We come first to petition PE374, on chronic pain management. The committee agreed to await the publication of a Scottish Executive-commissioned review of chronic pain services, the report of which is reproduced as an annex to paper HC/S2/04/30/4, together with a letter from the Minister for Health and Community Care. A note of suggested possible action is included in paragraphs 10 to 12 of the paper. I think this is the petition on which Mary Scanlon wanted to comment. Do you want to go first, Mary?
Official Report · Committee
Petitions
Chronic Pain Management (PE374)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 6
- Duncan McNeil Lab 3
- Helen Eadie Lab 2
- David Davidson Con 2
- Mary Scanlon Con 1
- Dr Jean Turner Ind 1
The record
15 contributionsThank you for letting me go first, convener. It is nice to be back at the Health Committee.I am the convener of the Scottish Parliament cross-party group on chronic pain and my deputy is Dr Jean Turner, who is here. The group's initial response was that the report from Professor McEwen is excellent; it has been very well received. I have been asked to remind members that the pain clinic in Perth is still functioning only because some of the clinicians from Ninewells hospital rescued it after it ceased to operate. Such situations exist throughout Scotland.Provision in the Highlands has been highlighted on page 10 of paper HC/S2/04/30/4, which states:"Highland Health Board does not claim to provide a comprehensive service, but consultant led pain clinics are held at Caithness General Hospital and Belford"—which is in Fort William. Page 11 of the paper states that"All boards with the exception of Highland have one or more identified consultant anaesthetists with special responsibility for chronic pain. All the mainland health boards with the exception of Highland employ nurses with special responsibility for chronic pain."I am delighted that that has been highlighted and I support the comments in the report's recommendations. I hope that the committee can work together with the cross-party group in providing feedback.I am also pleased to see what the minister has had to say in sending out the report to health boards. NHS Quality Improvement Scotland has asked to consult the cross-party group on chronic pain on a best-practice statement on management of chronic pain in adults. I phoned NHSQIS today; it will consider recommendation 12 from Professor McEwen's report, which is for a national framework and for people to work together. We are moving on from the report to a quality management statement.I counted about 20 "shoulds" in the recommendations. If Highland NHS Board intends to ignore Professor McEwen's report and NHSQIS's best practice statement, what will happen? That is the point to which we always seem to return and which I leave with committee members.
It is very good that so many people are engaged in trying to tackle this very worrying issue. It would be particularly helpful if we could follow one or more of the suggestions that have been put to us in the papers; there are several good suggestions. We should write to the Scottish Executive requesting that it report to the committee on the outcome of the consensus conference. That would be particularly helpful. Various other recommendations are set out in the paper.
You are saying that we should adopt the procedure in paragraph 10 of the paper.
There are a couple of issues that go along with that. I support Helen Eadie in suggesting that we follow the recommendations. We need to ask the Scottish Executive—or someone—to examine the cost to Scotland of chronic pain and where the cost savings could come from if we had managed clinical networks and a proper framework. That would quantify some of the issues that surround the petition. We should continue with the petition, but we need to know what the Executive is doing and what its consideration is.
I take it that your position is to adopt the course of action that is recommended in paragraph 10, but that you would add quantification of the current cost of not dealing with chronic pain.
I would also like to know the cost of putting in place a framework. My only qualification is that we should write to the minister asking when the Executive expects to be in a position to respond.
I agree with everything that has been said. I thought that Professor McEwen had looked at some costs. What stands out is that pain clinics save poor patients who suffer chronic pain, and their families, a lot of hardship. Professor McEwen says:"The evidence that is available suggests that pain clinics reduce overall direct health care costs by about £1000 per patient per year."Because of the Health Committee's recent work and the fact that we do not know how many people are in our hospitals, it is almost imperative that we deal with chronic illnesses. If we can get our national strategy right, we might help patients and save money. I go along with everything that has been said.
Were the report, its conclusions and recommendations drawn up before we got the letter from the minister? How does the minister's very positive communication to the health boards impact on the recommendations? We should take into account the minister's very positive letter. It might be going some way towards fulfilling the recommendations so that we might not necessarily need to repeat the actions.
I assume that the minister's letter was written after the minister received the report. However, the Health Committee received both at the same time. I dare say that the minister received the report and then wrote the letter.
That might be the point that I am making. We produced this report and called on the Scottish Executive to do certain things, but we did not know about the very positive letter from the minister.
Do you disagree with the course of action that is suggested in paragraph 10?
I am just being lazy, but I am not the only one, by the looks of things. Has the very positive letter from the minister, as acknowledged by Mary Scanlon, impacted on the recommendations in the paper? Is the minister already offering what we are calling for?
The bottom line is that both developments are very encouraging. What the minister suggests he will do is to be welcomed, but the committee is suggesting some good actions which are also very helpful. We are all pushing together in the same direction to address a serious problem.
The recommendations in the paper were drawn up on the basis that we had the report and the minister's letter. I do not think that the report and the minister's letter necessarily negate the committee's continuing to question people along the suggested lines, but we must also acknowledge that the ministerial response was positive. It is more a question of establishing how far that positive response will go in reality.Are members happy to base our response on the actions that paragraph 10 outlines? We could expand those to include members' comments. Nevertheless, we can make the point that we are grateful to the minister for his positive response.Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 14 Dec 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Health Committee Tuesday 14 December 2004 Committee business · 1
- Items in Private Procedure · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Petitions Petitions · 1
- Petitions Petitions · 15
- Petitions Petitions · 9
- Petitions Petitions · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.