Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Terrestrial Trunked Radio Communication Masts (PE650)

Wednesday 31 March 2004 Communities Committee Petitions 15 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

15 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

I welcome Mark Ruskell MSP. He is here to speak to petition PE650 on terrestrial trunked radio communication masts in Scotland. Petition PE650 is from Alison Mackay on behalf of a group called NO 2 TETRA Scotland.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Thank you convener. I will try to keep my comments brief; I know that you have a busy agenda.I want to make two points. The first concerns timescales. There is increasing public alarm about the roll-out of the TETRA police communication system. I first became aware of the issue at this time last year, before I was elected, when I attended a public meeting in Cupar. Since then, seven community-based campaign groups have been established in the Mid Scotland and Fife region alone, and I gather that other groups in other parts of Scotland are as concerned as we are about the system.The roll-out of the TETRA system has proceeded at a pace similar to that of the growing public concern. The background information in the committee's paper on the petition notes that 14 planning applications have been lodged in Fife but that Fife Council has held back on approving them until health studies have been completed. Since that information was presented to the Public Petitions Committee, 12 of the masts have been approved. Indeed, as we sit here this morning, another planning application for a mast is going before Fife Council for approval. This is all happening ahead of an NHS monitoring study into the only active TETRA mast in operation in Fife.Timescales are an issue. Roll-out is happening apace and public concern is growing apace. Now is the right time for a parliamentary committee to consider the issue that the petitioners have raised.My second point concerns the difference between conventional mobile phone technology and TETRA. The worry among communities and independent scientists is to do with the perception that TETRA masts pulse; they use different technology from the mobile phone technology that we are all used to. Scientists disagree over whether the masts pulse and there are concerns that the standards that are applied to mobile telecommunications technology predate TETRA and therefore do not deal with specific concerns about the technology. Government advice refers to the precautionary principle, which suggests that we should not be rolling out such low-frequency telecommunication systems until studies have been completed.There has been some delay in correspondence with the Public Petitions Committee but I believe that the time is right for an inquiry to take place. That inquiry should focus on the specific concerns that are raised in respect of TETRA, rather than rerun the entire mobile phone inquiry that took place in the first session of the Parliament.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

Thank you—I appreciate your brevity. Do any members wish to comment?

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

We will hear a ministerial statement tomorrow on planning and planning consultation; we have heard about GM crops, about pylons that are 70 feet higher and about wind farms. We now have TETRA masts as well. All these alleged health concerns are coming up, so this might be an opportune time to ask whether health concerns will be addressed in the forthcoming planning bill or will go out to consultation. I understand that the Scottish Executive is helping to fund research into TETRA masts—either research on their health impacts or a review of the available research—which will be published this year. At what point in 2004 is that likely to appear?From reading the background papers, I gained an impression that England was the guinea pig for TETRA masts before Scotland. However, the information that I have received from Newport-on-Tay, Kirriemuir and from Sussex and elsewhere—where TETRA masts already exist—shows that local communities and about 200 police officers who use TETRA handsets have been complaining about various health effects, including headaches, nosebleeds, nausea, disorientation, confusion, lack of concentration, dizziness and interrupted sleep.I have read the Stewart report, which recommends, for example, that mobile phones should not be used by young children of about eight or 10 who have developing brains. However, no such warning is given on the box or in the instructions for a mobile phone. I spent four years on the then Health and Community Care Committee dealing with various petitions, so I would be a little bit more cautious before giving the proposal the green light. I would like more information to be brought before us before we rubber-stamp the idea. There are serious concerns and we owe it to those who have expressed those concerns to do as much as we can to get hold of the available information before we comment.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

I agree with much of what Mary Scanlon says. I think that the Stewart report also recommended that mobile phone masts should not be located near primary schools and other places where children gather and play. I was concerned to read in the committee papers that some TETRA masts will be located in such areas, so I urge adoption of the precautionary principle. The recommendations in our papers are quite reasonable.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

My experience of telecommunication masts in my constituency is that a decision not to erect a mast in a school, based on the precautionary principle, can have the unintended consequence of a mast being erected on private land opposite the school. If you think about it, it is probably safer to have the mast cascading outwards from the school than it is to have it across the road, from where it cascades on the kids. Another problem was that, because the masts were not allowed in parks, they were erected in residential areas, where children play at night. We have to keep an eye on such issues.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

The Stewart report said that the masts should not be located near schools or places where children play. One of the reasons why they were not erected in schools was that a number of councils put a moratorium on them to ensure that they did not have masts on council land and buildings.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

My point is that the good principles that were being operated by local authorities and employers who were concerned about the health effects of the masts resulted in their being erected in areas over which the community had no control. The most vulnerable group of people—owner-occupiers with a lot of children—were worst affected. That was my direct experience of use of the precautionary principle, but that is an argument for another day.What Mary Scanlon says about the planning bill is important. Many of the issues around community involvement and so on should be addressed by the committee when we gather evidence during stage 1 of that bill. That process will enable us to explore generally many related issues. Mary Scanlon said that we should not give a green light to the proposal, but the reality is that the mast-erection programme is on-going. The green light has already been given.Are people happy that we follow the recommendation to ask the Executive for the research? We should gather as much information as possible before we consider the matter further. The Public Petitions Committee suggested that we might want to consult the Environment and Rural Development Committee and the Health Committee. Are members content with those recommendations? Members indicated agreement.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

Do members want to add anything further?

Shiona Baird Green North East Scotland
link

My concern is that, as you rightly point out, the masts are going up while we are taking evidence and considering the matter. We must proceed with as much speed as possible, otherwise any work that is done by the committee will be negated by the fact that the programme will have been rolled out. I urge the committee to take action as swiftly as possible, although that might not be easy. The matter is serious because the precautionary principle is not being observed.

Donald Gorrie LD Central Scotland
link

The matter is slightly like the previous one in that many—presumably well-informed—people are saying totally different things on the same subject. If there is evidence from England that police personnel have complained about the system, it might be worth contacting the chief inspector of constabulary in Scotland to ask whether he is aware of complaints about the system by the police elsewhere in the UK.The general situation is difficult. There is a Latin tag to the effect that everything unknown is considered dangerous. When a funny new mast is put up or a new system installed, people in a community are naturally apprehensive, which is quite understandable. The difficulty is in ascertaining whether the science backs up their fears. Scientists from different sides bombard us with different stories. It would help to try to get the official position from the Executive, but we should also contact the police.

Campbell Martin SNP West of Scotland
link

I am happy to follow the recommendations. Mary Scanlon described the symptoms of people who live close to TETRA masts in England, but that situation does not exist only in England. The symptoms are similar to those that have been described by people who have lived around the Firth of Clyde for a number of years. One of the suggested reasons for the symptoms was transmissions between submerged submarines and their bases on land. That was never fully investigated and ruled out. It would be remiss of the committee and Parliament not to fully investigate the potential harm of TETRA, given the symptoms that have been experienced by people in the Firth of Clyde, particularly in Largs. There might be something in the similarity between their symptoms and those of the people in England who live near TETRA masts.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

Donald Gorrie's suggestion that we contact the police to ask how they monitor their personnel is worth while. We should ask what process they follow. At what point would the situation become critical and cause them to deal with it? The police must have internal processes and systems to deal with reported complaints. Are they in dialogue with their colleagues down south to establish to what extent the matter is a concern there, and to what extent they are dealing with it? Are we content with those additions—that we contact the Executive in the first instance to ask about its research and for its comments? We should make a commitment to the planning legislation because the process is out of kilter with the concerns of communities. The situation is on-going, but concerns are building up. Those concerns might be unfounded, but we must ask to what extent the Executive can reassure people as the process continues. Is that agreed?

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Do I take it that the committee will refer other aspects to the Health Committee for it to consider?

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

The committee agrees to consult the Environment and Rural Development Committee and the Health Committee on the issues that have been raised, as suggested by the Public Petitions Committee.

  1. Scottish Parliament Communities Committee Wednesday 31 March 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 1
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  4. Petitions Petitions · 1
  5. Petitions Petitions · 12
  6. Petitions Petitions · 15
  7. Petitions Petitions · 7
  8. Budget Process 2005-06 Committee business · 110

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.