Petition PE515 is from Dorothy Wright of the Brae parent and toddler group, on measles, mumps and rubella vaccinations. I ask for comments, please.
Official Report · Committee
Petitions
MMR Vaccination (PE515)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Christine Grahame SNP 15
- Mike Rumbles LD 10
- David Davidson Con 6
- Shona Robison SNP 4
- Helen Eadie Lab 2
- Dr Jean Turner Ind 2
- Janis Hughes Lab 2
- Kate Maclean Lab 1
The record
42 contributionsSince the petition was submitted to the Parliament, we have seen the latest figures on uptake. If people are not using the vaccine, what difference would it make if individual injections were available on the advice of GPs? Would that help to cover some of the shortfall that we are seeing? We do not have herd immunity guaranteed at the low level of uptake of the MMR vaccine. That is obviously the drug of choice, but there is an issue around it. Perhaps the petitioners would like to comment on that. We might want to write to them, asking for their views now that the latest figures—which are only a few weeks old—are available.
This is a serious issue and it would be dangerous for us to make snap judgments as we flick through the petitions. It is a major cause of concern throughout Scotland. If we want to pursue the matter, we should discuss it when we are considering our work programme, and our decision on it should be made in the context of the other issues that we will be considering. I am not sure that we should take any further action on the petition now. If we want to decide to pursue the matter, we should do so at the appropriate time, when committee members discuss our future work programme.
I am not averse to Mike Rumbles's suggestion; he makes a fair point. However, there are a number of questions that are worth asking, which I am happy to discuss either when we come to consider the work programme or now. There are questions about the Executive's current position and in connection with the points that David Davidson made and the supply of the single vaccine. We should consider whether there ought to be a change to the current position.
I support the view that we should not leap to a conclusion on the matter; we need to give some considered thought to how the committee might want to pursue the matter further. We get many laudable petitions, but they must always be considered in the context of the Parliament's work programme, and we must be realistic. I support Mike Rumbles's view on that.
This is one of the most urgent petitions before us, given the worry about people not being immunised against measles, mumps and rubella, especially measles. People who have not been taking up the vaccine are now laid open—as I was as a young child—to measles and everything that goes with it. Folk have forgotten the seriousness of measles as an illness. Communities are in danger of not being protected. I do not think that there has been enough vaccine to cover everybody who wants single vaccinations. I accept the point about the difficulty of getting all the immunisations done in the appropriate time but, as I said, our communities are in danger of not being protected.
I suggest that we write to the Minister for Health and Community Care in the light of the recent figures on herd immunity. We should use his answer to inform a discussion of how to deal with the matter under our forward work plan.
I worry about the prospect of the Health Committee holding a further inquiry—the then Health and Community Care Committee already conducted an inquiry into the matter. It lends more fuel to the media fire. There seems to be little scientific evidence linking the MMR vaccine with autism, but because of the media coverage that the issue has attracted, the take-up of MMR vaccines has reduced quite dramatically, which is very worrying. We could possibly find out what the most up-to-date position is and make contact with the Executive before coming to a decision, but I worry that we might end up making things worse, with committee members not really being in a position to come to any more of a conclusion than was the case before. We would hear compelling evidence from both sides and we might add to the problem if we hold a further inquiry.
I am not saying that we either should or should not hold a further inquiry; I think that our discussion should continue when we come to consider our work programme. I, for one, do not want to discuss all the ins and outs of the matter now, because the issue is too big, and I agree entirely with what Kate Maclean said about our not having all the information. Equally, I would not want to raise issues that should not be raised. What I am trying to get at is the fact that I am conscious that we are going through all the petitions saying that we will do this and that, and that we seem to be reluctant to say to people, as would be appropriate in this case, "Thank you very much for your petition on this extremely important issue. We have closed discussion of the petition, but we have put the matter on the Health Committee work programme for discussion." We should leave the petition at that, so that we can consider the subject.
I would support that view if, when we had that discussion, we were able to decide whether we need to take evidence from ministers on the current situation, such as on the uptake figures that I mentioned earlier. We do not want to have a full-scale inquiry into whether MMR is a good or a bad thing. It is generally agreed that MMR is a good thing; the issue that has been raised is whether we can find out why people are not taking up the vaccine. Several members have mentioned that issue. I would certainly support our having a further group discussion on that.
We might want to follow up on the Scottish Executive Health Department letter of 27 February, which gave responses to questions. We might want to get progress reports on one or two issues.The response to the first question states: "the Executive and the Medical Research Council have developed a joint-funded research programme based on the agenda outlined".I would like to know what is happening with that programme.The response to the next question states: "MRC expect to receive research proposals on this subject".I would like to know what has happened to those proposals. Those sorts of things get put into letters, but we need to find out what has happened to them. Those are factual matters.The response to question 4 states: "The Scottish Consortium for Learning Disability is being funded by the Modernising Government Fund to develop a national database for people with learning disabilities and ASD."There are issues about what progress has taken place on that.I also noted a couple of other points in the letter. After all the bullet points, the response to question 5 states: "Local authorities and NHS Boards have been asked to conduct a joint audit of service provision for people with ASD, and to provide the Executive with this information by the end of April. That information will be considered by the reference group at its next meeting in May."We should find out what happened to that information.Finally, the response to question 7 states: "The Executive will give careful consideration to the findings of the National Initiative for Autism Screening and Assessment when they are published."Have those findings been published? I do not know what has happened to them.Those are just some things that I picked out from the letter. We should find out what has happened to all that information. Where has the information been published and what access do we have to it?Should we follow up on all the points that I have highlighted?
Before discussing the matter with the minister, we should write a follow-up letter to him on the points in the letter of 27 February.
That is my point. The letter is quite old.
I think that we have drifted and I do not like going down this line at all—
We are just seeking information.
It is a mistake to go through the petitions and say that we will write off a letter to the minister or, as David Davidson suggested, question the minister on the issues. Right at the beginning, I suggested that this is such an important topic that we need to get our work programme right. I am not downplaying the issue, but many other health issues are also important and we have only a finite amount of time to deal with them. It is entirely wrong to be discussing the ins and outs of the petition just now. We all know the importance of the subject.I am arguing that we should write to the petitioners to thank them for raising with us such an important issue. We should tell them that we will put the issue as an item on our work programme. We can then weigh up its relative merits against those of all the other issues that we have to discuss and take it from there. I do not agree that we should invite the minister to do anything when we have not even decided whether we are going to take up the issue.
If I may just clarify—
I will come to David Davidson, but Helen Eadie is first. I may also want to respond myself.
I support what Mike Rumbles has said. We need to keep focused on what the petitioner has asked for. She has asked that the Scottish Parliament take the necessary steps to make individual injections available without delay. The petitioner has not asked us to go into all the different nooks and crannies. The petitioner has asked a single clear question.The proposal from Mike Rumbles would make our work programme much more realistic. We need to consider the issue separately when we consider our work programme, when we can agree among ourselves on whether we feel that it is desirable to go down that route. If we move other priorities up the queue ahead of the priorities that we already have and do not take time to stop and reflect for a moment on what impact that will have on our work, that will create problems.That is not to say that many of the questions that are being raised are not valid in a different context but, in the context of the petition, the single question that is being asked is whether we can make individual injections available without delay. As I understand it, the petitioners want such injections to be available at the same nil cost as the MMR vaccines.
Yes.
I do not disagree with that, but we seemed to move on to a discussion about what we would do in the work programme. All I am saying is that, if we are to have a discussion, we need to have answers on the outstanding issues from the minister's letter.
I am not seeking an inquiry, by the way; I take no view whatever. Questions were raised by our predecessor committee and I am suggesting that we would like progress reports on the answers that were given. We just want to know what has happened in relation to the various things that we were told would be happening. That is all our questions are—they are no more, and no less, than factual questions. For example, we want to find out what happened to the "joint-funded research programme".
Covering the people who are not covered is such an urgent issue. Some people will never take the triple vaccine and we are confronted with the problem that they will be prone to having measles, mumps and rubella. I do not know what is wrong with asking how we deal with the problem. If children get those diseases, it will cause anguish and heartache. I had bilateral bronchial pneumonia as a child and I had a long recovery period after measles. People are suffering and we must decide how to deal with that quickly and how to get the best result for people. I do not know how we move forward. It is difficult to establish how to deal with the people affected.If we consider the issue purely from the point of view of cost-effectiveness and forget about the hardship element, it would be cost-effective to the health service if we could prevent measles and the other diseases. There are two issues at stake. Some people do not want MMR and some people want single-vaccine injections. The problem that we have is that some people will get those illnesses. We cannot run away from the fact that that will happen if we do not take steps to prevent it.
As I see it, we have two options. Either we go down the route that Mike Rumbles is suggesting by deferring the discussion that we are getting into until the issue is put on the agenda, or we simply write to the Executive to ask for an update and to find out whether it intends to have a change of policy and to take the necessary steps to make single vaccines available, which the petition requests. We should do one or the other, but there is no point in having an in-depth discussion now.
I did not think that we were having such a discussion, but that is how things have developed. I take it that we want an update on the latest letter, which was dated 27 February 2003. I pointed members to some of the issues on which we want an update. I ask Shona Robison to repeat her last point; I told the committee that my head was not in gear today.
Helen Eadie made the point that the petitioners make a specific request. They call on the Parliament to take the necessary steps to make individual vaccines available. We should ask whether the Executive is going to consider a change of position.
In addition to that, we should ask for an update on the issues that were referred to in the Executive's letter of 27 February.
Fine.
Are members content with that?
No.
You are not content.
No, I am not. To me, it seems that we are in a very odd situation. Shona Robison just said that we had two ways of proceeding. You seemed to assume automatically that we would—
No, I asked whether members were content.
I am saying that I am not content. I am proposing that we write and thank the petitioner for bringing the issue to our attention. The petitioner requests specifically that we take the necessary steps to make individual injections available without delay. I do not know enough about the topic; I do not know whether we should support or reject the petition. Asking one or two questions is not going to help me to come to a conclusion on that. Given all the other subjects that are in our work load, I want the committee to decide whether we will pursue the matter. I want to close consideration of the petition. I want to send the petition back to the petitioners with great thanks for doing a good job and to tell them that the matter is on our agenda and whether we pursue it will be up to us to decide at another meeting.
Is that your proposal?
Yes.
I would like to hear views on that.
My position—perhaps it is a slight compromise—is that we should write to ask the minister for his views on the recent figures on herd immunity and use his response to inform our discussion of our work plan.
I am happy with that, as long as we write back to say "Thank you very much" to the petitioners.
I agree with having two chunks—one is for the work load and one is a current response—because it is not in our gift to do anything other than discuss the subject more.
I am happy with that.
Is everybody happy with that?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 7 Oct 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Health Committee Tuesday 7 October 2003 (Afternoon) Committee business · 1
- Item in Private Procedure · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Petitions Petitions · 3
- Petitions Petitions · 10
- Petitions Petitions · 14
- Petitions Petitions · 8
- Petitions Petitions · 12
- Petitions Petitions · 3
- Petitions Petitions · 5
- Petitions Petitions · 7
- Petitions Petitions · 4
- Petitions Petitions · 8
- Petitions Petitions · 42
- Petitions Petitions · 12
- Petitions Petitions · 4
- Petitions Petitions · 5
- Petitions Petitions · 10
- Petitions Petitions · 3
- Petitions Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.