Welcome back to this meeting of the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee. Item 6 is consideration of a further draft statutory instrument, the draft Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme (Amendment) (Extension to Maritime Activities) Order 2026. The Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee has made no comment on the instrument in its report.I welcome the Cabinet Secretary for Climate Action and Energy back to the meeting, together with her supporting officials from the Scottish Government: Kay White, the team lead; Lauchlan Hall, the senior policy adviser; and Julia Burgham Pearson, a lawyer.The instrument is laid under the affirmative procedure, which means that it cannot come into force unless the Parliament approves it. Following the evidence session, the committee will be invited to consider recommending that the instrument be approved. Officials cannot speak under that item, but they can speak in this one.Cabinet secretary, would you like to make a short opening statement? I do not mean to bounce you, but we got the information that the impact assessment had been laid on Friday afternoon, which was after the committee papers had gone out. If you would like to bring anything in that assessment to our attention, it would be helpful if you could use your statement to do that.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme (Amendment) (Extension to Maritime Activities) Order 2026 [Draft]
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Gillian Martin SNP 15
- Edward Mountain Con 8
- Douglas Lumsden Con 6
- Michael Matheson SNP 4
- Mark Ruskell Green 2
- Sarah Boyack Lab 1
The record
36 contributions
link
I am pleased to provide evidence supporting the draft Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme (Amendment) (Extension to Maritime Activities) Order 2026. The ETS authority, formed and jointly run by the four nations of the UK, is extending the scope of the scheme to include emissions from domestic maritime activities. That builds on the existing coverage of aviation, power generation and energy-intensive industries within the UK ETS. It incentivises cost-effective maritime decarbonisation and encourages efforts across our society and communities towards net zero goals.The expansion is focused on emissions related to domestic voyages between UK ports as well as emissions at berth in UK ports, and it will apply to ships of 5,000 gross tonnage or more. In response to extensive stakeholder feedback, there will be exemptions for specific activities, such as search and rescue activities and humanitarian aid, and specific types of ship, including publicly funded research vessels.Importantly for Scottish interests and for our support for islands and peninsular communities, ferry services in Scotland are also exempt from the scheme, as they maintain essential connectivity to those areas, and fish catching and processing vessels are also exempted. The instrument that is under consideration provides technical detail on the practical aspects of bringing the domestic maritime sector into the UK ETS, including on the regulation of operators, the monitoring and analysis methodology, and annual reporting on maritime emissions.As in other sectors that are included in the scheme, owners of in-scope vessels or, on their behalf, those to whom the responsibility is delegated will purchase allowances for each tonne of carbon dioxide emitted and surrender them at the end of each scheme year. For maritime emissions, there will be a surrender reduction for voyages between Great Britain and Northern Ireland, in order to avoid a carbon pricing imbalance.As the expansion to domestic maritime emissions will occur in July this year, arrangements will also be in place to allow double surrender of allowances for both the shorter 2026 and full 2027 scheme years by April 2028.The instrument adjusts the ETS cap to account for the maritime sector. The scheme will extend to vessels that provide support or services for offshore structures from January 2027. Including those ships at a later date is an alignment approach that is taken in the EU ETS that avoids market distortions ahead of their equivalent inclusion in the EU scheme.The ETS authority has consulted extensively on the inclusion of domestic maritime in the UK ETS, in order to ensure that it is incentivising emissions reduction in a way that is fair and that accounts for industry best practice. In doing so, it has engaged with businesses across the UK and has held specific workshops with our island communities.The instrument represents an important step in the on-going development of the UK ETS, recognises the importance of maritime operations to our economy and net zero journey, and lays the groundwork for future expansion to international voyages, which was the subject of a recent authority-wide consultation.The business and regulatory impact assessment for the instrument was laid on 30 January, after extensive engagement with Scottish businesses.
Thank you, cabinet secretary. What are the main impacts on Scottish businesses and individuals of the introduction of the maritime sector to the UK ETS next year?
link
Mainly because of the exemptions, there is a very limited impact on Scotland-based operators. Approximately 96 per cent of the costs are expected to fall on international operators. We did extensive work with island communities and operators, and, as a result, we very quickly decided to exclude fishing and fish processing vessels and lifeline ferry services for island and peninsula communities, for the reasons that I set out in my statement.
I see that ferries to Scottish islands will be exempt from the introduction of the ETS and that the exemption will be reviewed in 2028. My brief research suggests that, for example, the MV Hamnavoe would fall comfortably within the weight limit for the ETS if the ferries exemption was not extended. Will the Government continue to push for the ferries exemption from the ETS?
link
I cannot pre-empt what the review will say, but the reasons for having the exemption in the first place are to do with the islands impact assessment and the lifeline nature of the ferry services. I do not think that that will change, but the review will take place.
Okay. Do you think that the tonnage limit will ever come down? If it came down too much, the MPV Jura, which is one of our main fisheries protection vessels, might fall within it.
link
A four-nations discussion needs to take place. As you rightly say, a 5,000-tonne threshold applies. The review in 2028 will consider whether the threshold should be lowered in the future, but that discussion will happen between the four nations and it will have to take into account the socioeconomic impacts of the inclusion of smaller ships. In the brief discussion that we have had, we have talked about the lifeline nature of the services and the fact that fishing vessels are important to the socioeconomic aspects of communities around Scotland. We will bring all that intelligence and those arguments to the fore in 2028 as well.
I hope that, in 2028, somebody will remember that I have mentioned maritime protection vessels when it comes to the tonnage limit.The deputy convener has a question.
You said that 96 per cent of the vessels that will be captured are internationally based. What are the primary options that are available to them to reduce their emissions?
link
There are two aspects. First, there is the fuel that they use for travelling. There are different types of fuel, and fuel switching might be available. Secondly, there is the fuel that they use when they are berthed. It is going to be an interesting innovation for Scottish ports to be able to offer different options. When I was at Montrose port a couple of months ago, there was discussion about the fact that ships can get green electric power while they are berthed there, rather than using diesel. There could be good opportunities for ports to offer different types of fuel supply to vessels that are berthed.
Are alternative options available for the fuel that vessels use for travelling? It will probably be much more difficult for large vessels to be hybrid or electrified. I do not know whether electric generators would be able to generate the levels of power that they need. I am keen to understand that.12:45
link
That is not my area of expertise, but the negotiations considered the different types of biofuels that might be available. It is ultimately for the shipping companies and the international operators to decide how they want to decarbonise and to consider the fuel options that are available to them. They could decide that some vessels are not able to decarbonise to a certain extent and that they will pay the fees and additional costs that are associated with not decarbonising. As an example of such decarbonisation, when cruise ships berth in UK ports, I hope that they will be able to take on an electric fuel supply to reduce the use of diesel.
Unless diesel is being used to generate the electricity—that is the challenge.
link
I have an example in my mind of a particular port that is using green electricity, but you are absolutely right that, if the electricity is being generated by diesel, there will not be an impact on the level of carbon emissions.The instrument is meant to incentivise a reduction in emissions. Given that wind energy is being constrained in Scotland, as we all know, there is a big opportunity for ports to make arrangements with generators to utilise green electricity that would otherwise be constrained.
Okay. Thanks.
How many ports in Scotland presently have the capability for cruise ships to connect and use electricity?
link
I do not have that data in front of me—I would need to speak to my transport colleagues about that.
Would it be a good idea to have an audit, so that people can see exactly what is planned at the ports?
link
It is very possible that the information already exists and that the Scottish Government already has it; I just do not have it in front of me now.
Would you be able to send that information to the committee?
link
Yes, I will speak to our colleagues in other departments and get that information.
Thank you.What is your plan for furthering the decarbonisation of vessels that are below the 5,000-tonne threshold?
link
You would need to speak to the Cabinet Secretary for Transport about that, because I do not have that information. I do not want to get into something that is not in my particular portfolio. If you are talking about fishing vessels, Ms Gougeon will have information about incentivisation in that regard. However, I can certainly find that out from those portfolio areas.
I was thinking more about the climate change plan. Is there any mention of how we will decarbonise some of the smaller vessels that are below the 5,000-tonne limit?
link
I will need to look into that, but, if those vessels want to decarbonise and stop using diesel, the most readily available option for them would be to use biofuels.
Okay. Thanks.
It would be good to get some joined-up thinking. We have talked before about opportunities for biofuels, and it would be interesting to see biofuels or electrification used in different ports when charging cruise ships.However, my question is about what the estimated reduction in emissions in Scotland will be from bringing in these proposals. The estimate is that domestic shipping makes up 5 per cent of the UK’s transport emissions, which is more than our rail and bus networks. What will be the overall reduction in emissions by agreeing to this piece of legislation?
link
I do not have an estimate of the particular emissions reduction that will be associated with the instrument. If there is any information on that, it will likely be a UK-wide estimate. However, we can write to the committee. If we have the information, I will get a letter back to the committee on all these detailed questions about specific issues, but I have information only about the instrument with me today.
link
I am interested in how the decarbonisation that will occur as a result of the instrument will link into the climate change plan, which we have just been scrutinising. I do not think that the plan contains a particular figure for shipping, unless shipping is listed separately from maritime figures. There is no assumption in the CCP of carbon reduction.
link
I would need to look at the climate change plan. It is a draft plan at the moment. If we have the figures that are associated with this particular instrument and if they are not already in the climate change plan—I do not believe that they are—then we could, as we are finalising the plan, and if the figures are large enough to make a difference to the plan, put them into it.
link
There are some chunky emissions figures that are associated with domestic shipping, as Sarah Boyack has already alluded to. It would be good to get a sense of the cross-Government programme of engagement that is taking place with the different sectors to consider options. For example, there is a pelagic fishing fleet that is based largely in Shetland, where quite large vessels—up to 4,000 tonnes—are doing what they do. It feels that there is low-hanging fruit that can be drawn into the climate change plan.
link
I will look into whether an exact assessment has been done on that particular issue and get back to the committee.
If would be helpful if you could feed that information in before we see you next week, so that we could consider it as part of our evidence session on the climate change plan. I am sure that your officials will love that suggestion.As there are no further questions, we move to consideration of motion S6M-20456.Motion moved,That the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee recommends that the Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme (Amendment) (Extension to Maritime Activities) Order 2026 draft be approved.—Gillian MartinMotion agreed to.
I invite the committee to delegate authority to me, as convener, to approve a draft of our report on the instrument for publication. Interruption. Well, if you are not happy, Mr Matheson, then, as deputy convener, you can write the report. However, I note that you are happy for me to do so.Do members agree to delegate authority to me?Members indicated agreement.
That is all that we will discuss in public. We will now move into private.12:51Meeting continued in private until 12:59.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportNo recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Feb 2026 →- 08:55 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 08:55 Draft Climate Change Plan Evidence session · 155
- 08:55 Budget Scrutiny 2026-27 Evidence session · 125
- 08:55 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 30
- 08:55 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 36
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.