Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Eating Disorders (Treatment) (PE609)

Tuesday 13 January 2004 Health Committee Petitions 11 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

11 contributions
Janis Hughes Lab The Deputy Convener · Glasgow Rutherglen
link

We have one new petition to consider, which is PE609, from Mrs Gráinne Smith, on behalf of North East Eating Disorders Support (Scotland) and the Scottish Eating Disorder Interest Group. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to ask the Scottish Executive to address, develop and fund specialised treatment of eating disorders.The Public Petitions Committee considered the petition last March and sought information from the Executive. In December, the Public Petitions Committee agreed to refer the petition to the Health Committee for consideration. With the petition, that committee sent the response that it received from the Scottish Executive, which is fairly detailed and is among members' papers. Are there any comments?

David Davidson Con North East Scotland
link

First, I declare an interest as the father of a sufferer of an eating disorder. I know Gráinne Smith very well. I have attended some of her support group's meetings in different parts of the north-east and I assure members that all that she says about her experience is absolutely genuine and valid. She is highly respected.Yesterday in Edinburgh, Dr Harry Millar from the Royal Cornhill hospital in Aberdeen and Dr Chris Freeman from the Cullen centre here in Edinburgh addressed a conference. As medical professionals who work in the national health service, they called upon the Scottish Executive to develop services within the NHS on a dedicated-treatment basis, not just on an out-patient basis. At the moment, the Huntingdon day hospital in central Scotland, which is a dedicated unit for 16 to 24-year-olds, is not receiving patients from health boards because health board professionals are seeking to develop services within the NHS, and are terrified about what will happen if the money starts to flow out in larger amounts. At the moment, Grampian NHS Board spends £400,000 a year on the private sector where, in some cases, it is actually cheaper to provide treatment. There is a crisis.Over the past three or four years, I have taken evidence from individuals and groups all over Scotland to the effect that there is difficulty in assessing eating disorders at an early stage, and in accessing dedicated residential care. Usually, by the time people get into such care they are at a life-threatening stage. The other issue is follow-up services in the community once people have partially recovered. That has all been requested not just by Gráinne Smith, but by all the health service professionals. There are not many of them, but they are good dedicated people.This is an important subject, which cannot be dealt with in a matter of weeks. I ask the committee to support the petition and, when time permits, to take evidence or ask the Scottish Executive about it. Malcolm Chisholm has told me twice in the chamber that the Scottish Executive mental health framework is supportive, but the Executive will do nothing about the problem, because it says that responsibility for that lies with individual health boards. However, every health board to which I have spoken on the subject—most boards in Scotland—says that it does not have the resources or the capability to deal with it. One or two, such as Highland NHS Board and Grampian NHS board, are working together to do something.Frankly, we must press the minister for a clearer response, if only to the appeals of those who have eating disorders, those who support them and the professionals in the health service who are desperate to make provision.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

The Executive's letter makes it clear that we would be pushing at an open door because the Executive is willing to explore ways of examining best practice in other European countries. That prompts me to suggest that we have two possible options. Bearing in mind our work programme, which we will consider later, we can either conduct our own inquiry with a reporter, or we can refer the petition back to the Public Petitions Committee for further consideration. I favour the latter option because I am a member of the Public Petitions Committee and I know that it is keen to undertake such work.I hope that I am not out of order in suggesting that, because I have just realised that that was the view of the previous convener and committee. I do not know the views of the new convener or the new Public Petitions Committee on the matter. However, the new Public Petitions Committee seems to be keen to undertake work on a petition that would result in a report. If we are to be polite about it, we should ask our clerks to liaise with the Public Petitions Committee's clerks in order to find out from its convener whether that committee would be willing to undertake an inquiry into the petition's concerns.

Janis Hughes Lab The Deputy Convener · Glasgow Rutherglen
link

I intended to seek your advice on the petition because you are, as you said, a member of the Public Petitions Committee. When the Public Petitions Committee first discussed the petition it agreed to write to the Royal College of Psychiatrists, but that body does not seem to have responded. I believe that the Public Petitions Committee discussed the petition again in December, when it agreed to pass it to the Health Committee. Our work programme means that we can consider a limited number of new inquiries. Would the Public Petitions Committee be able to take the petition further?

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

We would need to ask that committee. I know that the previous Public Petitions Committee wanted to undertake more detailed work on some petitions. The Conveners Group likes committees to follow protocol, which means that the Health Committee must ensure that the Public Petitions Committee would be happy to take the petition further. It is a question of following agreed procedures and checking that the Public Petitions Committee wants to do that.

Dr Jean Turner Ind Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

A paragraph in Trevor Lodge's letter states:"Most patients suffering from eating disorders will be seen as outpatients within the mental health specialty. No national data is available specifically in relation to patients with a diagnosis of eating disorder."If we could get information from the Royal College of Psychiatrists we might know what the depth of the problem is in terms of how many people suffer from it. That would give us a better idea of how to tackle it. Someone might have suggested that—perhaps it was David Davidson—and I missed it.

David Davidson Con North East Scotland
link

The current figure for sufferers from eating disorders is similar to the figure for ME sufferers that Alex Fergusson gave. However, those are only the diagnosed cases; many sufferers are not diagnosed until another illness happens to them. Death often results from such illnesses and the cause of death is recorded as something other than an eating disorder.

Dr Jean Turner Ind Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

The recorded number of eating disorder sufferers is only the tip of the iceberg. In fact, an awful lot more people out there need treatment. The same situation exists with other illnesses that we discuss on the Health Committee. The sad thing about young sufferers from eating disorders is that when they have to go into hospital they are often pushed into wards that are inappropriate for their condition and which might have inadequate supervision because of a lack of staff. That makes the situation worse. As I said, we should ask the Royal College of Psychiatrists for information.

Kate Maclean Lab Dundee West
link

I tend to agree with Helen Eadie that the petition would lend itself well to being dealt with by the Public Petitions Committee. We are discussing the health aspect of the petition, but discussion of it should also cover education. Much could be done in the education sphere in terms of early diagnosis and support. It would be good if the Public Petitions Committee were happy to take the petition on board. Perhaps a member of the Health Committee who was particularly interested in the issue could work with the Public Petitions Committee on the petition and report back to us.

Janis Hughes Lab The Deputy Convener · Glasgow Rutherglen
link

Do we agree to write to the Public Petitions Committee to ask whether it is willing to conduct an initial inquiry into the issues that the petition raises? If the Public Petitions Committee agrees to do that, we can consider whether we want to appoint someone to be, technically, our reporter on the Public Petitions Committee. We can ask for volunteers at that time. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Janis Hughes Lab The Deputy Convener · Glasgow Rutherglen
link

That concludes our consideration of petitions. Interruption.

  1. Scottish Parliament Health Committee Tuesday 13 January 2004 (Afternoon) Committee business · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 6
  3. Petitions Petitions · 1
  4. Petitions Petitions · 6
  5. Petitions Petitions · 13
  6. Petitions Petitions · 4
  7. Petitions Petitions · 33
  8. Petitions Petitions · 8
  9. Petitions Petitions · 24
  10. Petitions Petitions · 3
  11. Petitions Petitions · 8
  12. Petitions Petitions · 7
  13. Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. Petitions Petitions · 8
  15. Petitions Petitions · 11
  16. Petitions Petitions · 1
  17. Budget Process Committee business · 12
  18. Work Programme Procedure · 85

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.