The next item on our agenda is to take evidence on two affirmative instruments. We are joined by the Minister for Public Finance, Ivan McKee, who is accompanied by his officials: David Storrie, head of local taxation policy; Susan Robb, solicitor; and Rachel Currie, local taxation policy manager. I welcome you all to the meeting.These instruments are laid under the affirmative procedure, which means that the Parliament must approve them before they come into force. Following this evidence session, the committee will be invited, at the next agenda item, to consider motions to approve the instruments.
I remind everyone that Scottish Government officials can speak under this item, but not in the debates on the instruments that follow.There is no need for you to operate your microphones—we will do that for you. I invite the minister to make a short opening statement.
Ivan McKeeSNPThe Minister for Public Finance · Glasgow Provan
I am grateful to the committee for its careful consideration of the Visitor Levy (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill and its associated affirmative regulations, two of which are being formally considered this morning. The purpose of these regulations is to ensure that visitor levy appeals, as and when they arise, can be heard and determined effectively within the Scottish tribunals structure.The draft First-tier Tribunal for Scotland Local Taxation Chamber and Upper Tribunal for Scotland (Composition and Rules of Procedure) (Miscellaneous Amendment) Regulations 2026 amend tribunal composition and procedural rules to allow for effective administration of visitor levy appeals. With regard to composition, the regulations allow for a legal member to sit alone, or for a legal member to sit with one other member, depending on the complexity of the case being heard. That allows the President of Scottish Tribunals, or the chamber president, as appropriate, to adopt a proportionate approach and make best use of available resources when determining composition.With regard to rules of procedure, the regulations insert a new part to help ensure clarity, consistency and accessibility for visitor levy appeals. That provides a clear procedural route for appellants and local authorities, setting out the required contents of a notice of appeal; acknowledgement requirements; withdrawal rules; the tribunal’s order-making powers; and the permission-to-appeal procedure. The regulations also provide a tailored procedural framework for appeals to the Upper Tribunal for Scotland arising from visitor levy cases.The draft First-tier Tribunal for Scotland (Allocation of Functions to the Local Taxation Chamber) Regulations 2026 allocate responsibility for determining visitor levy appeals to the local taxation chamber of the First-tier Tribunal for Scotland. Such appeals have been allocated to the local taxation chamber because it is anticipated that they will be aligned with the chamber’s existing work and expertise.In relation to both sets of regulations, the Scottish Government consulted with the President of Scottish Tribunals, Lady Wise, and the Lord President as required. I am grateful for their thoughtful feedback, which the Scottish Government has taken on board in full in the development of the regulations as laid.Finally, I understand that the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee considered the regulations on 17 February and no points were raised.I am happy to answer any questions that the committee may have with regard to both sets of regulations.10:45
We have a number of questions. I will start by combining a few questions around detail.Will accommodation providers be required to pay a fee for any appeals that they submit? Will they be able to use the review and appeals process to challenge the basis on which the levy is charged, if for example, they would prefer the levy to be a fixed amount rather than a percentage?
With regard to the second question, that would be set by the local authority, so I am pretty sure that there would not be any scope for businesses to appeal on the basis of the charge. I will ask Susan Robb to talk about the fee structure.
Accommodation providers would be able to challenge the operation of the visitor levy scheme, but I do not imagine that that would encompass the fee structure.
Great—thank you.On the second point, about changing the fixed amount, I would hope that the local authority will have consulted well enough to understand what the right rate would be, whether it is a percentage or a flat rate.
The local authority will make that decision through its consultation. Clearly, not all businesses would necessarily agree with the decisions that are made by the local authority, but that would be the process.
As you will be aware, minister, the committee heard—and you have heard, too—from some tourism representatives who made the case that a per-night, per-person levy would be “unworkable”. If a local authority decides to introduce such a scheme, how many reviews and appeals does the Scottish Government expect would result from that?
There are a few different things in there that do not relate to these regulations. The Government has lodged amendments at stage 2 that would remove the per-person, per-night provision, so in a sense, that question is perhaps moot.
I can perhaps shed a further bit of light on that. It is difficult to anticipate the full case load, as there has never been something quite like this—it is a new addition to the chamber. We have worked with the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service to estimate costs: the costs are estimated to be between £150,000 to £350,000, based on a low amount to a high amount. Had there been a per-person, per-night levy, there may have been a greater increase in people challenging, and more dissatisfaction might have led to a greater case load. The fact that there will not be such a levy will possibly help to diminish some of the potential for disgruntled appeals, although perhaps not entirely.Another point, looking at estimating case loads in the first year, is that Edinburgh will be the first scheme to come online, in July 2026, which will be part of the way through the financial year. There will be a quarter of a financial year before the first returns happen, and then cases would need to be lodged and processed through the chamber.In the first financial year, therefore, I anticipate that there would be a relatively small number of cases. The numbers will grow not only as the Edinburgh scheme fully comes online in its first full financial year, but as the Glasgow scheme and other schemes come online.We will need to keep monitoring that, and I would anticipate that it will be covered within the statutory three-year review and in the report to Parliament on how these things are going.
Good morning. With regard to the appeals process, is it possible that accommodation providers and others could appeal the purpose for which a local authority wishes to spend the proceeds from the visitor levy? The draft regulations state that the appeals process relates to“decisions of a local authority relating to the operation of a … Visitor Levy scheme”in its entirety. Does that stretch to cover what the local authority intends to do with the visitor levy receipts?
That is a good question. My officials are telling me that the answer is no; I do not know whether they want to reflect on that or to go away, consider it and come back.
The answer is no. The purpose of the tribunal is to consider what is being charged and what is liable, and liability would not come into that kind of issue. There will, of course, be other mechanisms in which disputes can be heard. Local authorities will have a forum for businesses and the community to engage in and in which to raise such issues. However, I do not think that that would be an appropriate mechanism for an individual business to use to raise such an issue.Ultimately, it will be for the chamber to consider the scope of the appeals that it receives, so it is not for me to say that someone will not lodge an appeal in those terms, but it would be for the individual tribunal to consider whether the appeal met the scope of what it looks at, and it would then deal with that through due process. However, I do not anticipate that that issue would fall within its jurisdiction.
Good morning, and thanks for your answers so far. Have you looked at the resource and financial implications of the number of appeals that may go to the local taxation chamber, and do you have an idea of what that might look like?
Estimates have been made. Data will become clearer as things roll out across the local authorities. You might expect more to go through in the settling-down period and for that to settle as the process becomes embedded. However, as has been indicated, we have assessed the possible range of costs as from £150,000 to £300,000. That is the initial expectation but it will be monitored as we move forward.
Good morning. The financial memorandum to the bill that became the 2024 act said that the Scottish Government would engage with stakeholders when it came to the costs of the regulations. What engagement has the Government had with local authorities and tourism bodies or operators on the cost of the appeal process for them?
Engagement has been part of the process and we have arrived at the numbers that we have talked about. The Government would fund the cost of the tribunal. David Storrie can say more about the engagement.
The cost of running the tribunal will be met by the Government. The cost of taking a case or defending it from a local authority perspective will be covered by the local authority, which will take the money from its administration fund for the levy.We have engaged primarily with the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service—from the Government’s side, on costing and, from the SCTS’s side, on ensuring that the caseload is anticipated and worked through.
My other question is on a potential clash. We might expect a high volume of appeals when it comes to non-domestic rates and the on-going revaluation exercise. Particularly in Edinburgh, given that the City of Edinburgh Council is taking forward its scheme earlier than other areas, is there potential for a high volume of claims on NDR to clash with claims on the visitor levy? Is the courts and tribunals system adequately resourced to cover such a pinch point?
Processes are on-going to deal with that, and the capacity of the system will be sized appropriately. We have looked incrementally at what might happen with visitor levy appeals and other appeals that are going through the system, be those on NDR or anything else. Those considerations will be taken into account. It is not the first time that we have done a revaluation. Knowledge and expertise will be brought to bear on the impact on the overall system as things move forward.Both those issues will be considered separately, but the cumulative effect will have been considered as well.
On reviews and appeals, I am interested in understanding whether more regulations are likely to be issued between now and the coming into operation of the first scheme, and whether updated guidance on the appeals process is now required.
I will let officials talk to the regulations that are coming forward. However, clearly, some regulations relate to the original act, and others may follow from the amendment bill that is going through at the moment.
When it comes to regulation, we have laid all the—I am sorry, I am searching for the word; my mind has gone blank. We have laid all the instruments for the 2024 act. Those under consideration today are the last aspect of ensuring that the enforcement of the original act can be taken forward, and we have nothing further to bring to the committee. These are the last of the batch of regulations to enact the original act.
We will look at that. We have statutory guidance through VisitScotland, which will need to be updated in line with where the Parliament takes the amendment bill. We will consider that in the round. The guidance has been published and is in the public domain. As we go through the bill process, we will consider possible tweaks and improvements. We are already on the second iteration, so it is not something that we are doing just for the bill. We will keep updating the guidance as and when required.
Great. Thanks very much for that evidence.Agenda item 7 is the formal consideration of two motions. The first is motion S6M-20735, which calls for the committee to recommend approval of the draft First-tier Tribunal for Scotland Local Taxation Chamber and Upper Tribunal for Scotland (Composition and Rules of Procedure) (Miscellaneous Amendment) Regulations 2026.Motion moved,That the Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee recommends that the First-tier Tribunal for Scotland Local Taxation Chamber and Upper Tribunal for Scotland (Composition and Rules of Procedure) (Miscellaneous Amendment) Regulations 2026 draft be approved.—Ivan McKeeMotion agreed to.
The second motion, S6M-20734, calls for the committee to recommend approval of the draft First-tier Tribunal for Scotland (Allocation of Functions to the Local Taxation Chamber) Regulations 2026.Motion moved,That the Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee recommends that the First-tier Tribunal for Scotland (Allocation of Functions to the Local Taxation Chamber) Regulations 2026 draft be approved.—Ivan McKeeMotion agreed to.
Following consideration of the instruments, members are invited to decide whether to consider a draft report in private at our meeting next week or to delegate responsibility to me to approve it for publication. Are members content to delegate responsibility to me?Members indicated agreement.
That concludes our formal consideration of those instruments, and I briefly suspend the meeting to allow the witnesses to leave.10:58Meeting suspended.10:59On resuming—
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.