I am going to change the order again and bring us to PE2085, which was lodged by David Cornock, and calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to introduce a statutory definition of residency for fatal accident inquiries into deaths abroad. We last considered the petition on 12 November 2025, when we agreed to write to the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs, the Lord Advocate and the chief constable of Police Scotland.The Lord Advocate’s response confirms that she has met the petitioner and, as a result, a number of improvements have been made to communication with relatives who are affected by deaths abroad. The Lord Advocate states that she does not consider that the lack of a formal definition adversely affects the Crown’s decision making. Her submission also states that whether the person was ordinarily resident in Scotland will be clear from the initial information that was provided and that, for example, when a person has been living and working abroad outwith Scotland for many years, it is likely that they would not be considered to have been ordinarily resident. If there is uncertainty about the residency status of the person who has died, the Crown Office will instruct further inquiries to obtain information that will allow a determination to be made.The Lord Advocate also notes that a minute of agreement was finalised with the death certification review service and Police Scotland that updated the process for reporting and investigating deaths abroad. The minute includes detailed guidance on the facts to be considered when assessing whether a person was ordinarily resident in Scotland at the time of their death, with reference to relevant case law.The cabinet secretary’s response to the committee reiterates the Scottish Government’s position that creating a legal definition of “ordinarily resident” would not resolve the underlying challenges or improve outcomes for families. The cabinet secretary also states that she is aware of comparisons with the coroner system in England and Wales, but that it is important to note that the inquest system of England and Wales operates under a different framework. While the processes differ, both jurisdictions face similar practical obstacles in investigating deaths abroad.The deputy chief constable’s submission states that the assessment of residency status is always important and that when Police Scotland is instructed to undertake further inquiries, it will seek to explore the case fully with the family to provide sufficient information to assist the determination. He also reiterates that Police Scotland’s view is that the current definition of “ordinarily resident” is sufficient.The petitioner has provided a written submission that argues that the recent responses are ill-informed and dismissive to the 1,000 families who are affected and he reiterates his concern that no FAIs into deaths abroad have taken place, which, he believes, proves that the bar is impossibly high.We have also received written submissions from members of the Scottish Parliament Jackie Baillie and Michael Marra, who have previously addressed the committee on the petition. Ms Baillie’s submission states that it is unthinkable that a parent should be left without options to establish why their child died in unexplained circumstances, even while abroad, when they are a UK citizen. Ms Baillie believes that the system in Scotland appears to lag behind that of England and Wales, and Michael Marra’s submission asks the committee to keep the petition open and highlights the petitioner’s tireless campaigning on the issue.The committee has received unsolicited written submissions from two individuals, Mr Billy Milligan and Mr Dave Scott. Mr Milligan’s submission states that the absence of a statutory definition has produced uncertainty, inconsistency and injustice. He asserts that such uncertainty is not an academic quibble because it affects workers and families in Scotland’s globally enlarged economy.Mr Scott, who is an offshore energy industry representative, expresses disappointment that this area of legislation regularly fails the Scottish people.Finally, the committee has received an unsolicited written submission from Victim Support Scotland, which states that the support that it can offer bereaved families relies entirely on strict referral processes and requires criminality to be confirmed by the relevant authority. This means that deaths occurring either in Scotland or abroad where no criminality has been found, and which are unexplained or suspicious, or involve suicide or a road traffic accident, do not form part of its remit or funding agreement. The submission states that it would appear that there is a gap in support. Therefore, the onus is on families to investigate, challenge, query and understand complex international legislation, all at their own financial and time cost, while grappling with grief and trauma.Jackie Baillie, would you like to add anything to what you set out in your written submission?
Official Report · Committee
Continued Petitions
Fatal Accident Inquiries (Deaths Abroad) (PE2085)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jackson Carlaw Con 6
- Fergus Ewing Ind 4
- Jackie Baillie Lab 2
The record
13 contributions
link
Thank you for giving me permission to speak, convener. I would like to add a couple of things.You will know that the issue has been raised not only in the Scottish Parliament but in the United Kingdom Parliament, by Dave Doogan MP and now Douglas McAllister MP. There has truly been a cross-party effort on the petition, and Mr Cornock has met the Lord Advocate, as you said, and the First Minister.Although you are right to say that the process has been helpful and has led to changes, including the minute and guidance that you mentioned, the solution requires more than guidance. If the solution does not involve legislative change, I am yet to hear from the Government what change will consistently deliver the result that people want.As you acknowledged, the reality is that, since 2007, there have been no FAIs in Scotland for unexplained deaths abroad, while, in England, there have been 1,700. That is not right. There is a gap in the law.I would argue, given the thousands of Scots who work abroad, that this process is not over and that the petition needs to carry on. It is a matter for the committee whether you continue it, but I would urge you to do so, because the reality is that loved ones need clarity, truth and justice in the event of an unexplained death abroad.The committee has taken the trouble to make sure that the petition is heard. I hope that you will continue to keep it open but, if you decide not to, please take this as notice that the petitioners will bring the issue back to Parliament, because it is unfinished business.
The petitioners had the opportunity to meet the Lord Advocate, but the committee has not—we have only seen written evidence from her.One of the things that became apparent to the committee as we investigated the issue is that the systems in England, Wales and Scotland are wholly different to each other, and it is not possible to compare them at any stage along the line. They have different aims and purposes: one relates to post-mortems and another does not, for example. They are not similar.I think that the committee has probably taken the residency issue as far as we can, with regard to the Crown Office, Police Scotland and others. However, I come back to the point that the petitioner makes, which is that nothing has ever happened on behalf of anybody. That issue has continued to trouble the committee.Mr Ewing, do you have any thoughts on the matter?
I can see that the circumstances are tragic for the petitioner—
Who, I should say, is in the public gallery.
—and that the shroud of mystery surrounding the death of his son will linger for ever.Obviously, the petitioner’s desire is for there to have been a proper, thorough inquiry and investigation into the situation, conducted by an independent judicial authority in Scotland. It need not be said again—I do not need to lecture the petitioner about this, because he has heard this on many occasions—but there are extreme evidential hurdles in any such work concerning something that happens in another jurisdiction. I understand from the evidence that, normally, for there to be an investigation here, there needs to be the agreement of the host jurisdiction where the death occurred. I understand that Lord Cullen enabled the conduct of FAIs here, but said—to the extreme anger of the petitioner, frankly—that those “might be exercised rarely”. I think that the petitioner’s view was that the word “might” was doing an awful lot of heavy lifting.I think that the petitioner might now wish us no longer to focus on the definition of “ordinary residence”. The responses that we have had from the cabinet secretary, the Lord Advocate and the police have been clear that the issue is reasonably well understood and settled; it is rather that the petitioner wants there to be the capability of having investigations. It may be that that is not hampered so much by the definition of “ordinary residence” but by the fact that the processes in Scotland are so different.I would be interested to hear whether Ms Baillie thinks that that is a fair point—I am trying to pursue the matter fairly and rationally, to the benefit of the petitioner.However, it may well be that the petition could be reframed to focus on the desire to have a similar process to the post-mortem procedure in England, which, although different, may have offered a relief and remedy, had it been applicable in Scotland. That issue has not been fully examined and explored.In short, this is a case, as with the previous petition, where the petitioner has achieved clarity and focus of the sort that just would not have happened otherwise. There is not a shadow of a doubt about that. This clarity has resulted only because of the persistence, determination and guts of the petitioner, who has been assisted ably by Ms Baillie.I do not know why it is that Ms Baillie seems to get all the most tragic cases, but there we are. That may be a curious psephological fact.
link
In fairness, he was not assisted entirely by me. The petitioner has moved, with great judgment, from Dundee to Dumbarton, so he is now my constituent. Other people have been involved, and the assistance has been cross-party.
In conclusion, the petition has been successful in many ways in achieving clarity, where previously there had been a lack of consideration, rather than a lack of clarity, by the Parliament and the Government.I do not think that, in our closing the petition, it is a defeat, but it is not yet a victory. However, it could be, it should be, and it may be, if the petition is brought back in the next session of Parliament. I hope that whoever is on the successor committee takes it on, and, who knows—I would quite like to be here if the people say so. The knowledge and the corpus of work that has been done is a legacy of sorts. Whether or not the petition is closed is not really relevant; it exists because it is there for future members of the next committee in the next session of Parliament.I am sorry that I have taken a bit of time, but it is an extremely important matter. I recommend that the petition is closed, but that the petitioner should be thanked again for his work in bringing to Parliament a matter of grave importance to all.
Thank you. Colleagues, do we agree with Mr Ewing’s suggestion that that is the best course of action to pursue?Members indicated agreement.
We thank the petitioner and look to the petition being reframed and, I hope, coming back in the next session of Parliament. I note in passing Mr Ewing’s constitutional innovation of directly elected committee members by the wider public—
Why not?
—which would secure him his return.
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Feb 2026 →- 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
- 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
- 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 13
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 17
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 10
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.