The safety net of social security is something that we all value, but Scotland’s towering benefits bill stands at around £7 billion a year and is due to reach almost £10 billion by the end of the decade. I have said before and will say again that benefit spending is out of control. We know that it is unfair, unaffordable and unsustainable. Does John Swinney agree, or does he think that the Scottish National Party’s benefits system is fair, affordable and sustainable?
John SwinneySNPThe First Minister · Perthshire North
I think that the approach that the Scottish Government takes to benefits is based on the principles of fairness and dignity that this Parliament legislated for. I am proud to associate my Government with those values, which are enshrined in statute. I believe that the benefit system in Scotland is sustainable, as is demonstrated by this Government’s ability to ensure effective budget planning to meet all those commitments.
I make no apology whatsoever for being determined to protect the vulnerable in our society and to lift children out of poverty. That is what my Government is all about.
That is not sustainable. Just this morning, the Scottish Fiscal Commission told Parliament that the only ways to plug the benefits gap would be either by having higher taxes or by cutting money from public services. John Swinney cannot admit it, but the SNP’s benefits system is broken.
It is deeply concerning that, in some cases, the system acts as a deterrent to work. The Government’s own review of the Scottish child payment revealed that some parents turn down extra work or stop working altogether and that some even told their bosses that they did not want a pay rise, because extra pay would reduce their benefits, meaning that they would end up with less money.
We say that limiting the payment to two children per family would be a fair way to address that. [Interruption].
Surely people should be better off working than being on benefits. Is John Swinney really content with a system that encourages people to turn down a pay rise?
John SwinneySNPThe First Minister · Perthshire North
The Government’s approach to eradicating child poverty involves a number of measures, one of which is about putting in place effective support for employability to enable parents to get into employment. The measures in the budget also support that by providing wraparound childcare and breakfast clubs so that we can ensure that more parents can get into employment.
I want to see more parents getting into employment so that their families can be lifted out of poverty, but what I will not do and what I am absolutely determined that my Government will never do is punish the vulnerable in our society. Russell Findlay’s support for the two-child cap is a demonstration that the nasty party is back good and proper in the Conservative Party.
I will read to John Swinney a line from his Government’s report, which he has probably not even read. It comes from a parent who spoke to the report’s authors.
“I even asked my line manager not to move me up my annual pay award band because it would have meant maybe a £30 or £40 a month addition on my salary for myself, but it would have cost me around £300 in benefits.”
Encouraging people not to work is absurd and harmful, but that is not the only problem with a benefit system that SNP politicians love to boast is “light touch”. That might explain the following: in the rest of the United Kingdom, an average of 8,000 people are prosecuted for benefit fraud every year, but Social Security Scotland has reported only 29 cases to prosecutors in almost three years. Most claimants are honest, but those numbers strongly suggest that fraudsters are exploiting the SNP’s light touch system and getting away with it—[Interruption.]
When we established Social Security Scotland, the Scottish Government included measures that were designed to tackle any fraud that is perpetrated within the benefits system. The development of all that activity has been pursued by Social Security Scotland, with reference to the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service when it is appropriate for individuals to be prosecuted.
I accept the importance of ensuring that payments are made only to those who are entitled to them and that fraud should be pursued where there is any evidence of fraud. However, what I will not do is get into the gutter with Mr Findlay to attack vulnerable people in our society. The Government will ensure that there is proper support to vulnerable people as part of our efforts to lift families out of poverty. That is the mission of my Government.
John Swinney can hurl all the nonsense insults that he wants, but the reality is that Scotland cannot afford to pay for the SNP’s spiralling benefits bill.
To recap, we know that the SNP’s light-touch system deters work and is wide open to fraud, and that it spends—right now—more than £1 billion more on benefits than it receives in funding for them. Incredibly, Labour and Reform are okay with that. Four months ago, Audit Scotland said that John Swinney’s Government had no plan to plug the benefits black hole. There is still no plan, unless John Swinney is keeping it a secret from us.
We do have a plan. We identify £1 billion—[Interruption.]
We identify £1 billion-worth of savings that can be achieved through a series of reasonable proposals. Those savings would be used to cut taxes for hard-working Scots who are being hammered by Labour and the SNP. Is it not the case that cutting taxes for the lowest paid, rather than increasing benefits, is the best way to lift people out of poverty?
John SwinneySNPThe First Minister · Perthshire North
Mr Findlay comes along to First Minister’s questions and sets out his stall. We now have another chapter of that, with the hostile attitude towards vulnerable people in our society that is consistently represented by the Conservative Party. He also comes along and argues for £1 billion-worth of tax cuts for individuals in Scotland, without a scrap of evidence of being able to deliver any of those tax cuts, because they will undermine public services in our country. [Interruption.]
It would be helpful if we could hear one another. I have a lot of colleagues who would like to get in today. Let us make sure that we can hear one another.
John SwinneySNPThe First Minister · Perthshire North
When it comes to the sustainability of the public finances, I will pay not very much attention to what Mr Findlay says to me. I will pay more attention to what the credit ratings agencies say about my Government. What they say is that—[Interruption.]
Members! [Interruption.] If there are members who just want to come and have a good shout, perhaps they need to consider whether their behaviour is appropriate.
John SwinneySNPThe First Minister · Perthshire North
I will not listen to what Russell Findlay says to me about the sustainability of the public finances. I will rely on what the credit ratings agencies say, which is that this Government represents “prudent” financial management in Scotland. That is how we deliver sustainability in the public finances, and people can rely on an SNP Government to do exactly that.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.