious and clear challenges that communities face there. I did not stop there. I have been up to Fort William, down to the A83, to Cairnryan, and on the A75 and the A77. I also drive the A96 regularly.I have had the good fortune of speaking with stakeholders right across Scotland. However, the most important stakeholders I have spoken to are members of the public who are directly impacted by the various schemes that they want to see improved, which I am sure we will touch on today.I am conscious that this is the first opportunity that we have had to engage with each other, and I want it to be a bit of a scene setter, because I want to be as constructive as I possibly can with all of you. Having come from another Parliament and having previously sat on a committee, I recognise how important committees are to the good processes that a Parliament has, and their role in holding the Government to account.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Thank you very much. We all have lots of questions—I think that Lloyd Melville has enough questions to occupy the whole two and a half hours.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

That does not surprise me.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

We would like concise questions and answers, so that everybody gets an opportunity to ask their questions. We know that you will be back, at a future session, so we do not have to cover absolutely everything today, but we will try to cover a wide range of areas.I will start off. What is wrong with Transport Scotland?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

What are you implying, Mr Rennie? Are you alluding to the fact that it is our intention to bring Transport Scotland back into Government?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

The reality is that, considering public sector reform as a whole, we all recognise that the public sector landscape is cluttered. That was spoken about in great depth during the course of the election.In that context, it is important that we deliver on our manifesto commitment—which the public voted us in on—to bring Transport Scotland in-house. That work has begun. Transport Scotland now sits within the director general economy’s remit, and I expect that the work will be completed roughly by the turn of the financial year.What I am about to say is not a criticism of anyone, so please do not take it that way. It is important that we look across all our organisations to ensure that we have direct accountability in Government, and that sits with ministers. It is important that we are able to deliver the schemes that we want to deliver within the timeframes that we would like, but also that we streamline all our approaches in the context of wider public sector reform. Taking all those things together, it feels necessary to bring Transport Scotland in-house, and that is exactly what we will do.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Therefore, there is nothing wrong with Transport Scotland in itself or in the way that it operates and functions.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I do not seek to criticise—you would not expect me to, and I do not feel the need to.This has been a bit of an education for me over the past few months—you will forgive me in that regard. I have been wonderfully supported by Alison Irvine, who unfortunately cannot be here today, and by people such as Mary Docherty, who has done an absolutely phenomenal job. We were able to work with bus operators to get the £2 fare cap over the line within the 100-days commitment. I feel as though I spoke to Chris Wilcock on an almost daily basis about the situation in the Cemre shipyard a few weeks ago, and Fiona Brown is never too far away.The team has been wonderful in supporting me over the past months, and I am incredibly proud of the work they have done. That is not to say that we should not seek, as part of the wider public sector reform work, to ensure that there is direct accountability with ministers, which bringing TS back in-house does. I think that all parties would welcome that.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

This is no personal slight to those in the room. This is uncomfortable questioning, but it is important, when you are making what is apparently such a significant change, that we understand the reasons behind it. Will there be job losses? Will money be saved? Is that part of the motivation?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

That is not part of my motivation. The Government’s motivation in this regard is to ensure that we can get on and deliver the commitments that we made to the public. It is worth re-emphasising that we had an election just a few months ago and that this was a key part of our manifesto. It featured in the prospectus that we put to the Scottish people, who returned us to office on the premise of our bringing Transport Scotland back in-house. Forgive me for being a little old-fashioned, but I think that it is probably time that we got on and met the expectations of the promises that we made to the public.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

I am not sure that I heard about that issue much on doorsteps in north-east Fife—

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

You need to chap more doors, then.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

—but I take the point that it was in the manifesto. Let me turn the question the other way round: if you are making a change—change involves costs and effort—what are the tangible benefits of bringing Transport Scotland in-house?You have talked about streamlining and accountability. We assume that you were accountable for the whole transport system anyway—we certainly blamed you for it, so we assume that you are accountable for it. Let me give you some examples. The structure of the transport system has been criticised for a lack of transparency, and the predecessor committee was very critical of the information that it was provided with at different moments, so will the system be more open as a result of this change?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I have sought to do this in my time in Parliament up to now, and I extend this commitment to almost all members of the committee: if members seek transparency in relation to certain issues, all they have to do is come to speak to me, and I will make sure that my officials are in a position to sit down with them and have those discussions. If you do not feel that you are getting accurate answers to the issues that concern you, I give you a personal commitment that I will ensure that that happens, Mr Rennie.However, on your wider point, which you just referred back to, about the motivation for bringing things in-house, doing so does not have to mean that there is inherent criticism of something; it can come from a starting point of trying to make things better and ensuring that the line of sight, accountability and delivery sit with the ministerial direction that I seek to give.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

I understand that, but a lot of us are wondering what that is all about, because it is branded as public service reform, but it seems like just a name change. We want to understand whether it comes with a change of character. Let me give you another example: there has often been criticism that the processes, particularly in relation to rail development, seem to be taking for ever. They are overly bureaucratic, and we never get to a decision point. Nobody ever says no, and nobody is ever clear about it. Is that going to change?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I have been a politician for a long time. There are certain things that I have contacted the Government about that I wish could have been done. I am sure that, given your distinguished long service across two parliamentary sessions, you will have done likewise.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Charm will not get you anywhere.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

It will. Laughter. I will keep trying; I have been told to be nice. I am joking.I guess that we all get frustrated when it feels as though things are just pushed into the long grass. Some of it comes down to the fact that, often, it can be politically uncomfortable to make decisions. It is sometimes about the length of time that it takes to reach decisions, because of the various steps that officials need to go through before they can offer clear, tangible advice for ministers to respond to.My point is that, when TS comes in-house, there will be a direct line of ministerial responsibility—there is no hiding away from that. After that has happened, I expect that I will be able to offer you the clarity that you seek at committee meetings about any concerns with individual projects. I am sure that we will come on to that over the next couple of hours.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

All that sounds great—it sounds positive, open, transparent, swift, and lacking in bureaucracy. However, the most important thing is that I do not know how long you will be the cabinet secretary responsible for transport—I am not predicting your demise.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I am trying to be nice to you, and that is how you respond. Laughter.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

When you are no longer in post, the big question is about whether those characteristics will remain. I am struggling to understand that.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I say that on the basis of the culture that I have worked in under the First Minister. He has been clear with me and everyone—rightly so—that we must be as open as we possibly can be with parliamentarians. I was heartened to hear that, and I expected nothing less. Having been a member of the United Kingdom Parliament, particularly in opposition, I was sometimes incredibly frustrated with a lack of clarity from Government. I do not want to be a part of that; I want to see it change. I am happy to be as open and transparent as I possibly can be with you. It is a cultural issue, convener.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

To summarise, there will be no job losses and no massive savings. It is about accountability and streamlining, and we will see a change of character through your leadership.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I would not seek to accept the premise of everything that you have said, on the basis that, when things are brought together, there is natural attrition—that happens in every organisation. The motivation for the change was not about job cuts or making savings but about delivery for the public.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

That is not quite a no. Are you saying that there will be job cuts as a by-product of the change?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I am saying that, at this stage, it would be remiss of me to state that there would or would not be job cuts. I am trying to be as clear as I can be, bearing in mind everything that I have just said, but the work has only just got under way. Inevitably, there will be a conflict between some people’s current roles and the roles that exist within the Government. We will need to respond to that accordingly as part of the wider PSR piece. You know the principles that exist in Government when it comes to such issues.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

We look forward to the new dawn with the structure.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

It has already begun, convener.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Thank you for answering my questions on that. We will move on to the railways.

Collette Stevenson SNP East Kilbride
link

I extend a warm welcome to the cabinet secretary and his officials. The programme for government commits only to supporting progress on the Clyde metro. What precisely will the Scottish Government deliver during this parliamentary session? What funding has been allocated to the project? When will communities such as East Kilbride see a defined route, a business case and a deliverable timetable?09:30

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I was just double checking a point with my official, convener, to make sure that I am as open and transparent with the committee as I can possibly be.The Glasgow city region deal has a crucial role to play. If I recall correctly, the Clyde metro is one of three projects across Scotland of a similar scale and size that we are seeking to deliver. It is perhaps attracting significant levels of public attention, and rightly so.Through the city region deal, we are committed to working with partners to progress the project. I am not going to sit here and say that there is a blank cheque when it comes to such matters, because it would be very silly of me to do so; however, through the structures that exist—the officials and the city region deal—we will make sure that there is full communication and partnership working in order to make progress. I imagine that this will be exciting to many people in the local area.

Collette Stevenson SNP East Kilbride
link

You are saying that the project will ultimately come down to the city region deal, but can you confirm whether East Kilbride remains in the first phase of the Clyde metro development? Can you identify any specific work that will be completed by 2031?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

We are maybe jumping a bit ahead of where things are in respect of delivery and the impact that it would have on East Kilbride directly. I can certainly seek to ensure that the partners that are involved give you such clarity as soon as possible. I would not want us to get ahead of ourselves in respect of East Kilbride’s involvement in that context.

Collette Stevenson SNP East Kilbride
link

You touched on the partners. Who is ultimately accountable for delivering the Clyde metro? Is it the Scottish Government, Transport Scotland or Strathclyde Partnership for Transport? Are there any others involved?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I will be pretty candid—I think that we all have a responsibility to deliver big infrastructure projects. I do not think that it is for one individual to outline exactly what they want to happen, particularly when we are talking about something of such a scale. The cross-partnership working that exists in the region will be absolutely crucial to delivery.

Collette Stevenson SNP East Kilbride
link

I will move on to electrification. As you probably know, we have two fantastic new railway stations in East Kilbride, and work is under way on the electrification of the line. There has been quite a lot of disruption for passengers due to the electrification, and the replacement trains are not due to arrive until the 2030s. What improvements will there be at East Kilbride and Hairmyres for passengers?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

That is a helpful question, because we have made progress over the past few weeks with the procurement process for the trains. I think that everyone who has been on the train service in the area would acknowledge that the trains are not necessarily to the standard that we would hope them to be. That work is very much under way. I am conscious that the ScotRail fleet is older than it should be and than we want it to be. That is why we are procuring new trains in the west and are seeking to refurbish the class 222s, I believe it is, in the north-east, so that customers get the quality of journey that they deserve for the money that they are putting in.We proactively nationalised the ScotRail service. We are seeing the benefits from doing that and have been able to make some pretty swift decisions on peak fares and other things, which have been welcomed by the public. What comes next is making sure that the fleet is to the standard that people expect. We are very much committed to the timelines that we have already outlined.

Zen Ghani SNP Glasgow Cathcart and Pollok
link

I thank the cabinet secretary and his officials for coming today. I will pick up from where Collette Stevenson ended her questions on railways. Is there a timeline for completing the electrification of Scotland’s railway system?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

For the whole of Scotland?

Zen Ghani SNP Glasgow Cathcart and Pollok
link

Yes—the whole of Scotland.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I will be candid that I do not have that timeline in my head. The electrification of the entire network is a hotly debated issue in my part of the world. If I recall correctly, we are still using diesel trains because of the significant challenges that exist in electrifying the railways on the various bridges that exist on the route across the east coast. That situation will not and cannot be resolved without making significant investment in public infrastructure, which would take an incredibly long time to deliver. Therefore, I do not have a definitive date in my head as to when that work would conclude.However, progress is being made in relation to electrification, and Fife provides a positive example of the work that has been undertaken. I would certainly like to get to a position over this parliamentary session and—I assume—parliamentary sessions to come of being able to commit to the improvements in infrastructure that will allow us to provide the service that the public require while reducing our emissions, because we have a responsibility to do that.

Zen Ghani SNP Glasgow Cathcart and Pollok
link

Are there plans to further expand electrification in the central belt and Glasgow and improve the network with regard to its availability for the public?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I have had communication from some MSPs about their ideas for the city and region that you are talking about. There are technical challenges in relation to those ideas, and there are cost challenges, too. However, if there are specific proposals that you or other members have a particular interest in and would like to bring forward, I give you a commitment that we will take those proposals away and look at them in a bit more detail.

Zen Ghani SNP Glasgow Cathcart and Pollok
link

Great—thanks for that. I will move on to Great British railways, which has been talked about a lot recently. Do you have an update on discussions with the United Kingdom Government about the memorandum of understanding? How have discussions with the new Government and your UK counterpart been in general?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

One of the early conversations that I had was in Westminster with Lord Hendy, who is taking the Railways Bill through the House of Lords for the UK Government. I was incredibly heartened by the positive language that he used in respect to Scotland’s rail network, which is a testament to the work that officials have done over many years to improve standards. There is always work to do on punctuality and reliability, but that was a nice thing to hear.However, I have some concerns about the MOU and what the partnership will look like going forward. We have not yet been able to make a decision because we do not know what the corporate structure of GBR will be, and it would be remiss of us to move into that space without knowing that.What has become apparent during the parliamentary process in Westminster is that, until such point as you are regarded as being part of GBR passenger services, there is not necessarily a guarantee that you will be able to access the benefits of that. That becomes an issue if you go into a partnership, because you would want that to be on an equal basis—you would want it to be 50:50—but it looks as though the legislation, as drafted, would prevent us from having the benefits unless we accepted a proposal whereby we do not have majority ownership and there is a 51:49 scenario.I am reluctant to say that that is my preferred outcome at the moment. It is important that the United Kingdom Government responds to the concerns that I have expressed to it in writing, and I have no doubt that it will. When it does so, the UK Government must be cognisant of the fact that the Prime Minister himself has been very clear with the public about pushing power out of Westminster.I would like to see Scotland’s rail entirely in Scotland’s hands. That would be the starting point for the conversation that I want to have, but if the UK Government is not willing to do that at this juncture, it needs to be willing to accept a 50:50 partnership for the reasons that I have outlined.

Zen Ghani SNP Glasgow Cathcart and Pollok
link

Do you have any additional concerns about GBR, if the UK Government continues to push for that current status? Is there any likelihood that that will change, or is anything likely to be done to make the situation easier?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I do have other concerns. I do not want the committee to get the impression that there has not been a lot of really positive working going on, because there has been. Forgive me for focusing on the negatives a bit, but it is important to highlight what the Scottish Government’s current issues are.I will read from the letter that I sent to Heidi Alexander:“There is now no scenario in which Scotland would have a fully integrated rail body from GBR access date, and therefore no way in which Scottish passenger services could be brought within the definition of GBR passenger services”,which of course impacts our ability to have the access benefits that GBR is meant to provide for customers. That can change only if the UK Government is willing to be more flexible with its legislation, and I would certainly encourage it to be so. I have set that out in a very detailed letter to the secretary of state, and I look forward to an early response.Convener, to go back to your earlier point about how open and transparent I want to be with the Parliament, I hope that that gives you an insight into the discussions that I am having with the UK Government on what is an incredibly important issue for Scotland’s railways.

Zen Ghani SNP Glasgow Cathcart and Pollok
link

The issue of railways and improving services across the country regularly comes up on the doors.I will move on to ask about national smart ticketing. Do you envisage that changing the status of the national smart ticketing advisory board will help to speed up the delivery? You have already said publicly that smart ticketing will be delivered by 2031.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

It will be delivered by 2031. It is important that we look at whether that can happen, which is why we have outlined the steps that we are seeking to take.Let me reassure the committee that, having spent six and a half years living half the week in London, I find it moderately frustrating, to say the least, that, at the moment, passengers cannot move freely between different forms of transport and different companies that offer that transport—whether that transport is in public ownership, as is the case in Edinburgh and with our rail networks, or in the private sector—and use one card, with the total cost being accrued.We can and must do better in that regard. I am keen for that change to happen, because it would be transformative for how our transport system is delivered, and it would ensure that it is financially sustainable into the future. It opens up a multitude of doors in relation to ticketing across Scotland and how we charge for journeys.09:45

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Why has that not happened already? Why did the task force—the group that you had—make no progress for years?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

If I may be so brash as to say this, I do not know, because I was not here. What I can give—

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Honestly, you cannot say that.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

One Government has been in power for 19 years.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

You have responsibility for the decisions that predecessors took as well.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

You cannot just say that you do not know. You must know.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

You have asked me to be candid with you. I am not as familiar with the work undertaken by the national smart ticketing advisory board as I perhaps will be in the coming months, and as my predecessors were, as they were in post for many years, but I can give you a commitment to ensuring that the outcome that I want to be delivered will be delivered. That is where my focus lies.I appreciate that there will be many instances where people rightly seek to delve into the detail of what has happened over the course of many years, but I will be transparent with you about being accountable for the actions that I take in this post.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Can any of your colleagues give any insight as to why that work has not progressed?

Mary Docherty Transport Scotland
link

The national smart ticketing advisory board is purely that: it is an advisory body. It comprises experts from across the industry, as well as transport operators. It involves a hugely technical piece of work, which we should not underestimate. It is examining the difference between smart ticketing and smart payment.We are considering the art of the possible. I am a member of that board, representing the concessionary travel scheme. A significant amount of research has been undertaken, and a standards and technology advisory report—or STAR—was produced, outlining the route map as we go forward to deliver on smart and integrated ticketing payment across the country.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

It will be before that.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

I want to touch on two points: new stations and services on our railways. On the first point, can you give us an update on progress on a new Winchburgh station? It was in the budget for 2026-27, in which the Scottish Government made a commitment, saying:“working with partners, we will ensure a new station at Winchburgh is delivered.”However, that was not in the programme for government. What is happening there?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

There is a scenario where we cannot have an exhaustive list in the PFG of what the Government is seeking to do. As I am sure members will understand, that is for very obvious reasons; otherwise, it would run to quite a number of pages.The commitment to Winchburgh stands. A significant amount of work has been undertaken to date, and I am awaiting advice from officials in respect of the next stages. Local members have asked me a number of questions on the matter in the chamber, which is right and proper. As soon as I can outline the next steps to them, I will do so.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

Do you expect to see movement on that in this year’s budget?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Do you mean in the current year’s budget?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

That will be dependent on the advice that I receive from officials.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I expect to get it imminently. That is what I said to Parliament when I was asked questions on the issue previously by two of the local members, including the constituency MSP for the area, Pauline Stafford.Our commitment to deliver the station is cast iron. It is in the manifesto, and we will seek to do it. As soon as I have the ability to update members on the next steps, I will.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

Okay—that is pretty clear.I want to ask about Sunday services, which are hit and miss, particularly in certain small communities. For instance, the frequency of rail services in Monifieth, in my constituency, has massively increased during the past eight years, which is good, but there are still no services on a Sunday. I appreciate that there will be staffing issues, and that that is a matter for ScotRail, but does the Government have any expectation as to when Sunday services might become the norm for small communities?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

You were right to touch on the fact that this is not simple. We want services to run on a Sunday, and therefore they are going to run. The issue will require significant engagement between ScotRail and its staff and the unions. We have had a significant upturn in the number of Sunday services, which is welcome, and the announcements on passenger numbers that have been made during recent weeks and months reflect that.I would like to get to a position in which people are served based on their expectations, and I know that colleagues in ScotRail have the same desire, because that would benefit us all. It would benefit users, and the company would benefit from the additional revenue that it can secure. To build on my point about the increase in Sunday services, we had our busiest Sunday in the not-too-distant past, which is a reflection of the changes that have been made to date and the progress that is to come.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

I appreciate that. However, I am aware that discussions took place between my predecessor, Graeme Dey, and ScotRail for a period of years, and there has still been no progress for that community—my constituents in Monifieth—who have been asking for Sunday services for a long time. Do you not have a timeline for when the discussions are likely to conclude? Are the discussions between ScotRail, the Government and the unions ongoing?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

It is not for me to get into the middle of the discussions that ScotRail has with its staff. It is right and proper that it seeks to do that through the proper channels.I go back to my previous point, which is that we have seen significant progress to date. We have recently had our busiest Sundays, based on passenger numbers. We want to see more people on the railways, and we will do everything that we can to facilitate that.We have to be realistic, because the plans involve individuals, their contracts and the ability to ensure that we staff trains. We are also doing so in a way that ensures that the public purse is being protected. There are many considerations, but I am pleased by the progress that has been made, and I hope that we can build on it in the months to come.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I am sure that you will.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

If members will forgive me, I am going to jump forward to talk about ferries, and we will come back to buses later.Cabinet secretary, you will have seen the report on the BBC this morning about a faulty valve that led to the release of uncontrolled gas on the Glen Sannox. That incident happened last year. In the spirit of transparency and openness, why are we only finding out now?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

First, it is important for me to outline that I have heard directly from the communities in the Western Isles, and I am not happy with the way that ferry services were in the past. I know that a variety of issues impact individual ferries. I get a list of them, and they come into my inbox far too frequently, because of the age of the fleet.On the specific issue to which you refer, I would want to ensure that you have the full response that you deserve, and I will make sure that that is provided to you.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Have you been given a briefing on it?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Do you mean in relation to the news story this morning?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

No—unless I have missed it.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

You are just finding out today about an incident that happened last year. Were you not given a briefing over the summer that the incident had happened?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Well, I was not here last year.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Were you not briefed over the summer?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

As part of the wide array of information that is shared with me in respect of ferry issues, it may well have been the case that, over the summer, something that happened prior to my entering Parliament and taking on a Government position was conveyed to me. I would not want to mislead the committee. However, the specific news story to which you are referring is one that I would have to go and familiarise myself with. I was not listening to or watching the BBC this morning.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Last year, when 82 passengers were on the boat, there was an incident potentially threatening their safety, but that was not brought to your attention. It was on the very new ship that has been built, the MV Glen Sannox.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I do not want to convey to the committee something that would suggest that I have a level of detail that I can apprise you of.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

This is significant. It involved flammable gas.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Yes. I hear what you are saying.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

We are talking about significant volumes of flammable gas and 82 passengers on a boat that was built at Ferguson’s, which has been troubled for some time. That was not brought to your attention; you found out about it only this morning. In fact, you have not seen the news this morning and so, even now, you are not familiar with it.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I did not see the news because I was FaceTiming my kids, but that is a different matter. I will make sure that, subsequent to this committee meeting, you get the information that you deserve in that regard.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Do you understand our concerns?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I do understand your concerns, convener.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

You gave a commitment at the beginning about transparency and openness. On the news today, we discover information about an incident that happened last year. We are only just finding out now that there was a risk to 82 passengers on one of the newest boats in the fleet. Surely that is unacceptable and cannot happen again.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

If there is a situation that poses a threat to the public and I am the minister with responsibility—I am speculating here, because I need to go and look at the detail in a little bit more depth—I will ensure that the public and the committee are fully aware of that.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

I am sorry to emphasise this, but it was described as a “critical failure”. There were problems identified with the valves previously and that was not passed to CalMac. There has obviously been a communication issue in relation to the new boat.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

I wonder whether Chris Wilcock can help us with this.

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

I do not have the full details of that in front of me just now.I have seen the report. CalMac handles a lot of things very much in an operational space. As the cabinet secretary has said, I would want to get you an explanation. I understand the language that was used in that report. However, I would be cautious and I would want to see more detail from CalMac on the risk and threat and how that has been articulated, to see what space that was in.The report points out that CalMac has noted that procedural lessons have been learned from the incident. I do not want to underplay the committee’s concerns, but I want to fully understand the detail and have that explanation submitted.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Your title is director of ferries, but you cannot give us a full explanation as to what happened and how it will be resolved.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Let me be as candid as to say that I share your frustration in this regard. I give you a commitment that I will make sure that you are apprised in relation to your concerns subsequent to this committee meeting.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

The report this morning said that enough methane gas was released to fill a four-bedroom house. That is a lot of gas. Methane is a by-product of liquefied natural gas. The Glen Sannox was designed to run on diesel and LNG, and we knew all along that methane was a by-product. Methane is a greenhouse gas, so it is not very green, but the ferry was designed that way.My concern—I think that it is also the convener’s concern—is that the Scottish Government does not appear to have been told about the incident.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Mr Simpson, you are drawing a conclusion that might not reflect the reality of the situation. I apologise for not watching the news this morning—that is very much on me—but I will make sure that you get the full details.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

You said that you did not know about the incident, and Mr Wilcock did not know about it. I assume, therefore, that the Government was not informed, as neither of you knew about it.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I have told the committee what I can in relation to that situation at the moment. I will seek to ensure that you have the full details that you very much deserve subsequent to the meeting’s conclusion.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

I have to say that this is not a good start. There has been significant commentary on the incident from a number of organisations, and the only people who are not commenting are those in the Scottish Government. We, and passengers, deserve better than that. I hope that this is not the start of the way that things will be. I hope that the approach will be different in future.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Another incident that was reported in The Herald involved a 40-year-old ferry, the Loch Linnhe, running aground. It did not have a journey plan, although it should have done, and it ran aground and needed significant repairs. In fact, it should have been written off. One shipyard that was asked to give a price said, “We’re not going to touch this. We don’t want to know—it’s too risky.” Despite the ferry being valued at just over £200,000 at the time, CalMac or Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd—I do not know which one—decided to go ahead with a £1 million repair job on the ferry. Were you aware of that?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Yes. I have read the same news story that you have.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Have you been briefed about it?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

It will have been part of the various correspondence that came into my inbox in recent months.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

You have not really been briefed about it. You might have received an email, but you have not been briefed.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Can you tell us more about it?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I think that Mr Simpson has given a fairly rounded view of what is in the public domain.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Blimey. I am not here to inform people, but there we go.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

I thank the cabinet secretary and his officials for joining us. I share the concerns that have been raised about lines of communication between CalMac and the Government. I think that the committee would appreciate further information on that—we look forward to receiving that in writing afterwards.I will pick up on some points on the Sound of Harris service. Cabinet secretary, you were in the chamber yesterday when I went into a bit of detail on the situation regarding the MV Loch Portain. Do you have any reflections on what has happened over the summer? The situation began in the spring, when the vessel was out of action being re-engined. It then came back into service, only to be pulled off again. It now looks as though some pretty significant further works need to be carried out on the vessel, and it will not be returning soon, certainly not until after the summer timetable has concluded in October. Can you give us any information on that, please?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I listened closely to the points that you rightly raised in the chamber. I go back to my initial reflections to the convener in relation to ferries. The situation is profoundly disappointing. I sat down with your constituents and had multiple conversations with them, and with the business community, because I thought that that was the right and proper thing for me to do. I am incredibly disappointed and frustrated that they have not had the service that they deserve. The lack of certainty has had an impact, whether that is on someone who is trying to access the national health service, on a business that is trying to ensure that its customers can come across and are not making cancellations, or on those in the community who simply want to move from A to B.Ultimately, the situation can be resolved only by improving reliability. That requires regular maintenance, and a renewed programme has been taken forward in that regard. Issues will always arise in relation to when maintenance works are undertaken and how that impacts one of the many places that are served by the ferry services, and it is important that CalMac meets communities regularly to try to mitigate the direct impact. However, reliability issues will ultimately be resolved by ensuring that we have new vessels on stream.You will be familiar with the fact that about a third of the fleet will be renewed over the coming period. We have four Islay-class vessels on the horizon. Those are desperately needed and will have an enormously positive impact on the services that your constituents receive.We have the small vessel replacement programme, with seven vessels going through that—I imagine that we might get into some detail in respect of all those.Ultimately, you rightly make the point that reliability has not been provided. As a result of the massive capital investment that has been put into securing and building new vessels, that can and will change over the coming period.We have had the benefit of the MV Glen Sannox operating out of Stornoway to provide resilience support. I was a bit surprised earlier in the summer when I saw criticism of the Glen Sannox providing resilience, given that when I met folk fae Barra, they were absolutely delighted at the service that they had received. It is important to have resilience. We also have the MV Alfred on contract.I am trying to make the point that I recognise your concerns and that our response to those, and to the communities’ justified concerns, is to provide significant capital investment that will turn the situation around. That is to be welcomed.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

Thank you for that response. You have talked about the wider issues—we have seen a lot of disruption across the network, and you recognise that you do not want islanders having to deal with those situations.However, I asked a specific question about the Sound of Harris route and the situation with the MV Loch Portain. That vessel is a key part of our infrastructure—it links the Western Isles north to south. It is important for visitors and for businesses that operate across the islands. It was taken out of service in the spring for months to be re-engined, it then came back into service, but it is now out again for a prolonged period. Something major has clearly happened. Have you been in discussion with CalMac about that particular issue, and do you have any updates that you can share with us?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Chris Wilcock, do you want to give specific details on that particular vessel?

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

You are correct, Mr MacKinnon, that the vessel was re-engined earlier in the year. CalMac could give you a better explanation of the technical detail, but my understanding is that the vessel had some vibration issues when she returned to service—I am sure that that has been relayed to you by CalMac. You will be well aware that the Sound of Harris is a particularly challenging route, as there are only two vehicle-carrying vessels—that and the Loch Bhrusda—that can cover the route effectively.Earlier this week, I spoke to Councillor Robertson and reflected on the fact that CalMac is also considering whether there are other vessels that it could bring to the service, albeit potentially ones that would be significantly tidally restricted. Part of phase 2 of the small vessel replacement programme is very much about building at least two vessels for the Sound of Harris and the Sound of Barra in order to bring additional resilience for those routes.Although it is not ideal, particularly for the communities in Berneray and Leverburgh, the ability of the Glen Sannox to provide the Lochmaddy to Tarbert service and sustained connectivity across the period has demonstrated the success of having that resilience vessel. However, that is not without challenges for the people there.CalMac has still to give a formal timetable for when the Loch Portain will come back into service. These things are always detailed and it takes a long time to get to the bottom of them, but I know that it is a priority for CalMac to get that service back up and running. In the meantime, we are ensuring that there are alternatives for that vital link.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

Thank you for that answer, Mr Wilcock. You touched on procurement and phase 2 of the small vessel replacement programme. Back in March, the cabinet secretary’s predecessor, Fiona Hyslop, indicated that the Government was minded to make a direct award of those two vessels to Ferguson’s. However, there were a lot of caveats, with more work to be done in considering the practicalities and more discussions to be had with the regulatory bodies. Do you have any updates on the small vessel replacement programme and on those discussions?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

On the issue that I think that you are talking about, I would go a bit further than saying that there are a couple of technical issues. There are very significant legal matters involved that relate to the UK Government’s subsidy control regime and the Competition and Markets Authority, and the importance of those matters should not be diminished. The announcement of the direct award to Ferguson’s of the two small vessels and the two research vessels—the marine vessel and the research vessel—was made prior to my coming into post by my predecessors, Kate Forbes and Fiona Hyslop.As, I am sure, you will appreciate, we are working at significant pace to get to the point at which we will be able to fulfil the commitment that has been made, not just to the Parliament but to the workforce at Ferguson’s. It is incredibly important to me and the Government that we do that. When we stepped in to save Ferguson’s many years ago, we did so to ensure that it would have a sustainable and viable commercial future, and it is in our shared interest to see that realised.As soon as I am able to announce progress, I will do so. Next week, I will give an update in the chamber on the two Ferguson awards, in response to the justified concerns of parliamentarians over the summer about the announcement that was made at the yard, which was deeply regrettable but essential to ensuring the yard’s future. I will ensure that the committee is appropriately apprised of developments as they take shape.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

Thank you for that response. I look forward to hearing that statement next week and hope that there will be some information that answers my question.10:15

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

The tone today is strikingly different from what it was in March, when Kate Forbes said that it was a “watershed moment” and that“Now is the time to invest further in Scottish shipbuilding and bolster confidence in the future of Ferguson Marine.”She said that Ferguson’s would“become a competitive, thriving business which extends the long history of world class commercial shipbuilding on the River Clyde.”Now, a third of the staff at Ferguson’s have been cut, and you are emphasising the legal challenges, which were stated earlier in the year, but it was very much in the small print. Today, you are emphasising that small print. What exactly has changed between then and now, other than the fact that we have had an election?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Nothing has changed. I apologise for not using the words “watershed” and “competitive, thriving business”. I share—

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Will the award definitely be made?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I share Kate Forbes’s expectations. I was seeking to make a simple point to Donald MacKinnon in emphasising the importance of the Scottish Government complying with the subsidy control principles that are set in stone, in statute, by the UK Government. That is all that we are seeking to do.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

You are saying that there will definitely be a direct award.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

We must ensure that we comply with the UK Government’s subsidy control principles—

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

That is not an answer to my question.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I am very confident that we will be able to do so.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

We cannot circumvent that process.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

I am not asking you to do that.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

That process is arduous, and officials are working at pace on it. I am looking forward to updating the Parliament next week on the wider issues at Ferguson’s.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

It was convenient that all the rhetoric before the election was exaggerated, but it is now understated. We are not seeing any real investment in Ferguson’s. I think that only 4 per cent of the total investment that you were going to make in Ferguson’s has been awarded. Why is that?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I think that you are drawing a little too much attention to the fact that I did not say a couple of words that Kate Forbes said earlier this year. I share the same ambition and direction that she and Fiona Hyslop set out to the Parliament. There has been no change at all in that regard. All that I am seeking to do is to be candid with the committee about the legal obstacles that we must overcome in order to deliver that, which is exactly what we are going to do.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Will the award definitely be made?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

We will ensure that the vessels that we have said will be given as a direct award to Ferguson’s will be delivered within the subsidy control principles that the UK Government has set out. I want that to happen—I have been clear about that. In future, I will ensure that I use the terms “watershed moment” and “competitive, thriving business”, if that will satisfy you.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

The Government has known about the legal issues for years, which is why it did not make direct awards. Ministers knew that there were legal hurdles, and those still exist. Was it premature for Kate Forbes to make the announcement that she made, knowing that you might not be able to make a direct award?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

No. Perhaps you are not suggesting that we do not do this—although I find what has been said a little bizarre—but we must adhere to the law as set out by the UK Government. That is what we are seeking to do in order to deliver those vessels and ensure that Ferguson’s has the thriving commercial future that we want to see. That is in our interest, because we own the yard. We nationalised it and we need and want it to be successful, but it can be successful only if we give it the tools to be so. That is what we will do.However, we have to go beyond that. We need Ferguson’s and the shipyard to deliver those vessels on time and on budget to show the market that they can do that. That is how to draw in the commercial activity that will make Ferguson’s thrive in the way that the nationalised airport at Prestwick is thriving.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Why has only 4 per cent of the £14 million that was committed for investment in the yard been awarded?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

That money is required for modernising the yard in order to deliver the vessels. It is important that those things happen in tandem, which is exactly what we are seeking to do.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Everybody wants the yard to succeed. Everybody—

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I am sorry, Mr Simpson, but I do not accept that premise, because individuals in this Parliament, including many of your former colleagues, would go to any end to criticise the yard and the Government’s investment in it. Many politicians over many years questioned the fact that the Government sought to save the yard and protect the community in Inverclyde. We will not apologise for doing so—

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

We need to ensure that the yard has a thriving future, and we want that to take shape. That is why the announcement was made, and we will get on and do that within the principles of the law set out by the UK Government.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

It is quite obvious that the yard needs to win business, so a direct award from the Government would help it. That is clear. However, you have been clear today that you cannot promise that because of the Subsidy Control Act 2022. That is where we are, is it not?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

As a member of the Government, I cannot sit here and say that we will circumvent the UK Government’s subsidy control laws. That would be absurd.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

Sticking with procurement, I want to touch on the replacement for the MV Lord of the Isles. A different approach was taken to that and it has gone out to competitive tender. Ferguson’s was excluded from the bidding process. Is the process for replacement for the Lord of the Isles going to plan? Are you still on course to award a tender early next year?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

As I understand it from the information that has been shared with me, everything is still on track in that regard.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

Linked to that, is there any update on the upgrades to the pier at Gairsay and Lochboisdale harbour? Are you maintaining your commitment to those improvements?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

The commitments that we have made for various infrastructure improvements in the Western Isles stand. If any concerns are being raised by anyone in the local community in relation to that, I am quite happy to address those. There is regular—weekly or even daily—communication between the reps on the islands, which I welcome. I have been privy to some of that. We will make sure that that continues over the period ahead.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

Thanks. You will, no doubt, have been made aware through representations in correspondence from the island communities of the frustrations around the islands business resilience fund. During the election campaign, the First Minister made a commitment to a £10 million fund to be delivered within 20 days of the Government forming. That changed to a 100-day commitment and a £3 million fund in the current financial year, with the remainder of the £7 million to be available over the rest of the current session of Parliament. That is very different from what the First Minister said when he was in the Western Isles during the election campaign. Do you understand why island businesses are angry and frustrated about the change in position?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I can outline to you very clearly that the £10 million that was promised will be delivered. We are taking—

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Good. We are taking a phased approach to ensure that we properly get the resilience that is required from the fund, because that its purpose. It builds on the previous iteration of that financial support.I sat down with the businesses in Uist and I have had them explain to me in person the challenge that they face. We have responded to that with a multimillion pound package that we hope will provide them with the resilience support that they require. Ultimately, however, what they require is the new vessels to be on stream. Over the next six to eight months or so, we will have a number of positive announcements in that regard. I think that that will be welcomed by the business community because it goes to the heart of this issue. I refer you to my previous comments in that respect.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

Are you telling us that what the Government is doing now is consistent with the election pledge?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

The Government made a commitment to deliver £10 million of resilience support to the isles, and that is exactly what we are doing, but, importantly, what we are doing goes far beyond any resilience fund. I am sure that you and I would agree that we do not want to be in a situation where there needs to be a resilience fund.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

It is a reflection of the challenges that have been faced. However, we have a vessel that is due to come on stream over the course of the next six weeks to two months; we have another vessel from Ferguson’s, the MV Glen Rosa, that is due in November; and we have two more vessels that are due to come on stream early in the new year. That, on top of the small vessel replacement programme, will transform reliability in the isles. That is where the focus of folk and businesses on the isles will be, because that will provide them with the long-term resilience that they desperately deserve.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

I disagree that that is what was actually committed to in the election campaign.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

But you recognise that people and businesses will be happy—

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

I recognise that they will be happy with the new vessels that are coming on stream, but I do not recognise that what was committed to during the election campaign is what is being delivered now. There was supposed to be a £10 million fund that was going to be available immediately. That is what people were told, but that is not what has happened, but we will leave that there just now.I want to touch on governance. We have heard about governance in some of the discussion around public service reform, and statements have been made about changes in the governance approach to CalMac and CMAL. Can you give us any reflections on that and where discussions are up to?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Obviously, previous committees undertook significant work in that space, and we had project Neptune, which was very much part of my early summer reading.It is important that we recognise that there is TS, which is in effect the sponsor for the ferry networks, CalMac, which is the operator, and CMAL, which does the procurement aspect. Although we recognise the necessity for public service reform, it is also important, based on the work that has been done in the past, that we fully apprise ourselves of the options for what comes next. That work is at an early stage, and there are no definitive conclusions at this juncture as to what that will look like.If you were to model a system right now for the governance, procurement and operation of the ferry services, would you choose what is there at the moment? You probably would not, so it is important that we seek to reform that. For me, what needs to be at the heart of that is deliverability and ensuring that we secure the confidence of the island communities, because they are the ones who rely on these vessels the most. The governance structure needs to deliver for them.Various views have been expressed to me by representatives from the island communities in relation to how that works at the moment. This is the start of a process in which their views will be central.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

On that point, I think that what many islanders would say has been missing from the current process is their voice and their ability to feed into that governance structure. At the moment, we still have a CMAL board with no island representation on it. Local accountability and some level of democratic representation from the communities that are served by the ferry network will be absolutely crucial. Do you recognise that?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Yes. I think that we have a shared aspiration on that, and I do not feel any pushback from anyone in that regard, and I would not expect any.I am amazed at the work that Chris Wilcock undertakes in relation to his communication with partners in the delivery of services and the personal interaction that exists between him and others with people in the island communities. That should be a starting point for what we go on to create, and I am happy to work closely with him in that regard.I go back to my previous comment: if we were to design something, I am not sure that we would design it in the way that it currently exists. We can do better, and that is our intention.10:30

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

My final question is on timescales. When should we expect to have an idea of the direction of travel? What timeframes are you working to?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

A lot of work has already been undertaken, both by the predecessor committee and through project Neptune, and early discussions are under way about what the proposal looks like and whether it is deliverable. That will ultimately depend on the options that come to me, but we want to move at pace on public sector reform, and it is part of that process. I will hopefully be in a position, the next time that I attend the committee, to give you a full update on timelines.

Donald MacKinnon Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

I look forward to it.That is everything from me just now, convener.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Before we move on to buses, I will go back over some of the ground that we have covered already, because I have some questions—if that is okay, convener.I will start by going back to Mr MacKinnon’s questions on ferries and the move to a single ferries body. Cabinet secretary, you said in the programme for government that that would be for the Clyde and Western Isles ferry routes. Why not for the northern isles as well?

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

With regard to the northern isles, we currently have two new vessels out there, and we have a very positive service—I am familiar with it, because it shifts out from Aberdeen.At this moment in time, I am pretty comfortable with the structure there. We are obviously looking to secure a new operator, and that process is under way. That is the right thing to do—as the committee will know, it is a competitive process. I am not sensing an immediate urgency to address that from folk in the local community, but if you know different, Mr Simpson, please let me know.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

No, I do not know any different—it was just a genuine question.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Good. You said that you have been reading through project Neptune—good for you. Which of the international models that were mentioned are you most attracted to? I will remind you: Canada—in particular British Columbia—Norway, New Zealand and Australia were mentioned, but there are different models out there, so you could pick from any one of those.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Or you might not like any of them.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Look, Mr Simpson—how can I phrase this without just repeating what I said to Mr

MacKinnon? The situation as it stands is not one that we would organically seek to create. I am very open to the ongoing internal dialogue that is taking place, and will continue to take place, in relation to what the final outcome could and should look like. I will not offer a preference at this stage, because I am not going to pre-empt that work.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Were you attracted to any of them? I have looked at the various models—I actually spoke to the people at BC Ferries in Canada; there is an interesting model there. Maybe you should get on the phone or arrange a Teams call with people around the world.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

You never know—you might come up with something better than what we have.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

I am always keen to look at international comparators, and I will certainly heed your advice, Mr Simpson.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Thank you—I am here to help.To go back to the start, the convener was asking about the plans for Transport Scotland and bringing it in house. Transport Scotland is a Government body and is answerable to you. I was not clear from your answers to the convener what the difference would be. Those taking on its role in-house would still be accountable to you. Whoever remains employed there, including the three people with you today, I hope, would still be accountable to you.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

We should not be flippant about people’s jobs. That is not helpful, appropriate or necessary, quite frankly.I appreciate that we have a significant amount of time at our disposal, but I am not sure that it is best served by my simply repeating the answers that I gave to the convener to you.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

I am not clear what the difference is. It is a Government body. The only difference is that you are saying that will be in-house.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Mr Simpson, I cannot help you with your lack of clarity; that is a matter for you. I am comfortable with the answers that I gave to the convener earlier, and I see no need simply to repeat them for the sake of filling time.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

It is not a case of filling time. You are here to provide clarity. You keep using that word.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

I do not think that your answers are clear.

Stephen Flynn SNP Aberdeen Deeside and North Kincardine
link

Mr Simpson, that is your perspective.

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.