Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petition

Cancer Treatment (Cetuximab) (PE1108)

Wednesday 23 January 2008 Health and Sport Committee Petitions 30 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

30 contributions
Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Item 3 deals with an important petition. I refer members to paper HS/S3/08/3/2.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

As with all petitions, this one raises some general issues and it is those that are important, rather than the specific example.The petition gives us an opportunity to use the reporter system, if we can find a volunteer to be a reporter—that would not be me. When I was on the Health and Community Care Committee in the first Parliament, I did three reports. The reporter system offers an effective and less time-consuming way of elucidating the principles that are involved in the important issue that is raised by the petition. Perhaps my colleague Dr McKee would be a suitable reporter.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Ah, you are volunteering Dr McKee. For clarity, I should say that the petition has not yet been formally referred to the committee.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Yes. I call Michael Matheson, to be followed by Mary Matheson—I mean Mary Scanlon. Laughter.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Obviously, she has become my auntie. My auntie Mary, in the committee!

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I think that that was unkind—to be referred to as auntie. At least it was not grannie, I suppose.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Given that time is of the essence in relation to this petition and that it will be difficult for this committee to find the space any time soon to give this matter the consideration that it is due, I would be satisfied if the Public Petitions Committee were to undertake its own inquiry into the matter, if there were a willing volunteer from our committee to act as a reporter who could attend that committee and report back to us. However, I do not think that we should do anything that might delay consideration of the issue.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I apologise for not finding this out before the meeting, but I would like to know whether the drug that is referred to in the petition has been appraised and recommended by the Scottish medicines consortium.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

My understanding is that it cannot have been because, if the SMC had approved the drug, health boards would have been obliged to fund its use.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I am advised that that is indeed the case.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I am on the Public Petitions Committee and listened to the evidence that was given on the petition. It was moving and quite sad to hear about the human cost of the decision. I understand that the drug is available in other health board areas. However, the petitioner's husband had to fund his own drug treatment, which meant that he also had to fund treatments that, had he not been taking the drug, would have been funded by the national health service. It was therefore not just the drug that he was funding; it was the whole treatment, including blood tests and the like.I understand the argument that this committee will struggle to find the time to consider the petition and that we should therefore ask the Public Petitions Committee to go ahead with it. However, big issues arise that relate to our inquiry into health inequalities. With the help of family and friends, this man has been able to raise money, but he made the point—and, given his circumstances, he made it very strongly—that people who did not have access to financial support would be dead already, not having received the drug. He wanted to point out that the system was very unequal. He had access to money, but others did not.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

This is not an either/or situation. The committee might want to let the Public Petitions Committee deal with this, and a reporter from this committee could attend its meetings formally, or any of us could simply attend informally. That would not prevent us from taking this gentleman's situation into account when we come to our inquiry into health inequalities.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We have to remember that this case is urgent. Would any committee member be prepared to be a reporter? Rhoda, could you fulfil both roles—as a member of the Public Petitions Committee and as a reporter from this committee?

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Yes, it would be a formal reporting role.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Right, we will have you there in a formal capacity and you will report back to this committee. We will write to the convener of the Public Petitions Committee accordingly, saying that we want that committee to deal with the petition because of its urgency, and saying that we will consider the issue as part of our wider inquiry into health inequalities. So, we will make three points: the Public Petitions Committee should take the matter forward; Rhoda Grant will be our reporter; and this committee will absorb the petition into our inquiry into health inequalities. A letter in those terms will be sent on behalf of the committee.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

I dread to contradict Dr Simpson—I do so with some fear and trepidation—but my reading of the paper that we have received was that the petitioner's concern centred on both the lack of transparency and the different ways in which different health boards deal with recommendations from either the SMC or the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence. The inference to be drawn was that, in this case, the drug has been approved, but different health boards in Scotland took different decisions on whether to fund it and/or allow it to be used in their areas.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

The Public Petitions Committee could clarify that for us.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I agree. I will include that point in the letter. We are not clear about the status of the approval of the drug in different boards.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

My understanding—and I could be wrong, because for four years I have just been working in the field—is that, if the drug is approved by the SMC, the boards are obliged to fund it. Therefore, this issue should not have arisen.If boards are misinterpreting the situation, that is one matter. It is a different matter if drugs such as this one have been approved—in terms of their European and British licensing arrangements—but have not then gone through the NICE or the SMC process. These questions need clear answers before the Public Petitions Committee can proceed.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

In the first instance, we should write the letter to the convener of the Public Petitions Committee, so that the petition can make progress, but we should also ask for a briefing from the Scottish Parliament information centre on the status of the various approvals and the obligations that they place on health boards.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

That is now on the record for the benefit of the Public Petitions Committee.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The confusion was that one member of the committee said that the drug had been approved by the SMC but another said that the drug had not been approved. Going back to Rhoda Grant's points, I did not understand whether, if the drug was not approved, some health boards were offering it, perhaps through clinical trials. We have to get the SMC appraisal and then move on from there.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

The clerks will refer SPICe to our debate and will ask for clarification on all the points that members have raised. The convener of the Public Petitions Committee will also be aware of our concerns.

Meeting continued in private until 12:36.

  1. Scottish Parliament Health and Sport Committee Wednesday 23 January 2008 Committee business · 1
  2. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  3. Sportscotland Evidence session · 246
  4. Petition Petitions · 30

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.