We resume with the next agenda item, which is formal consideration of the Non-Domestic Rates (Levying and Miscellaneous Amendment) (Scotland) Regulations 2026. I remind those watching that this is a negative instrument and, as such, it is laid after it is made. It is subject to annulment by resolution of the Parliament for a period of 40 days, which begins on the day that it is laid.At our meeting on 3 March, we agreed to take evidence on the regulations following written evidence that we received from Scottish Land & Estates and the British Association for Shooting and Conservation. We have since received further submissions from Scottish Land & Estates.I welcome the Minister for Public Finance, Ivan McKee, along with his officials Anouk Berthier, head of non-domestic rates policy, and Donald Henderson, deputy director for nature. There is no need for you to operate your microphones; that will be done for you.I invite the minister to make a brief opening statement.
Ivan McKeeSNPThe Minister for Public Finance · Glasgow Provan
Thank you, convener. I am pleased to join the committee today to assist in members’ scrutiny of the Non-Domestic Rates (Levying and Miscellaneous Amendment) (Scotland) Regulations 2026.The regulations provide for a range of non-domestic rates measures in 2026-27 that were introduced in the budget, including the setting of the supplements on top of the basic property rates, which create intermediate and higher property rates that apply to properties with rateable values of more than £51,000 and more than £100,000 respectively; the continuation of the small business bonus scheme and fresh start reliefs; and the introduction of the new 10-year electric vehicle charging point relief.From 1 April 2026, shootings and deer forests will be excluded from eligibility for small business bonus scheme relief and fresh start relief, subject to some exemptions. I met members of the non-domestic rates consultative group immediately after the UK and Scottish budgets to hear their views and suggestions. In the development of the regulations, careful consideration was given to any concerns raised by businesses, including those in the rural sector, about the risks of unintended consequences.I am happy to answer any questions that the committee might have.
How did the Government arrive at the conclusions that it arrived at on the regulations? Why did you not consult rural businesses on the impact of this Scottish statutory instrument?
It is not normal to consult when we are making changes to the small business bonus scheme. That has not happened in the past. We will of course listen to the committee through this formal consultation process, and we engage closely with sector representatives on an on-going basis. As I mentioned, I worked with members of the NDR consultative group, which has a range of businesses on it, to get a sense of their thoughts on NDR matters. The Government also engaged with businesses in the rural sector following the initial budget announcement, and we made some changes as a consequence.
You have said that you have not consulted the rural sector, but hundreds of small rural businesses have warned that losing the small business bonus scheme relief will increase their fixed costs to the extent that they are considering making redundancies. The regulations will also have other impacts, including loss of revenue and productivity, and they could act as a deterrent to future investment in the rural sector. What is your response to the businesses that are going to lose out on the scheme?
A wide range of exemptions are included in the regulations that will, for the most part, cover many of the businesses that you are talking about. We have been quite clear that those exemptions are for individual businesses, depending on the nature of the business, but they are designed to cover businesses that meet the requirements.
On that point specifically, you will be aware that a broad range of activities take place on shootings and in deer forests. In many cases, they do not include sports—that does not feature in the activities that take place. How do you reconcile that with what has been proposed and what I understand to be the policy intention? Those are the businesses that will not qualify for the scheme.
Businesses that meet the exemptions will qualify, and I believe that the regulations are clear. The non-statutory guidance on relief regulations that we will publish in April, as we normally do, will clarify that further. As I said, we have been clear, and the regulations and the guidance will also be clear on what is included and what is exempt.
Finally, shootings and deer forests cannot be separated from the land that they refer to. Can the minister clarify what is meant by regulations 3(5)(d)(i) and 4(5)(d)(i), which refer to“shootings which are crofts, agricultural landholdings or small landholdings”?Do you share the view of others that further clarification of definitions and what is required needs to be fully looked into?
All those definitions are clear. Shootings are clearly specified on the NDR roll. Crofts are specified on our list of what is and is not a croft, and it is a long-established principle that agricultural landholdings do not pay NDR in any event. We believe that the regulations are clear, and the non-statutory guidance on the regulations that we will publish will clarify that further. We are happy to engage with anyone who thinks that more needs to be clarified in the guidance to make that crystal clear.
Meghan Gallacher’s line of questioning has inspired me to ask a question with my rural affairs hat on. Rather than discussing NDR, I want to get into a bit more of the story. A lot of work is being done on reducing the number of deer across Scotland, and we are looking at a four-year period in which that needs to happen. We are trying to move venison into schools, public kitchens and so on, but those who work in venison larders and in that space operate on a tight margin. That is a representation that I have had from people who work in that space. Is it clear that they will be able to apply for the exemptions?
I will just work my way through the list. Crofts are exempt. Agricultural landholdings are exempt. Small landholdings are exempt. A range of uses, including use for consumption, result in exemption.
I will give you a scenario. Somebody who is operating a venison larder rents land and the shooting rights from an estate, and they are working to bring the deer numbers down. They put the meat into a venison larder, and they have maybe one shoot a year to cover the cost of the rent. Will they be able to go for the exemptions?
I am happy to clarify a bit further. The minister is correct. When the shooting right is exercised solely for the purpose of environmental management or for preventing damage to woodland or agricultural production, or a combination of those purposes, and when any deer shot is made available for human consumption as venison, the business will remain eligible for SBBS relief. It is for local authorities to administer rates, including relief awards, and they will determine who remains and does not remain eligible for SBBS relief.
Okay—great. That is the detail that I think people want to hear, so thank you very much for that.As there are no more questions, does the committee agree that we do not wish to make any recommendations in relation to the regulations?Members indicated agreement.
The committee will now move into private to complete consideration of its agenda items, so that is the end of the public part of the meeting.11:11Meeting continued in private until 11:40.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.