Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Specialist Neonatal Units (Centralisation) (PE2099)

Wednesday 11 March 2026 Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee About 09:33 Petitions 8 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

PE2099 is one of the most consequential petitions that we have received. The petition, lodged by Lynne McRitchie, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to stop the planned downgrading of established and high-performing specialist neonatal intensive care services across NHS Scotland from level 3 to level 2. It also calls for the commissioning of an independent review on this decision in the light of contradictory expert opinions on centralising services.We last considered the petition on 14 January 2026, when we agreed to write to the Minister for Public Health and Women’s Health. The committee sent a substantial submission that drew together the themes of all the evidence that we heard and detailed the parts of the recommendations that the committee accepted, with significant caveats in the areas in which we thought that there was scope and a need for additional work to be done.The committee’s letter set out our position regarding the new model of neonatal care, which includes our outstanding concerns. We stated that, although we recognise that the Scottish Government’s decision was made on the basis of clinical judgment to improve clinical outcomes for the sickest and smallest babies, several points remain unresolved and unclear to us.Those points are whether adequate resources will be in place to support effective delivery of the new model, what the outcome of on-going modelling work will be and whether the Scottish Government has fully considered the provision of practical support for families, particularly for the small number of families that will be impacted by the new model of care.The committee’s key conclusion was that, in the light of the outstanding issues that have been identified, the level of provision in existing neonatal intensive care units in Scotland should not be reduced until the areas of uncertainty have been addressed by the Scottish Government.09:45I believe that we have the petitioner with us in the gallery today and I pay tribute to the extraordinary focus and resolve that she has shown. Again, I thank all those who took the time to meet us at the University hospital Wishaw. They shared their personal experiences and concerns about the new model of care, and those contributions have undoubtedly helped to direct our work and inform our position.The Minister for Public Health and Women’s Health has responded to the committee’s letter. The minister’s response sets out that“implementation will be a managed transition through a phased approach, with clear ... detailed financial and operational plans by the end of March 2026 submitted to the Task and Finish Group, with the aim to complete implementation by the end of 2026.”The end of March, of course, is after our last sitting day.On modelling, the correspondence confirms that“capacity modelling has now been completed”,but there is on-going work“to develop a cross-Board funding model to ensure receiving units are funded for the additional care that they provide”.The minister acknowledges that more can be done on support for families with babies in neonatal care, and the response states that the Scottish Government is“working with Boards to ensure that the concerns are addressed.”We made a very significant and substantial representation. The minister’s response is equally substantial, in so far as she thanks us very much for the bits where we have chosen to agree, but is slightly less than forthcoming on doing anything different in any of the areas where the committee has expressed its reservations.Therefore, before the committee decides what we now do, I note that Jackie Baillie has joined us this morning—ever keen to be on stage for the final act. Ms Baillie, is there anything that you would like to suggest to the committee before we draw our conclusions?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

How could I resist that invitation, convener?I understand that this is your last meeting, so I decided to rock up in support of what I think is the most consequential petition that the committee has dealt with. Like you, I acknowledge that Lynne McRitchie, a leading light in the Wishaw neonatal warriors, has joined us today. We are hoping that Tammy Johnstone-Little and her son Kai will make it through, but if not—traffic being what it is—we hope to see her at some point.I will make a general observation before I dive into the petition. I waded through the minister’s 14-page submission to the committee. I was equally aware that petitioners only get 1,000 words in which to express their view. I make the point for a future committee that, although committee members do not want to be deluged, it should be a level playing field. Therefore, 14 pages from the Government versus 1,000 words from the petitioner could be addressed for the future.I have to say to you that it is 14 pages of selective information, which is devoid of timetables. Although I thought you were very kind in your comments about the submission from the minister, I am going to be slightly tetchier.First, the original best start document referred to a reduction in the number of neonatal units from eight to three to five. That was very clear. It was only at the options appraisal part of the process that it became three. You will appreciate the significance of that in a moment. The original best start document was very clear that it was three to five units—not as the minister contends in the opening paragraph of her letter. It has always been our contention that it is right to reduce the number so that we have the specialist capability across Scotland, but that there did not need to be three units; there could have been four or, indeed, five. That has simply been disregarded by the minister and her team.The second thing I would say is that the involvement of the parents took place after all decisions were made—once the options were decided. If you read through this letter, it gives the impression that they were involved right from the get-go. That is simply misleading: it is misleading to the committee and does not reflect the reality of what happened.In the online survey that was mentioned, there was a facilitator. The survey had three questions, which were on psychological support, the young patients family fund and information about the unit. People were not allowed to respond to questions on any other points. The conversation was directed in such a way that people wanting to object to the proposal and give details of their experience were not allowed to contribute in that way. Therefore, I stress to members that to suggest that parents have been engaged is entirely misleadingOn the issue of misinformation, the Wishaw neonatal warriors have consistently, on their social media platforms, talked about the downgrading of the unit but at the moment, local MSPs are indicating that nothing is changing and there is nothing to worry about, which in itself is probably not quite accurate. I will leave that sticking to the wall.We have real concerns about implementation. It has gone really slowly. I know for a fact that there are genuine concerns about the capacity in different locations to cope with what is happening. I will give an example of that, which happened at the tail end of last year, I believe, to two parents, who I am not going to name. They come from Glasgow. There was no space in any of the facilities in Glasgow, so they were transferred to Aberdeen maternity hospital. Twins were born to them at 24 weeks; sadly, one of the twins did not make it. They feel that they have been unable to grieve. They have been separated from family support, which has been at a distance. They were transferred from Aberdeen to university hospital Wishaw to be nearer to home, then from Wishaw to the Royal Alexandra hospital in Paisley, and then, finally, back to Glasgow. Both parents are suffering considerably as a consequence of that. Both are on antidepressants, and at least one of them remains off work. Interruption. Excuse my cough—that is the problem with having a cold.I implore the committee to keep this petition open. I think that this is unfinished business. The committee has invested a huge amount of time in it. This change is just not capable of being implemented at this time. I have given the committee a real-life example of somebody’s journey through what might end up being the new system of transfer from hospital to hospital that shows how it is not in the interests of the parents or the children.I will leave that with the committee, with a plea to keep the petition open. That is the wish of the petitioners. I have explained to them the difference between keeping it open and closing it, and they want to keep it open.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Thank you, Jackie Baillie. That was helpful. A lot of what you said seems to tie in with the views that we have heard.That said, we took considerable evidence at round-tables, and I think that we were impressed with the sincerity of the professional clinicians who had arrived at the decision that they did, whether or not we felt that it was the correct decision and whether or not we were persuaded by it. Prior to taking that evidence, we might have doubted the sincerity of the motives of those who had come to the view that the new model would offer the best possible prospect for small and premature babies.Having said that, you referred—in slightly tetchier terms—to the substance of the minister’s response, with which I was also slightly disappointed.Davy Russell, do you have a view on how we might proceed? Should the petition be closed and a fresh petition be raised, or have we not got to a point where we should be satisfied, given all the work that we have done?

Davy Russell Lab Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse
link

I would keep it open. One of the reasons why is that the Government has not explained how it will finance all of this, from infrastructure to ambulance resources—it has no idea. I submitted a freedom of information request. I think that there are too many unanswered questions for us to close it at this time.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Let us hear from Maurice Golden, who is joining us online.

Maurice Golden Con North East Scotland
link

I agree with all the comments that have been made. There are probably two aspects that the committee should consider. First, there is new evidence today in the Press and Journal and The Courier, uncovering really concerning information about Aberdeen maternity hospital and whether it has capacity to absorb patients from elsewhere. That is incredibly relevant, and the proposed plans are really worrying.The second aspect is that the scope of the petition is such that, even though the committee has done so much work on it, it will still be very much applicable in a new parliamentary session. With petitions, the debate and the information often move on and the scope might not be so useful in a future parliamentary session, but, in this case, it is still entirely relevant. On that basis, keeping the petition open is worthy of consideration.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

We will keep the petition open. In the legacy report, we will need to make sure that we explain what we have done and why we have done it. It is still a matter of huge public concern. The worries that the committee has expressed about the realities of delivering the plans on the ground are only magnified by the reports that we have seen this morning from Aberdeen. Therefore, the reality of this situation must continue to be interrogated, and we will keep the petition open into the next parliamentary session. I wish all those at University hospital Wishaw well—Interruption.I hope that Ms Baillie does not need to seek urgent medical attention herself. Thank you very much, Ms Baillie, and sayonara.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:33 Continued Petitions Petitions · 2
  3. 09:33 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  4. 09:33 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  5. 09:33 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  6. 09:33 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  7. 09:33 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  8. 09:33 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  9. 09:33 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  10. 09:33 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.