The final petition is PE650. I welcome Mark Ruskell, who has been patient.The petition was referred by the Public Petitions Committee to the Communities Committee, which agreed to consult this committee. The Communities Committee is still considering the petition. Members should bear with me—we are nearly finished. The petition was forwarded to us to allow us to consider its health implications. Members may give their views once Mark Ruskell has spoken. This is the first time that we have considered the petition.
Official Report · Committee
Petitions
Terrestrial Trunked Radio Communication Masts (PE650)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Christine Grahame SNP 6
- Janis Hughes Lab 3
- Mark Ruskell Green 2
- Shona Robison SNP 2
- David Davidson Con 1
- Helen Eadie Lab 1
The record
17 contributions
link
I will take no more than a minute or two, as the committee has had a mammoth session.I should emphasise that a degree of urgency surrounds many issues with which the petition is concerned. The public is concerned by the issue, which first came to my attention in April last year, before I was elected, when I attended a public meeting in Cupar in Fife. That meeting was about TETRA, which is a new type of mobile communication system. In the 12 months since that meeting, seven community-based campaign groups that are concerned about TETRA technology have been set up in Mid Scotland and Fife alone. Many of those groups have organised public meetings, which have sometimes been attended by more than 200 people. There is a lot of public concern.While that concern has mounted, the TETRA communications system has been rolled out throughout Scotland and local authorities have approved new TETRA masts. In fact, the briefing material that members have received from the Communities Committee is now out of date. I think that, apart from two applications, all the 14 applications in Fife, which Fife Council was holding back on, have now been approved. The system will be operational in Dumfries and Galloway in the summer.The petition was lodged last autumn. The Executive, the Public Petitions Committee and the company have corresponded, but I do not believe that the correspondence has addressed many issues that the petitioners are concerned about and it might be time to take oral evidence and to consider the issues that are involved.The petitioners' concerns are not about mobile phones as a whole. I am aware that an inquiry into mobile telecommunications masts took place in the first session of Parliament. The specific concern of the petitioners and of many communities throughout Scotland is that the TETRA system pulses using very low frequency radiation. The companies that are involved and members of the scientific community disagree about whether the masts pulse.Another concern is about the potential health effects of the masts and handsets that will be used by the emergency services, starting with the police this summer. Further, the standards that have been devised for mobile communications systems predate the new technology—they deal with the mobile phones that we are used to using, not mobile telecommunications systems that use the very low frequency. The Stewart committee said that we should use the precautionary principle in relation to the new technology. We should not roll out a system that uses low frequency radiation until we are sure about the health effects.The committee could examine those issues. The petitioners have not yet given oral evidence to a committee, although they have been working with scientists who are concerned about the contradictions in the standards and in the evidence on whether the system pulses, which is the petitioners' primary concern.
It is fairly common knowledge that, in the past three to five years, the science community has not agreed about the safety of new systems, as a result of which certain areas in other parts of the UK have declined to use them, either because of the potential risk or because of inefficiencies in the process. Frankly, I do not think that the committee is qualified to deal with the science aspects, although we are concerned about the public concern. We need to collate information on various aspects of the science from both sides of the argument. Perhaps a body such as the Royal Society ought to consider the issue on a UK basis.When systems are rolled out, the planning authorities often have no positive evidence to argue against them. If an application does not breach the local plan or the strategic plan, the planning authority cannot do much about it. If we do not get the science right and do not have the knowledge, none of the committees of the Parliament can reach a firm conclusion and give the system a clean bill of health. I agree with Mr Ruskell that we should adopt the precautionary principle, but if we are to take evidence on the matter, we must do so in conjunction with Westminster.
I was a member of the Transport and the Environment Committee in the first session of Parliament when it carried out an inquiry into telecommunications masts, which concluded that no conclusive evidence existed and encouraged the use of the precautionary principle. The Transport and the Environment Committee took evidence from a huge number of people, which included evidence on the health aspects. I make that point because I think that the matter is best taken in the round, as part of a Communities Committee inquiry on the issue, if it intends to carry out such an inquiry. I do not know what can be gained from our input, except if it is asked for.
For clarification, was a report issued as part of the Transport and the Environment Committee inquiry to which you refer?
Yes.
Mr Ruskell, were you aware of that?
link
I am aware of the good work that was done in session 1, but it did not relate to the TETRA system. Perhaps the heading for PE650 in the agenda is misleading. We are talking not about mobile phone communication masts but about terrestrial trunked radio masts, which are a different technology that was not considered in session 1 because it did not exist then.
I was simply suggesting that the petition could be dealt with by the Communities Committee. We have been asked to comment; my comment is that if the Communities Committee is to carry out an inquiry, it should take evidence on the potential health aspects in the round, rather than have a two-committee discussion.
Like Janis Hughes, I was a member of the committee that examined the issue. We found that a scientific committee has been set up at European level to investigate the issues. David Davidson's point that we must have regard to the science is well made. If the petition is to go anywhere, it should go to the Communities Committee and be considered in conjunction with work at European level.
We must recognise the huge concern about the issue. I was contacted by constituents this morning about proposals. Has the Communities Committee offered to carry out an inquiry?
The Communities Committee is in the same position with this petition as it is with the petition that we discussed earlier.
We should suggest to the Communities Committee that there are unanswered questions, that more work needs to be done on the matter and that we hope that that committee will be able to do that work. If required, we will have input through a reporter.
We do not need to agree on a reporter today. We will defer the matter until we see what the Communities Committee decides to do.Before members leave, I have an issue to raise. I am sure that members have read in the newspapers that the former chief executive of NHS Scotland, Geoff Scaife, was killed in a dreadful car crash on Tuesday 20 April. He leaves a wife and four children. Do members agree that we should write with condolences to his family and his former team members?
Members indicated agreement.
That concludes the meeting. I thank members for their forbearance in a sauna. We will try to meet in the chamber next time, where it is cold.
Meeting closed at 17:32.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Apr 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Health Committee Tuesday 27 April 2004 (Afternoon) Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 55
- Budget Process 2005-06 Committee business · 155
- Petitions Petitions · 1
- Petitions Petitions · 18
- Petitions Petitions · 2
- Petitions Petitions · 4
- Petitions Petitions · 2
- Petitions Petitions · 15
- Petitions Petitions · 8
- Petitions Petitions · 10
- Petitions Petitions · 4
- Petitions Petitions · 9
- Petitions Petitions · 21
- Petitions Petitions · 4
- Petitions Petitions · 10
- Petitions Petitions · 41
- Petitions Petitions · 17
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.