I invite the minister to make any opening remarks on the regulations.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Regulation of Care (Fitness to Register, Provide and Manage Care Services) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2009 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Christine Grahame SNP 8
- Shona Robison SNP 5
- Adam Rennie 4
- Michael Matheson SNP 1
- Mary Scanlon Con 1
The record
22 contributionsThank you for the opportunity to speak in support of the regulations.Ensuring that the right people provide care services is an essential element of ensuring that those who use services receive good-quality care. It is part of the care commission's responsibility to ensure that potential providers are fit to carry out that role. Under the current arrangement, the commission has no discretion when someone who has a conviction applies to register as a care service provider: if an applicant has a conviction that resulted in a sentence of not less than three months—whether or not it was suspended—the commission must refuse their application. It does not matter what the sentence was for or how long ago it was.The committee's first thought might be that anyone who has any conviction cannot possibly be fit to provide a care service to vulnerable people. I understand that, but there are circumstances in which convictions do not affect a person's ability and suitability to provide a care service. I shall give you an example. A couple apply to provide a childminding service. The husband has a spent conviction for a driving offence from his youth, since when he has married and been in steady work and the couple have successfully raised their own family. He has had no further convictions, and all the other indicators suggest that the couple should be registered. Their references are good and their health is fine but, under the present rules, the commission must refuse to register them. It has no discretion in the matter. The proposed amendments to the fitness requirements give the care commission the discretion to decide whether a given conviction is relevant to an application to provide a particular care service. In the example that I have just given, the commission would consider carefully the circumstances of the conviction and decide whether it made the husband unfit to provide a childminding service.The changes will bring the requirements on providers' fitness into line with those of the Scottish Social Services Council, which has the discretion to consider convictions when registering social services workers. In practice, that means that someone with a conviction can be registered with the SSSC as a social worker and carry out that role but, if they applied to provide a care service, under the current arrangements the care commission would have to refuse their application.In proposing the power for the care commission, I make it clear that it will not be a charter for unsuitable or unscrupulous people to register care services. The commission will be required to come to a reasonable opinion, having regard to the circumstances of the conviction. It is currently preparing guidance for potential applicants who want to register care services, which will explain the criteria that will be taken into account and how the commission will exercise the power fairly and transparently. My officials will scrutinise the guidance carefully before it is published.I support the regulations, which will amend the provisions on fitness to register, provide and manage care services.
I have a question, although it might not be necessary. It is common sense that the commission should have discretion, given the example that you gave involving a de minimis offence, but if somebody applies to register and they are refused on the basis of that discretion will there be an appeal procedure?
Do you mean an appeal against the refusal of an application?
Yes—against a refusal to register.
I do not think that there is such a procedure, but we will get back to the committee on that. I am sorry that I do not have the information with me.
Once a discretion is introduced, decisions will be taken at the edges. The minister gave an easy example, but there will be some cases that are on the cusp.
We will have to clarify that. We would look to the SSSC to find out whether there is something in line with what it does.
It might simply be an application to the sheriff court relating to a decision by the commission. An appeal procedure is important when discretion is introduced.
We will get back to the committee on that.
That is a general point. The commission already takes all sorts of decisions that potential providers might or might not want to appeal against.
But it is absolute at the moment, is it not?
We are discussing another type of decision that the commission might take. I am sorry that I do not have the answer to that question.
We will get back to you on that.
I was going to raise the same point. As soon as discretion is introduced, some recourse will have to be introduced for those who wish to dispute the way in which the care commission applies the discretion. I encourage the minister to consider that. If the care commission's decision is to be final, that will have to be made clear to people when they apply for consideration under the discretionary power.
My point goes back to one that I made previously. Given that we know so little about the care commission, as it is monitored so lightly and audited even more lightly, how can we be sure that it will always come to a reasonable decision about who is a fit and proper person? The example that the minister gave was excellent and I fully understand that situation, but we are asked to recommend that the regulations be passed when we have no idea how the commission will exercise the discretion. We have no way of checking on the operational guidance for the care commission.
Ultimately, the care commission is accountable to me as the minister. I am happy to raise with it any concerns that members have, but I do not share the member's view about the commission. In the past seven years, it has built up a real competence in dealing with difficult situations, and it has produced a practical set of proposals to deal with a situation that was perhaps not envisaged when the Regulation of Care (Scotland) Act 2001 was drafted. It is common sense that the commission should not have to rule out people from running a care service for something that is absolutely unrelated to their ability to run a care service. The guidance that the commission is drawing up will come to me before it is published. There are enough checks and balances in the system to ensure that the care commission carries out its work with all due probity and professionalism.
As we have no more questions, I invite the minister to move motion S3M-3511.
Motion moved,
That the Health and Sport Committee recommends that the draft Regulation of Care (Fitness to Register, Provide and Manage Care Services) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2009 be approved.—Shona Robison.
Motion agreed to.
I thank the minister for her evidence; it has been a long morning for her. Mr Rennie will remain to answer any questions on the negative instrument that we will consider next.
In this meeting
Everything on 11 Mar 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Health and Sport Committee Wednesday 11 March 2009 Committee business · 1
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- Pathways into Sport Inquiry Evidence session · 186
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 39
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 22
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
- Cross-border Health Care Committee business · 19
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.