link
Good morning, and welcome to the second meeting of the Rural Affairs and Islands Committee in 2026. Before we begin, I remind everyone to turn their electronic devices to silent. I put on the record that Emma Harper joins us remotely today.The first item on the agenda is an evidence session on the Scottish Government’s draft climate change plan. This week, we will focus on the agricultural chapter of the draft plan by taking evidence from two panels of witnesses.First, we will hear from a panel of stakeholders from the agriculture sector. I welcome to the meeting Emma Patterson Taylor, project manager, Scottish Agricultural Organisation Society; Donna Smith, chief executive, Scottish Crofting Federation; Lorna Scott, senior policy manager for climate, land and business, NFU Scotland; and Nim Kibbler, Scotland manager for the Nature Friendly Farming Network, representing the Scottish Agroecology Partnership.Edward Mountain MSP will join us later in the meeting, and he will have the opportunity to ask questions at the end of our questions.As always—sadly—on this committee, we are limited in time. I therefore ask members and participants to be succinct with their questions and answers. I remind witnesses that they will not need to operate their microphones, as a gentleman will do that for them.I will kick off with a fairly broad question. Emissions from the agricultural sector have broadly remained stable since 2020, despite earlier predictions of decline. What is the main reason for the gap between policy expectations and on-farm outcomes?


